Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the role of the Council of Europe and on France's policy in favor of human rights, in Strasbourg on October 11, 2016.

France François Hollande · President of France

11 October 2016 · Council of Europe, Strasbourg, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Council of Europe in Strasbourg on October 11, 2016, reaffirming France's commitment to human rights and European values.
Main themes
Council of Europe, human rights, European Court of Human Rights, rule of law, fundamental freedoms, France's human rights commitments, prison reform, anti-terrorism, populism and extremism, refugee crisis, European cooperation, Venice Commission
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,924
74th percentile
Sentences
129
75th percentile
Readability
45
47th percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.03
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%38%
  • Geopolitical 31%31%
  • Social 23%22%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

129 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Mr. Secretary General,

Ladies and gentlemen, Members of Parliament,

Ladies and gentlemen, Ambassadors.

I wanted to express through my presence here today my commitment to your institution, the Council of Europe, here in Strasbourg, a European capital.

But I am aware that the particular context we are experiencing, which is serious, gives this visit a deeper meaning, because the values upheld by the Council of Europe must continue to inspire us. François MITTERRAND, who was at the Hague Congress in 1948, always reminded us that the European challenge was to safeguard the freedoms we have acquired and to extend them for the benefit of all.

And that is what your Council has been able to achieve over the past years. It now brings together 47 countries, representing 820 million inhabitants, and all these member states have committed to placing the human person at the heart of their legal systems. The Council of Europe is the custodian of 211 conventions, 135 of which have been ratified by France. At the top of this edifice is the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, and France ensures that it respects all its points and principles.

I also want to commend the constant progress of your commitments to further protect freedoms, not only by expanding borders, which you have done with your assembly, but also by broadening the areas of freedom protection. Thus, you have worked on ethical issues with the prohibition of human cloning, you have fought against all forms of human trafficking, you combat violence against women, and you ensure the protection of personal data, in the name of respect for privacy.

But beyond the proclamation of these principles, there is also the binding mechanism that must ensure their effectiveness. This is the mission of the European Court of Human Rights - I have just met its president. France, once again, and I want to reaffirm it here, takes all its responsibilities to support the Court in all circumstances. It has supported all the reforms that have improved its functioning, particularly the recent Protocols 14 and 15 that France has ratified. I commit here to prepare for the definitive adoption of the 16th Protocol.

Supporting the Court means ensuring the full execution of its judgments. That is why the French government has passed a law aimed at simplifying the procedure for reviewing criminal convictions that have led to France being challenged by the European Court of Human Rights. This will also be true, in civil matters, for decisions regarding the status of individuals, which can be re-examined whenever there is a decision from the Court concerning France. This is particularly the case for gender change or the transcription of a civil status act.

I have also taken into account, each time the Court has intervened with a judgment, to translate the decisions into French law. In 2013, we introduced a specific offense against human trafficking. In 2014, the regime of police custody was profoundly modified for better protection of defense rights, from the stage of the investigation. More recently, the right to professional representation in the armed forces was opened, and once again, this principle has not only been recognized but also implemented.

I am also aware of France's duties regarding the state of its prisons; we are aware of the extent of prison overcrowding and the challenge represented by individual cell occupancy. This is the subject of a plan announced by the French government, which will dedicate more than one billion euros to the construction of new penitentiary facilities.

But our penal policy also aims to implement alternative sentences to incarceration; that is why I am committed to the Council of Europe, because you advance the rule of law, because you allow us to vigilantly uphold the commitments we have made. I pay tribute here to the action of the Commissioner for Human Rights, to the Venice Commission, which has played a very important role since 1990 in the constitutional transition of Central and Eastern Europe, particularly in the Balkans, and today in Ukraine.

I also want to commend the action of the Council of Europe Development Bank, too little known, which finances highly social projects in 41 member states, and which has recently dedicated a fund to support refugees and migrants. France is honored to be one of the three main shareholders of the institution.

Ladies and gentlemen, in nearly 70 years, the Council of Europe has helped to build on the continent a space of peace, cooperation, and freedoms, unparalleled in the world. But let us be clear-eyed; this movement can be interrupted, it is not irreversible, there are threats, as you have mentioned, terrorism, but also the rise of populism and extremism, particularly in the face of the refugee crisis.

There are challenges to our values, there are nationalist retreats, there is a rise in sovereignty, which suggests that each country could find the solution within itself. Even the values you represent here are beginning to be called into question, suspected of not being able to sufficiently protect our fellow citizens. As if freedom could be a limit or if we could imagine a state of exception that would replace the rule of law.

Terrorism puts democracy to the test; our way of life, our freedoms, our fundamental principles are the targets of fanatics. France has been struck several times and in a terrible manner, on symbolic days, including July 14, and also in places that could evoke a form of war between religions. A priest was murdered in a church. And what can we say about those places of life, joy, happiness, that were also attacked because they were precisely places where young people wanted to share a moment of emotion?

France has not been the only country that has been attacked. There are many others, outside the European continent, but there are also European countries that are targeted, attacked, struck, and none can be immune to this scourge. The Council of Europe has taken its responsibilities in the development of protocols, particularly on the prevention of terrorism, and to address the phenomenon of foreign fighters.

France was led, after the terrible attacks of November 13, to invoke Article 15 of the Convention, which allows states to respond to security imperatives under judicial control. This is the state of emergency. This is the path I chose in the aftermath of the November 13 attacks.

But I ensured, with the government of Manuel VALLS, to take proportionate measures to equip the administrative authorities with the necessary means to act through searches or by placing dangerous individuals under house arrest. And Parliament was called to vote. Several laws have been passed in France since 2014 to strengthen our means against terrorism. All these laws have been validated by the Constitutional Council and have been able to be reviewed by you here.

We also wanted to provide a legal framework - it was the first time for intelligence activities - a coherent, comprehensive framework, so that we could act while also having the necessary controls.

We are also ensuring - and we cannot do this alone - to act against online propaganda that encourages radicalization. This is an issue that you must address here regarding the protection of privacy that must be defended, and for what is, on the other hand, also used by fanatics to propagate ideas that can lead some of our youth in our respective countries to go and wage jihad.

France has taken the responsibility to close what were seen as prayer rooms but were in fact calls to hatred. France has also expelled preachers who used freedom of expression to spread the most aggressive intolerance. But we ensure that there is no stigmatization, particularly towards Muslims. We ensure that there is no confusion between what we must do to protect ourselves and what religious freedom must be in our country, which must never be compromised.

I have had several opportunities to defend the French conception of secularism, and I want to do so again here. It is a principle of neutrality; it is also a rule that prohibits the financing of cults by the state, of all cults. Secularism guarantees each person the right to believe or not to believe, the possibility to practice their faith within the limits inspired by respect for public order.

These rules are not the result of circumstantial laws but are based on principles that were established more than 100 years ago and that today allow us to firmly uphold freedom of conscience, and also to ensure that provocations that may threaten communal life can be prosecuted. And I do not intend to reopen this subject for discussion because the balance has been found, and it is sufficient to apply the rules that exist in our country.

Safety and security are a requirement, and our fellow citizens demand to be protected. But security and safety are compatible with the rule of law. There is no question of opening, for example, detention centers in France for individuals monitored by intelligence services. Because that would undermine the principles of our criminal law, which state that only a judge can decide on a deprivation of liberty.

Similarly, France - and I do not need to reassure you on this - will not create an exceptional court for terrorist acts because that would be as unnecessary as it would be dangerous. We have specialized jurisdictions and magistrates at all stages of the procedure who do excellent work. Our law, once again, allows us to act effectively.

That is what I wanted to convey to you on behalf of a country that fights against terrorism while upholding its fundamental principles. Of course, we are evolving the legislation, but it remains in accordance with our constitutional order. In the face of this threat, what terrorists seek is to divide us, to separate us, to lead us to take exceptional measures that would be used to denounce our principles of freedom. It is freedom that is targeted by terrorists. It is freedom that we must defend.

Ladies and gentlemen, Members of Parliament, Europe has also been facing for several months the influx of migrants and refugees. The Syrian crisis has put millions of refugees on the path to exile. Many have joined camps in Jordan, Lebanon, Turkey, and I want to commend these countries for making the main effort. Other refugees and migrants have chosen our continent, but they have chosen it because they ultimately had no other destination, because they were fleeing, because they were seeking exile.

Europe has been slow to find a common response. This response involves the effective control of Europe's external borders. This is the condition for being able to welcome refugees with dignity, to return migrants who do not fall under this right, and to be able to set rules and enforce them, including those for sharing the effort of welcoming refugees.

Without these rules, without this border protection, without European coast guards, without the ability to know what falls under the law and what does not, I am talking about the right of asylum, then Europe will tear itself apart. Europe can disintegrate over this issue of welcoming refugees. France has made commitments, and it will honor them. Thirty thousand refugees from Greece, Italy, and Turkey will be welcomed by France by 2017. Similarly, we will continue the resettlement program implemented with the UN High Commissioner for Refugees in Lebanon and Jordan.

We are also facing, in France, the presence of refugees and migrants on our territory. I know that you are attentive to what, unfortunately, is happening in Calais, where a camp, for too long, with at least seven thousand people, is hosting individuals in conditions that are not worthy of those who have fled their country. That is why I have decided, with the government, to dismantle the Calais camp in order to be able to welcome differently and with dignity those who are currently settled there.

Every person will thus be able to be housed, to be able to make their applications, and at that moment, to be in the asylum process. On the other hand, and I have said this every time, individuals who do not fall under the right of asylum will be returned. But for the most part, those who are in Calais fall under the right of asylum. We are also working to resolve the issue of unaccompanied minors, and we must do so again with dignity and responsibility.

This question is being raised with the United Kingdom, and we are engaging in discussions so that these unaccompanied minors who have relatives in the United Kingdom can join them. This is also a condition for dismantling the Calais camp. It will be a humanitarian operation since everyone will be offered a place in a center. We have created and opened reception and orientation centers to address the issue of Calais and other encampments, particularly in Paris. Everyone will have a solution because it is the responsibility of France, but it is also the responsibility of all those who must understand that it is not possible to dismantle a camp like that of Calais without solutions being proposed across the entire territory.

Ladies and gentlemen, members of Parliament, the values of the Council of Europe inspire France's diplomatic action at the very borders of the Union and our continent. In Ukraine, the unlawful annexation of Crimea by Russia and the destabilization of Eastern Ukraine have first caused numerous victims and, there too, thousands of displaced persons. I have personally committed, along with Chancellor Merkel, to what is called the Normandy format, in the search for a diplomatic solution. This is what we have called the Minsk agreements.

I say it plainly: progress is too slow, and we must move forward on the political and security conditions that will allow for elections in Eastern Ukraine to be held as quickly as possible, as the Minsk agreements provide, according to Ukrainian law and in respect of international criteria. I am ready at any time, with Chancellor Merkel, to convene the Normandy format with President Putin and President Poroshenko to ensure the full implementation of the Minsk agreements. Ukraine itself must take its share of the expected reforms, and I know that the Council of Europe can play a useful role in supporting it.

With Russia, France has a major disagreement over Syria. The Russian veto on the French security resolution has prevented the cessation of bombings and the proclamation of a truce. The main victims are the civilian populations; those living under bombardments are dying under bombardments. That is why I believe that dialogue is necessary with Russia, but it must be firm and frank. Otherwise, it has no place; otherwise, it is a sham.

I am therefore ready at any time to meet with President Putin.

But if we have the opportunity to advance the cause of peace, to stop the bombings and to proclaim the truce, I also want there to be a discussion with Turkey that can be initiated there again because Turkey is making the main effort to host refugees and because Turkey is a stakeholder in a solution for Syria.

Turkey experienced a coup d'état on the night of July 14 to 15. Turkey faced it, and Turkey must also respect, despite this very difficult situation and the proclamation of a state of emergency, the principles that unite us.

This is France's position: always dialogue, but always in search of peace. France's position is the Security Council in the sense of the resolution we presented. I remind you that the Russian resolution received only three votes and that the Russian veto prevented the cessation of bombings. Dialogue always, responsibility always, and the search for peace.

I wanted to talk about Syria here because it is a challenge for the international community. Either it will find its honor in resolving this situation, or it will be its shame to see so many Syrians forced to leave their homes, so many families massacred, and the terrorism that has taken root in this soil and strikes us from Syria through its propaganda, but also through the terrorists it sends to Europe.

Aleppo, yes Aleppo, is the conscience of humanity that is being called into question; Aleppo is on the verge of joining the terrible list of martyr cities.

Ladies and gentlemen, I wanted to make this appeal here because it is here that the values, principles, and hope for peace have been forged. It is here that, in the aftermath of the Second World War, it was possible to make these calls for peace. It is here that unification was desired, where countries that were previously under totalitarianism and dictatorship were welcomed.

And this work of the Council of Europe is not finished; on the contrary, in these circumstances, in this context that I have mentioned, we need the Council of Europe more than ever. In 2019, the Council of Europe will celebrate its 70th anniversary; France will preside over its Committee of Ministers, and it is ready to organize a summit, the fourth, to give it a new direction.

This is the message I wanted to convey to you on behalf of the values that unite us because France stands alongside the Council of Europe, and I am sure that the Council of Europe stands alongside France for all the efforts that are useful for peace, freedom, and democracy.

Thank you.