Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the celebratory event for the 100th anniversary of the Stinnes-Legien Agreement on October 16, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

20 October 2018 · Celebratory event for the 100th anniversary of the Stinnes-Legien Agreement · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a celebratory event in Berlin marking the 100th anniversary of the Stinnes-Legien Agreement, the founding document of German social partnership.
Main themes
Stinnes-Legien Agreement centenary, German social partnership, collective bargaining autonomy, Weimar Republic founding, labor-employer cooperation, revolutionary crisis of 1918, trade union history, social democracy, political courage and compromise, civil conflict and stabilization
Duration
~18 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,218
62nd percentile
Sentences
96
61st percentile
Readability
38
32nd percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.21
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
61st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 29%27%
  • Social 24%23%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Geopolitical 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

96 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Yesterday, at this historic location, we remember a truly historic event in the history of our country. I fear that there are not many left in Germany who know what Stinnes and Legien and the agreement they made with each other stand for. It is nothing less than this: The beginning of German social partnership, the start of collective bargaining autonomy nearly 100 years ago.

We remember the essential contribution of this partnership to prosperity and peaceful coexistence, and thus also to democracy in Germany – today and tomorrow. At the same time, we reflect on the long, not always easy path of this partnership. A path that began in war and revolution, that led through oppression and dictatorship, through the downfall of the first democracy, and only in the second became a path of genuine, lasting cooperation. To understand this path, we must keep in mind what happened back then, 100 years ago, in the world and in our country.

Let us think of November 9, 1918: Even the Supreme Army Command had already given up on the war. The sailors in Kiel had been in revolt for six days. The Kaiser abdicates. In Berlin, Philipp Scheidemann proclaims the Republic – and Karl Liebknecht the Soviet Republic.

On November 10, Wilhelm II flees to Holland. In Berlin, a Council of People's Representatives is formed under Friedrich Ebert and Hugo Haase, and one day later, Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg announce the re-establishment of the Spartacus League.

On November 12, the Republic is also proclaimed in Vienna, while in Berlin, the Council of People's Representatives announces women's suffrage and the eight-hour workday. The following day, the manufacturer Franz Seldte drafts the basic principles of a right-wing reactionary paramilitary organization: the "Steel Helmet."

On November 15, the armed "Red Soldiers' League" is founded. The radical forces in the country arm themselves for civil war, and the lines of conflict harden in the coming months.

In these few strokes, it becomes clear: Events are unfolding rapidly in these days in Germany. Decisions and reactions are hardly comprehensible for the people, occurring by the hour. After the war, hunger and misery are compounded by daily breathlessness. The fronts quickly harden, the lines of conflict become sharp, compromise and reconciliation seem far away. Already in its first days, the young Republic threatens to sink into a spiral of violence. And yet – almost unbelievably – on the same day, November 15, 1918, something astonishing, completely unexpected happens: The "Agreement between Employers' and Employees' Associations," the Stinnes-Legien Agreement, is signed.

What incredible courage, what self-overcoming, how much sense of responsibility the participants must have shown to seek compromise and agreement in this heated atmosphere, against a backdrop of radical expectations! Indeed, it is courage and responsibility that stand at the beginning of German social partnership!

With the distance of 100 years, we can rightly assert: The foundation of what would later be called and highly praised social partnership was laid in revolutionary times. The agreement was a political act in those weeks when the foundations of coexistence in our country, four years after the war began and 70 years after 1848, were once again completely renegotiated.

The protagonists of that time were almost stylized into prototypes in their roles and functions. On one side, the industrial magnate Hugo Stinnes, first caricatured by the artist George Grosz as the "secret Kaiser" and a caricature of the inhumane capitalist, later misused by the Nazis as a projection surface against the elite. And on the other side, Carl Legien, a moderate Social Democratic member of parliament and union official, who had to fend off radical-revolutionary demands from parts of the working class while also grappling with the restorative resistance of the old regime.

The agreement that bears the names of these two men was, in this heated time full of uncertainty and doubt, a joint attempt by employers and unions to ensure economic stability – and of course also this: a joint attempt to secure their own influence and shaping possibilities. The employers, after some delay, finally recognized the unions as representatives of the entire workforce. They declared their willingness to engage in collective negotiations and binding agreements. Surely also because the danger of expropriation and nationalization was very real. The other side, the unions, refrained from abolishing existing property relations and from comprehensive nationalization. They wanted to protect their members from the unpredictable consequences of a revolutionary upheaval and complete chaos, yes, but they also wanted this: to secure their own survival and their power to shape. Because an expropriated industry, controlled by a socialist council state, ultimately does not need independent, free, and autonomous unions – so the fear at that time and later, in real socialism, became bitter truth.

I do not want to recount all the details of the agreement today. Others can do that better. I only want to highlight one particularity: For the first time, a central body for the cooperation of the social partners was created, which, in 1918, of course, was not yet called that. The "Central Working Group," as the body was called, encompassed all industrial sectors and was to answer fundamental questions – such as that of the daily maximum working hours. In doing so, employers and employees created something that had not existed in Germany until then – and which is still not often found worldwide today: a generally binding, voluntary economic and social regulatory level between state-legal regulation and the contractual freedom of the free market. This too was a kind of revolution and at the same time an important milestone for the development of a social market economy, a strong foundation of democracy in our country!

And even though the agreement lasted only a few years and the Central Working Group was dissolved again in the crisis of 1923/24: It was certainly one of the prerequisites for the Weimar Republic to even get on its feet. That the subsequent state interventions in the economy in the form of emergency decrees and the conflicts they caused – especially in the crisis after 1929 – would become a catalyst for social unrest and the disparagement of democracy; that the Nazis could only fully place the German economy in the service of their ideology and their war and extermination machinery through the alignment of the associations and the abolition of all collective bargaining autonomy – all this shows above all one thing: How important this regulatory level between state and market, this connection of economic freedom and social participation, is for the stability and integrative power of our democracy to this day!

And this is not an abstract theory. The daily interactions in businesses and companies, the agreement on acceptable working conditions, and the peaceful negotiation of conflicts – predominantly without strikes and lockouts – are relied upon by many in this country. I have experienced this more than once in my political life.

Just think of the greatest economic crisis of recent years, from the collapse of the investment bank Lehman Brothers in America to the drama of the sovereign debt crisis in Europe. This crisis had enormous effects on the German economy, from banks to service providers to the middle class and traditional industry. Families had to fear for their existence, entrepreneurs for their life’s work. Unemployment and a years-long depression threatened. In 2008 and 2009, in another capacity, I often received visits from CEOs accompanied by their works councils, united by concern for the company and jobs, sometimes even for entire sectors of the economy.

For me, it is clear: Without the wise ideas and the measured behavior of the social partners, both employers and unions, without employment guarantees, short-time work benefits, and wage restraint, without all that, we would have – like others – fallen much deeper into this crisis – and we would not have returned to stability and growth nearly as quickly! For this, I would like to express great thanks to all of you on behalf of our country!

We should also look forward today. If social partnership is lived democracy, and if this democracy is dear to us, then we must first develop a vision of the tasks of social partnership in the coming decades and second specifically address the preservation of the foundations of this partnership so that it retains its effectiveness under changed conditions.

The

first

point concerns the question: What role will constructive cooperation between employees and employers play in the future? We all expect a tremendous change in our working world in the coming decades. From job profiles to training and employment biographies to employment relationships: The waves of technological innovation are impacting all areas of the economy and working world ever more quickly and extensively.

Even today, we observe an ever-widening technological substitution of traditional activities, even entire job profiles, a rapid growth of the platform economy, and with the growth of the click-and-gig economy, a tendency towards dis-embedding. All this has enormous consequences for the traditional role of social partnership and for its instruments for social balance and social security.

We should take these forecasts seriously. Also the forecasts that warn especially of a polarization of the working world: higher incomes for the highly qualified and highly flexible, less income for less qualified activities. Such forecasts raise enormous questions – for the bargaining partners, for politics, for the entire collective labor law:

Who is the employer in this changing working world, and how do we determine the associated rights and obligations? To put it clearly: How do we prevent the erosion of the classic employer role, which is a cornerstone of all social partnership and must remain so?

How do we define and renew employee rights in the digital economy? How do we reconcile, for example, growing flexibility in everyday work with the right to be able to switch off and rest?

How can education and training keep pace with technological progress so that more employees can benefit from the opportunities of digitalization?

And how must we renew social security systems so that they provide sufficient protection for employees, even as classic employment biographies become less common and new forms, such as the transition between dependent and self-employed work, become more frequent? How do we design social security in digitalization so that the changes inspire courage for the future and do not instill fear of decline?

In all of this lies a huge challenge! And I strongly advise that employers, unions, politics, and science address it early and together! It must not happen that the debate in our country drifts apart – between a digital avant-garde that drives technological progress and benefits from it, and the social and political institutions that only clean up the societal consequences of this change. Only if we jointly address and also jointly answer the critical open questions that many people face as they look into the digital future will we maintain the innovative spirit and the desire for the future in our country. If we answer these questions together, we take the wind out of the sails of those who are currently politically stirring up fears of the future and doomsday scenarios!

The

second

point, the foundations of social partnership, is primarily directed at the decision-makers among employers and in the unions. To effectively maintain this important partnership, strong participation from both sides is needed. This is threatened to erode if the level of organization of unions in new sectors remains low or if employer associations organize less than half of employers. Lines of division keep emerging, for example, between old and new sectors, between different regions of our country.

The avoidance of division has made us strong and has proven to be a fundamental element of the social market economy. The experience of countries with weak social partnership, with wildcat strikes and political protests, should give us all pause for thought. The memory of the social fragmentation of Germany, which Stinnes and Legien sought to address 100 years ago, should serve as a reminder to us. We should make a new attempt to strengthen the social partnership of tomorrow. Associations of employers and employees have a genuine task for the future here, which requires courage and responsibility once again. And when I look at the joint initiatives of the social partners, aimed at attracting skilled workers or during the "Week of Vocational Education," for openness to the world and solidarity in our society, or for digitalization and the work of the future, I am pleased to see that they are addressing some of these challenges very concretely!

What began with the Stinnes-Legien Agreement 100 years ago is historically neither completed nor exhausted. That you, dear Mr. Hoffmann and dear Mr. Kramer, have jointly invited the Federal President to today’s celebration, I regard as a public promise from employers and trade unions to continue to work together over the next 100 years.

I am very pleased that you are commemorating this occasion so comprehensively and thoughtfully – and especially that you are not doing it alone, but in the company of our European neighbors and friends! What you are achieving is immensely important for our country. I wish you and all of us all the best for the next 100 years and a wonderful birthday celebration today.