Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the government's policy in favor of local authorities, in Paris on November 20, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

20 November 2012 · Congress of Mayors of France · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Congress of Mayors of France in Paris on November 20, 2012, outlining government policy toward local authorities and decentralization.
Main themes
Local authorities policy, decentralization, state-municipality relations, pact of trust, mayors' roles and challenges, marriage for all legislation, freedom of conscience, municipal finances, democratic governance, territorial diversity, republican unity, secularism and equality
Duration
~42 min
91st percentile
Words
5,071
91st percentile
Sentences
268
94th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%43%
  • Economic 30%30%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

268 sentences in 64 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Mr. President of the Senate,

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Mr. President of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council,

Ladies and gentlemen members of the Government,

Mr. Mayor of Paris, whom I greet for his hospitality and solidarity - he has demonstrated it here,

Mr. President of the Association of Mayors of France, I thank you for your welcoming words, your questions and your concerns that you express on behalf of all the elected officials, whom I also want to thank for their presence.

The Congress of Mayors of France is always an event anticipated by many and dreaded by others. It depends on the times... An important event due to the breadth of the issues addressed that concern the daily lives of our fellow citizens, but also due to the quality and number of elected officials gathered.

This moment is always set within a political, economic, and financial context. This is still true today, with a change of government, a new administration, a crisis that endures, and a social distress that we observe, regardless of our level of responsibility. Our necessity is to take courageous measures and to face the challenges.

Who better to address the issues of our country than the mayors of France? I want to align myself with a tradition, that of the presence of the President of the Republic at your congress. But I also want to establish a relationship of trust that is essential between the State and the elected officials of the Nation.

You embody France in all its diversity, that of cities, that of villages, that of metropolitan areas, that of the suburbs of the Hexagon, but also of the overseas territories. You represent France of all sensitivities, of all convictions, of all commitments. But you are also those who contribute to the unity of the Republic.

You mentioned, Mr. President, the subject of the bill on marriage for all. I am aware of the debates it generates - they are legitimate in a society like ours. Mayors are representatives of the State. They will have, if the law is passed, to implement it. But I also say - hearing you - that possibilities for delegation exist. They can be expanded. There is always the freedom of conscience. My conception of the Republic applies to all areas. In a way, it is secularism, it is equality: the law applies to all, while respecting the freedom of conscience.

I have served, as you recalled, as mayor. I was the mayor of a capital city - Tulle - in a department, Corrèze. I experienced for several years - a seven-year term, as the law allowed - the joy because it is a joy to be a mayor. An indefinable bond unites a territory, regardless of its size, a population, regardless of its number, and the elected official who represents them. You can be proud of this mandate. At the same time, I know all the vicissitudes and pains when a business closes. I know the distress that a mayor feels when he receives men and women who can no longer cope. And then also all these questions about the finances of your local authorities.

From this experience, I have drawn several lessons. The first is that our democracy needs the municipality. The second is that our Republic is honored when it recognizes the irreplaceable role of elected officials. You give a lot of your time with dedication and competence. What you receive in return is priceless, not valued on a market, not assessed by an agency. What you receive is the beautiful and great feeling of being useful to others.

But your task is becoming increasingly difficult. Being a mayor today means providing services for the population - which is becoming increasingly demanding due to the crisis. Being a mayor today means managing a team and handling conflicts - at the same time, you don’t need to be a mayor to experience this! Being a mayor today means applying increasingly complex, increasingly constraining, and increasingly changing regulations. Being a mayor today means assuming a responsibility that is not only political - that is legitimate - but also legal and sometimes criminal.

That is why energy and goodwill - which I imagine all the heads of state before me have rightly nourished you with - are not enough. You expect the President of the Republic to respond to your questions. I intend to establish before you a pact of trust between the State and local authorities for the years to come.

First, the time has come to give our territories a new framework through a stage of decentralization. Thirty years after the Deferre law, a great law of the Republic, the State has undeniably changed, and our territories have been transformed by decentralization. But over time, new forms of tutelage have reappeared - calling into question the transferred competencies - and especially a subtle way of circumventing the principle of free administration of local authorities through a multiplication of rules. You experienced the time of the central State - it was rich. Today, the State is poorer and may be tempted to decide in place of the local authorities.

Decentralization must therefore regain clarity and coherence. Clarity is what our fellow citizens demand of us; it is to be simple and understood in the distribution of competencies between the State and the local authorities and between the levels of administration themselves. That is why public action - and this will be in the next decentralization law - will address the idea of blocks of competencies but will also define the role of lead authorities and promote, territory by territory, consultations between local authorities to act, in each area, as effectively as possible. The generalization of service organization schemes will also be provided.

Coherence means engaging in a reform of local taxation, putting an end to certain perverse effects - which we see today - of the reform of the business tax. Because the property tax on businesses, as it has been planned, has resulted in some agglomerations where merchants do not understand the charges imposed on them, which had not been foreseen when the reform of the business tax was presented. I do not want a new misunderstanding to arise. The State will therefore have to correct - and the concerned local authorities as well - so that there are no additional charges on a number of businesses, especially the smallest ones.

In general, I am committed to a principle that is to encourage municipalities and intermunicipalities - what you call the communal block - to take advantage of business installations when there is an effort to bring them in. I am therefore committed to ensuring that we can localize part of the local resource in relation to what local responsibility should be. I am also committed to a principle - which I enforce at the State level during this period of very great economic difficulties - which is the stability of tax rules, particularly with regard to SMEs. This principle must apply everywhere, for the State as well as for local authorities.

The new stage of decentralization that the government will initiate must also lay the foundations for a code of good conduct between the State and the municipalities. You will tell me this goes without saying; but it is always better if we write it down! The State must refrain from creating all sorts of local commissions. They have become so numerous that the departmental associations of mayors can no longer find enough elected officials to sit on them. And when they do find them, it is not certain that the commissions will meet.

The State must also put an end to all its centralized calls for projects in all areas and to its announcements without prior consultation. That is why I announced in October, on the occasion of the general states of the Senate, the creation of a High Council of Territories. This is not an additional institution; it is, on the contrary, a new organization of everything that exists today allowing for a real dialogue between the State and local authorities on all the subjects that concern us. The Association of Mayors of France will be fully engaged in this process and will play a prominent role. This High Council will bring together the committee of local finances and the advisory commission on standards. I announce here that elected officials will be able to directly refer to the High Council when a subject justifies it.

I have mentioned standards. A ritual subject of the Congress of Mayors of France, where every year - I imagine - the State commits with incantatory formulas! "Never again, always less"... But I also know that the weight of these standards has become unlivable: 400,000 is an unacceptable hindrance to initiative and competitiveness. Why in France does it take, on average, 184 days to build a warehouse when it takes 97 in Germany and 27 in the United States? I am not talking about construction time; I am talking about processing time. And if we processed faster, we would build more! I therefore propose to strengthen the advisory commission, to give it the power to rectify obsolete standards, to require a favorable opinion from it for any legislative text, because it is about acting on both the flow and the stock.

At the same time - I also want to clarify this, because it would be too easy to make this speech - we must preserve the requirements of safety and environment. But we can introduce more flexibility to achieve the same objective without it necessarily resulting in a prohibition, an injunction, or a sanction. Let us establish a simple principle: an impact study will necessarily accompany the creation of any new standard to assess the financial, material, and human costs associated with its application. This is a commitment I make, and I will respect it.

What is essential? In reality, beyond the standards, it is the financial question. You have raised it, and I do not want to evade it. France can no longer circumvent difficult decisions. We no longer have time - not because some agency obliges us to do so - simply because it is our credibility, because it is our future, because it is the strength of France that is at stake. We are all concerned.

The State, first of all, because it is the one that must set an example. This has been done for the preparation of the budget for 2013 at the initiative of Jean-Marc Ayrault, since spending in 2013 will be exactly the same - perhaps less - than that which will be observed at the end of 2012. This effort will also be required of local authorities since the allocation will also be stabilized. We all must make our decisions with awareness, in relation to the mandate we have received. You in relation to the future of your municipality - but your municipality is not separate from France! There are not the municipalities of France on one side and France on the other! We are all engaged in the same process.

But I did not come to preach to you, because - as Bertrand Delanoë recalled - local authorities are obliged to present balanced budgets and cannot borrow for purposes other than investment. They are therefore not responsible - and I declare this here - for the continuous increase in debt over the past decade. It is the State. It is the State through its spending, but it is also the State for not having rebalanced social security. We carry a debt of more than 135 billion euros for not having financed our social accounts, that is to say, for having paid out expenses for pensions, for health, for families without having the first euro to do so and borrowing to achieve it.

I am not seeking to pit one against the other either. We have to face the situation. We are not judging the past; we are acting for the future. If spending has increased for local authorities - I acknowledge this, and it goes well beyond the outgoing majorities; all are concerned - it is because of the State's disengagement. I also know that many municipalities in rural areas, but also others in what are called the suburbs, are in an untenable financial situation.

Finally, I know that the answer is not in the application of a blind, mechanical rule - that would be too convenient - such as the non-replacement of one out of two departures for territorial civil servants. An even more questionable rule has been mentioned. Some have even proposed to grant funding to local authorities only in proportion to the reduction of their spending, which would lead the most fragile territories to be the most penalized. How can we accept that?

But beyond these precautions, we must reduce public spending; this is the logic of the financial trajectory that has been presented to Parliament for the next five years: 50 billion in total, 10 billion per year. We will need to add what falls under the competitiveness pact. But when we look at the total public spending, it amounts to 57% of national wealth today compared to 52% five years ago. Are we living better today than we did five years ago, spending more?

It will also be necessary to understand the stakes: 10 to 12 billion euros to find each year - let us hope that growth returns as quickly as possible, that will help - that is 1% of public spending. Would we not be able - we, France - to achieve this?

But as you said, Mr. President, this can only be done through consultation and justice. Consultation is the idea of modernizing public action put forward by the Prime Minister. He will bring together the State, social partners, and local authorities to jointly seek, area of competence by area of competence, the necessary savings.

I have been elected in a municipality, a department, and even for a time in a region. I have been a deputy for a long time. The only mandate I lack - but it is too late - is that of senator. I will not take revenge on the Senate for that! We are all aware that there are duplications, redundancies, structural costs, and burdens related to procedures. We have mentioned the standards, the accumulation of which is very heavy for our public finances. We can move forward, but on the condition that we pool our resources, make better use of our assets, without compromising the quality and presence of public service.

This is the idea of a trust pact between the State and local authorities over several years. We will work on this. This pact will include not only allocations but also transferred charges and counterbalances. We can also discuss equalization because we must also bring about justice.

Justice is the fight against all inequalities. They are social, and they are also territorial. Moreover, they are reinforced because it is often in poor areas that there are also the most poor. That is why there was an exceptional effort for 2013, both for vertical equalization and for horizontal equalization, that is to say, the one you have consented to. 238 million euros more for equalization coming from the State through these allocations, but also an equalization in the communal block to which you have contributed fully.

We must reflect on the criteria, because it is the same for municipalities as for individuals; everyone is for equality, with a very particular conception of equality, considering that one must almost always receive almost as much as one has given. Well, no! But it is not a matter of stripping some to clothe others, and poorly. It is about properly setting the rules and evolving them always in consultation.

Justice is also the possibility for all municipalities, I say all municipalities, to access financing for their investments. However, today, for many of your municipalities, there is a difficulty in finding liquidity. This is all the more damaging as interest rates are low.

So how to explain this situation?

There is surely the timidity of banks, which are also constrained to apply prudential standards. There is the collapse of Dexia, which for me remains an enigma. How could the fund for local authorities, which became the Crédit local de France, sink while making toxic loans and subprimes? And today it is the States and ultimately local authorities that are asked to foot the bill! A malfunction of our financial system! A lack of vigilance! So yes, let us set up new structures. That is what you are asking for.

First, there is what needed to be done urgently. Thanks to the intervention of the Caisse des dépôts and the Banque postale, the 6 to 8 billion euros that were expected in the middle of the year have been provided. I thank these organizations.

But I want to go further: to find a solution for the replacement of Dexia, it will see the light of day in early 2013, with a Public Bank for Local Authorities established and supported by the Banque postale and the Caisse des dépôts. The Caisse des dépôts will make available, over the period 2013-2017, a budget of 20 billion euros for very long-term investments.

These 20 billion euros will be found thanks to what are called savings funds, themselves increased by raising the ceiling of the Livret A, which has provided us with exceptional resources. To finance public transport, distribution networks, water treatment, high-level digital infrastructure, local authorities will therefore be able to find support from the Caisse des dépôts, provided that interest rates are kept as low as possible - and here I ask the Ministry of Economy and Finance to be very attentive to this. It would be quite ironic to have mobilized resources and not lend them at acceptable levels for local authorities! So there will be additional financing.

But I know that there is a proposal that you have put forward with presidents of associations who are present here: a financing agency for local authorities. What would its interest be? To diversify sources of liquidity supply, to pool risks, to allow modest-sized municipalities to access financial markets - which is not possible today - to have particularly low interest rates... This is the challenge of the period. If we want to be credible, it is to have interest rates that are historically low.

Today there are questions following the intervention of a rating agency. We must take this into account, pursue our policy, maintain our course, and understand that we have every interest in restoring our public accounts and acting for competitiveness. Because it is what allows us today to have interest rates like we have not seen for years on sovereign debts. Even today, interest rates have not changed, and the gaps with German interest rates have remained exactly the same.

This is the credibility of France. That is why I want local authorities that wish to participate fully in this financing agency to take full advantage of historically low interest rates in financial markets, which will help lighten the burdens and thus contribute more easily to the balance of your accounts.

Since I am talking about finances, I will talk to you about education. Not to oppose education to finance, but because education is the great priority. I am speaking to mayors, and I know that a number of municipalities no longer have schools, and that this is always a pain. But the municipality is the republican school. So when I say that priority must be given to knowledge, to learning, to school, I know that here you understand me because it is a national issue, because we know well that competitiveness will be all the higher as we have succeeded in training, qualifying our young people and providing them with a future. If we are proud of a demographic trend that is the highest in Europe, it is because we have confidence in the school of the Republic. So we must give it the means. The State has done so through the budget allocated to it, through the necessary recruitment of teachers.

But there are reforms that are underway, particularly those concerning school rhythms. Again, I believe there is consensus. The four-and-a-half-day week that existed previously appears to be the solution for children, for their interest, for their development, so that there are both school activities but also homework support and cultural and sports awakening.

But I have also heard your remarks, Mr. President, on behalf of all elected officials. For some municipalities, it is an additional burden. It will be necessary to find premises, find staff, know what will be proposed for the children who will stay. You are therefore asking me for the reform to take time. If I were to give you too much time, there would be no reform. However, I agree with what you propose: this reform will be spread over two years. Municipalities that can, starting in the 2013 school year, participate in this movement will be able to do so and will indeed be supported. Others will take the necessary time so that we can, in consultation, succeed in this reform.

I have also asked the government to set up, starting next school year, a specific fund of 250 million euros to support local authorities that - when they are in a situation that justifies it - will implement this reform. I am thinking of rural municipalities and the most disadvantaged cities.

The Republic is its school, but it is also its public services that must find their place throughout French territory. Each territory, however, is specific. We must build together a response that meets the needs.

I will take two examples: security, police and gendarmerie personnel had fallen by 11,000 over the past five years. At the proposal of the Minister of the Interior, we have decided, the Prime Minister and I, to increase the personnel again. Increasing personnel means stopping the cuts and creating 500 more positions each year. Will we place them everywhere? No! We will allocate these additional resources where there are high crime rates, where there are efforts to be made in prevention, deterrence, and action, that is to say in priority security areas. I say this here in front of mayors who are not all in what we call cities: priority security areas also concern rural areas because, unfortunately, crime no longer distinguishes between the size of municipalities.

The second example is the fight against medical deserts. There are those that pertain to rural areas, with particular adaptations, but there are also rural deserts that must be compared to other deserts, which are the suburban deserts. We must put in place additional resources so that there are more doctors in these territories. This will already be the case in 2013: 200 territorial general practitioners will be recruited and assigned to these areas. These are not coercive measures; I do not believe in them: we cannot force a doctor to come to a territory, let alone a young doctor. We can convince them, we can encourage them, we can also change the remuneration model for doctors and ensure that when they settle in a territory, they are better paid because it is also a contribution to public health. Finally, but you are already doing this and the State will support you, there are health houses, and everything we can organize to promote the essential multidisciplinary approach.

I finally want to talk about the responsibility of the State in its expertise, because it still has some; you know those State officials who, through their excellence, can assist municipalities: the ATESAT, a mysterious name for the general public but well known to many elected officials here. Never have State officials been so requested by elected officials - this should please them - to the point that some are even recruited by intercommunalities. Unfortunately, this is the rule. I announce to you that the State will continue to make available to local authorities the skills of its technicians and engineers to assist you with the most complex projects.

I want to conclude on local democracy. Not to discuss the conclusions of Lionel Jospin's report on the non-cumulation of mandates - here you are not concerned, at least not all! - but to take up a proposal that has been so often announced, so often proclaimed, and so often postponed: the status of elected officials. I take responsibility for this because I have been sensitive to what has been reported to me once again during these general states. Elected officials must be able to be available, respected, and considered.

There is a bill that has been drafted at the initiative of Jacqueline Gourault and Jean-Pierre Sueur. It provides the elements of the response and possible reform: extending the benefit of the suspension of the employment contract for elected officials of municipalities with fewer than 10,000 inhabitants, the right to professional reintegration after two mandates, validation of acquired experience, training for elected officials... and also the idea of setting an allowance, no longer by municipality with rules that are currently too broad, but directly by law.

Elected officials do not ask for any privilege, no protection. They simply want to exercise their mandate in the service of their fellow citizens. And it is better to have clear rules; I say this to those who are not here, that is to say to all those who elected you and who elected me too - we must never forget those who allowed you to be in charge of a community or the country - if you want available elected officials, if you want respected elected officials, you must ensure that they also have a status.

Nothing is worse than suspicion or doubt. The State must take this initiative. Trust is about reminding - this has been done before me by both the Mayor of Paris and the President of the Association of Mayors of France - the attachment of our fellow citizens to the municipality as such. But you also know that the process of intercommunal cooperation is irreversible, it is desirable, it is necessary, provided that it is based, as has always been the case, on voluntarism. However, there must be sizes that allow for action and the carrying out of projects. Here too, we must have courage. We cannot simply define territories in relation to electoral issues. We must ensure that intercommunalities have the necessary size and at the same time these intercommunalities must not be a new local authority. The local authority is the municipality and the intercommunalities are public establishments.

There must be more than today a pooling of resources. It is unacceptable that there are creations of positions at the intercommunal level without the transfer of what exists at the level of the central municipality or the most important municipalities. We must accept these transfers, otherwise we are in an endless process.

But there is also a need for citizens to have control over their community elected officials. Hence the question that arises about what the mode of designation for community councilors should be. The proposal I made is that - at the time of municipal elections - community elected officials should be designated with one principle: each municipality must be represented in the intercommunal structure. I believe this is a good principle of clarity, representation, and at the same time democracy.

However, there are large intercommunalities, communities that are not all urban as they say but that are of the size required today by competition between territories. We must be at the European scale. That is why in the next decentralization law, the metropolitan fact will be recognized with - once again - a status that must be granted to these large cities of France without preventing municipal representation.

Ladies and gentlemen, I want to say these simple words to conclude my remarks. I wanted to convey a message here, that of trust, responsibility, and the essential unity if we want to rise to the challenges that lie ahead of us. France is France. There is not one side the State, on the other the local authorities, each living with its constraints, its priorities, and its objectives as if we were to be distrustful of one another, regardless of the national issue that unites us all.

What is this national issue? It is to know what will be the place of our country in the world and in Europe in 5 years, in 10 years - what will be its capacity to create jobs, to manage the energy transition, to meet the challenge of equality. Yes, what will be the fate of France? Many of our compatriots believe that we are in decline and that it would be inexorable. I have said it, decline is not the destiny of France. The destiny of France is to move forward, to lead the upcoming generation towards a better life than ours. We will only achieve this through unity.

Beyond what divides and separates us in democratic life - there is a need for large parties to provide choice - this unity requires clarity, respect, and solidarity. Here we are all aware of the efforts to be made. There will be efforts and I have not hidden them from you! But we can introduce innovations in all areas, in employment, in economic development, in competition... It is a pact of trust that the State offers you.

What I am sure of - because I have this experience as an elected official and because I have this responsibility that is mine today with the awareness of our History - is that a large part of our solutions lies in the territories and in your ability to mobilize all our strengths for the success of the country. It has always been this way that in the great moments of our republican life we have advanced. We will demonstrate this again because you, mayors of France, want to succeed and because it is my mission to advance France in all its diversity and with the ambition to give the upcoming generation the destiny it deserves. Thank you.