Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Zeit-Stiftung on May 18, 2022, in Hamburg:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

21 May 2022 · 50th anniversary celebration of the Zeit-Stiftung · Hamburg

Context
Steinmeier addressed the 50th anniversary celebration of the Zeit-Stiftung foundation on May 18, 2022, in Hamburg, reflecting on democracy's resilience amid Russia's war in Ukraine.
Main themes
Democracy and rule of law, Russia's war against Ukraine, threats to liberal democracy, freedom and civic resilience, authoritarianism and illiberalism, Zeit-Stiftung anniversary, social cohesion, disinformation and conspiracy theories, complexity and societal insecurity, nationalism and resentment, democratic institutions, role of civil society
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,992
75th percentile
Sentences
123
73rd percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
73rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 44%38%
  • Ceremonial 26%23%
  • Geopolitical 20%17%
  • Institutional 9%8%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 14%

123 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Fifty years of the Zeit-Stiftung – who has more reason to celebrate? But celebrating carefree is hardly possible these days. The inhumane war of aggression by Russia against Ukraine shakes, outrages, and depresses us, and of course, it also overshadows this festive occasion today.

However, your anniversary is also an opportunity, especially in these times. For it is a good occasion to reflect on what makes our democracy alive, strong, and resilient. What can we as citizens do to defend our freedom? That is the question that has preoccupied Gerd Bucerius throughout his life and to which the Zeit-Stiftung has oriented its actions since 1971. It is an old question that we must answer anew in light of the war. That is why I am pleased to be here with you today, and I thank you for the invitation to your anniversary. An anniversary that we want to celebrate confidently, but also thoughtfully. Thank you very much.

How threatened freedom, democracy, and the rule of law are, how much we must defend them against challenges and attacks, is brutally illustrated by Putin's invasion of Ukraine. The gruesome images from Bucha, Kharkiv, Mariupol, and Odessa; the war crimes and the violence against civilians; the terrible suffering of Ukrainians, all of this shows us every day what violence, what inhumanity emanates from the Russian dictatorship and Russian nationalism. This war is a warning to all who flirt with freedom-hostile illiberal democracy, nationalism, and resentments. A warning also to those who do so within the European Union.

For we know, not just since the beginning of the war against Ukraine: Our liberal democracy is threatened not only from the outside but also from within. We have been experiencing for years how authoritarian and illiberal forces repeatedly find support in certain places – worldwide, but also on this side and the other side of the Atlantic! We see how governments in many regions of the world, unfortunately also in parts of Europe, restrict civil rights, put pressure on the media, and curtail the independence of the judiciary. And at the same time, we experience that many people still react with indifference or disinterest when the fascination of the authoritarian spreads, as if it were none of our business.

The COVID crisis has shown us once again how fragile cohesion is even in our society; how quickly trust in democratic institutions, in science, and in the media can fade; how susceptible many are to disinformation and conspiracy theories; how loud the calls for supposedly simple solutions can swell at times; and how many people are daily vilified, threatened, and covered in hate, especially in the digital space.

Armin Nassehi recently looked for reasons in his new book and cast his gaze on what he calls an "overburdened society." And indeed, the palpable longing in some places for a strong hand and for nationalist isolation, the susceptibility to resentments and intolerance, all of this surely has its roots in a deep insecurity that many people feel in a restless time. Apparent certainties are being called into question. The rapidly growing complexity of the world makes it difficult to form a secure judgment – what is right, what is wrong? One no longer knows their way around the megastructure of the global village and its dynamics of development.

Our own society is also changing due to a new diversity of life forms and backgrounds; the world of work is becoming more digital and international; the upheavals required in the fight against global warming affect all areas of our lives. And on top of that come global crises or local disasters that repeatedly shake us, most recently the pandemic or the flood in the Ahr Valley, and after all that, a murderous war in the middle of Europe.

In this confusing and contradictory situation during a time of successive crises, many people feel as if they are losing their footing and are almost powerless against change. Many are concerned about their place in society, fear for their jobs, their prosperity, their values, and beliefs. And many wonder whether their children and grandchildren will really have a better life than they themselves do.

I believe we all feel this unease in one way or another, in our families or at least in our close social circles. I say this for one reason only. I say it because this feeling should not lead anyone to the false conclusion that liberal democracies are weak and unable to cope with their internal tensions or, due to a lack of problem-solving competence, to tackle the great challenges of the 21st century. Those who believe that plurality, democratic processes, and openness to the world stand in the way of effective solutions are mistaken; I am firmly convinced of that.

Where have dictatorships ever peacefully resolved their internal contradictions and tensions? Dictatorships and autocracies cannot integrate the new and the different; they must exclude and suppress opposition with force. The more persistent the contradiction, the tighter the reins are pulled. And there is only this one direction; the possibility of self-correction is excluded in dictatorships. Only democracies can integrate the new and the different. Only democracies can correct what has been recognized as wrong. The ability to correct is one of the most important building blocks in the genetics of democracy!

Liberal democracies are strong because they can preserve freedom and diversity in the process of problem-solving, which is sometimes difficult and lengthy, yes, but because they can do so. They are strong precisely because they guarantee free media, free science, and an independent judiciary; precisely because they allow for free information, the expression of one's opinion, and engagement; precisely because they protect public spaces where we can weigh arguments, balance interests, and strive for compromises; precisely because they keep open the possibility that a outvoted minority can win over the majority at a later time; precisely because they collaborate across borders in an interconnected world.

And our liberal democracies are strong because they are also supported by engaged citizens beyond democratic institutions, by people who know that freedom always brings responsibility, who care not only for themselves but also for others and the common good. Millions of women and men contribute their time, energy, ideas, and humanity every day, as volunteers or in their professions, in clubs, initiatives, or organizations, in their neighborhoods or even worldwide. A vibrant civil society also includes those who establish charitable foundations to permanently use their privately acquired wealth for a specific public purpose, uniquely combining individualism and community spirit.

I am truly very glad that our country has such a great treasure of foundations. Precisely because they are dedicated to so many different goals, they make an important contribution to a good coexistence in our diverse society. Some foundations are firmly rooted in a city or region and build bridges to the world from there. Others promote unconventional or unpopular ideas and perhaps create awareness of problems early on because they also operate where the public is currently not looking or at least not yet.

Foundations promote change and help shape societal upheavals – not as stopgaps that catch what the state does not provide, but as creative forces that open up opportunities, enable understanding, and set things in motion. That is precisely why authoritarian rulers fear organized civil society; that is why they often deploy their entire apparatus of coercion to suppress free initiatives, associations, and foundations; I want to mention today, on behalf of many, many others around the globe, only the Russian human rights organization Memorial.

My thoughts, our thoughts are with the Ukrainians today, who have built a civil society in their country over the past years and are now resisting the Russian aggressor to defend their freedom. I also think of the Russians, Belarusians, the women and men who fight against unfreedom in their homeland or now from exile, even if they must fear being arrested, abducted, poisoned, tortured, or murdered.

Their courage is immense, and it should make us all the more resolute. All these civil rights activists and opposition members not only defend their freedom; they defend the idea of freedom itself. And they deserve our respect and solidarity, yes, but they deserve even more; they deserve that we stand up to dictators and aggressors with the clear stance of supporting the victims of inhumane violence.

"Unrest creates foundations," as Herfried Münkler once put it. Especially in times of upheaval, wealthy citizens have founded foundations, even here in this city, which has such a long tradition of philanthropy, from Johann Hinrich Wichern to Kurt A. Körber. I wish that even now, in this restless time, even more charitable foundations will be established. Right now, we need donor personalities like Ebelin and Gerd Bucerius, who advocate for an open society!

The "restless spirit" that founded the Zeit-Stiftung in 1971 was – in the words of Ralf Dahrendorf – the "living proof of the power of a liberal and independent attitude." What distinguished Gerd Bucerius was his will for freedom and change. He never simply accepted the circumstances he found; he never took the path of least resistance, was unconventional, combative, and opinionated, and yet always open to new ideas. His ideal was a country of self-confident citizens, and his drive was the joy of argumentative engagement.

As a young lawyer, he defended Jews during the National Socialism and fought for justice in times of injustice; as a publisher, he helped build a free press in West Germany after liberation, founded Die Zeit, and later acquired a majority stake in Stern; as a critical contemporary, he himself liked to take up the pen but always emphasized that journalists should not "dance to the publisher's tune."

Even in the dual role of politician and publisher, Gerd Bucerius stood for the independence of the press. He resigned his mandate as a member of the Bundestag for the CDU when Adenauer demanded that he take action against journalists from Stern who had criticized the Catholic Church. And as a founder, Gerd Bucerius supported young journalists and lawyers throughout his life, advocated for more competition in higher education, revitalized literary discourse in Hamburg, and repeatedly breathed the spark of freedom into our society.

What a great fortune it is to be able to continue working with the wealth and intellectual legacy of this founder! The Zeit-Stiftung, your foundation, continues to contribute to fostering confidence, strengthening cohesion, and promoting the future – and in this way, defending our freedom. It promotes the liberal culture of debate in our country by standing against hate and inhumanity online or by inspiring young people to debate. It encourages public debates and creates open discourse spaces, where it does not act as an advocate for a specific position but as a moderator who brings different people into conversation.

I am convinced: especially now, in a time of great upheaval, we need such discourse spaces where we can meet and exchange as different individuals, across social and political boundaries. For it weakens and endangers our democracy when it falls into narrow, closed communication circles where like-minded individuals only reflect, confirm, and reinforce each other from morning till night. We must learn again to listen to each other and to communicate in public discourse, even to learn again to argue with each other, peacefully, respectfully, and in reasonable dialogue!

That it is about much more than just good manners, we are experiencing in these restless days and weeks. We are witnessing the first major war in Europe that is being fought in the age of digital media and social networks. We are seeing how an authoritarian aggressor is trying to flood public opinion across national borders with false information using all technical means, to deceive and manipulate.

And at the same time, we are experiencing how public discourse in our liberal democracies is increasingly determined by the logic of digital communication. Simplification and escalation, mockery and polemics, provocation and emotional confrontation are gaining the upper hand. Often, the quick punchline or the flashy effect seems to be more important than factual plausibility, even when it comes to questions of war and peace.

In existential decision-making situations, it is vital that we listen to one another and, wherever possible, encourage reflection. That we also allow for the possibility of being wrong, rather than drowning out other voices in a tumult of outrage or discrediting them as immoral.

I hope that you will continue to bring together people of different backgrounds, cultures, and beliefs, that you will also include those who feel unheard or fear becoming the losers of change. Foundations like yours foster cohesion because they provide spaces where we can argue, but also experience community in diversity. And they foster a willingness to change because they encourage citizens to actively shape the great upheavals that are inevitably taking place.

How important it is for private foundations to advocate for a diverse media landscape and a free press, especially in Eastern Europe, is something that Russia's unlawful war makes painfully clear to us.

If we want to defend our freedom, we need independent media that report reliably and fairly, that clarify facts, expose disinformation, and we need them in the digital space as well. We need journalists who conduct thorough research, who make their own observations on the ground, who observe, analyze, and only then evaluate, rather than advocating their opinions all the more vehemently the less clear the facts are.

I have the utmost respect for the reporters from around the world who are currently reporting for us from Ukraine and also from Russia. They ensure that we learn what is happening in Bucha, Kharkiv, or Mariupol; they witness war crimes and violence against civilians; and they make it possible for us to receive reliable news from Russia despite bans and repression. They too help defend our freedom, these journalists, and I believe they deserve great thanks for that!

Maintaining a culture of remembrance, based on research in the humanities and social sciences, is perhaps more important today than ever. For we are witnessing how authoritarian forces weaponize history and stir up new conflicts with historical myths, justify imperial claims, and legitimize wars. Precisely for this reason, we must confront remembrance across borders to overcome prejudices, promote understanding, and hopefully make a peaceful future possible again.

I am grateful to the Zeit-Stiftung for helping to preserve cultural heritage, for revitalizing cultural dialogue, not only in Northern Germany, but throughout Germany and into Eastern Europe.

And I am also grateful to you and many other foundations in our country for opening up opportunities for people who face greater challenges in school, at university, or in their careers than others, for paving educational paths for children and young people from poorer families, for people with migration backgrounds, or for refugees who have just arrived. I look forward to visiting the Louise-Weiß-Gymnasium in the Hamm district later to speak with Ukrainian students who are being supported there by mentors from your foundation.

Finally ensuring greater educational equity is and remains the task of politics. But the many foundations that support disadvantaged people help ensure that we also provide future perspectives for those in our diverse society who have a harder time, or in other words: who are born with fewer opportunities.

In any case, I hope that the Zeit-Stiftung will continue to enrich places beyond the affluent neighborhoods of Hamburg, that it will support and include people for whom a legal career or the Hanseatic cosmopolitanism may not have been laid out for them from the start.

A foundation that turns fifty is no longer just the child of its parents; it has learned from experiences and evolved. The Zeit-Stiftung has been shaped by many women and men – not least by its chairman.

Dear Mr. Göring, you have led the foundation for more than thirty years, first as managing chairman and then as chairman of the board. You have succeeded in making Gerd Bucerius's legacy fruitful for change, and you have also considered it a great fortune to be able to support it. Your commitment to freedom and democracy has left its mark, and, I know from personal experience, not only in this city. You have inspired many people with your passion, and I am sure: your name will forever be associated with the Zeit-Stiftung.

For the time after the foundation, I wish you all the best, and I wish us all that the engaged citizen, the restless spirit, and not least the novelist Michael Göring will continue to accompany and inspire us! Thank you very much for your decades of tireless work, for your openness, your creativity, and, if I may say so, also for your big heart – my personal thanks and the thanks of our entire country!

Dear Mr. Hartung, you took over as chairman of the board at the beginning of the year, and you said that freedom must be "defended offensively" when it is in danger. I think that sounds very much like Gerd Bucerius, and I like the attitude expressed in that.

I am convinced: Our democracy is strong because the idea of freedom is strong within it. It is this inner strength that makes us resilient and willing to change. It is this inner strength that is stronger than the external coercion of any dictatorship! No enemy of democracy, no despiser of freedom should underestimate this strength. And above all, we should not downplay it ourselves. We can make many things possible, we can trust ourselves, we must remain optimistic, despite all setbacks and all upheavals!

I thank everyone who works every day for the common good in our country. And I thank you, the fellow campaigners of the Zeit-Stiftung. How much we can achieve together is something you have shown us for half a century. And that is, especially in these times, a reason to celebrate.

Congratulations and thank you!