Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the award ceremony for Matthias Katsch and Father Mertes on April 8, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

9 April 2021 · Award ceremony for Matthias Katsch and Father Mertes · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed an award ceremony in Berlin on April 8, 2021, honoring Matthias Katsch and Father Mertes with the Cross of Merit for their work exposing child sexual abuse.
Main themes
Sexual abuse of children, institutional cover-up, courage to break silence, Catholic Church accountability, victims' advocacy, societal reckoning with abuse, recognition of whistleblowers, order of merit award
Duration
~13 min
45th percentile
Words
1,533
45th percentile
Sentences
71
47th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.96
42nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 77%76%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Institutional 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

71 sentences in 24 paragraphs

It is a great pleasure and honor for me to award both of you today the Cross of Merit on the Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany.

You both have indeed earned great and, above all, lasting merits for our community. You have engaged with much courage and great perseverance in uncovering and clarifying heinous crimes in our society. You have stood up for the weakest among us, for children and young people deeply wounded in body and soul, for those long forgotten or silenced.

The sexualized abuse of power against dependents, wards, against students – you have taken on the urgent and difficult task of uncovering it and, as far as possible, making amends for it.

For this, not only the victims are grateful to you, but we as a society are as well. For decades, powerful institutions have spread the mantle of silence over countless abuses. Children and young people with experiences of abuse often stood alone and without support. They were victims and yet in a heavy dilemma: all too often, the institution where they were abused was their home, not least an environment of friends they did not want to give up. They also long hesitated to speak out and often did not do so later out of self-protection, when another life had begun. “I lived two lives,” Albert Ostermaier has his Sebastian say in “Schwarze Sonne scheine.” And so the silence lasted long – too long!

To break the insidious taboo that lay over the sexual crimes against children for decades, brave women, victims who spoke out publicly, made important contributions in the 1980s. Through your efforts, Mr. Katsch and Father Mertes, the fight against sexual abuse of children and for clarification of the unimaginable dimensions it has taken in our society has become a topic, a topic that is now on the agenda and has remained there.

Not far from here, at the Canisius College, this began. We now know that sexualized violence against children and young people extends far beyond the institution where the uncovering began in Germany in 2010. With shock, we have all had to learn how widespread sexualized violence is in the Catholic Church – and how infinitely laborious it was and is to bring these acts to light.

These acts were committed by individuals to whom parents entrusted their children, whose task was to protect and promote these children. The perpetrators betrayed their wards, inflicted injuries on their bodies and souls, often robbing them of the ability to trust others for a lifetime. And superiors concealed these acts for years. The publication of the report on the events in the Archdiocese of Cologne and the debates surrounding it have brought all of this back to our attention in recent weeks.

You both, Mr. Katsch and Father Mertes, have set a turning point in this terrible history of crimes and their cover-up; you have remained steadfast and tenacious in your efforts, even when many opposed the clarification. You have not only made friends with this, both of you have spoken and written about it in your public statements and in your books. Among many other things, you had to endure the old derogatory term of “nest polluter.” Yet it is precisely the so-called nest polluters who are the first to have started cleaning the nest. They make it possible for the acts of decades to become visible and for the necessity of clarification and visibility to be recognized.

You both did not choose this task. But when you were confronted with what you deemed intolerable, you did not hesitate to take on this task.

When today the fight against sexualized violence against children and young people is understood as a societal task of utmost importance, when sexualized abuse of power is a topic not only in the Catholic Church but also in many other institutions, when the silence is broken, when victims find the courage to speak out, when perpetrators are named and abuse-enabling structures are uncovered and changed, when cover-up is condemned and the protection of the individual takes precedence over the protection of the institution, then all of this also has its roots in your courage to break the silence.

That was the first goal, and it is always about that: breaking the silence, which is the strongest protection for the perpetrators and the continued violation of the victims.

Breaking the silence – you took the first step in that, Mr. Katsch. Speaking helps – but one must find the courage to do so. You and some of your classmates ultimately found that courage. If it were easy to talk about these terrible experiences of violence, it would not have taken so long for all of this to come to light. We can only guess how much personal shame and fear must be overcome. For speaking in this case also means: one relinquishes control of their story, leaving it to the public. I can imagine that this first step was very difficult. You took it, and you have encouraged many others to take it as well.

Sexual abuse of children is a serious crime. I am glad that there is no longer any doubt about this, also due to your tireless commitment. A crime demands clarification. And it demands criminal prosecution. It must be prevented that the same perpetrator finds new victims in new places. Good advice and calls for individual penance are not enough. Such cases must never again be treated merely as internal matters of the affected institutions, not even of the churches. It is almost unbearable for the victims that in far too many cases, also due to statutes of limitations, there has been no criminal prosecution.

For accountability and clarification, for help and redress, dear Mr. Katsch, you continue to advocate today, nationally as a co-initiator of the victims' association Eckiger Tisch, as a member of the Independent Commission for the Review of Sexual Abuse of Children, and in the working group “Review of Churches” of the Independent Commissioner for Questions of Sexual Abuse of Children. Internationally, you are engaged in the association ECA, Ending Clergy Abuse.

You have taken on a task that was not your responsibility. Those who become victims of sexualized violence are not responsible for clarifying the acts. The responsibility lies with the perpetrator, with the institutions in which the abuse occurred.

What you had to say demanded a counterpart, someone who would listen to your story and believe in the story and you. It was important that you found this counterpart in Father Mertes: that he not only listened to what you and others had to say, but that he – as a responsible school leader and pastor – encouraged you to speak.

For you, Father Mertes, that was also not an easy step. You were and are a passionate Catholic priest, a committed member of the Jesuit order – and now you must see how much heavy injustice has been committed by some of your fellow brothers. The tornness that this causes within you, you have described often. And you have also described your pain and your anger. As you had to experience time and again that people did not want to understand that this was not just about the acts of individuals, but about structures that enable sexualized violence and that urgently need to be changed.

Child abuse, sexualized abuse of power, this is, as you have said again and again, often the result of closed institutions, opaque, hierarchical structures, a misunderstood loyalty that conceals acts in order to maintain a shiny image outwardly.

You fight these acts in the Catholic Church. But the whole truth is: such acts exist and there are structures that favor such acts in many places – in state institutions and associations, in educational and training institutions, in sports, in choirs and orchestras. And we must not forget that it is families and the closest family environment where children are most exposed to sexualized violence.

Some progress has been made, but we must do better, for although there are many initiatives that are actively committed to uncovering and addressing these issues and improving prevention, it has not yet been possible to sustainably reduce the extent of sexualized violence in childhood and youth.

We must act quickly. This applies to the protection of children in families and institutions. And it applies to the urgent clarification of cases that date back many years; numerous victims are now older individuals who have waited far too long for relief and support.

You both have taken on your task from different sides – and made that clear from the very beginning. Those who speak in the name of the victims, their suffering, and their legitimate interests think and act differently than those who seek clarification and change within their own institution, which has favored the acts and protected the perpetrators. There remains a contrast that you could never blur and, above all, did not want to blur.

That is precisely why it is right that you both are being honored together today.

With great joy, I now hand you both the Order of Merit.