Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the CRIF, Islamist terrorism, anti-Semitism, Franco-Israeli relations, and the conflict in the Middle East, in Paris on February 22, 2017.

France François Hollande · President of France

22 February 2017 · CRIF annual dinner · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the annual CRIF dinner in Paris on February 22, 2017, speaking on terrorism, anti-Semitism, and democracy in his final appearance as President.
Main themes
Islamist terrorism, anti-Semitism, defense of democracy, CRIF annual dinner, Franco-Jewish relations, political extremism and nationalism, French Republic values, radicalization, Franco-Israeli relations, Middle East conflict, unity against division
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,681
83rd percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
51
64th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.10
61st percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
68th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 43%40%
  • Ceremonial 25%24%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Institutional 15%14%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

159 sentences in 51 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Senate,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Mr. Prime Minister,

Madam Mayor of Paris,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians, elected officials,

Ladies and gentlemen ambassadors,

Ladies and gentlemen who represent here all the faiths of our country,

Mr. President of CRIF,

Ladies and gentlemen,

For more than seventy years, CRIF has carried a strong and necessary voice: that of the Jewish institutions of France, in all their diversity. This annual dinner manifests the permanence and quality of the dialogue you have managed to establish with the highest institutions of the State, despite all the alternations that have succeeded one another.

Tonight's dinner is not quite like the others, as you said, Mr. President, neither for you nor for me. For you, as president of CRIF, and you expressed your emotion, you have an immense responsibility to speak on behalf of the Jews of France and to ensure that you can not only be heard but also understood.

I want, beyond you, to pay tribute to your predecessors. I am thinking particularly of Richard PRASQUIER and Roger CUKIERMAN. We have lived through tragic moments together that we will never forget, and I want to express to you what your actions have meant to me and the recognition of the Nation regarding the courage and dignity you both demonstrated in the exercise of your responsibilities, in abominable circumstances. I think it was important that your voice, precisely, could carry on that day, those days, and that your sorrow could not simply be shared between you, but could truly be that of the entire Republic of which you are a component.

I also wanted, beyond you, to greet Henri HAJDENBERG and express my respect to Théo KLEIN. Théo KLEIN who, beyond all he has done, had a happy idea in 1986: the CRIF dinner.

I have participated many times, I cannot even specify the exact number, in the CRIF dinner, in all the positions I have held. But today, this is the last one I am attending as President of the Republic, and I wanted to be with you, among you, precisely because it is the last and that I must assert what I have done, on behalf of the Republic, and also be accountable to you for the responsibilities that have been mine in the trials we have gone through.

I also wanted to be here because we find ourselves, as you said, Mr. President, in a particular moment of our political life, since in barely two months, there will be the first round of the presidential election. Here are gathered those who governed yesterday, those who govern today, and those who aspire to govern tomorrow; sometimes they are the same, it is both the law of alternation, but it is also, and this is the symbol I want to retain, the unity of the Republic.

Divisions are necessary, and it would even be perilous to want to erase them, to smooth over the differences between sensitivities. But above all, there is a common awareness of belonging to a whole, to a nation, of sharing the same values and also reminding ourselves of our responsibility and our pride. We are the country that first declared that men, and I must say: women, are born and remain free and equal in rights. And that is what brings us together today.

The message I want to convey to you this evening is simple: let us be aware that democracy is our most precious asset, but also the most fragile. It is never guaranteed, never acquired once and for all. History teaches us this sufficiently. It is a conquest that must be fiercely defended, that must be constantly recalled, and this fight must be waged against all forces, here or abroad, that would seek to undermine democracy, our way of life, our common ideal, freedom.

First, this force is Islamist terrorism that has struck our country: March 2012, January 2015, November 2015, July 2016, so many dramas, tragedies, so many blows that have been dealt to us, so many heinous attacks, and today, the threat has not diminished, justifying the vigilance we must demonstrate at all times, and the fight we must wage against radicalization.

There lies and will remain for a long time the major danger, and we must prepare for it. We must not oppose or divide ourselves on this issue. If I have one lesson to impart to you, it is that the Republic will win this fight on one condition: that it is capable of uniting and carrying together, beyond sensitivities and divisions, the same ambition, the same strength. This is what the terrorists fear, because they want to divide us.

There are other challenges that our democracy must face: extremism, which thrives throughout Europe, nationalism, including its economic version, protectionism, authoritarian drift, not to mention relativism, transgression, provocations, the equivalence of opinions, as if racists could have the same opinions with the same values as democrats! Our duty is to restore meaning, to indicate the markers, and to call for awareness and responsibility, to defend reason. This is not the easiest task. Because being in reason does not mean yielding to passions, fears, or excesses!

Being in reason means being faithful to our history, to the Enlightenment. It is, in a changed world, being able to discern the true from the false, to reject fanaticism and simplistic thinking. It is being able, each time, beyond the complexity of the world, to say where we are going and what the direction is. It is being able not to yield to the vile fear of the crowd to address the entire people.

Anti-Semitism is undoubtedly the oldest hatred; it has humiliated and killed for more than 2,000 years. It reached its peak more than 70 years ago, during the Holocaust. After this absolute horror, we could have believed that the hatred of Jews would finally dry up, condemned without appeal by the moral ruin to which it had led Europe. Well, no. In France, there was the attack on Rue Copernic in 1980; I want to say here that we obtained two years ago the extradition of the main suspect, and I assure you, Mr. President, that we will seek all the perpetrators and bring them here to be judged.

And then, there was the desecration of the Carpentras cemetery in 1990, the torture of Ilan HALIMI in 2006, the massacre at the Ozar Hatorah school in Toulouse in 2012, the tragedy of Hyper Cacher in 2015. Anti-Semitism is there, always there; it has not lost its old references, it has not changed its vocabulary, it has not renounced conspiracy theories, but it is true, and you said it, Mr. President, and I agree, it now draws from other sources. The hatred of Israel serves as a pretext. The result is that in certain neighborhoods of our cities, French Jews are afraid, and the Republic cannot accept this. But it must not be content to say so; it must act for the safety of all Jews as well as all citizens, for if the former are always at the top of the list, others are always struck at one time or another.

I wanted, in response to this threat, to ensure that the numbers of our law enforcement and intelligence services could be reinforced. I look at what is being said by the candidates for the presidential election, and I am pleased that all want to continue this effort, that they do not relent, and that they are aware that what has been initiated has not been done for a majority, for a legislature, but for a long duration in which they must inscribe themselves. 10,000 soldiers as part of Operation Sentinelle are mobilized on national territory in support of the police and gendarmerie to protect places of worship, schools, and cultural centers. And again, I warn those who would want to deprive us of this essential contribution that is Operation Sentinelle; we need it, it is indispensable. Thanks to this deployment, nearly 820 Jewish sites are subject to protection measures in mainland France, and I assure you, Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen, that the guard will not lower.

I also wanted the fight against racism and anti-Semitism to be established as a national priority, that a global plan be designed and implemented, and that DILCRAH, which you wanted to salute along with its head Gilles CLAVREUL, be tasked with implementing these measures.

Fighting anti-Semitism means first repressing it; in this matter, no act, no statement is trivial, and nothing should go unpunished. A law was passed a few days ago, the Equality and Citizenship law, which ensures that racist, anti-Semitic, or homophobic motivation is an aggravating circumstance for all crimes and offenses. Furthermore, the procedural rules provided by the 1881 press law applicable to offenses of provocation, defamation, and insults have been modified to facilitate prosecutions. As for the perpetrators, they now face much higher penalties, up to one year in prison.

Fighting anti-Semitism also means identifying it; too many victims refrain from filing complaints. We must lift these hesitations, and that is why there is now the possibility of resorting to group actions, which has been extended to victims of discrimination. Finally, in accordance with a commitment I made, the Ministry of Justice now publishes statistics related to complaints and convictions because transparency must be ensured.

You mentioned the Internet, which is both a place of information, to which many give credit too easily, but it is also a dumping ground where calls to hatred hide behind the cowardice of anonymity. The PHAROS reporting platform was rightly designed to identify these abject messages, have them removed, and pursue their authors. Again, Gilles CLAVREUL has the mission to report, based on Article 40 of the criminal procedure, any discriminatory content on the Internet. As for the major Internet operators, I have asked myself, as you have, why they cannot permanently ban anti-Semitic and racist statements while they do so for pedophilic acts? We must hold them accountable and condemn them if they do not.

Fighting anti-Semitism also means tackling the roots of the evil by combating prejudices and increasingly precisely establishing historical truth, relentlessly opposing the truth to all attempts at falsification. The Holocaust, which is part of the curriculum for CM2, 3rd grade, and 1st grade, must be taught everywhere without restriction in all our cities, in all our neighborhoods, and in all territories, and it is also the role of moral and civic education.

This mobilization has produced results since, as you pointed out, acts of violence and anti-Semitic threats are at their lowest level in 15 years, down by 58%. The same is true for anti-Muslim acts, even if we have seen an increase in anti-Christian acts.

But I hear your call; the figures do not express everything; they do not reflect the fear of the mother who brings her child to school, the anxiety of the faithful who goes to the synagogue; they do not express the full reality of this phenomenon of being afraid while we are in a Republic and that we are aware that we must be safe.

This fear is not simply that of Jews; it is also that of Muslims, Christians, and those who have no faith and who can also live in this time when terror can resurface at any moment, yes, terror.

I mentioned what we have experienced with these terrorist attacks. It is true that Islamist terrorism has declared war on us, that it will be long, and that we will win. This fight is first and foremost waged on our soil with, notably, one objective: to prevent attacks. We do this—I dare not say every day, but almost—without these pieces of information being public. We must also identify dangerous individuals, prevent the departure of young fanatics to conflict zones, Syria and Iraq, and then punish them upon their return. If they return, they will be immediately arrested; this is indeed the case for a number of them, and they will be tried in France as the law requires since a law, that of 2012, allowed French citizens to be tried in France for terrorist crimes committed abroad.

At the European level, we have revised the Schengen code to strengthen border controls because the terrorist threat, as we have seen, does not only concern France but has struck all of Europe: Brussels, Copenhagen, Berlin. The fight against terrorism also justifies the intervention of our armed forces, and I want to salute the courage of our soldiers who have liberated Mali from jihadist control, who today fight against Daesh in the Middle East. Today, we support the Iraqi forces who are fighting in Mosul to wrest this city from the grip of fanaticism, a city that Daesh had claimed as its stronghold.

I want to greet the Yezidis and Christians. Our will is that they can return to the villages where they lived until now. We have in France the record, if I may say so, of resettlements and relocations in Europe. That is to say, we are the country that has done the most, and which has undoubtedly not done enough, to welcome the refugees who were in camps or who were displaced in combat zones.

They are not all Christians, they are not all Yezidis. But we have made sure that the Christians of the East and the Yezidis are also prioritized. I would like to thank all the associations, all the communities that have welcomed them because it was our duty, because it was our honor, and we do not distinguish between refugees, I affirm here, according to their religion, according to their origin. Refugees have the right to asylum and we must ensure it for them.

In Iraq, our will is that they can return to the villages. It is Muslims who erected the cross on the churches that had been devastated by Daesh. This is the meaning of what we want to do in the Middle East, reconciliation and, once again, the ability to live together.

In Syria, the debate, I say, is not about the choice that should be made between Bashar al-Assad and the Islamic State, with a form of hierarchy in horror. No. The solution is to be able to organize a political transition with all the forces present except, of course, the terrorists. This is what France is tirelessly doing and what it must continue to do by discussing with all the states, the neighboring states, as well as those that have an influence in the situation in Syria.

In this dangerous world, for it has become more uncertain due to a number of choices that have been made, France must be a force for stability, a nation devoted to dialogue and peace, which does not mean renouncing the use of force if necessary. But our role is to foster solutions. We are one of the few countries that can do this. We can do it all the more because we have a national defense and also a capacity for foreign policy. We are probably the only one doing this in Europe, able to do it at this level. With the departure of the United Kingdom from the European Union, we will be the only permanent member of the Security Council, possessing a deterrent force, thus able to lead Europe towards greater responsibilities on the international stage.

This is also our role in the Middle East. I understand the attachment of French Jews to Israel, I know what this state created in the aftermath of the Shoah represents for Jews around the world, the pride it inspires, the hope it embodies. I also know the pain that Jews feel with every attack that strikes Israel, again last January in Jerusalem, the indignation they feel when Israel is attacked, when its right to exist is called into question. No other country in the world is thus denied in its very existence.

So, let us be clear, criticism of the Israeli government and particularly of its decisions regarding settlements is legitimate, as is that of any government, and here in France, no one refrains from it. This criticism is also exercised within Israel, and you have reminded us once again, because Israel is a vibrant and demanding democracy. But anti-Zionism is not legitimate when it is merely a mask for anti-Semitism. This is France's position to be firm regarding Israel's right to exist and to live in peace. We have had the opportunity several times to demonstrate its correctness.

France is the origin of the recognition by the 57 OSCE countries that the denial of Israel's legitimacy is akin to a form of anti-Semitism. France has fought tirelessly against the so-called BDS movement whose objective is simple: to deprive Israel of all economic, financial, and also cultural contact with the outside world. The Court of Cassation recently confirmed that calls for a boycott constitute an offense of incitement to discrimination based on national belonging. France is therefore the only country to have legislation prohibiting calls for a boycott, and I assure you that we will enforce it.

France has always been a friend of Israel. President Shimon Peres, who passed away last year, knew better than anyone what France had done for Israel's security, and he reminded it every time he had the opportunity. Israel, for its part, contributes to the security of the French, particularly through the close cooperation we have in the fight against terrorism.

As we prepare to celebrate the 70th anniversary of the creation of the State of Israel, as next year a France-Israel cross-season will open, which will of course be funded, it is for the security and integrity of Israel and all the peoples of the region that France acts. Our country, this can be a temptation and it has been expressed in other times, our country cannot be a giver of lessons nor a distributor of blame and praise. It does not position itself as an arbiter, nor as a mediator between peoples and states that remain free. But through its special ties to the Middle East, France must take its responsibilities.

It has taken them, and I know that this has been a question between us and between you. It has taken them during the negotiation of the nuclear agreement with Iran for which we have ensured perhaps more than others that Iran offers solid guarantees. France will remain vigilant regarding their respect. At the same time, I justify this agreement; it would even be dangerous for it to be called into question, unless the Iranians deviated from it, because we need to have rules and to be able to verify them. In the same way, we must ensure that Iran never gains access to nuclear weapons.

France has also taken its responsibilities on the Israeli-Palestinian issue in international organizations, and I have heard you starting from a simple principle that I repeat to you: as long as the Palestinians, neighbors of Israel, do not have secure and recognized borders, Israel will not have them either. For peace in the Middle East, we know the solution; it is that of two states, Israel and Palestine, living side by side in peace. It is the only guarantee for Israel to remain what it is, a pluralistic and democratic state.

It is true, and we have also said that colonization continues at a pace that is dangerous because it makes the solution of a Palestinian state more improbable. However, without a Palestinian state, there will be no peace. But once I have said that, I want to add two clarifications. The first is that the solution will never be imposed by the international community, never. It is up to the Israelis and Palestinians to agree on each of the questions of the final status, particularly on that of Jerusalem. The second clarification is precisely on this point. France will never accept that the presence and the Jewish history in Jerusalem can be denied or even that they can be relativized. France will continue to ensure the preservation of the status quo in Jerusalem, that is to say, free access to worship for all believers, Jews, Christians, and Muslims. This freedom is an acquired right that must remain guaranteed internationally. This is France's position, and I am sure it will not change.

Mr. President, you recalled the figure of your father, and you did so with great emotion. You also mentioned your perspective as a child with the pride of being where you are today. A child's perspective also on France as you wanted it, as you dreamed it, as you love it today, generous, fraternal, protective of all its own without distinction of origin, belief, and religion.

I will also mention another perspective, perhaps the same, that another child had on France about a century ago; his name was Albert Cohen. He was 10 years old, he came from Corfu with his Jewish parents, he arrived in Marseille, he lived in a small apartment, and he wrote this childhood memory: "I had set up an altar for France in my room. On the shelf of a wardrobe, I had placed a reliquary of the glories of France surrounded by candles, mirrors, and cups. The relics were portraits of Racine, Corneille, La Fontaine, Joan of Arc, Pasteur. There were also small French flags and then small votive plaques with these inscriptions: 'Glory to France.'"

Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen, France will not disappoint the passion you have for it, that this Jewish child had for it. France will always be at the rendezvous of freedom and law. France will not let obscurantism pass. France will never succumb to extremism. France will be worthy of its word and of the affection you show it, as you do this evening, you, the children of the Republic. France, I am sure, will make the choices that correspond to its honor and its greatness.

Long live the Republic and long live France!