Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the closing ceremony of the academic year at the College of Europe in Bruges on June 21, 2024, in Bruges:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

21 June 2024 · Closing ceremony of the academic year at the College of Europe · College of Europe, Bruges, Belgium

Context
Steinmeier addressed the 2024 graduating class of the College of Europe in Bruges, Belgium, delivering the closing ceremony commencement speech on June 21, 2024.
Main themes
European unity and integration, public service commitment, geopolitical challenges, democracy under threat, generational responsibility, optimism vs. pessimism, Russia-Ukraine war, climate change and transformation, populism and extremism, College of Europe graduation, personal reflections on political career, European identity
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,744
72nd percentile
Sentences
154
82nd percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 39%35%
  • Social 28%25%
  • Ceremonial 17%15%
  • Institutional 13%12%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 11%

154 sentences in 38 paragraphs

What a day! Today, you graduate from the College of Europe under the proud name of Madeleine Albright. You have worked hard to get here; you have also worked hard during your studies here; you have completed your final exams – and now we all here in the hall, your professors, your parents, your friends, and I, would like to say to you: congratulations, dear graduating class of 2024! You did it!

I am sure you are all excited about what lies ahead. You are eager to step out into the world and help shape it. But before that, let me give you a presidential piece of advice: take a deep breath and enjoy this special moment in your life! Rejoice in the knowledge you take with you from this beautiful city of Bruges – a city like a fairy tale, isn’t it? Be proud of what you have achieved, spend time with your friends you have made during your time at the College – and who knows, perhaps one or two friendships will turn into something more. I have heard that this does happen here.

So enjoy your summer – and as the German Federal President, I must add: please watch the European Football Championship! So far, it has been an exciting tournament with many strong teams, and no one knows yet who will win. But here comes another outstanding aspect of the College of Europe: since students from truly all European countries are gathered here, we can be sure that some of you will celebrate in the end – and the others can celebrate with them.

This graduating class of 2024, bearing the name Madeleine Albright, is just as diverse as our wonderful continent: students from 50 countries, with a wide range of life experiences and views.

But there is something that unites you: Europe matters to you. Public service matters to you. The miracle of the European Union, of nations that have chosen peace over war, cooperation over confrontation, a shared future over a divided past – that matters to you. Ensuring that on the battlefields in Flanders, which you all have visited, the blood of young Europeans is never again shed in the name of nationalism and hatred – that matters to you.

I am confident that all of you, including your friends in Natolin and Tirana, will find your place to work for the miracle of Europe, to work for its future. Wherever it ultimately takes you – to the institutions of your home countries or the European Union, into diplomacy or non-governmental organizations – I commend you for wanting to commit yourselves to the common good. For the good of Europe.

I commend you and have the utmost respect for your choice to take this path, for we all know: these are historically difficult times in which you are committing yourselves to the common good. Russia’s war against Ukraine, the brutal attack by Hamas on Israel, and the suffering of men, women, and children in Gaza. The threats to our democracies both from outside and from within. The temptations of populism and extremism, as was clearly demonstrated in the recent European elections. The fight against climate change and the profound impacts of the energy transition as well as the digital and economic transformation in all our societies. Yes, it is truly a difficult time to commit oneself to public service.

Every generation hears the call of history. Every generation faces defining challenges. But when you look at the world around us, I believe it is fair to say: your generation is being asked for more than many generations before you.

Allow me to take you back a few decades. Thirty-three years ago, I stood in your place. Let me say right away: I did not attend the College of Europe. I did not think about going into politics or public service until my early thirties. In 1991 – I had just completed my doctorate and was preparing for an academic career – I received a call from Brigitte, a good friend who had just taken a position in the new Lower Saxony state government in Hanover. She said to me: “Frank, it’s an exciting time here, you have to come to us!”

And indeed, it was an exciting time, a time full of hope. The wall was gone. The people in East Germany had accomplished a peaceful revolution. Germany was a reunified country in the heart of Europe. The peoples of Eastern Europe had fought for their freedom and thrown off the yoke of the Soviet Union. From Tallinn to Timișoara, from Vilnius to Varna, people were rebuilding their nations and setting the course for their path into the European family. Freedom and democracy seemed to be on the rise everywhere. History was on our side! So when I entered public service, my mindset was: the world is getting better every day, and I want to help. I want to do my part.

The contrast to today could not be greater. Optimism is a scarce commodity – especially in our part of the world, in a Europe where the crisis mode seems to be the new normal. Your generation, which is now committing itself to public service, therefore has a very different perspective: the world seems to be getting worse every day. Therefore, the attitude must be: let us do everything we can to make it different!

I have the utmost respect for that! When the winds of history do not fill your sails – how much harder and how much more important it is then to commit oneself to the common good!

To be on the winning side is easy. It is easy to support Real Madrid. It is much harder to step onto the field and fight when the opposing team is ahead, when you are being booed from the stands, when it is pouring rain. I promise this will be my last football analogy – after all, politics is not a game. Our future is not a game.

Dear students, I am not here to talk about the dark clouds of the present or the brighter days of the past. That would be neither helpful nor appropriate. No, I am here to talk about you – about the wonderful young people who want to make a difference, even in difficult times. I am here to talk about what it takes to make a difference. What it takes for you to shape your future instead of enduring it.

There is one word that is central to all politics: realism. To take the world as it is, but not to leave it that way – that is realism.

I place this term at the center of my speech because I believe that we Europeans need to rethink what realism means at this critical moment, in this crisis-ridden time. Many of us are asking: what should we do, what can we hope to achieve, what concessions must we make if we want to make something good happen in a world that seems to be developing for the worse in many ways?

For many years, realism and idealism, action and aspiration seemed to complement each other naturally. And of course, it is easier to be active in the world, to take risks, to invest in new partnerships, politically and economically, when you believe that things are generally on the rise. When you believe that the world as a whole is moving towards freedom, democracy, human rights, and the rule of law.

That realism and idealism point in the same direction was a notion that was particularly strong in my country, in Germany, where we assumed that the happiness of our nation – peaceful reunification, democracy, prosperity – would extend linearly to the rest of the world and also into the future.

This belief has been thoroughly lost to us – especially since the turning point of February 24, 2022. On that February 24, Vladimir Putin not only attacked Ukraine – he shattered the entire security architecture of our continent. He destroyed the idea of an order built on rules and peaceful coexistence, which we had worked so hard to establish.

Instead of being able to spread peace and prosperity further, we now find ourselves in a situation where we are rearming again, where we are sending weapons to Ukraine to defend against the aggressor and strengthening our own resilience on all levels: in the military, in energy and trade, in our democratic institutions.

For many, especially for young people witnessing this, it seems as if reality and ideals are drifting further apart, as if our actions in the world and our goals for the world are increasingly diverging.

How do we deal with this? Some say our actions are wrong. Others say our ideals are half-hearted. I believe: more than ever, we must engage! Even if we are facing the headwinds of history – deep in my heart, I am still a realist. I still believe that it is better to try and fail than to never try and always be right. I believe that it is better to act and be judged by history than not to act and judge others.

When I look around this hall, when I see all the youthful energy, all the skills and connections you have developed here, I am deeply convinced that you will try and that you will make a difference.

No graduation ceremony, no speech can end without well-meaning advice from the older generation. So here is mine: What does it take? I think realism in our time demands three things from you: humility, courage, and a willingness to compromise.

Humility means: you are not always right. No one is always right – except in the world of Twitter and TikTok. The world of social media has devastating effects on the quality of our public discourse. Self-righteousness, black-and-white thinking, hasty, polemical, and aggressive judgments – that brings clicks and likes. What we need is the opposite: to filter out the noise, to really listen to the other side, to perceive the shades of gray in the world and to deal with its contradictions – that is necessary, but it is difficult.

I say this on an individual level, but I think it also applies on a systemic level. It applies to the European project as well. Yes, we have every reason to believe in our values and to defend them. We have every reason to be proud of our liberal democracies and our European institutions that we have built and to protect them. However, we must never feel superior or become complacent because of our values and institutions!

As Timothy Garton Ash wrote in his wonderful book “Europe: A Personal History”: “When we celebrate Europe’s multifaceted heritage, we always run the risk of falling back into sweeping claims about the uniqueness and quasi-natural superiority of European civilization.” Such sweeping claims, such superiority and self-righteousness ultimately play into the hands of China and Russia with their anti-Western narratives, and it harms one of our most important strategic interests as Europeans, namely to form partnerships with all the countries around the globe, in Asia, Africa, and Latin America, that are rising and seeking their rightful place on the world stage.

Let us not forget: Europe’s “multifaceted heritage,” our history of enlightenment and emancipation is – from the perspective of many in the world – inextricably linked to a history of imperialism, colonialism, and oppression. As Europeans, we must never overlook the dark sides of our history. Only by acknowledging that Europe’s history – in this regard – is full of double standards can we prevent ourselves from falling into a new double standard today. That is what I mean by humility.

Secondly: courage. One of the reasons social media is attractive to people is its simplicity. It is easy to be loud. It is easy to express your opinion and leave it at that. But declarations change nothing. Engaging in dialogue, seeking common ground, striving for solutions, and acting accordingly – that brings about change!

In a time when the world is developing as unpredictably as never before, there is no guarantee of success for what you do in politics or public service. Therefore, it requires your courage. You will be active in European affairs, in national politics or in diplomacy, you will bring all your passion and intellect to bear – and yet you can never be sure what judgment history will pass.

I give you an example: Your esteemed rector, my good friend Federica Mogherini, has always been a fearless diplomat. Never knowing what will happen in five, ten, or twenty years, she has always strived to make a difference in the present. Dear Federica, I often think back to the long days and nights ten years ago when we negotiated with Iran about the end of its nuclear program. Could we see into the future back then? Did we know how things would develop in the Near and Middle East? No. But one thing I know: The only moment over decades when Iran's nuclear enrichment demonstrably decreased was the three years from 2015 to 2018, when the nuclear agreement was in force, before the Trump administration decided to unilaterally withdraw from it. And when I consider the destructive power that Iran is unleashing in the region today, I am glad that this regime does not possess nuclear weapons, and I still believe that we must work to ensure that it never comes to that.

It takes courage for that, and I believe courage is urgently needed in the Middle East today. Since October 7, indescribable suffering has prevailed. I visited Kibbutz Be’eri in southern Israel, which was devastated by Hamas. I saw the bloodstains, the burned houses. And I met Palestinians from the Gaza Strip who have lost mothers, brothers, children. They have lost everything they had built.

But, my dear friends, expressions—whether expressions of solidarity or outrage—do not change the situation on the ground. The only way out of misery, in my opinion, is to continue to advocate for the release of the remaining hostages and to negotiate a ceasefire. That alone can be the first step towards a political process. And every political process must lead both sides to a future of security, dignity, and self-determination. That is the courage that both Palestinians and Israelis deserve—that is the courage I expect from those in power everywhere, in Israel and in the region. The courage to say: This cannot go on. Yes, a two-state solution has never seemed so far away—but it has also never been so urgently needed!

Third: Compromise. Compromise is—from the media's perspective—the least sexy element of democracy, and yet I believe it is the most important. And history has shown: Compromise has always been the strongest engine of European integration. You all know that all-night negotiations in the European Council are anything but glamorous. On the contrary, they are nerve-wracking.

But that is how Europe works. I even say: That is the beauty of Europe! Compromise creates cooperation. Cooperation creates unity. Unity creates strength. And how much strength have we shown in the past two years in the face of Putin's war! When he invaded Ukraine, Putin thought the West was weak and divided. We proved him wrong. We in Europe, we in NATO were stronger and more united than ever before—and we must continue to support Ukraine for as long as necessary.

Working together and staying together will, as you all know, not be easier after the European elections. Compromise will still be necessary, but my years in Brussels have taught me: Compromise can only be found in the spirit of Europe and not against the spirit of Europe. Yes, all leading politicians in Europe are elected for their own agenda, for the concerns of their own population. But: If we all want to impose our own way and tear apart the bigger picture of Europe, then no one wins, but everything is lost.

There has never been a more difficult time to fight for Europe—and there has never been a more important time to fight for Europe!

My heartfelt congratulations on your graduation from the College of Europe. I sincerely hope that you will fight for your Europe—with courage and humility, with an open mind and an open heart. Europe is important to you. And believe me: You are important to Europe.