Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the reform of local authorities, in Paris on October 5, 2012.

France François Hollande · President of France

5 October 2012 · Estates General on the reform of local authorities · Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Estates General of local authorities in Paris on October 5, 2012, to call for a new stage of decentralization reform.
Main themes
Decentralization reform, local democracy, territorial organization, Estates General of local authorities, history of French decentralization, regional and local governance, state-territory relations, competency distribution, local finance, republican unity, François Mitterrand legacy
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,584
93rd percentile
Sentences
291
95th percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
41st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 63%62%
  • Economic 21%21%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

291 sentences in 99 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Senate,

You have therefore convened the Estates General. This is serious! It is a heavy decision to call not only the parliamentarians -- those from the Senate and the National Assembly, and I salute President Claude BARTOLONE -- but also the elected representatives from our regions, departments, cities, and villages to express the voice of territorial democracy. You are doing this here in Paris, Paris of which Bertrand DELANOË is the mayor, but which only gained true status as a fully-fledged local authority in 1977.

The government has responded to the call, which is always more prudent. There are precedents for those who did not attend... I therefore salute Prime Minister Jean-Marc AYRAULT and the ministers accompanying him today.

If you have used the reference of the Estates General, and you have done so deliberately, it is indeed because you wanted to conceive your work less as the opening of grievances than as a series of useful proposals and conclusions that could, if necessary, inspire the government in the preparation of the next bill on decentralization.

I commend the initiative of Jean-Pierre BEL and the Senate. I recognize the immense process: more than 20,000 contributions have been collected, and many of your conclusions, your proposals will inspire the government's work.

I also see a shared awareness between elected officials and state officials. At a time when we must mobilize all our forces, all our resources, all our means to restore our country, to make it both stronger in competition, fairer in distribution, and more effective in action, you have considered, and we too, with you, that the territories were not a burden for a country like ours, but an asset for successful recovery.

This idea, moreover, does not come naturally. For a long time in the Republic, it has been contested. Territorial democracy was a struggle in the Republic. It was the French Revolution in 1789 that created the commune and the department, but did not give them all the means to act. We had to wait for the Second Republic, which was very brief, for universal direct suffrage to be established and for the election of mayors to be restored, but only for small communes.

It was the Third Republic, the great Republic, that recognized local freedoms: 1871 for the department, 1884 for the commune. But with what mistrust! At that time, there remained the fear of the influence of notables and parishes, and this fierce will to preserve, at all costs, the unity of the Republic persisted. Hence the vigilance of the state in the face of all excesses of local assemblies, symbolized by the oversight of prefects.

The Fourth Republic, more lenient, could have, after Liberation, initiated a great movement of local freedom. It did not happen. Because governmental instability would be compensated by a strengthening of central administrative authority.

As for the Fifth Republic, it long preferred deconcentration to decentralization, until General de GAULLE, aware of what the events of May 1968 meant, proposed regionalization to the country. He was not understood, and the idea receded.

We therefore had to wait until 1981, the election of François MITTERRAND, for a decentralization process to begin, to which many here in this room contributed.

Let us celebrate the success: the expansion of local freedoms with the abolition of oversight, the democratic advance with the election of regional councils by universal suffrage, the modernization of the country through a transfer of competencies to the benefit of local authorities, but above all to the citizens who have seen their environment change in thirty years, regardless of the political sensitivities of the elected officials in charge of local responsibilities. So much so that after 30 years of decentralization, a consensus has been established, and I do not complain about it, even if it is not easy to build consensus, even for the Estates General!

And so, a consensus has been established, beyond the political parties of the republican arc, to consider that the decentralized Republic is now our common good. But we must also look lucidly at the limits reached by our territorial organization. You have indeed established them. I do not say this to blame the elected officials or to imagine theoretical constructions without a future, but to, with you, reflect on a new stage of decentralization that will also be a reform of the state because the two movements go hand in hand.

How to understand the multiplication, the complexity of local interventions, the cross-financing that adds to the confusion? How to accept the unreadability of actions when elected officials devote themselves to the common good, but cannot make it clear who is responsible for what with the entanglement of competencies? How to accept the opacity of local finances and the growing inequalities between local authorities? How to justify all these structures born of freedom, goodwill, sometimes constraint, but which, in reality, leave a number of areas of public action without coherence? Every majority for the past 25 years has tried, in good faith, to provide answers to this situation, but it must be noted that successive laws have rather added to the confusion than contributed to simplification. And in the absence of a genuine reform of local finances, the state and local authorities have ended up multiplying the subjects of conflict.

I will share my conviction with you -- it has been established for a long time: the countries that succeed best in global competition are those that are able to federate all actors around the same project. This applies to social dialogue, and it also applies to territorial democracy. We need actors who are recognized, who are respected, and at the same time who are responsible. Local democracy is first and foremost a requirement of citizenship, but it is also a lever for growth. The competitiveness of our economy -- which we talk about a lot, rightly so -- relies on the quality of know-how, on innovation, the intelligence of businesses, but also on the involvement of territories.

Let us remember that local authorities are, today, the ones who realize, build, equip the country since they are responsible for 70% of public investment. It is local authorities that allow the public policies decided by the state to be translated into reality. It is local authorities that accompany, follow, transcribe, and even apply the laws of the Republic. Even today, when the government of Mr. Jean-Marc AYRAULT engages in a reform of social housing, releases land, modifies the rules so that there can be more housing in municipalities that have not necessarily made the effort towards social construction, when the government of Jean-Marc AYRAULT launches future jobs - the law will soon be definitively voted - to whom is it addressed, if not to local authorities so that these texts become a reality in our country? Without local authorities, no social housing! Without local authorities, no future jobs! Without local authorities, no solidarity, no economic action!

That is why we need a strong relationship between the state and the territories. I know what our country owes to the elected officials of the Republic. They are, depending on the circumstances, opportunely flattered or unjustly vilified. There are said to be too many elected officials, too many municipalities, too many levels. Should I remind you that municipal councilors are, for the most part, volunteers? 80% of those elected receive no compensation. Should I remind you that our local democracy is perhaps the most unique, since it does not recognize at any time a status for these elected officials and that many sacrifice their professional lives for the public good? But this recognition, this tribute even to the elected officials, cannot in my mouth be a justification for the status quo. The challenges of employment, education, housing, public service, the aging population, but also the energy transition call for a new phase of public action.

That time has come, this necessary page of our history we will write together, it is the spirit of the bill that the government is preparing and which it will present at the beginning of next year. The first reading will come to the Senate.

This project is based on 4 essential principles:

The first is trust because beyond words, intentions, the state and local authorities need a stable framework to exchange, to dialogue, to decide. This framework will be the High Council of Territories, which will become the consultation, evaluation, and negotiation body between them, the state and the representative of the associations of elected officials. This High Council will bring together all existing structures. It will also be a factor of economy and cohesion. It will include the committee of local finances, the national commission for the evaluation of standards, and that on the transfer of charges. It will be consulted on every text concerning local authorities and before each finance law. It will therefore be a factor of recognition, coherence, and responsibility.

Trust is also the right to experiment. The Republic is one, but it is not uniform. There already exists a right to experiment today, but as often, so many conditions, so many locks have been placed that it is not truly used. It will therefore be expanded and relaxed so that local authorities can implement new policies, different practices, or even adapt, as they see fit, existing provisions.

Trust can also mean -- within limits that must be clearly defined -- considering a local power to adapt the law and regulations when the general interest justifies it, taking into account the specificities of the territory. This evolution is not simple; it may even be deemed perilous. It is legitimate to frame it, but we also need to take into account the diversity of our territories. I am not just talking about overseas territories that already know this evolution; I am talking about our regions that need, with the local authorities present, to be able to imagine a better adaptation of the law.

Trust is finally the reduction of standards. I understood that this was one of the concerns that emerged from your Estates General.

400,000 standards would be applicable, and one can measure, by mentioning this figure, how decentralization is ultimately circumvented, diverted as long as there are so many constraints weighing on local authorities.

There is also a part of schizophrenia in the denunciation of standards. There are legislators in this room who vote for laws that introduce them, sometimes even make amendments to strengthen them. When they return, it is still possible for a while, as mayors, presidents of the General Council, or presidents of the Regional Council, the same people stigmatize all these obligations and denounce the legislator who may have had the idea. French contradiction! But we can no longer accept this situation in terms of cost for local authorities, in terms of delays for procedures.

One way to gain growth is, of course, to seek, through supply and demand, all the conditions that allow all economic life to be more dynamic. But another way to seek growth is to do more quickly what we have already decided to undertake and even finance.

Thus, the question of standards is not only a relationship between the state and local authorities; it is also a matter of mobilizing our assets. Provided, of course, that we do not enter into a form of deregulation, where the objectives of safety, health standards, or environmental protection would become unbearable burdens.

I propose a new method, and the government will have to implement it.

First, no standard can be decided without the favorable opinion of the evaluation commission, whose composition will itself be renewed.

Then, any regulatory standard that has not been expressly confirmed by a date set by law will immediately become void.

I realize what this change will require to evaluate and sort existing standards. This task is essential. To prevent proliferation from continuing, once we have addressed the stock, I have again asked the Prime Minister that for every new text, every new standard be accompanied by the abolition of another. One can always find inflation. Some say: eliminate two standards for one! And it is often the same people who have created two without eliminating one... Another French contradiction!

What I want, what you want, I have heard you, is the meaning of these Estates General, to make it simpler, to go faster, to respect the imperatives that are ours, of safety, environment, health. Without needing to delay projects.

The second principle I wanted to mention before you, after that of trust, is clarity. We must emerge from the confusion of responsibilities between the state and local authorities, but also between the local authorities themselves.

Thirty years after decentralization, everyone can see that the State continues to intervene in the exercise of local responsibilities. It does so sometimes legitimately when it comes to controlling the legality of acts voted by local authorities. It also intervenes in areas that have been transferred, thus adding confusion, contradiction, and misunderstanding.

I therefore propose that the next text on decentralization, which the minister is preparing, fully embraces the logic contained in the first decentralization laws. That is to say, the blocks of competencies. This is the only way to recognize the full responsibility of elected officials, but also to put an end to duplications in the functioning of services.

The law must clearly assign to the regions all the responsibilities that are still those of the State in the areas of vocational training, guidance, and the coherence of employment support policies at the territorial level, so that there is the best link between the qualifications offered and the needs of businesses.

In the same way, the State will allow the Region to have the role of steering all policies conducted in the area of employment and training so that there is the best link between the qualifications offered and the needs of businesses.

All territorial policies regarding aid and support for SMEs will also be transferred to the regions. The regions have been doing this for a long time. They will need to benefit from new instruments to carry out these policies.

The first of these instruments will be the Public Investment Bank. Certainly, it will be national, but it will be possible to pool its resources with those of the regions to create a single window and a decision-making body chaired by the Regional Council.

The Public Investment Bank and the regions will be associated to act towards SMEs, innovation, investment, and export.

The second instrument, which will be made available to the regions, is the European structural funds. There is no justification for the State to manage resources in France, unlike what happens with our neighbors, when the very purpose of these resources is to help territories carry out their development. Management by the regions will be more economical, faster, at a time when it is also our responsibility to seek the resources that the growth plan, adopted in June, allows us to hope for.

This movement of decentralization, of clarification towards the regions, will also be directed towards the departments, which will be entrusted with all policies related to disability and dependency, outside the scope of health insurance.

This transfer will, however, require defining sufficient and sustainable funding for the General Councils.

Finally, the State will have to share with the municipal block the responsibility for the energy transition.

This is the vision I present to you for this new stage of decentralization.

We can still improve, deepen, and broaden. But these are the foundations on which I wanted us to enter into discussion.

The third principle, after those of trust and clarity, is coherence. A debate has been opened for several years on the opportunity to eliminate a level of local administration. At one point, the municipality was called into question. This was dangerous, not so much for the municipalities as for those who had the idea, because everyone ended up considering that the municipality was irreplaceable! Especially at a time when our country needs, more than ever, to tighten the social fabric, whether in rural areas or in the neighborhoods of our cities.

Today, it is the department that is under scrutiny. Too old, too archaic, too outdated. I am not a defender of one local authority among others. Everyone must have the lucidity to look at the changes that need to be made.

Arguments in terms of economy are often put forward to eliminate a level. They do not hold up to scrutiny as long as it is not a question of abolishing the competencies that this local authority exercises.

Apart from reducing a few dozen elected officials, where is the economy? As for the hoped-for simplification, it would most often lead to distancing our fellow citizens from decisions made without affecting the very effectiveness of the service provided.

Thus, in my view, the problem is not so much the number of levels. Moreover, when I look at our neighbors, I find about the same number under different names. The problem, and let’s face it frankly, is the distribution of competencies and the governance of our territories. That is what we need to change.

There is no question of calling into question the general competence clause, which is a founding principle of local authorities since the origin of the Republic.

No question either of going back on the absence of one authority's oversight over another.

On the other hand, the objective is to clearly identify the authority responsible for a policy so that any other authority that might wish to intervene can only do so within the framework set by the authority that has the competence. This is the principle of the lead authority, already provided for in the constitution. It is Article 72.3.

It exists in economic matters. If a department or a city wants to grant direct aid to businesses, it can only do so within the framework determined by the region, which guarantees the overall coherence of the systems.

It is this principle of the lead authority that must be extended to all areas of local action.

I think of transport, of mobility, where it is clear that it is necessary to articulate what is decided in cities, departments, and regions. For housing, for training, and even for youth, we need a will and then modalities to intervene.

In certain cases, the law will set the rule. It will also open another possibility, which would be to allow local authorities to organize and decide together through a territorial governance pact.

For each major policy, there would be a single authority that would set the modalities and the action that can be delegated to other authorities.

This organization can vary depending on the territories, the regions. Given the specificities or the size of a number of authorities. It is not the same to have large agglomerations in a department or not to have them.

Finally, France can no longer overlook the need to organize our large urban agglomerations. We have seen, for more than thirty years, the emergence of European-level metropolises, sometimes around a large central city, sometimes around a network of cities that weave links of solidarity and project among themselves. Paris, Lyon, Marseille are already concerned. But other urban centers also want to take charge of their development and their influence in coordination with the regions. I believe the time has come to give them the means to do so.

I therefore propose to create a metropolitan status that will go beyond the current public establishments and will be able to exercise all responsibilities for urban development by benefiting from transfers of competencies from the State or the Region. The metropolitan fact will therefore be included in the next draft law.

The last principle is democracy. This was the idea of decentralization: to bring decision-making closer to citizens, to encourage their participation, to renew practices. It has partly achieved its objectives. But a distance has also been created. It is measured by the rates of abstention observed during local elections. Moreover, our country is experiencing several situations, not to say anomalies, that it is our responsibility to correct.

We must take democracy, I would say seriously, not as a necessary accompaniment, but as the objective of the republican pact.

I am as concerned as you are about abstention in local elections, about the multiplication of ballots, which, by the way, relates to the issue of entangled competencies, the absence of clarification, and a form of unreadability of public action.

That is why a decentralization law is not simply a law for the State to rid itself of a number of competencies. On the contrary, it is so that there is more efficiency, more speed, more proximity, and more democracy.

There are situations that deserve reforms or corrections.

The first evolution that needs to be accomplished is to revisit the question of the territorial councilor. It has not had the time to come into effect, it has been misunderstood and therefore it has not been accepted.

No one understood whether it was a matter of changing a voting system for opportunistic reasons or whether it was, through this election, to merge two assemblies while maintaining two authorities. No one succeeded, so the territorial councilor will be abolished. But as soon as the election of this councilor is no longer envisaged, two questions arise: the first is the date of the regional and departmental elections. Here too, let us try to keep it simple. In 2014, three electoral appointments are already planned: municipal elections, the renewal of the European Parliament, and senatorial elections. I believe that for the respect of our fellow citizens and our concerned assemblies, it is preferable to postpone the organization of the two consultations on the same day: regional and departmental. I have therefore asked the government to proceed with a consultation to confirm this schedule.

The question remains of the voting system for departmental elected officials. Again, a consultation is planned with the Assembly of Departments of France. But, allow me to indicate my preference; it does not bind you. We are in a general assembly, it is you who will have the final say. I know our territories well, especially the department. I believe there is a need for territorial anchoring and at the same time there is a requirement for parity. It is with these two principles that we will find the effective voting system.

The second evolution concerns intercommunal cooperation. The budgets that are currently voted in these structures justify that community councilors be elected by universal suffrage, at the same time as municipal councilors. Again, my preference is for a system of designation that will allow citizens to know, at the time of voting, which elected officials will sit on the Community Council without needing a separate vote from the municipal election.

Finally, the third situation that needs to be corrected is the accumulation of mandates. It is a strong demand from the French to limit it. It is a commitment I made to them. The commission chaired by Lionel Jospin on the renovation of political and public life will submit its conclusions to me at the beginning of November. Again, the government will engage in a consultation with elected officials and parties, and a text will be presented to Parliament in the spring of 2013. If the law is passed, it will be a factor of renewal and modernization.

Everyone must understand that if we go in this direction, we will have to draw another conclusion: it is because the exercise of a mandate is a noble, demanding task that elected officials must have the means to carry out their missions serenely. This is the meaning of the status of the elected official. The limitation of the accumulation of mandates, the end of the accumulation of mandates, will also be the best way to justify the status of the elected official. I believe this is an essential condition to facilitate the access of private sector employees, young people, to local responsibilities. I take responsibility for strengthening the social rights of elected officials and the means that must allow them to reconcile professional life and the exercise of a mandate. The risk, otherwise, is the weakening of our local democracy and the impoverishment, if it were still needed, of the diversity of representation of the country.

I want to conclude on the question that is on everyone's mind: that of the resources of local authorities. A new stage of decentralization, a new territorial organization, a clarification of competencies, a more vibrant democracy also require a renewed financial framework between the State and local authorities. I call for the conclusion of a pact of trust and responsibility for the next five years between the State and local authorities. The principles will be set within the High Council of Territories, as soon as the discussion of the draft law on decentralization begins, so that Parliament can deliberate with full knowledge of the facts.

But I will not hide the reality from you. Everyone knows the context in which the elaboration of this pact is situated. The priority of the government of Jean-Marc Ayrault is the recovery of public accounts.

This is not simply to meet a European obligation. It is not to respect commitments that may have been made before us. It is because it is necessary if we want to reduce our country's debt, preserve our sovereignty from financial markets, and regain maneuvering room.

This recovery of public accounts will also go hand in hand with productive recovery, because it must also allow us to let companies finance themselves at the lowest possible interest rates, with employment being the only priority that fits within budgets alongside education. And so we can, within a horizon that cannot be too distant -- I said two years -- put our country in a position to face global competition, but also to hold its rank, its place.

I know that efforts will be required from everyone, and thus from local authorities as well. You will tell me, they have the obligation to balance their operating budget and, when they borrow, it is only to finance investment. They did not need a golden rule or a treaty to know what they had to do. The debt of local authorities, in relation to national wealth, has remained stable in recent years. It could not have been otherwise since local authorities only borrow for investment. However, local authorities represent 20% of the total public spending of our country, and these charges have continued to increase at a rate of about 3.1%, which is higher than that of national wealth.

The restoration of our financial balances therefore calls for a contribution from all public actors. This applies to the State, and it also applies to local authorities.

We will therefore have an open, calm, respectful discussion about the financial contributions of the State, about controlling public spending, but also about the reform of local taxation, that is to say, adapting local taxation to the realities of local authorities.

Two principles, once again, must guide us.

The first is simplification. Local tax is undoubtedly seen as the most unfair and archaic when there is still the possibility for local authorities to levy taxes.

The second principle is to create a taxation system that is compatible with the dynamics of spending so that no local authority finds itself overwhelmed by the responsibilities it has to implement.

Regions must regain a share of fiscal autonomy. I also know the difficulties faced by departments, caught between regularly increasing expenses -- dependency, disability, and the RSA especially during this period -- and revenues that are stagnating or decreasing. That is why a "financial package" will be put in place for 2013, and beyond these one-off or emergency measures, it will be necessary to find a sustainable financing method for dependency and for the management of solidarity. This will be a reform so long promised, so eagerly awaited! At some point, it will come, it will be next year.

Finally, it is important to guarantee access to credit for local authorities, which are increasingly plunged into uncertainty.

After the bankruptcy of Dexia, the State decided to mobilize the resources of the Caisse des dépôts, but also of the Banque postale. A new financial tool supported by this bank will emerge at the end of negotiations with the European Commission. I will ensure, along with the government, that there is no disruption in the financing of investments and the cash flow of local authorities. I add that we will examine ways to assist local authorities that are suffering the consequences of toxic loan offers that currently threaten their ability to repay.

But these reforms are only conceivable if, at the same time, we strengthen financial equalization. Financial equalization, that is to say, the one that the State can organize, for itself, for its allocations, for its contributions to local authorities, in favor of the most fragile territories, both in urban neighborhoods and in rural areas.

But courage, too, is to mention another equalization between local authorities, those considered wealthier and others more fragile. This equalization is already at work for 2013. It will be expanded and adapted within the framework of the pact of trust and responsibility that will be signed, I hope, between the State and local authorities.

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials, convened before you for these General States, I wanted to come with proposals. It was wiser.

They will not meet all your expectations, because my role is not to respond to all requests, because what the government does is not to satisfy all demands. How could it? Because what we have to do is not to solve, for a circumstance, for a budget, the problems of the country. It is to find solutions over several years, allowing us to regain confidence in ourselves, to rediscover enthusiasm, to also give ourselves the means to hope. Because we know that growth is weak, if not nonexistent, and it has lasted for nearly a year now. We cannot simply say: let’s wait, we’ll see, it will come back. No, we must immediately prepare the means to regain growth and economic dynamism. That is why what you are doing today is not a parallel exercise, it does not come alongside, it is part of the subject. If we manage, and I thank the Senate and its president for this, to nurture reflections that are as many means of action for the success of our country, then you will have launched a great movement through these General States.

Decentralization is an opportunity and not a matter of principle. It allows the State to reform itself, territories to mobilize, and citizens to get involved.

I have long been the elected representative of a department that is said to be rural, even if today in all departments we find all situations, that there are remarkable technologies in places that until now were considered distant from decision-making centers, that we find in neighborhoods of our cities situations far more serious in terms of civic desertification than what can be found in certain rural areas facing human desertification.

So there is, beyond this diversity, a solidarity. I have been the elected representative of a department. I believe in this France of territories. Our Republic, I have said, is one, it is indivisible, it is at the same time diverse. We know that we want to live in the same space with the same values, the same freedoms, the same principles. That is what unites us. But we also know that we belong to territories, we live in places, landscapes, which make us also concerned about our own identity. This geographical, economic, and human diversity is also an asset.

We are facing a great challenge, ladies and gentlemen elected officials, which I hear posed everywhere by our fellow citizens.

What is and what will be France's place in globalization? Can we still have a rank? Can we determine our own destiny? Do we have the capacity to nurture a project that can give meaning to the action we are undertaking? The place of France! That is the great question for the President of the Republic who must provide direction and guidance and for you as well. We must together ensure that France is at its best level, and we can all contribute to that.

And the second question posed by our fellow citizens: what is their place, individuals, economic actors, employees, retirees, young people? What is each person's place in this France that we are preparing together? Will we still be able to live together with our freedoms, our principles, our values? This question is also posed to you.

The challenge is to mobilize ourselves, prepare for the mutation, the transition, create jobs, invent a new model of development. This is what we have to pursue, local authorities and the State. The challenge is to use all our identities, all our diversity to unite them in a common destiny.

It is the role of the State to open this perspective, but I announce to you, it will not succeed alone. It needs you — you, elected officials of the Republic, you, territories of France, you, parliamentarians aware of the common good. That is why your General States are preparing, I am sure, the Republic of tomorrow.

Thank you.