Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at a dinner with the members of the Order Pour le mérite for Sciences and Arts on June 9, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

11 June 2024 · Dinner with the members of the Order Pour le mérite for Sciences and Arts · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed Order Pour le mérite members at a Berlin dinner on June 9, 2024, reflecting on the day's contrast between NSU terror commemorations and honoring science and arts.
Main themes
Political violence and democracy, right-wing extremism and NSU terrorism, civilization versus barbarism, role of science and arts in democracy, commemoration and memory, threats to democratic discourse, rule of law, cultural defense of civilization, Order Pour le mérite for Sciences and Arts
Duration
~13 min
45th percentile
Words
1,545
45th percentile
Sentences
55
36th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
13.4
61st percentile
Syntax
3.39
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 41%35%
  • Geopolitical 26%22%
  • Ceremonial 20%16%
  • Institutional 9%7%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 16%

55 sentences in 16 paragraphs

You have all spent the majority of today together at the concert hall at Gendarmenmarkt, at the annual spring meeting of the Order Pour le mérite. And it is tradition for the Federal President, as the protector of the Order, to participate in this session, and it has indeed not happened very often that the protector's chair has remained empty.

However, today such a rare case has occurred, and it unfortunately has a serious and sad background. I just returned from Mannheim on Friday – after discussions with the relatives of the murdered police officer and a memorial service. Last Sunday, I remembered the murdered Walter Lübcke at a large event in Kassel; just an hour ago, I returned from Cologne, where I attended the memorial service for the victims of a right-wing extremist terrorist attack on Keupstraße. It has indeed been 20 years since a nail bomb detonated there, in the middle of a shopping street with many Turkish shops, placed by terrorists of the self-proclaimed "National Socialist Underground" (NSU) in front of a hair salon. 22 people were injured at that time, many of them severely. They all, as well as relatives and neighbors, suffer, as was visible today in the conversations, still today under the consequences of the attack – just as, of course, all those who mourn the ten people murdered by NSU terrorists across Germany.

It was important, or I could also say: It was necessary to be in Cologne today, not only to express condolences to the victims of the attack and the relatives of the victims; not only to show the residents of the neighborhood in Cologne that they are not alone in their grief, in their pain; but also to leave the message, especially in this time, that we must confront the brutalization of political discourse in our country, that we must never become accustomed to violence in political conflict. I am and remain convinced: Violence destroys democracy. And that is why we must, especially on such occasions, at such remembrances and commemorations, try to clearly state that we must condemn violence, regardless of the political motivation from which it arises, whether it is right-wing or left-wing extremism or religious fundamentalism, in the end it does not matter. If violence dominates political discourse, then democracy will degenerate.

This preamble only because my two appointments today could not have been more different: earlier the remembrance of inhuman terror and now the honoring of sciences and arts. And that is – if you will, somewhat pathetically – the stark contrast between violence and culture, between barbarism and civilization, that has defined my day today.

It is, of course, just a coincidence that the memorial service today in the early afternoon and this dinner have fallen on the same date. But I still believe that this coincidence tells us something perhaps fundamental about our time. For the simultaneity, the coexistence, perhaps even the opposition of destructive violence and creative culture can be observed in many places, not just in Germany.

Disturbing outbreaks of violence are becoming a defining feature of our present times. And I am not only thinking of the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine, nor only of the terrorist attack by Hamas on Israel, nor only of the war in the Middle East. But I am also thinking of right-wing or Islamist motivated terror. I think of the almost daily hatred that runs through our society, especially in the digital space, but increasingly also on streets and squares. And I think of insults and demeaning remarks, of physical attacks on dissenters, on those of different faiths, on those who live differently, but increasingly also on representatives of the democratic state, but – I hope you have not experienced it yourself – also attacks on science and culture, summed up: attacks on all those who embody and defend what we call civilization.

The fascination with violence, the lust for unrestrainedness and for crossing boundaries, which we observe today in so many places in the world – all of this sometimes strikes me as a surge against the civilizational principle that there are indeed rules for our coexistence. This current, indeed almost ubiquitous violence makes us very aware today that civilization, as Bärbel Bohley once said a long time ago, is a thin skin that can tear at any moment.

And once again we face the great question of how we can protect and nurture this thin skin, how it is possible to preserve and strengthen civilization. Enforcing the prohibition of violence, holding perpetrators accountable, that is the task of the democratic rule of law. But that alone, you all know, is not enough. I say this here because it is not least also sciences and arts that, in my firm conviction, prepare the ground for civilization to grow and thrive.

You just passed by the Salon Voltaire on your way here on the ground floor. It has not been around for very long. I initiated the repurposing and renaming of this room almost three years ago, to give the era of Enlightenment, also the Prussian Enlightenment, a visible place at the official residence of the Federal President. For a few weeks now, we have been exhibiting a precious manuscript from the pen of Immanuel Kant, whose 300th birthday we have just celebrated. It is the first pages of his work "Perpetual Peace," in which Kant, as you know, formulated a central goal: All states should be republican in nature and unite into a worldwide league of nations.

Even if we are not aware of it every day: The European Union comes closest to this ideal – as a joint project of European democratic states that has secured peace and growing prosperity for millions of people for several generations now. And even though this European Union is certainly – the closer you are, the more you know it – not perfect, even though we know that it needs to be further developed: We must not allow it to die, as President Macron recently strongly advocated during his state visit to Germany. Whether the hope is fulfilled that voters today will choose the Europe of peace, freedom, and democracy by a majority, we will find out later this evening, when all polling stations across Europe have closed and we know the results.

In any case, we are today further away from a global peace order, as Kant envisioned it, than most of us, I count myself among them, could have imagined after the end of the Cold War. But especially now, in times of war, we must not lose sight of great guiding ideas like those of Kant. A world order that effectively condemns war, that protects universal human rights, a global community that decisively advances the fight against the climate crisis, that must remain our goal, despite all difficulties. That must remain our goal if people, flora, and fauna on this planet are to have a future!

If we want to preserve civilization and help shape a more peaceful, just, and better future, then we should continually turn to the famous Kantian questions: What can I know? What should I do? What may I hope? What is man? And it is especially you, the sciences and arts, on which the hope for viable answers to these questions rests. It is you, all of you together, who show us what humans are capable of – and what is needed for a good coexistence to succeed. It is you who allow us to see the world with different eyes, who teach us empathy and show us that we are all dependent on one another.

But you are also the ones who uncover the contradictory relationship of humans to nature – and provide us with ideas and solutions for a more climate-friendly life. You are the ones who make us think, who move us to change course, who let us rise up against inhumanity, injustice, and violence. And you are the ones who bring different people into conversation with one another, in our society and beyond.

And, not least, I want to say this without exaggeration: It is you, the sciences and arts, who provide support and also inspire courage with your work. And that also because you continually remind us of what Kant formulated: "Out of such crooked wood as that which man is made, nothing straight can be fashioned." I believe that is one of Kant's perhaps most beautiful sentences, because it reminds us that we must always critically examine everything human and human-made, including ourselves, and because it simultaneously relieves us from paralyzing perfectionism and thus encourages us to act.

For the humane power of art and science, the two new members of the Order Pour le mérite also stand – of course in their own, outstanding way: Dear John Neumeier, dear Heinrich Detering, we are very pleased to welcome you here in this circle this evening – it is wonderful that you are with us!

The events of today, which I have briefly described to you, are behind me and also behind us. I am looking forward to an exciting dinner with all of you, and I promise that I will be back at the next spring meeting.