Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the ceremonial event marking the 75th anniversary of the Constitutional Convention of Herrenchiemsee on August 10, 2023, in Herrenchiemsee:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

16 August 2023 · Ceremonial event marking the 75th anniversary of the Constitutional Convention of Herrenchiemsee · Herrenchiemsee, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremonial event at Herrenchiemsee on August 16, 2023, marking the 75th anniversary of the 1948 Constitutional Convention that drafted the Basic Law.
Main themes
75th anniversary of the Herrenchiemsee Constitutional Convention, Basic Law origins, German democracy, postwar reconstruction, Cold War context, gender equality in the Basic Law, National Socialism legacy, collective guilt and complicity, constitutional drafting process, Parliamentary Council, rule of law and freedom
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,702
71st percentile
Sentences
114
69th percentile
Readability
39
34th percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.27
66th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 61%61%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

114 sentences in 34 paragraphs

A preliminary draft for a provisional text. That is really all that our celebration today revolves around. This "document for further consultation," as it was modestly called back then, which was drafted by excellent experts, we are rightly celebrating today, in my opinion, with splendor and glory, together as federal and state.

"Document for further consultation" – we here, who are gathered today, know that we are celebrating much more than that. But how many people are even aware of the matter? The Constitutional Convention of Herrenchiemsee is possibly one of the least known among the truly important moments in the history of German democracy. Yet it is undoubtedly one of the most significant. One could almost say that its importance stands in inverse proportion to its notoriety.

The Herrenchiemsee Convention accomplished the essential work on the Basic Law 75 years ago. This Basic Law has been the foundation for freedom, democracy, and law to determine coexistence in our state since it came into force a year later. We can only be glad about that, and we can only be grateful for it. And that is why it is also appropriate for us to commemorate this significant event in this very splendid place – even if this hall in the New Palace of Herrenchiemsee, consciously a copy of Versailles, stands in the greatest possible contrast to Germany in 1948. And also to the work that was done next door in the Old Palace, characterized by more modest circumstances and often by improvisation.

After the barbarism of National Socialism, our country was destroyed, morally shattered, and divided. The cities were largely devastated, countless people had become homeless and displaced, nine million refugees and displaced persons had come from the East, and millions of men were still in captivity or were considered missing. Housing shortages and hunger burdened the people.

And at the same time, the Cold War had already begun. While this convention was in session, West Berlin was suffering under the Soviet blockade. The newly won freedom had to be defended against the communist dictatorship, through the airlift, through "raisin bombers." That was the time.

What kind of state should one actually design in this time, here in Herrenchiemsee, where on August 10, 1948, representatives and delegates from the countries of the western occupation zones had come together to make a proposal for a new, joint constitution for the upcoming Parliamentary Council?

It was a small group of politicians, officials, and scholars – all men. Women were only present as secretaries and accompanying wives in Herrenchiemsee. Only later in the Parliamentary Council were they involved as representatives, just four of them, but influential enough to write that article into the Basic Law that was still missing in Herrenchiemsee: "Men and women are equal." Berlin's representative Otto Suhr had already pointed out the absence of such a statement on gender equality during the discussions. Perhaps it was because his wife Susanne was not only accompanying him but also following and commenting on the convention as a journalist for Berlin newspapers.

No matter how different their biographies and political beliefs were: The men of the Constitutional Convention were all, in different ways, shaped by dictatorship, war, and genocide.

The constitutional lawyer Carlo Schmid, the representative of Württemberg-Hohenzollern, signed in Herrenchiemsee as "Karl Schmid," but later changed his name to Carlo to avoid being confused with the notorious ideologue of the Nazi state, Carl Schmitt. Carlo Schmid, a liberal social democrat, significantly influenced the discussions of the convention as well as those of the Parliamentary Council later on.

Hermann Brill, the representative of Hesse, had survived the Buchenwald concentration camp and had to flee from Thuringia before the new SED dictatorship. The constitutional lawyer Hans Nawiasky had lost his professorship in Munich in 1933 and had been driven into exile in Switzerland by the Nazis as a Jew. His colleague Theodor Maunz, on the other hand, had made a career in the "Third Reich" and was among those jurists who had given the dictatorship the appearance of legitimacy. Lower Saxony's representative, Justus Danckwerts, was deeply involved in the genocide of the Jews in Eastern Europe as a representative of the war administration of the Nazi regime.

In a way, the Herrenchiemsee Convention reflected that post-war Germany, in which not only victims, persecuted individuals, and resisters were involved in building a new democracy, but also many who had borne guilt during National Socialism or were entangled in it through complicity or passivity.

In the name of the state, the worst crimes had been committed; it had been possible for the state itself, its organizations and structures, and its judiciary to contribute to the exclusion, expulsion, and extermination of entire groups of people or even to actively carry them out. It was this horrific past that made the departure into the future so special. The tortured from Buchenwald and Dachau, the murdered from Auschwitz, the fallen from Stalingrad, as well as the dead from D-Day should not be forgotten. In the idyll of Herrenchiemsee, the men of the convention wanted to build a state that could no longer, never again, be misused for such monstrous crimes.

The formulation of the first article of their draft was therefore: "The state exists for the sake of man, not man for the sake of the state." This is the deep fundamental conviction that underlies the entire draft of Herrenchiemsee. Some have regretted that this formulation was not also adopted into the Basic Law. But the entire draft of Herrenchiemsee and also the later adopted Basic Law are profoundly shaped by what this sentence expresses: The state exists for the sake of man.

Here, the still vividly alive historical experience was reflected, of which they would say in Herrenchiemsee at that time: "Never again!" And this "Never again!" was to become irreversible through the constitution and also practical politics of the new state.

When, for example, all detainees are guaranteed "protection from physical and psychological abuse," the cries of pain from the torture chambers of the Gestapo still echo here. When "restrictions on radio reception" are declared impermissible, this is also a response to the fact that in the Nazi regime, listening to foreign broadcasts was met not only with severe penalties but also with the death penalty. And when the preparation of a war is expressly made punishable, it shows the will to put an end to the era of a fatal German militarism.

First the person, then the state! What was meant in the first sentence of Herrenchiemsee and was further emphasized in the second sentence, "the dignity of the human personality is inviolable," is expressed even more clearly and decisively in the final version of the Basic Law: The Basic Law first speaks of the person itself – "The dignity of man is inviolable" – and only in the second sentence of the state: of its obligation to respect and protect this dignity. This is, in its brevity and precision, perhaps the clearest rejection of everything that had previously happened in and through the state that was inhumane.

Thus, the fundamental rights and freedoms are formulated decisively and succinctly; they stand, so to speak, at the entrance of an entire constitutional edifice. The freedom of man is at the ideal, but also at the practical center of this constitution.

This includes, centrally, the freedom of opinion, of the press; the freedom to assemble, to form communities, associations, and parties; the freedom of art, of science, and also of faith. This freedom is the fundamental counter-model to totalitarianism in the years of dictatorship. An anti-totalitarian basic consensus shaped the draft – above all, the decisive priority of freedom.

To protect this freedom is precisely what the democratic and legal structures and functions of the state are meant to serve. The bitter experience that democracy in Weimar had not been strong enough has been formative for many decisions and formulations in Herrenchiemsee. For example, for the strong position of the parliament and the parties that support the parliamentary system. Also for the impossibility of being able to dismiss a chancellor without appointing a new one, thus the constructive vote of no confidence. Or for the federal order with a strong position of the states. I do not want to list everything that could still be mentioned, nor the various unresolved points of contention, such as the shape of a second chamber, from which the Bundesrat later emerged.

One thing, however, was important and remains important to this day, namely the goal of all efforts: a democratic and social rule of law of free citizens who are equal before the law and whose freedom and integrity are protected in the same way.

The convention here in Herrenchiemsee evidently did good, very good work, because the Parliamentary Council was then able and willing to rely heavily on this draft in Bonn, despite all the disputes that still took place there. Substantively, large parts of the Basic Law stem from the preparatory work of Herrenchiemsee; the provisions on fundamental rights, as you will see when you compare them, were almost completely adopted by the Parliamentary Council. The Basic Law, which has served our country for almost 75 years now, has brought us much good, for which we all owe our freedom, our well-being, our security, and our democratic decision-making options; this Basic Law thus has its origin here in Herrenchiemsee.

It is astonishing for us contemporaries today to see how quickly a result was reached back then. Certainly, time was pressing; on September 1, the Parliamentary Council was to begin in Bonn, and one had to and wanted to produce something useful for further consultations by then. Thus, discussions were held here and a whole draft was written within less than two weeks. The representatives of the states and the invited experts must have worked very goal- and fact-oriented; they must have, otherwise one cannot imagine it, quickly agreed on decisive, essential ideological convictions despite all their different life paths and experiences. Although the Herrenchiemsee text also contains some minority votes, the formulation of the fundamental rights, for example, was found unanimously.

Finally, one can only remember with gratitude how the Basic Law not only simply "came into effect," as one says, but how its values, how its spirit became alive in a democratic society. One must always keep in mind that democracy as a form of government in Germany had hardly lasted 15 years before that, had existed. And in the Weimar democracy, many had not become democrats at all. And those who were around 18 years old in 1948, at the time of Herrenchiemsee, thus belonging to the generation of the future, had practically lived their entire conscious lives only in dictatorship – in school, in public, heard, read, and seen nothing but the propaganda of totalitarianism.

In retrospect, it is still astonishing that the Federal Republic has become, all in all, a community that, although it had to practice freedom and democracy, fair parliamentary and public debate a little at first, quickly grasped the rules of the game. Initially in West Germany, and for 33 years now in all of Germany. We should also remember this today: The Herrenchiemsee Convention and the Basic Law were written from the very beginning with a perspective of all of Germany.

No one embodies this better than the aforementioned Hermann Brill. How much Brill would have liked to represent his home state of Thuringia here in Herrenchiemsee. But the Soviet occupying power always saw the committed democrat as a thorn in its side, which is why it removed him as government president, arrested him, and drove him to flee to the West. Even though the Soviet Union had prohibited the participation of the states in its occupation zone – the ideas of Herrenchiemsee, later the values of the Basic Law, were shared by many people throughout Germany. When we today and in the coming months remember the rebuilding of democracy 75 years ago, we should also think of those men and women who, especially in East Germany in 1953, stood up for freedom of expression, democratic elections, and the rule of law – and who often had to pay for it with their freedom, yes, with their lives. That is why I found the commemoration of June 17, 70 years ago, so important this year.

The citizens of our country have endured and fought through many, even harsh conflicts over the decades. This has been possible because the rules of the game were not only adhered to but, above all, accepted. Among these rules is that we do not all have to agree, that we do not have to like one another, that we can reject other ideas – but that we also grant all of this to everyone else.

Whether more or less consciously, I emphasize: the vast majority of citizens were and are, in a deep sense, "constitutional patriots"; they have internalized the spirit of the Basic Law – democracy, freedom and equality, social responsibility, liberalism.

A community shapes its citizens with its constitution. However, they must also live it, and by living it, defend this constitution. Our Basic Law can withstand hard and harsh confrontations. However, the constitution cannot integrate enemies of the constitution – and we must not ignore the danger they pose. Political opposition is one thing; enmity towards the constitution is something entirely different. Enemies of the constitution want to destroy their political opponents; their goal is rule without dissent, and that is not the democracy of the Basic Law.

In the fight against extremism, there is a historical lesson that runs like a red thread through the constitutional draft of Herrenchiemsee and that still holds true today: A democracy must be resilient against its enemies. Never again should democratic freedoms be misused to abolish freedom and democracy.

Being robust and resilient in everyday life means, first and foremost, demonstrating the will to oppose attacks on freedom and democracy and not accepting the brazen lies of enemies of freedom with silence and appeasement – which may even encourage the enemies of freedom. Clear, determined, and combative opposition from democratic parties is always required and demanded, for example, when agitators in public gatherings or even in city council and municipal council meetings vilify our democracy as a "system," "unjust regime," or "dictatorship," discrediting and contemptuously undermining democratic institutions.

Let us remember that our democracy arose in the shadow of dictatorship, war, and genocide. And let us recognize what is at stake for our democracy today. We all have the power to rein in those who despise our democracy. And we all, every politician, but also every citizen, share a common responsibility for our democracy. We must protect it! No responsible voter can excuse themselves with mitigating circumstances when they knowingly strengthen political forces that contribute to the brutalization of our society and the erosion of freedom-based democracy.

A commemoration like today also calls us to such serious thoughts. The inviolability of human dignity and the principle of democracy are, by the constitution itself, exempt from any abolition. But politically – politically, not legally – we must always be clear: Our constitution loses its validity on the day it becomes indifferent to us.

This day of thanks and joy is therefore also a day of self-commitment. This self-commitment includes remembrance. The Herrenchiemsee of Ludwig II is an impressive piece of German, or more precisely: Bavarian culture. And the Herrenchiemsee of the Constitutional Convention is a lasting chapter in the history of German democracy. I hope that Herrenchiemsee and the Constitutional Convention will come more into the public consciousness as a true place of democracy. With the new and expanded exhibition, a significant step has been taken in this direction; I wish for many visitors and thank the curators and everyone who made this new exhibition possible.

The Constitutional Convention 75 years ago may have convened in the relative barrenness of the Old Castle. But with its central emphasis on human dignity as the maxim of all state action, the constitutional draft that emerged then shines even brighter into the present than all the splendor and glory of this wonderful hall.