Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at a discussion round on hate and violence as a threat to democracy on August 17, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

18 August 2021 · Discussion round on hate and violence as a threat to democracy · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a discussion round in Berlin on August 17, 2021, commemorating the centenary of the assassination of Weimar politician Matthias Erzberger by right-wing terrorists.
Main themes
Hate and political violence against democracy, Matthias Erzberger's legacy, Weimar Republic and its defenders, right-wing extremism and political murder, parliamentary democracy and compromise, historical memory and commemoration, courage and democratic virtues, threats to democracy then and now
Duration
~14 min
48th percentile
Words
1,668
48th percentile
Sentences
73
48th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.08
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.44
93rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 58%53%
  • Geopolitical 18%16%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

73 sentences in 24 paragraphs

"Hated because you are the administrator of the bankrupt company German Empire, you lie shattered like a cold and dead man – and Germany is the same. Hated because you show civil courage to the gentlemen with monocles – because at just seventeen you do not conceal the disgrace of the Ludendörffer… The German cannot tolerate this: that someone tells him the truth, that someone without a lieutenant's collar chases away the spirit of the mercenary."

One hundred years ago, on August 26, 1921, Matthias Erzberger was murdered during a walk in the Black Forest by right-wing nationalist terrorists. A few days later, Kurt Tucholsky's obituary appeared in "Weltbühne," from which I have just quoted. Verses that express horror and outrage. And which also vividly illustrate: The gunshots aimed at Erzberger were an attack of the old on the new Germany, an attack on the first German democracy.

Since the November Revolution, hundreds of political murders have shaken the young Republic. The vast majority were committed by right-wing extremists. Especially communists and socialists were beaten to death, shot, or drowned in the torn post-war society. Rosa Luxemburg, Karl Liebknecht, Kurt Eisner, and Gustav Landauer are among the most well-known victims.

Unlike them, Matthias Erzberger, the party man of the Catholic Center, was not a representative of the red revolution. He was brutally murdered because he embodied, like few other politicians of his time, the new state order, the parliamentary democracy of the Weimar Republic.

The bullets of the murderers struck a passionate and combative parliamentarian, a mediator who built bridges between parties and forged coalitions; a pragmatist who wanted to orient himself not by illusions but by reality. They struck a foreign policy expert who had fought for peace and international understanding since 1917 and had signed to end the First World War. And they struck the former finance minister and vice chancellor of the Weimar Republic, who tirelessly advocated for the common people and for social justice.

Matthias Erzberger was neither a hero nor a saint; he was not free from contradictions, errors, and mistakes; he corrected many positions during his political life and adapted to new circumstances. Thus, in 1914 he had been enthusiastic about the war, even dreamed of great annexations – and then transformed under the impression of the impending defeat into a champion of a peace of understanding. In his obituary on Erzberger, the publicist Stefan Großmann wrote in the weekly "Das Tage-Buch": "He was one of the few politicians in Germany who had the strength for transformation and becoming within himself. For that reason alone, he had to be hated."

Matthias Erzberger stands for the breakthrough into political and social modernity; he was indeed a pioneer of democracy. I am pleased that we have the opportunity today to remember this fascinating politician together, here in Berlin, in the city where he lived and worked for almost two decades – without ceasing to be a home-loving Swabian.

For far too long, the Weimar Republic has been viewed only from its end, from its failure, as a prehistory of National Socialism. For far too long, those who – like Erzberger – took responsibility after the failure of the monarchy and built the first German democracy were denied the rightful recognition. It is good that this has changed in recent years.

Since 2004, the birthplace of Matthias Erzberger in Buttenhausen has been a memorial site that showcases the life, work, and death of this significant man. I am very pleased that the key players of this project are here among us today. My special greetings go to you, Mayor Münzing, and the volunteers from Münsingen, Professor Lutum-Lenger from the House of History of Baden-Württemberg, and last but not least, Dr. Christopher Dowe, who has tirelessly engaged in the Erzberger commemoration for many years. You have all accomplished a true pioneering achievement, and I thank you from the bottom of my heart for that.

Matthias Erzberger embodied political virtues that are still indispensable today for the success of a democracy: the greatness to question one's own positions and admit mistakes, the strength to forge compromises with political opponents, and the determination to take on government responsibility even in difficult times; finally, the courage not to bow to any threats against one's own person – unfortunately, this is again relevant.

It was therefore a correct decision that the German Bundestag recently named one of its buildings after Matthias Erzberger. This is largely due to the efforts of Bundestag President Norbert Lammert; he is here among us today, and I also thank him very much for his initiative.

When we commemorated the 100th anniversary of the proclamation of the Republic in the Bundestag on November 9, 2018, I expressed the wish that we dedicate even more attention, more passion, and also more financial resources to the places and protagonists of our democracy's history.

Since then, much has happened. The federal government has expanded its commitment to Hambach Castle; it is permanently supporting the House of the Weimar Republic in Weimar. The future of the Paulskirche in Frankfurt as a national symbol of German democracy history is on the agenda, and just before the summer break, the Bundestag decided to establish the new federal foundation "Places of German Democracy History."

The example of the Erzberger memorial site shows how important local memory political engagement is. Democracy history begins locally. This good example must be emulated. In other places, in other federal states, the men and women whose legacy our democracy rests upon should be traced, yet far too little is remembered about them. The new federal foundation will hopefully act as a motor to discover and preserve many more places of democracy history.

The murder of Matthias Erzberger was preceded by an unprecedented campaign of incitement and defamation. Erzberger was slandered as a traitor to the state, as corrupt, as a "Reichsschädling." Antisemites spread that he was not a Catholic but the illegitimate son of Jewish parents.

The ringleader of this incitement was not a confused outsider but came from the midst of the old elite: Karl Helfferich was a former state secretary and board member of Deutsche Bank. His apocalyptic scenario, which predicted the downfall of Germany, knew only one solution: "Away with Erzberger!" and he suggested that ultimately any means would be justified for that. No one could be surprised that in the agitated situation of Weimar democracy, such words quickly turned into actions. Erzberger himself had sensed shortly before his death: "The bullet that is to hit me has already been cast." That far too many – especially in the bourgeoisie – did not distance themselves from the incitement at that time, but rather secretly or openly shared it, that the judiciary did not resolutely counter the slanders, and that the security authorities allowed the murderers to escape abroad, all this remains scandalous. It also illustrates the destructive forces to which Germany's first democracy was repeatedly exposed.

"A democrat in times of hatred" – this is how Erzberger was once referred to in a book title. The question is: How does it stand today, in our times, with hatred and democracy?

The feeling of a new coarsening of political discourse is widespread – and it is justified: According to a recent survey, more than two-thirds of all mayors have experienced insults, threats, or violence; many have been beaten or spat on. The number of politically motivated crimes rose significantly again last year – acts from the right, from the left, and increasingly also across this political arithmetic. With Walter Lübcke, for the first time in the history of the Federal Republic, an officeholder became a victim of political murder two years ago. When we remember Matthias Erzberger today, we also think of Walter Lübcke.

No question, a democracy needs debate, needs conflict and strife – but there is never a justification for violence. Violence seeks to stifle freedom, violence kills every democracy!

It is part of the tragic experience of German history that democrats must always draw a clear firewall against all those who openly or covertly propagate or even justify violence as a means of political confrontation with hatred and incitement. In Weimar, this was lacking.

The state and society must never again leave those democrats who become victims of hatred and violence alone. I have therefore taken on the patronage of the initiative "Strong in Office," with which the municipal top associations support the many volunteers who engage in local politics and who are now far too often – across the country – attacked.

The judiciary today needs the necessary resources to investigate and punish crimes committed online in the digital society. And we need particularly high standards for those who wish to serve in public office today. If there are important lessons to be learned from the Erzberger murder, it is that a democracy erodes from within when its institutions and officeholders do not unequivocally stand on the ground of constitutional order, when citizens, even well-off ones, allow themselves to be carried away by obscure lies, irrational fantasies, and calls for violence filled with hatred. And yet this happens every day, every hour, in our time, in our country!

"You were not the first – you will not be the last," it says at the end of Tucholsky's obituary on Matthias Erzberger. Unfortunately, Kurt Tucholsky was right: Erzberger was not the last. No more than twelve months later, the same terrorist group murdered Germany's first Jewish foreign minister, Walther Rathenau. And a good ten years and many more murders later, Germany's first democracy was destroyed.

The knowledge of this destructive work has made the Federal Republic a resilient democracy. A democracy that powerfully protects and defends its values and institutions; a democracy that guarantees freedom of expression but does not allow that this freedom is misused to take it away from others. A democracy that now has a solid tradition and today confidently honors Matthias Erzberger, one of its pioneers and courageous champions.