Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the government's policy in response to the economic and financial crisis, in Paris on April 17, 2013.

France François Hollande · President of France

17 April 2013 · Conference on the government's policy in response to the economic and financial crisis · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed an international economic conference in Paris on April 17, 2013, outlining France's response to the ongoing global financial and European sovereign debt crisis.
Main themes
Global economic and financial crisis, European sovereign debt crisis, austerity vs. growth policies, French budgetary recovery, financial deregulation, public debt reduction, economic inequality, international policy coordination, European recession, productive economic recovery
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,914
85th percentile
Sentences
218
91st percentile
Readability
56
80th percentile
Grade
9.8
18th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 52%51%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Geopolitical 16%16%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

218 sentences in 132 paragraphs

Mr. Secretary-General,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen ambassadors,

Dear Jean-Paul FITOUSSI,

Ladies and gentlemen,

A few words first, to thank you for the welcome you have extended to us on the occasion of this conference and also for the action your organization is taking, Mr. Secretary-General, to try to coordinate economic policies, which we need, to recommend good practices in economic policy, which we also need, and to allow member states to reflect on the best way to emerge from the crisis.

This is the question you are asking. When will we emerge from the crisis?

I must say that I am asking myself the same question because this crisis is long. It began in 2008 and has taken multiple forms over the past five years. Surely it must be named for what it is, namely, first and foremost, a crisis of deregulated finance. But it is no longer just that; it is also an economic crisis and therefore a political crisis.

The first act came from the United States with a banking sector that had arrogated all means, all powers, all instruments, to the detriment of savers and the productive sector, and with excesses that speculation had seized upon.

A financial system had thus developed outside the real economy, with its own references and its own standards, or should I say its absence of any standards.

Inequalities have widened, not just in the United States, but across all developed countries and even beyond. Inequalities that we have never known since the very history of capitalism.

The financial bubble thus at one point emerged and eventually burst.

The second act of this crisis is European.

With the sovereign debt crisis, markets discovered that they could increase the financing conditions of the states themselves, with another mechanism that also emerged, linking banks and states.

The fragility of one making the vulnerability of the other.

The third act, we are experiencing today, is the prolongation of the depression in Europe, through the continuation of austerity policies in countries that had been viewed as the most vulnerable.

Should I name them: Greece, but not only Greece, Ireland, Portugal, Spain, Italy. These policies have not been without effect; they have allowed these countries, under the best circumstances, to regain access to the markets. But these austerity policies, as long as they have not been compensated by stimulus policies in surplus countries in terms of current account, have caused a slowdown in the European economy, even a recession.

You know this observation, but it must be made. Otherwise, how can we make our peoples, our public opinions, understand what is happening?

The crisis, first financial, then budgetary, has become an economic crisis. To resolve it, we must address finance, which has indeed been engaged for several years, address the budgetary question, but also respond to the question of supporting the economy.

I have two strong convictions.

The first is that since this crisis is global, it can only be addressed globally, that is to say economically, socially, and politically.

The second conviction is that the outcome of this crisis will not be a return to the status quo ante, to the world before. We must therefore build another, a new world, the one you have inscribed in the program of your conference.

France must play its part in the construction of this new world.

To contribute to this, I will first focus on the economic policy that the government of Jean-Marc AYRAULT has been conducting for eleven months.

I have set a goal: the productive and budgetary recovery of France, with three main principles of action.

The first is the gradual return to balance in public accounts. Not for some theoretical reason or obstinacy, but simply because as Head of State, I cannot leave the burden of debt on future generations. That would be irresponsible, blind.

I recall a few figures regarding France. Ten years ago, the public deficit, which was already considered too high, represented 1.6% of national wealth, and the debt was around 57% of GDP. Today, I should say in 2012, the deficit was nearly 5.2% in 2011. It will be 4.8% in 2012. The public debt represents 1.8 trillion euros, over 90%. If nothing is done, we will be at 100% in the coming years. I refuse that.

Hence the policy of budgetary seriousness, but which must also set itself objectives, and therefore not undermine the recovery of growth that we must promote and stimulate.

That is why the solution to this crisis is not austerity; it is credibility, it is sustainability, it is stability.

It is in this perspective that the government will present to the European Commission and before that to the French Parliament the program to restore balance to our public accounts in the medium term.

I recall the efforts we have already made over the past year.

Just for the years 2012 and 2013, the reduction of deficits, independent of any cyclical effect, will represent nearly 3% of national wealth, 3%. This has never been done in our country. It is considerable!

That is why the French government will advocate with its partners, but I know that we have already been heard by a number of organizations, for the return to a deficit of 3% of GDP to be postponed, to be delayed by one year. Why?

To defer choices, no. Since I have maintained the course, reaffirmed the trajectory, and notably announced that public spending of the State in 2014 would be at a level lower than what it will be in 2013.

The objective must be on the level of expenditure. Then, there may be cyclical effects.

But the commitment I make, beyond the trajectory we set, is on the level of expenditure, on savings.

The improvement of public accounts, moreover, in 2014, in France, will come two-thirds from savings and for the rest from revenues. Between 2015 and 2017, it is through structural reforms that the recovery will occur and not through automatic cuts, which we see, if made blindly, cause considerable social damage. Because at some point, it is on education, training, investment that adjustments are made, that is to say on the preparation for the future, the very conditions for growth.

What I want is budgetary seriousness, essential for medium-term debt reduction. But it is also growth, because without growth, there will be no reduction in deficits. If there is no commitment in terms of public accounts, there will be no return of confidence, and therefore no growth. Everything is interconnected.

That is why the second principle of the economic policy that the government is conducting is to implement an investment strategy. It is the "competitiveness pact" - which has been presented, the "competitiveness-employment tax credit" that accompanies it to promote employment, investment, and exports.

In the same way, I have identified several areas of excellence that must be supported, including through an exceptional mobilization of savings. I am thinking of housing, digital technology, thermal renovation, and more broadly, energy transition and new technologies, because that is where the growth of tomorrow is at stake.

The state, from this point of view, must change. I hear a number of recommendations that are being made to us.

- First, the state must be the guarantor of the stability of rules: that is why I announced the permanence of all tax measures in favor of SMEs and in favor of supporting innovation and research. Throughout the five-year term, these measures will be preserved no matter what.

- The second commitment that the state must make: it is to simplify the lives of economic agents, both businesses and individuals. By simplifying procedures, shortening deadlines, and accelerating decisions. What I deeply believe is that the mode of action of states and public actors is no longer suited to the economic situation.

It is too slow, it is too heavy. A large part of the dissatisfaction of our fellow citizens is seeing that beyond these decisions that are announced, voted on, and even implemented, it takes too long in relation to the urgency.

For entrepreneurs, when it comes to providing them with investment conditions, for individuals, to send them messages for consumption or for their purchases of durable goods, or for energy transitions.

Signals can no longer be merely indicative; they must be real, translated into daily life.

The third principle is support for employment. How can we accept the levels of unemployment we are experiencing? Youth unemployment and senior unemployment.

This is the whole meaning of what we have done for labor market reform.

I commend the social partners who have made this commitment that we have indeed translated into legislative form.

This is also what we have introduced, the "Generation Contract." This is what we must do for the employment of these young people who are the furthest from the labor market.

This is not just a French problem; it is a European problem.

In the European budget, there will be a specific financial provision for supporting youth employment.

The government now wants to go further with the same method on training.

I had the figure that was given to me this morning. The number of job seekers in France who access training decreased in 2011. It is the opposite that must be produced; I want that through negotiation, the means of professional training be redeployed towards job seekers, towards young people, towards employees who are victims of a number of changes and who must be qualified for new jobs.

This will be the second stage of the reform that we will engage in employment.

This is what we are doing in France: budgetary seriousness, a condition for credibility.

Investment: a necessity to prepare for growth.

Improvement in training, employment conditions, and preparation for changes, essential to combat structural unemployment that is taking hold in our country and in Europe. Because the second level on which I want to intervene, where France is expected, is the European level.

The eurozone is in recession. Never has unemployment been so high since the introduction of the euro. I do not make a connection, as some would like to try to introduce. It is not because there is the euro that there is a crisis. It is because there is an insufficiency of Europe that the crisis continues.

No country will get out of this alone. Even the one that seems most protected by its high level of competitiveness ends up being affected by depression and recession.

I do not want to blame Europe; I want to defend it, including for what it has done over the past year.

The eurozone has been preserved in its integrity; that was not certain, it was not written.

When I took responsibility for France last May, the question was posed: will Greece remain? Will Spain be able to hold on? Will Italy not crack?

What we have seen for nearly a year now is that even if it has taken too long, I agree, on Greece, on Cyprus, and even on Spain today, there is one certainty: the eurozone has been preserved. None of the members has been abandoned. This was an essential condition for regaining confidence.

Europe has also been able, it is not a given to say this today, to reintroduce stability on the financial level with the creation of the Banking Union, that is to say shared rules, common principles that apply to all, with a supervisory authority, tomorrow resolutions, and with the possibility of recapitalizing banks, without it costing anything to savers and taxpayers.

France has weighed all its weight; it has even taken the lead by passing a banking law, which I am told does not go far enough. We are the first to have it voted in Europe, the first even before the provisions that the European Commission provides.

What does this banking law do?

It separates speculative activities from deposit and credit missions.

It also allows for holding banks accountable, to protect savers.

Banks will no longer be able to be shareholders of hedge funds and at the same time, banks will finance the fund that will be intended in case of crisis to save establishments, without it costing anything to taxpayers.

I want to commend what Europe has done in terms of the integrity of the eurozone, the Banking Union, the intervention mechanisms to support states that were in difficulty.

But at the same time, I also want to highlight what it has not done or has not done enough, particularly in terms of growth.

Certainly - it was also a French initiative - we have adopted a growth pact, 120 billion euros, of which we see today some translations in terms of loans from the EIB or mobilization of structural funds, and that is good.

But Europe must do more.

I am not just talking about its budget; I am talking about the funds it could mobilize, the loans it could raise, that is still my idea. Because what Europe was able to do in the aftermath of the Second World War, after terrible conflicts between nations, that is to say, capable of creating a community at the time based on coal and steel, Europe must, after this crisis, be able to pool a number of policies.

I am thinking particularly of the energy plan, the infrastructure plan, the transport plan. And I believe that ideas progress first among businesses - a number of which are represented here - and between states. Will we be able to do this with 27, with 28? I do not know. What I do know is that, in any case, France and Germany must have this will. Including because we do not have the same energy policies and that we can make a number of choices together on renewable energies.

The exit from the eurozone crisis will not come from a single or simplistic recipe.

Some would have us believe that the solution would be to reduce deficits even faster. But everyone knows the risk, which is that there will be no results in terms of restoring public accounts because there will be a recession that will continue, and I know the consequences: unemployment and the disarray of the people, and with it, the rise of a number of populisms. There is no need to invent them; they are already there.

This is the first policy that is being proposed to us: to go even faster, even further, even stronger, at the risk of breaking the economic machine.

Others would like to find loopholes, to suggest that by letting deficits run, and I know that this is not the idea that is proclaimed here - we could make Keynesianism a good account. If it were proven that when we have this level of debt, more deficit leads to more growth, it would be known.

And then, there is another policy that is also displayed, sometimes discreetly, sometimes more directly, which is the exit from the eurozone, the breakup of the eurozone. And all countries are aware of this debate.

So there is not just one possible policy; there are always several.

There are drastic cuts in spending with the end of a number of social models.

There is the widening of deficits with the risk of sanctions that will come sooner or later.

And then, there is the policy of breaking up the eurozone, of the end of what we have built together.

So, the policy I propose is the necessary budgetary seriousness, the competitiveness that we must restore, the growth that we must seek, which therefore requires a reorientation of Europe's priorities. How?

In no monetary zone, worthy of the name, can policies be left to the discretion of states.

There is a need for coordination. On what basis? Countries that are in balance of payments deficit, in public account deficit must restore within a reasonable time what makes them deviate from others.

But conversely, countries that are in trade surplus or that have restored their public accounts must support demand to allow those who are in a more difficult situation to have the support of activity.

That is why a monetary zone like the eurozone - and I care about this because I am attached to the European project - is not homogeneity (everyone doing the same policy), nor hegemony (certain countries imposing a model on others), it is coordination, cooperation, and therefore convergence; that is called solidarity.

Europe, I quote Jean-Paul FITOUSSI - is orphaned by politics; it is true. This means that Europe was born of politics. It will only be relaunched by politics.

What does that mean? Not words, not speeches, but political acts, stronger institutions, a respected parliament, an identified power, faster decisions, and mobilized means.

I often reflect on this when I go outside of Europe. We are sometimes looked at with admiration - that is legitimate - sometimes with a bit more pity, "but what is happening in Europe?"

We forget to say that Europe is the world's largest economic power - both in terms of its industrial, technological, and human resources - and we must claim this place.

Europe must become aware of itself and weigh in on the fate of the world.

This is the last level I wanted to address: the world.

The world has changed a lot over the past decade, considerably changed: the balance of power, positions, levels of growth. Emerging countries are no longer emerging; they are now at considerable levels of development. Catch-ups have been made. The growth we see in Asia and parts of America is incomparable to the growth in Europe.

This new world that is being built needs cohesion.

I see threats, given the tensions that exist today.

I see two.

Protectionism, which can be the response, continent by continent, sometimes country by country, to say that since we cannot succeed, let us try to make exchange more difficult.

The second threat is the currency war; it is here. Moreover, it is the same thing, protectionism and currency war. And it is often in periods of depression that these temptations exist, if we want to recall some historical reminders.

We must fight against protectionism, but at the same time against free trade without rules, without standards. European countries cannot have social and environmental monetary rules and continue to ensure trade with countries that have transgressed these rules or have not applied them without compensation. Totally free exchanges are not entirely fair. Regulating global trade is one of the urgencies for the recovery of growth.

But there are also two demands that we must address.

The first is to control reckless finance and fight against tax havens. There should not be a country on the world map where concealment, money laundering, and fraud are tolerated. No one should be able to think they are safe behind the ease of a tax system or the protection of a secret.

On this, France's will shall not waver. I will say this both at the G8 in June and at the G20 in September.

What are the principles we must establish?

The first principle is the automatic exchange of information for the benefit of tax administrations. This must be the rule worldwide because it is a simple rule. France affirmed it last week; it was in Dublin at the European Union Council of Ministers. We want these exchanges of information within Europe to be automatic, mechanical, and that this can also be the rule we establish with third countries. Already, five countries have signed a common letter on this subject, and it will be on the agenda of the European Council.

This generalization must also cover mechanisms for taxing savings that must be common to the whole of at least the eurozone.

I know I can count on the OECD to work in this direction - that is to say, on the fight against money laundering, on the harmonization of tax rules.

The second demand we must establish, beyond the fight against money laundering, against fraud, against what disrupts the real economy, rightly disturbs public opinion, and that is a short-term demand.

The other demand, which is a medium-term demand, is sustainable development.

This is not a secondary issue that we should wait until the end of the crisis to revisit. That is why France will organize the climate conference in 2015. Because none can be truly sustainable if there is not a change in rules on a global scale for access to energy, to raw materials, for their proper management.

This is the future we want.

But none of the challenges I have just mentioned, none, whether it be economic growth, the order of finance, the resolution of budgetary difficulties, the reduction of inequalities, the organization of Europe and other continents, none of these challenges can be truly met without a change in global governance.

Again, let us take historical examples.

I mentioned Europe in the aftermath of the war, but I should mention the world in the aftermath of the war.

What was it capable of again, even when the war was not yet over?

The Bretton Woods systems were built in the aftermath of the Cold War - when this Cold War appeared for what it was, we created an organization so that countries that wanted to be free could cooperate.

It is the same in today's world; we need to strengthen global governance; this applies to monetary institutions, the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, but it also applies to what I have called the Economic and Environmental Security Council, which should be established just as there is a Security Council to prevent conflicts.

This is the project we must carry. It is demanding, and what is at stake, I measure here, and everyone must keep in mind these risks and these hopes.

The risks are that national cohesions fray country by country.

The risks are that populisms grow, in the absence of hope.

The risks are that European construction - this great adventure, this great idea - may one day be questioned.

The risks are that the world may experience imbalances that it will not be able to resolve. So hope, hope is primarily here in France to be able to show the horizon line - which is not simply the good management of public accounts necessary, which is not simply having control of spending that is essential.

Hope must be to find the path to growth, the path to employment, with sectors that we must establish, with a strategy that we must carry, a pride in a number of achievements, particularly in the field of innovation and research.

Hope for Europe is to be able to rebuild its political project around cooperation, coordination, and common investments.

Hope is a world that manages to reduce inequalities, to set rules, and to ensure that we are all responsible for our common destiny.

This is the world after, which requires first and foremost a France capable of carrying its voice because this voice is awaited.

A Europe aware of its future and a world that knows it is now necessarily linked to a common destiny.

We not only have to prepare this world for the generation that is here but for the next one because one day - and that day has come - it is possible that the current generation will hold us accountable before the future generation.

Thank you.