Statement by Mr. François Hollande, President of the Republic, on the situation in Ukraine and sanctions against Russia, in Newport on September 4, 2014.

France François Hollande · President of France

4 September 2014 · Newport

Context
Hollande addressed journalists at the NATO summit in Newport on September 4, 2014, discussing the Ukraine crisis, sanctions against Russia, and the suspension of the Mistral contract.
Main themes
Ukraine ceasefire, EU sanctions against Russia, Mistral warship contract suspension, political settlement in Ukraine, NATO response, separatist conflict, Normandy format diplomacy, Russian military involvement, territorial integrity of Ukraine, France's diplomatic role
Duration
~7 min
24th percentile
Words
827
24th percentile
Sentences
61
40th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.50
4th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 83%82%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

61 sentences in 19 paragraphs

Mr. President, you were able, thanks to this morning's meeting with Mr. POROSHENKO and five other heads of state, to get a better understanding of the current situation. You then had a one-on-one exchange. What is your assessment of the situation on the ground today? And above all, how much credence do you give to the ceasefire proclaimed by Vladimir PUTIN?

The President:

The situation in Ukraine is serious because there are, at this very moment, military operations taking place. We must do everything we can, France in particular, because it was the origin of what we called the "Normandy format" meeting on June 6, to ensure that there is a ceasefire, a real ceasefire, which then opens the way for a political settlement. There must be no ambiguity, either regarding the ceasefire or regarding the prospects for this political agreement.

Sanctions are necessary. That is why Europe will have to specify them further tomorrow. But what I wish is for the sanctions to achieve their objective, which is to convince the Russians to ensure that the separatists stop their operations so that a political agreement can be reached. With, beforehand, a true ceasefire.

I think that is what was the very idea of this morning's meeting with the five heads of state. They expressed their full support for the unity of Ukraine, its territorial integrity, and President POROSHENKO. They wanted to affirm the necessity of a ceasefire and a political agreement. What happened this morning is important.

Journalist:

Concretely, what do you plan to do? What can NATO do to constrain Vladimir PUTIN? What concrete measures do you think you can come up with?

The President:

Concrete measures have already been taken. Europe, that was the subject of its last European Council, and it will be implemented starting tomorrow, has imposed sanctions. It has even increased the level of sanctions as, unfortunately, military operations were taking place and there was evidence of Russian equipment and even Russian soldiers supporting the separatists.

Europe and the United States can also make it clear, and this has always been France's position, that a political agreement is desirable and that there will be no military solution to what is happening in Ukraine, neither for the Ukrainians, nor for the separatists, and therefore not for the Russians either. There cannot be a military solution. That is the message I had to convey here at NATO and that the heads of state expressed this morning.

But we must apply sufficient pressure. Hence the role of sanctions and the political will to seek a solution together. I have once again proposed to President POROSHENKO, and I will do so again to President PUTIN, that if a ceasefire occurs, we hold a meeting with Chancellor MERKEL, like we successfully did on June 6 in Normandy. France is available.

Journalist:

You have decided, Mr. President, to suspend the MISTRAL contract. Why did you decide to do this now, when American pressures have been ongoing for several months?

The President:

These contracts involve at least two ships, helicopter carriers. They were signed in 2011, so I was not President of the Republic at that time. Nevertheless, I wanted to execute these contracts. It was France's word, and it was also hours of work for the shipyards in Saint-Nazaire.

When the crisis in Ukraine broke out, I warned. I considered that there could be no sanctions that would affect signed contracts. I was not under any pressure, of any kind and from anywhere. But at the same time, I told the Russians: we want this contract to be executed, that the ship be delivered. The first one is almost ready; it could be ready in November. But there must be conditions. That is what I said yesterday. The conditions must be met for the ship to be delivered.

What are the conditions? A ceasefire and a political settlement. Today, these conditions are not met. How could I authorize the delivery of a ship that could, tomorrow, be a warship when there is a crisis in Ukraine? But as soon as, and it is quite possible in October or November, the conditions are met, the ships could be delivered.

If there were to be other complications, then the contract will not be suspended, but there will be delays. Because it is not possible to deliver a ship, or even two, under conditions that are not those of peace.

For now, there is no ceasefire. The ceasefire has not yet been decided. It is therefore not credible, since it has not yet been enacted. There can only be a ceasefire if it is accompanied by a set of principles allowing for a political settlement. There cannot be a ceasefire if there is no prospect of a political agreement. That is what France supports as a position; that is what France is ready to facilitate with a meeting in the Normandy format of June 6. Because France now feels committed.