Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the role of the Council of State, in Paris on March 22, 2017.

France François Hollande · President of France

22 March 2017 · Council of State (Palais Royal), Paris, France

Context
Hollande addressed the Council of State at the Palais Royal on March 22, 2017, to honor its advisory role and express gratitude for its work during his presidency.
Main themes
Role of the Council of State, the French state as common good, state legitimacy and reform, fundamental freedoms and security, counter-terrorism, decentralization and institutional complexity, long-term governance, advisory function of the Council of State, state versus private interests, historical continuity of French statecraft
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,976
85th percentile
Sentences
137
77th percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
14.2
69th percentile
Syntax
3.21
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 80%78%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

137 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Mr. Keeper of the Seals,

Mr. President of the Council of State,

Ladies and gentlemen Presidents,

Ladies and gentlemen,

There are traditions that we must sometimes let go of when they have fallen into disuse. There are others that we must strengthen as long as they are based on respect. This is the purpose of my visit here, to the Council of State as President of the Republic.

Coming to the Palais Royal is not the longest journey for a head of state. But it is, in fact, coming to the heart of the state. First, on a historical level, since this is the place where RICHELIEU did everything to strengthen the state against baronies and private interests. There is no doubt that his struggle is not over, but his spirit has survived.

Once the seat of power, the Palais Royal is today home to one of the first institutions of the Republic, yours, as if the Council of State were the executor of RICHELIEU's will, reminding us, before dying in his chamber, which I have been told has become, a few meters from here, the office of the president of the Section of Reports and Studies, I am therefore happy to remind you, before dying, I speak here of RICHELIEU, that he had no enemies but the enemies of the state. General de GAULLE himself reminded us, here in this hall of the general assembly, during his visit on January 28, 1960, that "there has been France only thanks to the state and that France can only maintain itself through it."

Today, our society has become even more complex than in the 1960s, with strong growth, a society aspiring towards progress, a republic that had been restructured in its institutions, a state that was strong even if it was contested. Today, we have a more ardent, divided, and shaken society, a more fragmented institutional landscape, local authorities playing a renewed role with expanded decentralization, Europe has become, as you reminded us, Mr. Vice-President, a source of rights and an increasingly abundant source. As for social partners, particularly professional organizations, they rightly aspire to participate in the creation of norms.

But what is certain and remains is that the state is the only one capable of enabling citizens to live together. Without the state, our country would revert to an aggregate of private interests and disunited communities. Without the state, economic, social, and environmental progress would no longer benefit the majority. Without the state, security, the ability to live together, French and foreign residents on our soil would no longer be assured. It is always towards the state that our compatriots turn when a major crisis occurs, as during the attacks that painfully struck our country in 2015 and 2016.

If terrorism seeks to destroy the bonds that unite us and prevent any common destiny, it also aims to reach our state, its capacity, its legitimacy, its role, its place. It was therefore very important that the state, in the face of this peril and in the circumstances we have known, could ensure security while respecting fundamental freedoms. This is what it has done, and there is no doubt that it will continue to do so.

The state is our common good, and we must tell our compatriots: we must preserve it, whenever it is called into question, denounced, weakened, deprived of resources. We must also reform it to allow it to adapt and, above all, to better serve the French and prepare for the future. For the role of the state is not simply the management of the present. It is anticipation, the ability to define a long-term strategy, a long vision, even as the dynamics of our elections and the succession of alternations might lead us to lose sight of the importance of duration, of what is decided today to be built tomorrow and last the day after tomorrow.

This guiding principle has been at the heart of my actions, and I know, during these five years, the part that this Council of State has played under your authority, Mr. Vice-President. I have come here to express my gratitude to each and every one of you and beyond you, for your work. It has been presented to me regularly, both at the Council of Ministers since the opinion of the Council of State informs our decisions. But it has also been presented to me when the vice-president, along with the presidents, particularly the president of the Section of Studies, came to offer me as a gift: the report of the Council of State, so that I could, if not draw inspiration from it, translate it into simple language for the French and carry out the reforms that are expected.

But I particularly appreciated the quality of your reflections and especially your actions in the three functions that are yours. First, you advise the state, thus the government, but first the state, beyond majorities, beyond governments, and even beyond, I must say modestly, the Presidents of the Republic. You illuminate this path with your reflections, and you have recently done so on whistleblowers, digital issues, and the rescript, and we have made it a point to translate your conclusions into our texts.

You have also, Mr. Vice-President, participated in reports, I think, on civic service and citizen reserve with a teammate who was not necessarily from the same promotion as you from the École Nationale d'Administration, which undoubtedly created a healthy emulation.

Your advisory action mainly concerns draft texts, and it is true that you have not been spared. Since 2012, in five years, you will have provided the government with opinions on 337 draft laws, 245 draft ordinances, 3,578 draft decrees, and it is not over. These figures, I will return to them, may seem excessive, but they reflect a reality: your institution has put all its skills, all its talents at the service of a reformative action, the opinion of the Council of State is simply irreplaceable, and it is so in these two aspects.

On the one hand, the Council of State ensures legal security through the thorough examination of legal questions submitted to it, and this explains why the government rightly follows its opinions more than 98% of the time. Does this mean that we take risks on the 2% and that we do not on the 98%? Experience sadly leads me to regret that despite the comfort provided by your opinions, the government, and then Parliament, have sometimes faced disappointments before the Constitutional Council on a few occasions. But I will not enter into a debate between the Council of State and the Constitutional Council. I would fear that I might be heard through the door next door. But it is true that you cannot also prejudge, nor can you grant the right. Then there is the decision that is imposed on all of us, from the Constitutional Council.

This trust that governments have placed in your opinions is also to prevent future disputes, and following the opinion of the Council of State is, for the government, the best preventive remedy. And here, we are more assured since we can think that the Council of State will not contradict itself in contentious formation after it has issued an opinion through an administrative section. But this is a hypothesis I am formulating, and I do not want to force the contentious sections.

There is also in the opinions of the Council of State, a part of opportunity. I do not mean to say that you escape legal notions, but you also indicate what society can accept or not, based on its fundamental principles regarding legislative or even regulatory intervention. You thus rendered an unfavorable opinion on identity checks at the decision of the prefect near sensitive sites at a time when there was great tension related to the attacks. I considered that the government should align with your opinion, as it not only avoided disputes but represented a balance that had to be preserved at all costs.

This quality of the work of the Council of State has also led me to make public the opinions on the main draft laws. Here too, it was not to yield to a pressure related to transparency, nor to fear that your opinions kept secret could be made public. It was to enlighten, not only the government, which was done, but also Parliament and society, so that we all understand the meaning of your reflections and what may have led the government to follow your opinion, or not to follow it, as the case may be.

Our fellow citizens are now informed, parliamentarians know the legal boundaries raised by the Council of State, and the Constitutional Council can also take this opinion into account in its decision. This publicity is part of a conviction: respect for the law is an absolute necessity, it is a guarantee, for everyone equally.

The government can, in some cases, also benefit from the work of the Council of State without these needing to be made public. This is necessary, for example, for financial laws, as was the case for the text on withholding tax. I thank you for having examined this text, which was not the easiest, with great attention and with the informed opinion of the Secretary General of the Government, so that we could implement this major reform in such a way that it would not be called into question by a vote, even if it will be up to the next President to decide. But everything is ready for this reform to be implemented. Here too, the fact that the opinion was not published allowed us to expedite its execution.

I also thank the Council of State for its contribution to the increase in the rates of application of laws. In two years, we have gone from a rate of 59% to 91%, which has little to do with public opinion satisfaction indices, but which confirms my own judgment. It is not enough to draft texts, to pass reforms for us to feel light-hearted and certain that we have fulfilled our duty. Too many texts, too many laws remain unenforceable because they are not applied. Too many texts that may have been the subject of great discussions at the parliamentary level find, in reality, little translation in the daily lives of our fellow citizens, due to this shortcoming, this failure. For it is a failure.

Thus, I have insisted with successive governments that there be this determination to take the decrees corresponding to the texts voted by Parliament. Every month, at the Council of Ministers, I conduct a precise evaluation of the implementation of application decrees, and I thank you for contributing to this, as I also know the amount of work that this determination justifies. But it is a matter of the credibility of public action; nothing is worse for democracy than announcing changes that do not occur, than boasting of laws that have had no effect, than allowing people to believe that the lives of those who have succeeded your frescoes could be changed, when in fact, it has not been.

I know that the Council of State, at the moment I am speaking, is still seized with numerous draft decrees, more than 200 "250," the Vice-President tells me; I thought that already, 50 had been resolved before my arrival, as if to welcome me with even more hospitality. The government will indeed be at work until the second week of May, and I know I can count on all the members of your institution to examine them swiftly, but also with the required serenity.

Secondly, the Council of State carries out the mission of judging; it is the supreme court of the administrative order. You have recalled the figures; they are impressive, 10,000 cases judged each year, which is roughly the number of new disputes you receive annually. Your average judgment time for ordinary cases is slightly over a year. The existence of the administrative order is enshrined in the Constitution, the independence of justice applies to administrative justice; I do not separate the two orders of jurisdiction, I do not place one above the other, and I believe that the same guarantees must be provided to both because both protect freedoms.

This independence is a fundamental principle recognized by the laws of the Republic, and it is not for me to revisit the substance of your decisions. But I want to salute here two features of your action: first, the dematerialization of exchanges—with the parties and the procedures—which has become a reality. Citizens owe you this simplification, and I am very attached to simplification; it is not only valid for the administration, it is also valid for justice and administrative justice in particular. Citizens have the possibility to reach you through dematerialized means.

Next, the Council of State has demonstrated its ability to adapt in contentious matters, with the law of July 24, 2015, relating to intelligence. It has thus established a specialized judicial formation, responsible for controlling the legality of the implementation of intelligence techniques. Mr. the Keeper of the Seals, who was at the time the president of the Law Commission, discussed this provision extensively. It was not necessarily obvious, at least that is what he thought, even if today he is pleased with it. I considered it to be one of the guarantees we needed to establish in the necessary balance between maintaining public order and protecting fundamental rights. But this has a consequence for the members of the Council of State in this specialized judicial formation, which is that they are bound to secrecy and must be fully aware of what they have to deal with.

Lastly, the Council of State has a third mission, which is to provide the State with high-level officials that it needs for its actions and for the reforms to be carried out. It is true that at various positions in the civil service, up to the highest levels, the State must be able to call upon members of your institution to successfully carry out public policies and necessary reforms. In ministerial cabinets, having a member of the Council of State is reassuring; I do not know if it reassures the Council of State, but it reassures the ministers who believe that this way they can act in compliance with the law. But this mission is very important because it justifies recruitment at the exit of the École Nationale d'Administration, as you are meant to serve the administration for a time and not simply remain in the formations that are those of your institution, namely advice and litigation.

You have given me the figures, Mr. Vice-President; there is a constant in recent history between the members who remain at the Council of State and others who have left for more or less long periods, particularly in the public sector, even in the private sector. The important thing is the movement and the back-and-forth because the first of the great bodies of the State must be the first reservoir of its servants, but it must also be fed by skills, including those coming from outside through appointments that can be made.

As for the necessities of action in public service, it is true that the independent high authorities have called upon the Council of State a lot. Here too, it was to give them all the guarantees of the law and to allow them to establish themselves in the institutional landscape, and it was very important not to appear as a jurisdiction but also not as an administration, truly as an independent high authority. It has been pointed out by parliamentarians that many members of the Council of State presided over these authorities, and this is undoubtedly the first stage of their life. Once established, they may have other members at their head, but I do not want to presuppose here because I already feel that the vice-president of the Council of State is vigilant regarding my remarks. So I think it is very important that you have been able to give this strength to the independent authorities.

Under your leadership, Mr. Vice-President, your institution has evolved over the years, and I want to mention a few of these developments. The first is the success of the transformation of the administrative sections and your general assembly, and you have been able to differentiate treatments according to the cases, and the deadlines have been managed. The second success relates to the balance between constitutional principles that can sometimes be opposed and that you have had the wisdom to preserve. In the face of danger, I was led to proclaim a state of emergency that Parliament has extended several times, but I have ensured to reconcile the necessity of preventing public order and protecting freedoms. Your institution has also acted in this sense. You are the judges of the acts of public authority, as you have reminded us; you are notably the judges of administrative police, and you are thus judges of freedoms because these acts can infringe upon them, and you have several times reminded the government of its obligations, particularly regarding administrative search measures and house arrest.

The Council of State has also fully drawn the consequences of France's European commitment, and this project is particularly close to your heart. Your relations with European courts, notably that of Strasbourg, are based on respect and mutual understanding, and you have recalled what the intervention of the European Court of Human Rights can be. It has been the initiative of several decisions that have led to important reforms, one of which—Mr. PÊCHEUR knows something about this—is having allowed the right of association in our military institutions.

This was a considerable change when one thinks of what could exist through certain claims in the past and the refusals that had been brought to them. We were able to carry out this reform with much moderation and at the same time with effectiveness. The European Court of Human Rights can sometimes compel us to change a number of our legislation and also your jurisprudence, but it is very important that we can maintain this coherence. I know that today this court is being challenged by countries, by states, by political leaders, and therefore it is very important to remind it of the trust we place in it. You have also—the Council of State—sought to develop a French and European public law through a construction that is a community of minds, and this ongoing work of adaptation must continue.

I would now like to mention three projects; the first is normative production, which is ultimately one of the lessons learned from the role I have held for five years. The parliamentary process of law-making is no longer adapted to the circumstances and marks serious dysfunctions that endanger the quality and stability of the norm. I will give some figures: during the legislature that has just ended, more than 260,000 amendments were submitted to the National Assembly and the Senate, nearly 60,000 were adopted; the most serious figure is not the 260,000 submitted, but the 60,000 adopted. Only 12% of these amendments were of governmental origin. These are staggering figures, and this situation has negative effects; certainly, the right to amend is a major right, it is a fundamental right for the parliamentarian, but in the future it can only be framed—like speaking time—following the reform of July 23, 2008. This will be the case for both the government and Parliament. The developments to be conceived for the future are very important for the Council of State because otherwise it will be marginalized in the law-making process, which will harm its quality.

Already, the Council of State knows less than 20% of the legislative provisions ultimately promulgated, given this proliferation of amendments, and it is known that they have not been prepared with all the necessary care, regardless of the quality of the civil servants of both assemblies and the parliamentarians who submit and defend them. This observation highlights that the future is not also about multiplying administrative bodies or preliminary studies before going to the Council of State or as many discussions as should be engaged with society.

This is necessary, but what needs to be reviewed—and when I hear proposals being made to modify our Republic, it is not on the executive that reflection and attention should be focused, it is on the legislative—it is necessary to review the process of voting on the law. In this context, the Council of State knows how to be reactive to litigation; it can also invent jurisprudences that will allow for the re-examination of amendments, but we must first change the mode of elaboration, discussion, and voting on the law.

The second project concerns you more directly; it is that of the contentious mass, 10,000 cases per year, I said. This figure was the one that led President Marceau LONG to judge the situation untenable and likely to undermine the balances of your institution. All the supreme courts of Western countries judge significantly fewer cases; the future must therefore allow the Council of State to refocus on regulating jurisprudence and addressing the major questions of contemporary law.

Finally, I conclude, the model of the Council of State has never been that of a jurisdictional court, and, as I told you, it is made of a constant movement between the administration and the Council of State, between the Council of State and society. We all have the idea that we must serve society, the country, the Republic; we all want to be its reflection, but we note that diversity is not necessarily what we do best despite all the texts we have produced in this area. It is not simply a matter of copying what a society would be to replicate it at the level of our institutions; it is above all about understanding it, measuring its expectations, perceiving the risks that lie ahead, but also the assets that can be valued at a given moment, and ensuring that our fellow citizens turn to the institutions not simply for them to represent them but for them to serve them in the best possible way.

Mr. Vice-President, Ladies and Gentlemen Presidents, Ladies and Gentlemen, it is true that we are living in a period where there is a contestation of the law, of the rule, of conventions, all in the name of a more global questioning of what decision-making is in our country or of the elites that represent it. Nevertheless, we must defend this conception of the Republic because the law, the texts, the international agreements, the European treaties are not made to dispossess the citizen, to submit him; they are made to protect him, to give him elements that allow him to succeed. The power has had, in relation to the Council of State, nuanced, contrasted, and different attitudes in the history of the Fifth Republic. During the five-year term I have just completed, beyond the work I have imposed on you, I have not had any particular contentious issues with you, and I have had great respect for what you decided here in this institution.

But you must also be attentive to the fact that this situation is not simply linked to a good order of our institutions and that there are always dangers, risks that beyond you the law may be called into question, that the protection of freedoms may be at stake. Therefore, I once again refer to your commitment and your competence, and I tell you this because I sincerely believe it, the Republic needs you, needs the missions you accomplish in its name, and for all this, I want to express my gratitude to you.