Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the Bellevue Forum on the topic "Times of Change – How to Achieve Social Cohesion?" on February 1, 2024, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

2 February 2024 · Bellevue Forum on the Transformation of Society · Bellevue Palace, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the second Bellevue Forum on societal transformation in Berlin on February 1, 2024, focusing on social cohesion amid crises and change.
Main themes
Social cohesion, liberal democracy, transformation of society, climate neutrality, political polarization, public trust in institutions, social division, populism and right-wing extremism, protest movements, economic restructuring, loss of trust in democracy, consensus and conflict in Germany
Duration
~16 min
56th percentile
Words
1,966
56th percentile
Sentences
72
47th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
13.9
66th percentile
Syntax
3.33
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 37%36%
  • Ceremonial 26%25%
  • Economic 17%17%
  • Environmental 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Not in focus 3%

72 sentences in 22 paragraphs

It is nice to have you here. I am pleased that you are interested in this second "Forum Bellevue on the Transformation of Society." In this series of discussions, we are focusing on the major restructuring that has begun to make our economy and society truly climate-neutral by the year 2045.

At the outset, we discussed in July how we can become a post-fossil industrial nation, technologically leading, globally connected, and better equipped to face crises and disasters. Today, we want to look at how the transformation affects our society: How are opportunities and risks perceived locally, who experiences reservations and resistance to change, where are there success stories that can encourage others? And at the center of today's discussion is the question of how, in this time of crises and changes, we can maintain cohesion in society and defend our liberal democracy.

All of you here in the hall are committed in different ways to democracy, healthy living conditions, and good social coexistence – in local politics, in business and science, in culture, churches, and religious communities. It is wonderful to have you all here today; please join me in warmly welcoming everyone!

Agitated farmers and hauliers blocking the country with tractors and trucks, perhaps similar to activists from the climate movement who glued themselves to the asphalt and were dragged away by angry drivers; public debates that heat up suddenly when provocative topics like speed limits or meat consumption are touched upon; citizens indicating in surveys that they intend to vote for populists or right-wing extremists in the upcoming elections – all of this exists. But there is also this: hundreds of thousands of people from all walks of life taking to the streets across Germany for democracy and human rights, from Görlitz to Kleve, from Rosenheim to Westerland.

I believe the question is justified: What is going on in this society? And those who ask the question are initially glad when Steffen Mau is nearby. Dear Mr. Mau, in your latest book, you measure and map the conflicts in our country. And you arrive at a finding that may initially surprise readers: The widespread image of a divided society, in which two groups with opposing worldviews stand irreconcilably or even hostile to each other, does not correspond to reality according to your study. On the contrary: When it comes to issues of distribution justice, humanity in the reception of refugees, the coexistence of different groups, or concern for climate change, there is quite a bit of consensus in our diverse society – that is the result of your study.

There may be some in this hall who disagree, but we will discuss that. However, I want to make it clear that you do not want your study to be understood as an all-clear signal. Nevertheless, your findings are thought-provoking and also urge us to look more closely, perhaps not to dramatize every protest just because it receives a lot of attention. Let us beware of sweeping judgments, enemy images, and moral arrogance! And let us not infer from individual characteristics that indicate differences to closed political worldviews of others or other groups!

In any case, the results of the study we will discuss shortly rather support what I remain convinced of: We are connected in Germany by more than what divides us – despite all the undeniable conflicts, despite the loudness with which they are fought out, despite the radicalization of language that I also observe. The vast majority of people in our country stand by the democracy of the Basic Law. And most want to continue living in a free and, above all, diverse society in the future.

And that does not mean – you all feel this and know it – that there is no cause for concern. Many people in our country live in relatively closed social circles; the distance between different life worlds has grown, encounters across these life worlds have become rare, the "lives of others" are characterized mainly by the fact that they are hardly known – and thus also not the needs and troubles of people with very different life plans and very different limits to their possibilities. Many people have lost trust in the institutions and representatives of liberal democracy – either because they feel unseen, unheard, or unrepresented; or because they experience in their daily lives that many things, from the train to the internet, do not work as they should according to expectations; or perhaps also because they have lost faith in progress, because they worry about the future of their children.

If we want to strengthen liberal democracy and win back people, we must also – and we will do this shortly – ask about the causes of disappointment, bitterness, or anger. And we will begin this together here at the front and then continue with all of you in the hall.

We are living in an extraordinarily difficult time. The pandemic, climate change, weather disasters, the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine, terrorism and war in the Middle East – all of this has shaken our society, unsettled people, and worried everyone. In this time of already overlapping crises, the transformation to a sustainable society is increasingly becoming part of everyday life. It is becoming visible and tangible everywhere, in cities, in industrial regions, but also in rural areas. How we produce, cultivate our fields, generate our energy, move around, how we build, heat, and live – all of this is changing at a rapid pace. And people are experiencing breaks from the familiar; that one must rethink, must act differently. And it is becoming increasingly clear that the opportunities and risks of change are unevenly distributed, that burdens and demands affect people very differently.

The vast majority of people in our country, across classes and generations, want more climate protection, want a policy for healthy living conditions. But of course, and this was palpable: When it comes to concrete steps and changes, conflicts often turn into resistance. Those who have already had to cope with difficult upheavals in their lives are often skeptical. Those who experienced losses and grievances after reunification in East Germany, those who have lived through decades of structural change in industrial regions like the Ruhr area or Lusatia know how much can be lost in the process, not only economically but also in terms of appreciation and a sense of home for people. Especially in the East, where the third major transformation is already being experienced in one generation, many are weary of change.

It is not always the experience of loss, but sometimes also the expectation of loss, the fear of loss that drives people against change. Especially those who have something to lose in terms of work, prosperity, or social standing sometimes react with rejection and incomprehension – particularly when they feel overwhelmed by change or "changed from above," or when they get the impression that they are being lectured about their supposedly wrong life.

I hope that Mr. Mau is wrong with his prediction that climate protection may be the great "class conflict in the making." But it is true: If we want to prevent parts of our society from drifting further apart, if we want to win back people who have turned away, we must place the question of justice even more at the center of climate protection debates. How can individual steps into a post-fossil future be designed so that costs and burdens, opportunities and gains are distributed fairly? How can we ensure that those who fear they will be among the losers of change also have something to gain? How will we become a climate-neutral country where there is good work and prosperity for as many as possible? We must answer these questions, and they must be answered now, not in ten or twenty years, and not in 2045!

This also means that we should not only talk about what is difficult, but we should also discuss the success stories that exist in great numbers in our country.

I see this repeatedly during my travels in Germany, whether under the title of "Local Time" or "Workshop of Change." Such different cities as Altenburg, Quedlinburg, Neustrelitz, Freiberg, Völklingen, Senftenberg, Eckernförde, or Zwickau are already on their own path to a post-fossil future, and they have often used the restructuring to productively connect the old and the new. And I am not just talking about wind turbines that stand on areas where lignite was once mined.

I recently met a man in Zwickau during my last visit who has experienced two major upheavals in his professional life: He built Trabbis during the GDR era, worked his way into a future at Volkswagen after reunification – and has now mastered the transition to the age of electric mobility. And, what can I say: This seasoned car manufacturer was almost bursting with pride because his Zwickau plant is now a pioneer in the production of electric cars.

In Lusatia, where people were proud of lignite for years, new railway technology is now being developed – innovations for the energy transition and for climate-neutral air travel are emerging at the Brandenburg University of Technology Cottbus-Senftenberg and in the "Lusatia Science Park," and a medical faculty is set to come to Cottbus. And also in Freiberg in Saxony, which has been shaped by mining and the metal industry for centuries, it has been possible to modernize and future-proof a traditional site: The former VEB Spurenmetalle, for example, has been transformed into a company that cultivates crystals for microchips; other companies there produce silicon wafers or supplies for communication technology.

I do not want to gloss over anything. Restructuring remains challenging. It causes tensions and disappointments, even if we all consider it inevitable. Mayors from here in the hall – also from the industrial regions in the East and West – can report on this.

All of you here in the hall are dealing with the challenges of transformation from very different perspectives. Whether you come from the perspective of business or science, federal politics or local politics, social or environmental associations, or churches – please do not hesitate to join our debate shortly; I am looking forward to your experiences, your ideas, and suggestions.

To start, I actually wanted to discuss with two guests here at the front of the podium – but Judith Borowski, managing director of the watch manufacturer Nomos, has unfortunately fallen ill; she had to cancel at short notice. She would have had much to say about a manufacturer in the East that has become a globally operating company; she would have had much to say about why the East is a good location and why it hopefully remains so. We wish her a speedy recovery from here, and perhaps she is even watching us on the livestream.

Therefore, we will begin our forum with a dialogue on the podium. I have already mentioned my guest; he does not need much introduction here in this round: Steffen Mau is a professor of sociology at Humboldt University here in Berlin and also a public intellectual who has reached a broad audience with his books, essays, articles, and interviews, especially at the moment, but also before. In his book "Lütten Klein," he sheds light on experiences with transformation in East Germany, and now, in his substantial work, which he co-authored with two others, "Trigger Points," he examines the fragmented conflict landscape of our society. It is wonderful to have you here, dear Mr. Mau; a warm welcome to you as well!

This castle hall does not transform itself into a debate space. I thank the Zeit-Stiftung Bucerius and you, dear Mr. Hartung, for the good collaboration. And now I look forward to our conversation.