Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the award of the Cross of Merit to former Federal Minister Gerhart Baum on July 19, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

21 July 2023 · Award of the Cross of Merit to former Federal Minister Gerhart Baum · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier awarded the Grand Cross of Merit with Star to former Federal Minister Gerhart Baum in Berlin on July 19, 2023, honoring his lifelong commitment to civil liberties and human rights.
Main themes
Civil liberties and human rights, German democratic identity, post-war Germany and Nazi legacy, freedom and democracy, Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Russia-Ukraine war, political discourse, Thomas Mann and culture, World Conference on Human Rights Vienna 1993, fight against extremism
Duration
~16 min
54th percentile
Words
1,877
54th percentile
Sentences
91
58th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 34%34%
  • Ceremonial 29%29%
  • Institutional 26%25%
  • Geopolitical 11%11%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

91 sentences in 23 paragraphs

"Is it pathological remorse to pose the question of how, in the future, 'Germany' in any of its manifestations should be allowed to speak up in human affairs?"

Dear Mr. Baum, when you read this question in Thomas Mann's "Doctor Faustus," you were a young man, just 20 years old. But you had already experienced so much, seen so much horror. You had endured the bombing night of Dresden during the war when you were twelve. You fled with your mother and siblings through the devastated Germany down to Bavaria, to Lake Tegernsee. There, in school and even more in your free time, you engaged intensively with the crimes of the Nazi regime. But your teachers forbade you to remember the resistance fighters of July 20, with the outrageous justification that they had broken their oath to the Führer.

When a young person has gone through all these experiences, they naturally ask questions like the one in Doctor Faustus: How could this country ever reconnect with its "other" history, with culture and humanism? How could this country ever again be part of the community of nations? And how could this country manage to free itself from fascist and far-right ideologies?

But even then, it was not your way to simply ask questions. No, at just 20 years old, you had the courage on New Year's Day 1953 to write a letter to the Nobel Prize-winning author Thomas Mann. And you even received a response! Thomas Mann wrote to you about how pleased he was to reach young, politically minded people in post-war Germany with his thoughts.

Dear Mr. Baum, with your firm conviction to build and shape a different Germany, you have dedicated many years to civil rights, human rights, the fight against extremists, and your heart's theme, culture. For this, I am honored to award you the Grand Cross of Merit with Star today. And I mean: With this diverse commitment, you have provided an answer to the question in "Doctor Faustus" of whether Germany could ever again "speak up" in human affairs. Yes, a modern, liberal, democratic Germany can do that—and must do so!

"I knew from my experiences as a German what a state of injustice means. I knew what democratic freedom means, and I felt a duty to those who did not have it." This quote does not come from "Doctor Faustus," but from your book that you wrote two years ago. And I find that in these lines of the 88-year-old man, one can still sense the urgency and desire of the 20-year-old. You also wrote: "We Germans must be allies of the oppressed." And that is exactly what you are, dear Mr. Baum. You are an ally of the oppressed.

Thirty years ago, in 1993, you led the German delegation to the World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna, which aimed at nothing less than committing states worldwide to the protection of human rights. Geographically, at that time, not far from war and violence in the Balkans, the conference, thanks in part to your negotiation skills, set a "sign for humanity," as your French counterpart, the already legendary Stéphane Hessel, called it. But you did not only negotiate in Vienna; you worked everywhere in the world to truly implement human rights—because what good is the best declaration if it has no effect? You traveled to Sudan and Colombia, always in close contact with human rights lawyers, journalists, women's initiatives, and of course politicians—always with the maxim of advancing the protection of freedom and human rights.

This year, we celebrate the 30th anniversary of the World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna and the seventy-fifth anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The adoption of the Universal Declaration was, back in 1948, a signal to the world: a sign of confidence and hope for the people whose present lay in ruins after the Second World War.

And today? Seventy-five years after the adoption of the Universal Declaration, human rights are once again being trampled in the heart of Europe, through a war, a brutal, unlawful act of aggression by Russia against Ukraine. Russia wants to destroy independent Ukraine, and for more than 500 days now, millions of Ukrainians have been fighting for their freedom, for their self-determination. Your grandfather, dear Mr. Baum, came from present-day Ukraine. And the images of this war, as you have very vividly expressed, awaken in you memories of the horrific bombing night of Dresden.

From your experiences of the Nazi dictatorship, from your own experience of unfreedom and state oppression, your life theme has emerged: the passion for freedom and for discourse. "Discourse is the lifeblood of democracy," you wrote in your book "Freedom," which I briefly quoted earlier. In a free democracy, there can never be just one opinion—otherwise, it is a dictatorship, otherwise, it is unfreedom. We need a diversity of opinions, and we need political debate about the best way forward.

And you have fought for your cause, dear Mr. Baum: When you abolished the routine inquiry at the Office for the Protection of the Constitution in 1979 as Minister of the Interior, you were, as one would probably call it today, subjected to a real shitstorm. You faced similar backlash when you sought to investigate the origins of the terrorism of the Red Army Faction and contributed to the book "The Minister and the Terrorist." There you ignited the next—presumably calculated by you—debate of outrage. But you have always been convinced: Without discourse, a country cannot be changed.

And that is why you went into politics: to change the country with a new Germany policy, a new Eastern policy, a new domestic policy. For you, there could be no contradiction between the demands of internal security in times of terrorism on the one hand and the freedom opportunities of the individual, as you stated in your inaugural speech as Federal Minister. A democratic society can and must deal with threats without falling into unfreedom. "Evil can be overcome by good," you formulated your guiding principle most recently.

As Minister of the Interior, you had a huge portfolio—you were also responsible for culture and the environment by virtue of your office, and you addressed both topics with remarkable foresight and great passion from today's perspective. Your concept of freedom was never limited to domestic policy. You always cared about more than just "freedom from"—from oppression, from violence, from dictatorship. You also cared about "freedom to"—the freedom of every citizen to develop, to have social security, to have access to art and culture.

To this day, you have remained a champion: for civil rights, human rights, culture, data protection, fundamental rights in the digital world. With your topics, you have always been at the forefront of the times.

For one thing, I am personally grateful to you, and our country is as well: Last year, you helped ensure that 50 years after the horrific attack on the Israeli Olympic team in Munich, we could collectively commemorate the victims with dignity. For many years, the families of the victims felt forgotten, repressed, and silenced by German politics. Almost no joint commemoration in Fürstenfeldbruck would have been possible because negotiations over compensation between the German state and the survivors had repeatedly stalled despite many efforts. As a last-minute lawyer, you, dear Mr. Baum, then played a crucial role in reaching an agreement. For that, I truly thank you from the bottom of my heart.

"He can argue until his opponents fall from their chairs," wrote Heribert Prantl about you last year, on your 90th birthday. And so it is: You spare neither yourself nor those with whom you discuss. In Günter Verheugen's memories, I read that you both once, on a return trip from an FDP party conference, were so exhausted from all the debating that you had to take a nap on the shoulder of the highway in your slightly battered Ford.

Just a few weeks ago, you debated for an incredible five and a half hours with the two moderators of a podcast—and to be honest: My impression was that your counterparts, although significantly younger than you, would not have lasted much longer than you did.

You even got to know your long-time political friend and ally Burkhard Hirsch, as I learned, through a confrontation: When he represented an expulsion procedure against you in the Young Democrats at the end of the 1950s, he was on the opposing side. However, the procedure then fizzled out—and I believe Burkhard Hirsch was just as glad about that as you were, as you both decisively shaped the social-liberal profile of the FDP together afterward.

Your political life, dear Mr. Baum, shows us that political controversies in our country have always been conducted fiercely: The CDU and CSU repeatedly demanded your resignation as Federal Minister of the Interior, and during the joint government periods of the Union and FDP, Franz Josef Strauß referred to you and Burkhard Hirsch as notorious coalition disruptors. Despite all the harshness, it was clear in these confrontations: Here, democrats are debating among themselves, fighting over political positions. But we are currently experiencing a change in political culture. Too many no longer argue about the right path within our democracy but mobilize against "the politics," against democratic institutions and their representatives.

Especially in social media, the color scale of debates is increasingly limited to black and white; everything becomes a question of victory or defeat, of betrayal or loyalty. If this dynamic continues, it will not end well. The reasonable middle ground needs its place in a democratic debate. Democracy cannot tolerate a final knockdown. It is always aware of the provisional nature of its answers and is the only form of government in which the correction of decisions is possible without fundamental upheavals in society. Weighing and negotiating compromises are not reprehensible or alien to the system but are intended. Reconciliation and balance are part of democracy! A controversy in which nuances have no place, in which irreconcilability is stirred up, such a controversy harms democracy. Without nuances, without the connective, society cannot hold together. Because cohesion arises when we communicate with each other—and do not hold our own identities against each other and fragment society.

If debates are only about winning, then we all lose. If we allow those who would prefer to have no discourse to destroy our political discourse, we allow our democracy to be destroyed. Defending civilized political debate in our society is the common task of all democrats!

Dear Mr. Baum, in response to the question "What gets better with age?" you gave a typical Gerhart-Baum answer some time ago. You said: "Life becomes more intense. Time is limited; you sort things out. What is important? What do you still need to know? I throw out a lot of unnecessary things, the time thieves." And I find that the urgent and, as your wife says, somewhat impatient, knowledge-thirsty 20-year-old can be heard again in that.

You do not like to wait, we all know that, and so I do not want to keep you waiting any longer, but I may now award you the Grand Cross of Merit with Star for your many contributions to our country. Congratulations!