Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the economic development of the audiovisual sector, in Paris on October 2, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

2 October 2014 · Statement on the economic development of the audiovisual sector · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the CSA and audiovisual sector leaders in Paris on October 2, 2014, outlining the economic and regulatory future of French audiovisual.
Main themes
Audiovisual sector regulation, CSA independence, pluralism and cultural diversity, French audiovisual industry, digital disruption, Francophonie, public broadcasting, freedom of expression, creator rights, economic development, media and democracy
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,027
76th percentile
Sentences
158
82nd percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
2.95
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
30th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 29%29%
  • Social 28%28%
  • Economic 25%25%
  • Technological 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

158 sentences in 63 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen of the Parliament,

Ladies and gentlemen members of the Higher Council for Audiovisual Affairs,

Ladies and gentlemen distinguished personalities who contribute to what our audiovisual sector is today and what it can be tomorrow,

I would like to first acknowledge the institution; that is the purpose of my presence here, at the CSA, which plays a major role in upholding pluralism - that is its function - but also in regulating the audiovisual system.

That is why I wanted to strengthen its independence. I do not mean to say that it was not independent before. This institution was independent, but its powers of appointment for the presidents of public broadcasting had been removed, to the benefit of the sole President of the Republic.

The law of November 15, 2013, allowed the CSA to exercise this competence once again. I affirm here that the executive does not intervene in any of its decisions, I say none. This applies both to the power of appointment, which has been returned to you, and to the various choices you can make when you are seized.

In the same spirit, the law has also tightened the composition of the Council and its power of sanction has been strengthened. The CSA is now endowed with what is called legal personality, which means for those who are not yet specialists, that the State is now distinct from this Council or the Council distinct from the State.

These advances, which are democratic advances, I cannot imagine could be called into question tomorrow or the day after.

The law has also allowed the CSA to better take into account economic balances in the exercise of its prerogatives. Its second mission, beyond upholding pluralism, is to understand what the French audiovisual system can become.

However, this system has been profoundly disrupted in just a few years. By techniques, by habits, by new competitions. Never have we watched so many images, on so many screens. Not just in France, but in all countries, it is now series, films, and videos posted on the Internet that nourish imaginations and shape emotions.

Public life has also changed, profoundly changed. Today, an opinion becomes information, the hierarchy itself has disappeared. An image can overshadow a discourse, so I take a risk today. Videos, alas, we have seen the demonstration, can also be weapons.

Faced with this profusion of sources and content, the purposes of regulation touch on the essential. It is always about defending freedom, thus pluralism, ensuring the promotion of cultural diversity - to which we are particularly attached - supporting creators, and protecting minors, in a context that is much more difficult to grasp.

But regulation must also focus on the future of an economic sector that has always been an area of excellence in France. I want to acknowledge here all those who contribute to it.

For several decades, an original and dynamic audiovisual offering has indeed been built up, which fully participates in the growth and influence of France.

The sector represents nearly 15 billion in added value, 30 billion if we also want to combine the indirect effects, which amounts to about 500,000 jobs. For this reason alone, the audiovisual sector deserves to be regulated as an essential economic activity and as a factor of influence.

Moreover, France is fortunate; it has wonderful talents: producers, actors, technicians, broadcasters, distributors, and even operators who have been built up, sometimes for a long time, sometimes more recently, and who are now of European size. We are one of the few countries to have these operators.

The challenge is also the French language. Francophonie has always had a particular dimension in audiovisual. This has always been a goal even if external audiovisual has gone through many vicissitudes, before now experiencing many successes. But this dimension of Francophonie has taken on another scale, as we are in a globalized system where ideas and images, and thus languages, must also circulate.

One of France's strengths, beyond its creators, operators, industrialists, producers, and managers of audiovisual systems, is that it has never opposed industry to culture, having thought that culture needed an industrial vector and that the French industry in audiovisual could not lose its cultural character. This is how we have been able to develop our cinema, maintain a market share, one of the strongest in Europe. This is how we have been able to keep independent production, and it is also how, not without difficulty, we can preserve the rights of authors - I say not without difficulty given what is happening.

This success is the result of a long political, administrative, and economic construction. Public policies were needed to protect works. Financial solidarity was needed to encourage creation. A framework was needed to regulate the activity of broadcasters. A public audiovisual service was needed so that there could be alongside the market a number of norms that could themselves be transposable or disseminable.

But this system, as I said, is today being put to the test. First, there is the economic situation with overall advertising revenues declining, which will also require a number of evolutions.

There is the fragmentation of audiences on television, which is now changing listening habits and thus the relationship to advertising. There are changes in practices among young people, and there is competition from advertising on the Internet.

To the digitization of broadcasting has been added a profound change in usage: new services but also globalized operators who first entered and then imposed themselves. I do not forget the platforms that offer programs, websites, search engines, recommendation services, in short, a whole new system.

The cinema hall, fortunately, the television set, the radio have not disappeared, but eyes are now forming on other objects: on tablets, computers, phones. In short, viewers have become spectators, meaning not just in front of the television; they seek out what they want to see, where they want, at the time they like, and on one of the supports they have chosen. We will call this freedom, but it also changes the entirety of what the regulatory system can be.

What are the risks now that we know there are new usages and new modes of distribution? What are the risks? The abuse of dominant position: those who have access can have the content, can prioritize information, can absorb all the value. This is a first risk. It is considerable, especially for our own economy, for France, for Europe.

What is the second risk? It is tax inequity. Some establish themselves far away but broadcast here without having the same obligations. The risk is also that content is progressively absorbed by access providers. We therefore have the obligation to redefine the rules.

The rules, first at the European level, is the fight for cultural exception. We will be told: "Really, the French, you always have the same words, the same demands, and you have let your turn pass." I heard this debate at the time of the negotiation, where there is still negotiation between Europe and the United States for trade.

Know well that cultural exception is not a French fight. It is a fight that many European countries share and understand, because there are issues that go well beyond simply the singularity of what we can represent. It is the right to creation, it is the right to works, the specificity that means that audiovisual or creation should not be considered as a commodity like any other.

This fight has been won for a time - I say for a time - because we must remain vigilant. The new commission will have to continue the negotiation work. But cultural exception has meant that audiovisual and cinema have been excluded from the scope of negotiation.

The second fight is to make knowledge and thus in a certain way digital and audiovisual a priority for Europe. It is a German commissioner who will take care of digital. I think it is a good decision. Because with our German friends, we are aware that digital must be a major issue.

Earlier, I received the Finnish Prime Minister. The Finns are also very attached to having a digital policy at the European level and that we can have leaders in digital at the European level. We must therefore make it a priority, and I have no doubt that in the 300 billion euros that Mr. Juncker announced, of which we do not know very well whether they are private or public - I believe they are both - of which we do not know very well the source, we will see! But let us keep the figure of 300 billion, of which a good part can be allocated or directed towards audiovisual, culture, creation, and education.

We also need to harmonize and coordinate our action at the European level. In this regard, we will need to review the directive applicable to audiovisual media services.

They are based on foundations that date back to 2007, barely revised in 2010. We are in 2014, and I would say everything has changed.

We must therefore review this directive. France will soon send its proposals to the new Commission so that there can be the same rules that can be imposed. Hence the importance I attach to the coordination you have initiated, that is to say, the fact that there is now a network of audiovisual regulatory authorities in Europe, of which you are the President, Mr. Olivier Schrameck.

It is on the fiscal issue that, as often, we must be the most pressing. Digital companies established elsewhere must be subject to the same tax regime as historical operators as soon as they broadcast in the same locations.

We have already made a number of progress. For example, in terms of VAT, the destination country rule will replace the country of establishment next year. This may seem trivial, but it is already an essential point. This means that someone who may be established far away, their service will be subject to the taxation of the place where they broadcast, in this case, if it is in France, at the level of our country. This thus creates additional revenue and also allows other operators to be placed on the same competitive footing.

This is a first step; I say it is insufficient, and France will propose, because we need to get into the details, that the notion of virtual establishment be preferred to that of stable establishment, because we have seen that there were some possibilities for evasion. In short, operators who act in the same market must be able to operate within a common and coherent framework. That is for Europe.

France, too, must evolve its own regulation. However, we have several authorities, the CSA, ARCEP, the Competition Authority - I salute its President - and all have to intervene at some point.

We also need to look at the compartmentalization that exists due to past modes of operation between producers, broadcasters, and distributors, and I think there is - and that was the purpose I imagine of your gathering today - a need to build an alliance between these different professions: producers, broadcasters, and distributors.

The ongoing reform of the production decrees will go in this direction: to promote alliances. It is, moreover, essential to better articulate the rules applicable to audiovisual and telecommunications, as they can no longer be thought of separately.

Likewise, creation, to be financed, cannot simply ask the television channels to do it. Since television channels are no longer the only mode of distribution. There are, I am not telling anyone anything new, other operators coming in. The new distribution systems, platforms, applications, but also connected televisions must be included in the same way in this principle so that all those who broadcast have, ultimately, the same obligations.

To define this new regulation, the legislator, I salute here the parliamentarians, will have to define a foundation of strategic objectives. What do we want to do? Where do we want to go? How should we think about regulatory systems? In the meantime, we must also ensure that the applicable norms are alive, taking into account the diversity of situations.

The CSA, through its competencies, through its mode of intervention, can play this role provided it develops its market analysis capabilities - I believe it is working on this - that it promotes conciliations - this is not always easy - that it becomes a place of dialogue and consultation, and that it can even, if necessary, resolve a number of disputes.

There are subjects of common interest between ARCEP and CSA. They are necessarily linked to the evolution of technologies, which are increasingly numerous, with economic actors developing in both telecommunications and audiovisual sectors.

It is inconceivable to deny the specificity of each sector or the different subjects, which therefore require specific mechanisms. But it is also time to evolve our regulation towards integration, as has been done in other European countries.

I have therefore asked the relevant ministers, the Minister of Culture and the Minister of Digital, to quickly make proposals on this transformation so that we can engage in a debate.

As for the license fee itself, it is the subject of many questions. The mere possession of a television set cannot be excluded from this reflection since one can watch public service channels on instruments other than television. So, I reassure you, the objective is not to increase revenues; the finance law provides for an increase of 3 euros. The goal is a constant yield and for there to be a broader and fairer base (note that the press has already picked up this morning: "without it costing anyone anything more"). I believe this is part of what the evolution of the system should be.

I want to conclude, as everyone will understand, by emphasizing the particular responsibility of public audiovisual without exempting other channels or all other operators from their own responsibilities or roles.

The audiovisual sector must embody both a reference point and a driving force, particularly in the financing of works. This is the case. I remind you that public service finances 60% of the contribution of television channels to works, 40% for cinema. This implies that the State must have a vision of what public service should be. It is the CSA that, in the first half of 2015, will appoint the future leader of France Télévisions. Before that, the State will need to express its strategic vision, its fundamental objectives, particularly regarding the arrival of digital technology.

Why do we need a powerful and dynamic public and private audiovisual sector? Because it is our wealth, because this plurality is ultimately what can make us even more radiant today.

We first need an audiovisual sector that can widely and effectively and securely broadcast. This is the challenge of transferring the 700 MHz band to the telecommunications sector. The State will ensure that the available resource for audiovisual is guaranteed.

The timeline is now set since ARCEP will launch the procedure for frequency allocation as early as next year, and this deadline is imperative as far as I am concerned.

Ladies and gentlemen, I will conclude.

Let us never forget, beyond what we have addressed, namely the economic development of this sector called audiovisual, that the challenge is also to make it what it is: a communication tool, a link in an increasingly fragmented society. It is the images, it is the words, it is the programs, it is the creations that create the link in a society.

Your role is not to add fragmentation to fragmentation, segmentation to segmentation, narcissism to narcissism, disintegration to disintegration. The role, but no one imposes it on you, everyone must measure what they have to do: it is to create links, it is to create unity, not simply in relation to information, that is not the essence, but in relation to what constitutes a common culture.

The challenge of audiovisual is to be able, thanks to this diversity, to offer quality programs, to open citizens to sources of knowledge, discovery, and information.

Audiovisual is therefore an economic challenge. We have seen it, and we must be mobilized regarding what is a source of jobs and wealth creation and also competitiveness on a global scale. But it is also a civic, cultural, and republican challenge.

What is at stake is that in France we can continue to produce works, works that bring people together, that spark debate, that also embody the creators' view of the world.

What is at stake is France's influence everywhere in the world, producing so that others see us. Producing so that our culture is shared by others. We are completely open here; we welcome all the works of the world, all the series of the world. We live in a time of events occurring across the Atlantic, but we receive them with kindness, sometimes even with admiration given the quality of these programs. At the same time, our role is also to demonstrate that our culture can also be a reference.

What is at stake - and I know that CSA is attentive to this - is our ability to live together, to communicate together through a shared community of values, a diversity of expressions. This requires that through programs, through works, through information, we represent all of society, all talents, and therefore the entire population.

A few days ago, I was in a place in Bondy where a young person said: "I no longer watch television because it never talks about me, and when it does talk about me, it is not necessarily the image I would like it to convey of me, my neighborhood, my city, my situation, my future."

The role of all channels, of all operators, is to speak for everyone, in what can indeed be legitimate questions to ask when they are also successes, excellences. It is this that makes us together and allows us to represent all talents and all of society. It is this democratic ambition that must guide our audiovisual policy.

Thank you.