Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the deportation of Jews during the Second World War and on the fight against anti-Semitism, in Paris on July 22, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

22 July 2012 · Commemoration of the deportation of Jews during the Second World War · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed a commemoration ceremony in Paris on July 22, 2012, marking the 70th anniversary of the Vel d'Hiv roundup of Jews by French police.
Main themes
Vel d'Hiv roundup commemoration, French responsibility for Holocaust, deportation of Jews in World War II, memory and remembrance, Vichy collaboration, fight against anti-Semitism, honor and resistance, truth and historical accountability, righteous individuals, Franco-Jewish history
Duration
~15 min
51st percentile
Words
1,769
51st percentile
Sentences
104
65th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.44
93rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 57%57%
  • Ceremonial 22%22%
  • Geopolitical 13%13%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

104 sentences in 61 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Gentlemen ambassadors,

Mr. Mayor of Paris,

Mr. President of the Representative Council of Jewish Institutions of France,

Mr. Chief Rabbi,

Ladies and gentlemen representatives of the faiths,

Ladies and gentlemen,

We are gathered here this morning to recall the horror of a crime, to express the sorrow of those who lived through the tragedy, to evoke the dark hours of collaboration, our history, and thus the responsibility of France.

We are also here to transmit the memory of the Holocaust, of which the roundups were the first step, to fight against forgetfulness, to bear witness to new generations of what barbarism is capable of and what humanity can itself contain in resources to overcome it.

Seventy years ago, on July 16, 1942, in the early morning, 13,152 men, women, and children were arrested in their homes. Childless couples and single individuals were interned in Drancy, where the museum created by the Memorial of the Shoah will rise in the autumn.

The others were taken to the Vélodrome d'Hiver. Packed in inhumane conditions for five days, they were then transferred to the camps of Pithiviers and Beaune-la-Rolande.

A clear directive had been given by the Vichy administration: "Children must not leave in the same convoys as their parents." Thus, after heartbreaking separations, parents on one side, children on the other, left for Auschwitz-Birkenau, where the deportees from Drancy had preceded them by a few days.

They were murdered. For the sole reason that they were Jewish.

This crime took place here, in our capital, in our streets, in our courtyards, in our stairwells, under our school porches.

It would pave the way for other roundups, in Marseille and throughout France, that is to say, on both sides of the demarcation line. There were also other deportations, notably of Gypsies.

The infamy of the Vel d'Hiv was part of an undertaking that had no precedent and cannot be compared to anything: the Holocaust, the attempt to annihilate all the Jews of the European continent.

76,000 Jews from France were deported to extermination camps. Only 2,500 returned.

These women, these men, these children, could not have expected the fate that awaited them. They could not even imagine it. They had faith in France.

They believed that the country of the great Revolution, that the City of Light, would serve as their refuge. They loved the Republic with a passion inspired by gratitude. Indeed, it was in Paris, in 1791, under the Constituent Assembly, that, for the first time in Europe, Jews became full citizens. Later, others found in France a land of welcome, a chance for life, a promise of protection.

It is this promise and this trust that were trampled upon seventy years ago.

I want to recall the words that the Chief Rabbi of France, Jacob KAPLAN, addressed to Marshal PETAIN in October 1940, after the promulgation of the odious Jewish statute: "Victims, he wrote, of measures that affect our dignity as men and our honor as Frenchmen, we express our deep faith in the spirit of justice of eternal France. We know that the ties that bind us to the great French family are too strong to be broken."

There lies the betrayal.

Beyond time, beyond mourning, my presence this morning testifies to France's will to watch over the memory of its lost children and to honor these unburied dead, these beings whose only tomb is our memory.

This is the meaning of the demand posed by the Republic: that the names of these tortured souls do not fall into oblivion.

We owe the Jewish martyrs of the Vélodrome d'Hiver the truth about what happened seventy years ago.

The truth is that the French police, based on the lists it had drawn up itself, took charge of arresting the thousands of innocents trapped on July 16, 1942. It is that the French gendarmerie escorted them to the internment camps.

The truth is that not a single German soldier was mobilized for the entire operation.

The truth is that this crime was committed in France, by France.

The great merit of President Jacques CHIRAC is that he recognized this truth right here, on July 16, 1995.

"France," he said, "France, the homeland of Enlightenment and human rights, a land of welcome and asylum, France, on that day, committed the irreparable."

But the truth is also that the crime of the Vel d'Hiv was committed against France, against its values, against its principles, against its ideal.

Honor was saved by the Righteous, and beyond them by all those who knew how to rise against barbarism, by those anonymous heroes who, here, hid a neighbor; who, there, helped another; who risked their lives to spare those of the innocent. By all those French people who allowed three-quarters of the Jews of France to survive.

The honor of France was embodied by General de Gaulle, who stood up on June 18, 1940, to continue the fight.

The honor of France was defended by the Resistance, that army of shadows that did not resign itself to shame and defeat.

France was represented on the battlefields, with our flag, by the soldiers of Free France.

It was also served by Jewish institutions, such as the Oeuvre de secours aux enfants, which clandestinely organized the rescue of more than 5,000 children and welcomed orphans at Liberation.

Truth does not divide. It unites. It is in this spirit that this day of commemoration was instituted by François MITTERRAND, and that, under the government of Lionel JOSPIN, the Foundation for the Memory of the Shoah was created. It was under this same government, with Jacques CHIRAC, that the commission for the compensation of victims of anti-Semitic spoliations was established, whose aim was to repair what could still be repaired.

It is now my responsibility, in the chain of our collective history, to continue this common work of memory, truth, and hope.

It begins with transmission. Many drifts find their source in ignorance. We cannot resign ourselves to the fact that two out of three young French people do not know what the Vel d'Hiv roundup was.

The republican school, to which I express my confidence here, has a mission: to instruct, educate, teach the past, to make it known, to understand it, in all its dimensions. The Holocaust is included in the curriculum for CM2, 3rd grade, and 1st grade.

There must not be a single school, a single middle school, a single high school in France where it cannot be taught. There must not be a single establishment where this history is not fully heard, respected, and contemplated. There can be no, there will be no, lost memory for the Republic.

I will personally ensure this.

The challenge is to fight tirelessly against all forms of falsification of history. Not only against the outrage of denialism but also against the temptation of relativism. Transmitting the history of the Holocaust is indeed to teach its terrible uniqueness. This crime remains, by its nature, by its dimension, by its methods, by the frightening precision of its implementation, a unique abyss in the history of mankind. This uniqueness must be constantly recalled.

Transmitting this memory is finally to retain all its lessons. It is to understand how ignominy was possible yesterday, so that it may never resurface tomorrow.

The Holocaust did not arise from nothing nor come from nowhere. Certainly, it was implemented by the unprecedented and terrifying alliance of obstinacy in racist delirium and industrial rationality in execution. But it was also made possible by centuries of blindness, stupidity, lies, and hatred. It was preceded by multiple warning signs that did not alert consciences.

Our vigilance must never falter. No nation, no society, no person is immune to evil. Let us not forget this judgment of Primo LEVI about his persecutors: "With few exceptions, they were not monsters; they had our face." Let us remain alert, so that we can detect the return of monstrosity under its most innocuous appearances.

I know the fears expressed by some of you. I want to address them.

Aware of this history, the Republic will pursue with the greatest determination all anti-Semitic acts, but also all statements that could only lead the Jews of France to feel anxious in their own country.

Nothing in this matter is indifferent. Everything will be fought with the utmost energy. Silencing anti-Semitism, hiding it, explaining it, is already to accept it.

The safety of the Jews of France is not the concern of the Jews; it is the concern of all French people, and I intend for it to be guaranteed in all circumstances and in all places.

Four months ago, in Toulouse, children died for the same reason as those of the Vel d'Hiv: because they were Jewish.

Anti-Semitism is not an opinion; it is an abomination. For this, it must first be looked at squarely. It must be named and recognized for what it is. Wherever it unfolds, it will be unmasked and punished.

All ideologies of exclusion, all forms of intolerance, all fanaticisms, all xenophobias, which attempt to develop the logic of hatred, will find the Republic in their way.

Every Saturday morning, in all French synagogues, at the end of the service, the prayer of the Jews of France resounds, the one they address for the salvation of the homeland they love and wish to serve: "May France live happy and prosperous. May it be strong and great through unity and concord. May it enjoy lasting peace and maintain its spirit of nobility among the Nations."

This spirit of nobility is one that all of France must be worthy of.

To teach the historical truth tirelessly, to scrupulously ensure respect for the values of the Republic, to constantly recall the demand for religious tolerance, within the framework of our secular laws, to never yield on the principles of freedom and dignity of the person, to always promote the promise of equality and emancipation. These are the measures we must collectively set for ourselves.

It is by thinking of the lives that could not be fulfilled, of these children deprived of a future, of these destinies cut short prematurely, that we must elevate the demands of our own existences to an even higher level. It is by refusing indifference, negligence, and complacency that we will become stronger together.

It is by being lucid about our own history that France, thanks to the spirit of concord and unity, will best carry its values, here and everywhere in the world.

Long live the Republic!

Long live France!