Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at a discussion event on the topic "Future of Democracy and Social Cohesion" on September 2, 2021, in Bratislava:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

6 September 2021 · Discussion event on the topic "Future of Democracy and Social Cohesion" · Bratislava

Context
Steinmeier addressed a discussion event on democracy and social cohesion in Bratislava, Slovakia on September 2, 2021, engaging in German-Slovak democratic dialogue.
Main themes
Future of democracy, social cohesion, trust in democratic institutions, political polarization, democratic resilience, liberal democracy vs. illiberal democracy, digital transformation of public discourse, climate change and long-term governance, COVID-19 pandemic and state credibility, Germany-Slovakia dialogue, authoritarian challenges, democratic representation
Duration
~11 min
37th percentile
Words
1,267
37th percentile
Sentences
57
37th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 63%63%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Geopolitical 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

57 sentences in 22 paragraphs

Democracy and Cohesion: Where in Europe is this question not at the top of the agenda? Here in Germany, just as in your country, Slovakia. I hope you do not expect me to provide definitive answers to these challenging questions; they will be German answers – and they tell something about the debates we are having in our own country. I believe it can only be done by sharing our experiences with each other.

There is no magic formula for a successful democracy. Our different influences from geography and demographics, political culture and political cycles, history and society, economic development and social movements are too great.

All these peculiarities shape the democratic life of our countries, presenting each democracy with its own unique questions. And yet, as democrats, we are all in the same boat. On the one hand, we are united by the conviction that the democratic constitution of our societies is the best way to bring the diverse hopes, expectations, and abilities of our citizens to their fullest peaceful development. On the other hand, we are grappling in our two countries with fundamental changes that challenge our democracies as we know them:

How can representation and debate succeed in the future when parties lose their binding power, social milieus diffuse, and the public discourse space, especially on the internet, changes rapidly?

What do we counter the tendency towards polarization and escalation with, which discredits and scorns the important concept of compromise that is so vital for the success of democracy?

How can democracy tackle the great challenges that extend far beyond a single legislative period and require long-term thinking as well as decisive action in the here and now – for example, in the fight against climate change or in the dignified management of digitalization?

And what responsibility do democracies bear in their engagement with other systems for the universal validity of their own standards? – A question that must particularly concern us these days in light of the images from Kabul.

I do not expect that we will find a definitive answer to these difficult questions here and today in our circle. But I want to name the questions because the search for answers to these questions is at the center of my speech and actions as Federal President. I pose them to you also to make it clear that for me, the debate about the future of democracy must be about more than a largely static defense of what we once recognized as right.

Rather, it is about us jointly developing a compelling idea of the democracy of the future. We must not view this change only defensively, but must also understand the idea of democracy itself as a dynamic development. Then, whether in America or Australia, in Berlin or Bratislava, it holds true: We are all searching for the most convincing answers, for the best way. I am convinced that we can learn a lot from each other if we embark on this search together, in conversation among democrats, in the dialogue of democracies. Why? Because our "being democratic" connects us more than anything else.

If I had to name a fundamental prerequisite for all functioning democracies, it would be: trust. Only with trust – in ourselves as sovereign voters, in each other as citizens, in our public debates, but also in our procedures and institutions – only with trust can democracy succeed.

Trust in a democracy is primarily based on this always fragile agreement between citizens and their state: You, state, do your part; I, citizen, do mine. The past months have shown us how precious, but also how fragile this trust can be – for example, in the fight against the Covid-19 pandemic and its consequences.

The way our states meet the demands they set for themselves shapes the credibility of our order and the trust of citizens in this order, in democracy, its representatives, institutions, and procedures. In short: The trust of citizens has prerequisites! That officeholders see themselves as advocates of the entire people, that the majority does not ignore the legitimate interests of minorities, that state institutions function, that democratic influence is not excluded and corruption is fought, that the rule of law is upheld.

The periodic recurrence of elections alone does not secure democracy. Those who misunderstand or deliberately disregard this are the ones who now want to see "illiberal democracy" merely as an expression of the same constitutional tradition. My conviction remains that democracy is either liberal – or it is not.

The internal resilience of our democracies is currently being put to the test. In addition to external challenges from authoritarian counter-models, whose fascination penetrates deeply into our own societies, there are attacks from within that we must not ignore. Attacks on our democratic public spaces. Loud minorities are also using the tools of digital manipulation to make democracy contemptible. What is happening in the news feeds and comment sections of social media in terms of polarization, the coarsening of language, and silent but effective manipulation of our public debates should not be downplayed – and we must not accept it!

When bridging party lines, the willingness to cooperate with political competitors, and compromise are defamed as betrayal, then that is a problem for democracy. When respect for the views of others, the fundamental insight that others may also be right, is drowned out by the cry for clarity, then that is also a problem for democracy. When mayors resign because they can no longer endure the attacks on the internet, when the German Federal President has to establish a support network for threatened local politicians, when verbal violence online quickly turns into physical violence on the streets, then it becomes clear how unchecked polarization can become a burden on democracy.

All the more urgently, we need strong, trustworthy, independent media that inform, educate, and contextualize. Their functioning should not be aimed at turning the daily spiral of outrage one more turn.

Across Europe, we should agree on a few fundamental things: Those who attack journalists and silence free media, who harass universities and seek to dictate public opinion from ministries and party headquarters, are undermining trust in our democratic public and undermining democracy – and with it, the values that we have made the common foundation in the European Union.

If I may add a third aspect for our discussion regarding trust in democratic institutions and trust in the public debate space, it would be – quite simply – our trust in each other as citizens.

This trust in one another is expressed in a democracy in many ways – above all, however, in the recognition of the necessity of limiting one's own freedom in order to enable the freedom of others. We have just experienced this anew in the hardest months of the pandemic.

It worries me when this basic trust is waning in many democratic societies today, when polarization is spreading, when the political opponent is increasingly stigmatized as an enemy. This not only poisons political discourse. It also erodes the understanding of the fundamental value of peaceful power transitions. But democracy is rule for a time.

This basic trust cannot be mandated by any parliament or conjured up by any newspaper; we cannot wish it into existence or litigate it from one another. We must live it. And we must cultivate a political culture that seeks democratic competition but avoids declaring internal enemies among democrats. This applies in Berlin just as much as in Bratislava.

I am greatly looking forward to today's debate. Thank you very much for your attention.