Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at a symposium on the Bellevue Forum: "On the Future of Democracy – How do we strengthen the Republic?" on March 11, 2022, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

11 March 2022 · Bellevue Forum symposium on the future of democracy · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the Bellevue Forum symposium in Berlin on March 11, 2022, discussing democracy's future amid Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
Main themes
Future of liberal democracy, Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine, resilience of democracies, European solidarity, transatlantic alliance, defense capabilities, democratic reform, sanctions against Russia, refugee crisis, civil society engagement, autocracy vs. democracy
Duration
~17 min
56th percentile
Words
1,979
56th percentile
Sentences
94
60th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
12.0
46th percentile
Syntax
2.96
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
50th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 38%38%
  • Institutional 26%26%
  • Ceremonial 23%23%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

94 sentences in 29 paragraphs

We are all deeply affected by the images and reports from Kyiv, Kharkiv, Odessa, Mariupol, and many other cities in Ukraine. The brutal war of aggression that Russian President Putin has been waging for more than two weeks, the many lives that this invasion costs, the suffering and destruction it brings, all of this shakes us to the core.

Even in these hours, countless Ukrainians are risking their lives to defend their republic against Russian troops. The fight that the people in Ukraine are waging against a militarily superior aggressor is not only courageous; it sets an example. It dramatically shows the world that freedom and democracy are not guaranteed forever, that they are being fought for again today, also because autocracies feel threatened by the openness of democracy.

For many people in our country, in Europe, and in the world of liberal democracies, Putin's war is a shock. But this shock has not driven us apart or paralyzed us; rather, it has brought us closer together and made us act more decisively.

We are witnessing these days how the liberal democracies in the European Union and the Atlantic alliance stand side by side to support Ukrainian independence and to rein in a regime that invades another country with the aim of subjugating its citizens.

We are witnessing how hundreds of thousands of people, women and children from Ukraine, seek and find refuge in the European Union. We are witnessing how millions of people across Europe are taking to the streets to make a statement for peace. We are witnessing how many are also showing solidarity with the Russians who do not want this war, who suffer from its consequences, who courageously oppose the dictatorial regime in Moscow, and who are threatened with imprisonment and worse for speaking the truth.

This war of aggression, which increasingly affects the civilian population in Ukraine, challenges us. This injustice cannot go unanswered. Most people in Germany feel this with great clarity.

The turning point that the war of aggression initiated by Putin represents also demands a price. Not only is our humanitarian solidarity in receiving fleeing people once again required. The necessary, sharp sanctions that isolate Russia inevitably bring burdens, losses, and uncertainties for us as well. And that is not enough. We are challenged to strengthen our own defense capabilities and those of the alliance. The return of war to Europe teaches us that we must be able to defend ourselves against attacks. In other words: democracies must be resilient, even when diplomatic opportunities arise again. Because we can only negotiate successfully from a position of strength, not from a position of weakness. I always like to quote the wonderful line from John F. Kennedy's inaugural address: "Let us never negotiate out of fear. But let us never fear to negotiate."

In light of the war in Ukraine, we want to take stock of our forum on the future of democracy and look ahead: How do we strengthen the republic? And what can, what must we do now to make liberal democracy, the European Union, and the transatlantic alliance future-proof?

Here at this table today, nearly thirty women and men from science, culture, media, and politics have come together, who have participated in one of the twelve editions of Forum Bellevue in recent years. They live or work in Germany, Austria, Bulgaria, Hungary, the Netherlands, Italy, the United Kingdom, or the United States; they view liberal democracy and, of course, its opponents from different perspectives, and they represent viewpoints that provoke thought and certainly also dissent. They all stand for a culture of argumentative engagement, from which our democracy lives and from which its strength arises.

Most of you have reformulated, updated, and further developed the thoughts you presented here in this hall on panels over the past year. In this way, a book has emerged, a 432-page plea for liberal democracy that points the way to a democratic future.

I would like to thank everyone who contributed as discussants and authors to this forum and to the book "On the Future of Democracy." And I thank the Bertelsmann Foundation and especially you, dear Liz Mohn. This series has been a heartfelt concern for you! We are grateful for the support without which we could not have managed a forum of this magnitude and such a book project. My heartfelt thanks to all of you! And it is wonderful to see you gathered here today.

In my speech before the Federal Assembly on February 13, I said: Mr. Putin, "do not underestimate the strength of democracy!" I had good reasons for this warning. And many of those reasons will resurface today in our debate.

It is a special honor for me, dear guests, to welcome the Federal President of the Republic of Austria to our gathering today. Dear Alexander Van der Bellen, we are always in contact; we have just exchanged thoughts over the phone in recent days, and I know how much the war in Ukraine concerns and disturbs you and your fellow citizens in Austria. That you are here today to share your perspective on the situation and the future of democracy with us is not only a sign of friendship but also a symbol of solidarity in our European family.

Dear Alexander, I am pleased that you are engaging with us today and sharing your thoughts on the future of democracy. A warm welcome to you here in Bellevue in Berlin!

"What future does the West have?" was the question with which we opened Forum Bellevue in September 2017. Back then – it seems like a long time ago – Donald Trump had just taken office as President of the United States, the government in London was initiating the exit of the United Kingdom from the European Union, the dispute over the admission of millions of refugees from the war in Syria was shaking the European community, and in many democracies, resentments and nationalist forces were gaining traction, a new fascination with authoritarianism seemed to be spreading.

The COVID-19 pandemic, which broke out in spring 2020, deepened divides in our society, created new rifts, and showed how fragile trust in democratic institutions is. At least for a portion of the citizens, this trust has waned. The great task of quickly and decisively changing course in politics, economics, and society to stop global warming also puts liberal democracy and our cohesion to a new test.

The experience of confusion and uncertainty, of complexity and contingency, the experience that in our lives, in our world, much is possible but nothing is taken for granted, in my view, is not an argument against democracy, but rather a strong argument for liberal democracy!

Despite all the challenges I have spoken about: I remain optimistic. Because liberal democracy is the only political order in which we can confront the facts of the world as politically free and equal individuals; in which we do not place our fate in the hands of others but develop trust in our own abilities; in which we learn from mistakes, and above all, are able to correct our course and perhaps for that very reason can continually turn things for the better.

This is laborious and exhausting in the everyday life of politics. We are not always inspired by the high values of this social order in the strains of democratic daily work. And yet, we are experiencing these days what we would lose if we were to give it up.

In democracy, we accept society as it is: in all its diversity, with its contradictions, with its conflicts. We recognize ourselves in our individual differences as citizens who should and can participate in political decisions in equal freedom. Dictatorship, on the other hand, knows only supporters and enemies, dependents or outcasts. Diversity is suspicious to it; dissent is treason. Control, punishment, paralyzing fear, and violence increasingly replace vibrant debate.

In democracy, we acknowledge that the people always exist only in the plural. The will of the people is neither clear-cut nor simply already there; we must continually recreate and express it in open and imperfect processes by arguing for what we hope is the best solution, negotiating value conflicts, balancing interests, and forging compromises. Perhaps this is precisely what gives the liberal society its internal and external capacity for peace. In any case: authoritarian nationalism weaves a web of ethnic lies in which the people become a historical myth with ascribed collective characteristics and claims to ownership. Groups that deviate from this are declared the "anti-people" and threatened with annihilation. This is what characterizes the internal and external aggressiveness of authoritarian nationalism.

So if we give up democracy because it is too laborious for us, we not only lose our freedom but ultimately also the chance to live together in peace in this world of cultural differences.

Strengthening democracy also means recognizing its conditions and defending its prerequisites. The erosion of these conditions and prerequisites does not begin with raw violence. It starts where inertia and impatience, irritability and indifference gain the upper hand, and where the democratic center loses its self-confidence.

For liberal democracy to succeed, it needs institutions of will formation in which decisions can be made and held accountable. It needs strong parliaments and wise minds who do not shy away from the path to public mandates and offices. It needs free art and independent media that can distinguish between facts and falsehoods, expose disinformation and conspiracy theories, give voice to many perspectives, and reach a broad audience. It needs education, not least historical and political education, because it thrives on enlightened, critical, self-aware citizens who have the courage to use their own reason. Liberal democracy needs free science because it cannot solve real problems without being guided by verifiable facts and reasoned normative judgments. It needs a rule of law in which political power is subject to the law and we are protected from state arbitrariness.

And last but not least, or rather first and foremost, liberal democracy needs the engagement of its citizens! It needs women and men who do not see themselves merely as "state customers" but as citizens who get involved and participate, who care about more than just themselves.

We must once again reflect on the values and strengths of our democracy in this time. And we must above all learn again to fight for liberal democracy! We have the better arguments, certainly better than the enemies of the open society. Right now, we must make self-determination, freedom, and human rights our common cause; right now, we must take a stand for the cause of democracy!

After the peaceful revolutions in Eastern and Central Europe, the collapse of the Soviet Union, and the end of the Cold War, many of us hoped that there was such a thing as historical progress, that we were on the path to a future of democracy and global cooperation. And we hoped: there is no turning back from this. This hope was illusory, as we know today, but perhaps it was not entirely wrong as a guiding star for our actions. On the contrary, the confident belief in the strength of freedom and democracy is something we need all the more today.

At the latest in these days, we have understood: peace and freedom are not a given. They demand a price from us; they require personal commitment. It is up to us, the citizens, to defend and strengthen liberal democracy. It is up to us to ensure that future generations can lead a self-determined, good life on this planet.

What we can do together, what we want to do, what we must do, we will discuss shortly. But for now, I will hand over the floor and the microphone to my friend and colleague Alexander Van der Bellen. Thank you very much.