Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at a dinner for the members of the Science Council on October 23, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

27 October 2024 · Dinner for the members of the Science Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed members of the Science Council at a dinner in Berlin on October 23, 2024, reflecting on science, democracy, and AI challenges.
Main themes
Science-policy relationship, free science and liberal democracy, Karl Popper and critical rationalism, artificial intelligence opportunities and risks, German innovation and university research, Science Council advisory role, open society under threat, trust in science and democracy, demographic change, teacher education reform, health prevention, optimism despite uncertainty
Duration
~9 min
32nd percentile
Words
1,103
32nd percentile
Sentences
43
27th percentile
Readability
37
30th percentile
Grade
14.4
71st percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 32%30%
  • Social 27%26%
  • Institutional 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 20%19%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

43 sentences in 14 paragraphs

"All life is problem-solving" – who does not know this oft-quoted statement by Karl Popper? In fact, it is nothing less than the insight that our knowledge is constantly growing, but that every piece of knowledge we gain raises new questions again and again. In Popper's words: "With every step we take forward, with every problem we solve, we not only discover new and unresolved problems, but we also discover that where we believed we were standing on solid and secure ground, in truth everything is uncertain and in a state of flux." I shouldn't have to present this to you; you experience it every day. But in the first year of the pandemic, this was something that not only scientists in our country had to understand.

For Popper, as you all know, this insight into the uncertainty and provisionality of intellectual, social, and political achievements was not a reason for pessimism or resignation – quite the opposite! This insight encourages us, in his view, to continually ask critical questions and to research, in order to gradually approach the truth. And it encourages us to act pragmatically, reasonably, and above all responsibly.

Free science and democratic politics, as different as their logics may be, have one thing in common: they both represent the never-finalized search, the provisional solving of problems, and a continuous learning process. And if we engage in our open society to ask and act in this sense, not succumbing to a normative scientism, nor dragging science along with political strategies, if we take these two axioms into account, then we can not only shape the future, but we also have every reason for at least cautious optimism – despite all the disappointments and setbacks that we also experience.

I say this also because just yesterday a new comparative study from the European Patent Office was presented, which shows how great the innovative capacity at German universities still is. According to this, every fourth academic patent in Europe is registered by a German university. And that means: Germany leads the European patent ranking of universities. I find that is already a reason for optimism – but not only that; it is, of course, also a mandate to maintain good conditions for independent science.

In this time of wars, crises, and upheavals, in which free science, liberal democracy, and open society are being attacked from both within and without, during this time, scientists, political leaders, and democrats should do everything they can to bring the relationship between science and politics, their respective laws of nature – that is, the process of independent science as well as the process of democratic decision-making – closer to more people and especially to more young people. Only in this way, I believe, can we succeed in strengthening trust in free science and at the same time in liberal democracy.

The Science Council stands for critical-rational thinking, more precisely: for critical-rational thinking that leads to actionable recommendations. With your statements and ideas, you strengthen and improve the scientific institutions in our country, whose insights and innovations we so urgently need if we want to secure the future of our country. I believe, dear guests, that especially in this time, your collective commitment cannot be appreciated enough, as you all help ensure that our country remains capable of facing the future.

In your role as the "Science TÜV," if I may say so, you check and ensure the quality of universities and research institutions. As profound advisors in science policy, you ensure a high-performing science system. And as a think tank, you continually provide important impulses for concrete changes, most recently, for example, for contemporary teacher education.

I am particularly grateful to you for consistently addressing the major issues of our time – currently, for example, the question of what strategies universities need in light of demographic change or how we can ensure that improved health prevention reaches as many people as possible in our aging society.

One of the most pressing issues of our time that affects us all is the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) on our lives and our self-understanding as human beings. Yuval Noah Harari, with whom we just sat down and discussed last week, and Geoffrey Hinton, the British pioneer of machine learning who was recently awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics, are not the only ones warning that AI could spiral out of control and become a threat to freedom and democracy.

On the contrary, I believe: We have the chance to rein in the wild growth surrounding AI and to keep AI compatible with democracy, to shape it in such a way that it benefits the individual and the common good rather than harms it. Promoting artificial intelligence while simultaneously civilizing it, seizing the opportunities it presents while keeping the risks it entails under control, that is the dual and truly challenging task we face. To tackle this task, we need scientific research. We need schools and universities that confront the issue. We need digitally literate citizens, societal debates, and political decisions.

I believe our country is now among the European leaders in AI research – others say and write: even among the world leaders. And precisely for this reason, we in science, politics, and society now bear a particular responsibility when it comes to making the potentials of AI usable and ensuring our own future viability, and to shaping this future in such a way that humanity, freedom, and democracy are preserved.

I hope that the Science Council will accompany this development as critically as it is pragmatically, as a voice of reason and optimism. That you have already issued recommendations for the digitalization of teaching and studies in recent years, that you have discussed how science can assert sovereignty in the digital space and protect data, and that you are currently preparing a paper on AI in higher education, all of this is important progress. And I can only add the request: Stay on this path!

"All life is problem-solving," yes. But especially in this difficult and unsettling time, when crises and challenges are piling up, we also feel how exhausting, how conflict-ridden, how draining this can be. From time to time, we therefore also need a break from problem-solving, time to catch our breath, space for new impressions and inspiring encounters. Our shared dinner today is such an opportunity to pause. It is wonderful that you are here! I look forward to the conversations with you.

I raise my glass to free science, to problem-solving – and to your health! A warm welcome and thank you very much!