Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the fight against poverty, in Paris on February 14, 2017.

France François Hollande · President of France

14 February 2017 · Anniversary session of the fight against poverty, before the Economic, Social and Environmental Council · Economic, Social and Environmental Council, Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Economic, Social and Environmental Council in Paris on the 30th anniversary of Father Wresinski's landmark 1987 opinion on extreme poverty.
Main themes
Fight against poverty, social exclusion and precariousness, income inequality, Father Wresinski and ATD Fourth World legacy, inclusive society, human dignity and citizenship, social experimentation and reform, redistribution systems, housing and employment policy, solidarity-based development
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,978
75th percentile
Sentences
123
73rd percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 63%63%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

123 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council,

Ladies and Gentlemen Councilors,

I am once again before your assembly for an anniversary, an event, but also a determination: to fight against poverty in a society like ours, considered, rightly or wrongly, as rich.

I come before you, and this is not the first time; it is undoubtedly the assembly I have attended the most often. It must be said, too, that since I cannot go before others, I have taken refuge with you.

What is perhaps most troubling in our contemporary societies is this precariousness, this doubt about our redistribution systems, this difficulty, despite growth and whatever its pace, in reducing inequalities. How can we ensure that our devices, our mechanisms, our public decisions can not only generate progress but also reduce as much as possible what is an indignity, that is to say, the fact of being in a form of exclusion?

Thirty years ago, on February 11, 1987, the Economic and Social Council adopted the opinion "Extreme Poverty and Economic and Social Precarity" presented by Father WRESINSKI - he would die a year later, and for him, it was the culmination of a struggle: the one he had undertaken on behalf of ATD Fourth World.

Your assembly had indeed honored itself by addressing this issue and being able to come together beyond the sensitivities of one another. When we reread the opinion drafted by Father WRESINSKI, it strikes with its conciseness, clarity, and simplicity, as if he wanted to get to the essence, because it is essential to fight against poverty. It was more than an opinion; it was an exhortation, a call. A call to make the fight against extreme poverty a priority and to place this commitment under the sign of dignity and citizenship, and even of the spirit of resistance.

The term "inclusive society" is not yet mentioned in this text, but already all the elements of this concept are gathered. It thus calls to "cross a new threshold on the path to a more solidarity-based development within our society."

This message is so strong that it will be engraved a few months later on the Parvis des Libertés des Droits de l'Homme, at Trocadéro, on October 17, 1987, with this phrase: "Where men are condemned to live in misery, human rights are violated. To unite to have them respected is a sacred duty." This is still ours today.

This opinion is essential because it marks a date.

It marks a date first by its method. Because this work mobilized not only statisticians, who have long tried to define what poverty is, but also concrete testimonies, monographs of neighborhoods and families; it provoked direct encounters with people in situations of great fragility. These testimonies expressed the mutual aid existing in these social environments, but also the feeling of confinement and the weight of external gazes that the most precarious experience. The analysis is lucid: "Negative factors often attract more attention than positive factors such as the willingness of parents to work and see their children succeed in school so that they can have a better life." J. WRESINSKI wanted to emphasize these positive factors because there is a form of light in the eyes of the poor, a form of pride - not of being poor, but of wanting to get out of this situation. The poor do not want to remain poor. They do not get used to poverty. They do not seek poverty. They seek to escape it.

There were also visits, to prepare this report, that were extremely powerful, notably one that was organized in Noisy-le-Grand where, thirty years earlier, Geneviève de GAULLE-ANTHONIOZ had gone with Father WRESINSKI to meet 250 families crammed into shacks. She had understood that the ghosts she had seen in a previous life, that of deportation, were resurfacing from her past. She had seen the same looks, from those who are hungry, who are cold, who are afraid, and at the same time, the same hopes through outstretched hands; and also the will to be united and together.

This opinion proposes a pragmatic reform method that goes through experimentation. It was to know great success. Today, for example, the guarantee against unpaid child support, the youth guarantee, the "Zero long-term unemployed" territories, the "Housing First" programs, or supported employment for people with disabilities owe much to experimentation, as your opinion had foreseen.

This report also marks a date by the principles it establishes. First, the necessity of addressing the problem of precariousness in its entirety, through education, employment, training, income, family support, health, housing, culture. Not a policy, not actions, but a whole, which implies close coordination among actors. The second principle is to ensure that the most precarious populations can be accompanied towards common rights, that there is not one right for the poor and one right for others, but the same right for all, with the will to have the same access to essential services. The third principle is the participation of the people concerned in the policies that affect them.

This opinion has inspired many public policies.

First, as you recalled, Mr. President, it mentioned the establishment of a resource floor in the form of a differential monthly allowance granted within the framework of an integration process. In fact, it was the invention of the Minimum Insertion Income. A few months later, it was established by the government of Michel ROCARD with the law of December 1, 1988.

The opinion also recommended the use of voluntary civil service. Again, it foreshadowed civic service and the unprecedented scale it was given, notably under the impetus of François CHEREQUE, whose memory I salute here.

There was also another concept, another right that was affirmed, that of "access for all to housing." This was the subject of the Besson law in 1990 with the Housing Solidarity Funds and, later, the massive development of housing assistance for millions of households, then the creation of the enforceable right to housing, which was also included in the opinion of the Economic and Social Council.

There was also the call for the "generalization of coverage of health expenses," which again found its translation in the Universal Health Coverage in 1999, and then in the successive improvements of complementary health coverage.

Finally, this opinion contained the idea of an orientation law to combat exclusions. This law came into being in 1998, and it was Geneviève de GAULLE-ANTHONIOZ who presented it herself during the debate in the National Assembly. She invited all deputies of all sensitivities to vote for this text. Its first article, which still obliges us today, makes this struggle "a national imperative based on the respect for the equal dignity of human beings." This text has three titles: access to rights, prevention of exclusions, and coordination of social institutions. Its relevance remains intact today.

So, where do we stand today, in 2017?

There is still a poverty that has settled, which has, alas, for a number of our compatriots, expanded and worsened. There is also a precariousness that is not only that of work but also that of housing and sometimes that of access to energy. Energy precariousness is perhaps one of the most difficult to resolve, and one of the most difficult to live with.

What have we done so that we can rightfully claim the legacy of what this opinion has left us?

Basic health insurance is now universal; this means that it is based on only one criterion: the criterion of regular residence; thus, any person who lives in France regularly can access Social Security. The third-party payment system is in place for 15 million patients, and its generalization will be completed by the end of the year. I know there are still difficulties or concerns, but we must do it.

The redistribution carried out by our social system has strengthened over the past five years, particularly for modest families: thanks to the revaluation of benefits dedicated to them, thanks to the development of childcare services for very young children - this was an important point in the 1987 opinion - and also by making parental support a full-fledged mode of intervention and improving support for autonomy, particularly for families facing the disability of one of their members.

The multiannual plan against poverty, which benefits several million very modest households, has allowed for the revaluation of numerous benefits, including the RSA, which will have increased by 10% in five years. Special attention has been given to single-parent families, which we know are the most subjected to constraints and, alas, the most affected by poverty. This commitment is reflected in the establishment of assistance for the recovery of child support and in the creation of the activity bonus, which benefits two and a half million households, in nearly half of the cases being single women, often with children to support.

I was this morning in Aubervilliers to evaluate the Youth Guarantee. These young people under 25 who are neither in employment nor in training, who have no qualifications and who expect much more than a benefit, much more than a counter, who want to be accompanied towards employment. This has already been done for 100,000 of them with this Youth Guarantee, which will be generalized throughout the territory for all young people who wish to engage in it. It consists of providing training, a qualification, a housing solution, an allowance of over 400 euros, and also an apprenticeship towards citizenship.

Poverty is often a youth poverty. They are the ones most confronted with the difficulty of gaining autonomy and thus succeeding in life. In certain neighborhoods, this situation can lead to doubts about the Republic, can lead to the belief that there are ultimately no fundamental rights for those who live there. Hence the importance of fighting against poverty, to fight for citizenship - the link is direct. All those who suffer must think that they are first and foremost citizens, and that through citizenship, they can rise and be supported above what their condition is today.

Father WRESINSKI insisted on housing. The State since 2012 has equipped itself with new legal, economic, and fiscal means to restart the production of social housing and even very social housing - it is restarting - to ensure a fairer distribution of this offer across the territory and a faster allocation of these homes to the most deprived. The same goes for emergency accommodation: our reception capacities will have increased by half over the five-year term, averaging 10,000 more accommodation places per year, and this is still insufficient to meet the needs of the most deprived and refugees in the context of the migration crisis.

Finally, I would like to pause on a chapter of the report presented by Father WRESINSKI thirty years ago, in a prophetic manner: it is the attention paid, among the deprivations associated with extreme precariousness, to the fact of "not being able to acquire new knowledge." Being poor also means not being able to access training, information, and qualification. Here is what the opinion of the Economic and Social Council said thirty years ago: "In a changing society like ours, where it is necessary to develop to the maximum the capacities for initiative and creation, training and adaptation of all, everyone must have the means of existence allowing them to prepare for their future and that of their children. Not being a burden on others is not enough. It is also necessary to be able to make one's human capital fruitful, otherwise, one risks seeing one's social and cultural exclusion worsen over time."

These words have lost none of their strength, and this issue is crucial. That is why I wanted to place particular emphasis, during this five-year term, on vocational training, with the creation of the Personal Training Account and then the Personal Activity Account, which will be a fundamental right, which is the right for every worker to increase and evolve their qualifications, to change activities, and also to organize their work more freely throughout their life. It is an opportunity for the employee; it is also an asset for businesses and for our entire economy. Because this sum of skills, talents, "human capital," to use Father WRESINSKI's words, is what makes the collective success of a country. Exclusion is, of course, first and foremost a wound, a pain for the people concerned, but it is also a tremendous waste for the country as a whole.

So let us be aware, and this is the meaning of the event you are organizing today, of the obstacles that remain to be overcome: the progression since the 2008 crisis of the feeling of social downgrading that affects some of those who work and who do not feel they are receiving a fair return for their efforts, which makes them doubt their abilities and their future. There is this insidious image of "welfare dependency" that tends to blame the most vulnerable; today, this thesis is stated, and there is a kind of presumption of guilt that strikes the most precarious. Finally, there is the allure of false freedoms - for example, the freedom to choose one's health coverage on the market - and the allure of false solutions - retreating behind one's borders, forgetting European solidarity, rejecting the Other, or even a form of discrimination that, from insidious, would end up being provocative.

That is why we must always resume not only reflection but especially action; we must consider that no system should be maintained simply because it was created several years ago; we must consider that all our mechanisms must be continuously revised to be more effective; that it is not enough to organize collective redistribution but that we must provide personal support for the most vulnerable; that our social system cannot be confused with benefits, that it is much more than that, that it is an organization of responsibilities, of access to information and knowledge, that we have individual rights within a collective framework. The most vulnerable have rights, and these rights are primarily their own.

All of this can be summed up in one word: dignity. This dignity that is recognized when we appeal to intelligence - which is not the case for everyone, as one can also appeal to stupidity, one can even sometimes be applauded by stupidity, but it is better to be supported by intelligence and to support intelligence. This dignity that is recognized when we refuse simplistic solutions: I refuse to distinguish patients according to their wealth, to send the job seeker or the homeless person back to their personal responsibility; I refuse to let our mode of production remain frozen when we must constantly evolve our capacity to create wealth. This dignity that is recognized when we reform the School to give every student every chance of success, when we improve access to culture, to mastery of the French language, especially for the most vulnerable, because it is their first passport to being a citizen.

I also believe that we must be very attentive to equality between women and men because, even if everyone can be affected by precariousness, it is always women who pay the highest price. Human dignity also means considering that the planet is not for the benefit of some but is our common heritage. Human dignity finally means this capacity for initiative that civil society has, including the most modest who want to take their full part.

If there is a necessity for public authorities to be the most engaged in reducing poverty, precariousness, and inequalities, we also need social partners to build a more supportive society, because it is also in the workplace that paths to success are forged.

We need the commitment of each and every one. There are high school students here who have come because they want to be involved. They have an essential responsibility. It is up to them to seize what other generations have built before them, notably Social Security, collective rights, but also the school of the Republic. It is up to them, to these high school students, to this new generation, to conceive what tomorrow's solidarity will be.

I count on the economic and social forces represented here, on their capacity for dialogue and compromise. There are still possibilities for negotiation, including until the end of the five-year term and even beyond. And I count on these forces to produce better, because that will be the challenge of the coming years: to be able to make the best use of technologies, the energy transition, skills, to equip our country with all the conditions to ensure its success.

I count on these forces to create more jobs. We have shown that even with a growth rate that is not as high as we might have imagined, it was possible to create jobs thanks to everyone's efforts.

I count on these economic and social forces to reduce inequalities, which widen the gaps between generations, between neighborhoods, between individuals.

I believe that economic and social forces also have the capacity to create this ideal of progress in our society. Progress, that is the word that must be placed opposite poverty. It is an ongoing debate. Does progress alone allow for the reduction of poverty? No, it requires human will. But there is no reduction of poverty without progress, and it is this ideal of progress that we must continue to carry: human progress, social progress, ecological progress, economic progress. This is also the message that thirty years ago Father WRESINSKI and all those who adopted this report wanted to convey to the society they could know. Ours has a duty to continue this message through the actions undertaken.

Thank you for this event. I salute the Economic, Social and Environmental Council. I will miss you.

Thank you.