Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the 200th anniversary of the Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelm University of Bonn on October 18, 2018, in Bonn:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

20 October 2018 · 200th anniversary of the Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn · Bonn, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the bicentennial celebration of the University of Bonn on October 18, 2018, in the former plenary hall of the Bonn Federal Republic.
Main themes
University anniversary, academic excellence, history of democracy in Germany, Enlightenment and liberal thought, Prussian educational reform, Vormärz and 1848 revolution, notable alumni and faculty, University of Bonn history, German intellectual tradition, Fields Medal and Nobel Prize achievements
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,047
86th percentile
Sentences
192
88th percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.10
61st percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
56th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%36%
  • Social 36%34%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

192 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Two hundred years of Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn – what a celebration!

I must admit, three weeks ago, on September 27, I briefly had doubts about whether I could actually come here today. Some of you may have heard: On September 27, it was announced that the University of Bonn is by far the most successful university in the current excellence round. Not two, three, or four, but a whole six clusters are coming to the Rhine – what a coup!

And since the Federal President is known to behave in a non-partisan manner, I suddenly wasn't so sure whether my appearance today would not be seen as taking sides elsewhere. For example, 30 kilometers downstream, there at the Cathedral. The Archbishop already laid bare all sensitivities this morning in the church service.

But to my luck and your listeners' delight, I was at the large congress of German political science at the University of Frankfurt am Main that same week. They assured me after thorough consideration: "That's perfectly fine. You can safely go to Bonn; they have earned it." With such encouragement, I am here. Well then!

You can tell, dear Mr. Hoch: I am very happy to be here today, on the great festive day of your university, to personally say to you: Congratulations on this wonderful success, and above all, heartfelt congratulations on your 200th birthday!

It may have been called something else in the past, but excellence has existed at the University of Bonn long before September 27, 2018. I am of course currently thinking of Peter Scholze, this year's winner of the Fields Medal, and the other famous Bonn mathematicians. But also of the Nobel Prize winners Reinhard Selten and Wolfgang Paul, to name just a few from the recent past. They all stand today as representatives of many, many others who have contributed to the outstanding reputation of your university over the past 200 years.

This was of course planned from the very beginning: The Prussian government did not hold back and brought in some intellectual luminaries so that this third university foundation after Berlin and Breslau could have a dream start. For example, the Schlegel brother August Wilhelm, the first German Indologist, came to the new Rhine province, along with a whole network of great public intellectuals. Barthold Georg Niebuhr was also among them, then a real star among historians, or the still ambivalent figure of Ernst Moritz Arndt, a well-known historian and freedom fighter on one side, a nationalist, France-hater, and anti-Semite on the other. They and a few others brought a lot of academic capital to the new non-denominational university. And so it is, as I look around, only logical that today, 200 years later, we are also celebrating the round anniversary of this officially excellent university with much prominence.

We celebrate this anniversary in the former plenary hall of the Bonn Federal Republic, with many friends from Europe and the world, in a place of German democracy. The history of democracy in our country is closely intertwined with the history of the University of Bonn. I want to speak today about this long journey.

As I said, the starting conditions in Bonn were good, also for fresh ideas. The new university benefited from the high esteem that scholarly learning, natural research, and literary intellectual life enjoyed at the beginning of the 19th century. It had the wind of change in its sails, which was blowing in double fashion through the Rhineland. On the one hand, through the Prussian-Humboldtian ideas of a modern university, and on the other hand, from the legacy of the Kurköln Academy in Bonn from 1777 – also a child of the Enlightenment, albeit a short-lived one. Or to put it in Schlegel's words: "The genuine new only sprouts from the old; the past must ground our future."

That sounds torn, and it probably was. The Enlightenment and liberal, simultaneously romantic and national thoughts of the Vormärz spread along the Prussian Rhine, in the shadow of a strict authority. Heinrich Heine learned a lot from his teacher Schlegel and later wrote, when the Silesian weavers called for rebellion, a curse on "the king of the rich." The Bonn alumnus and fraternity member Hoffmann von Fallersleben sat in 1841 on British Heligoland and dreamed of unity and justice and freedom. The Bonn art historian Gottfried Kinkel founded the Democratic Association, with a conservative counterpart in the Constitutional Citizens' Association of Johann Wilhelm Loebell. The Bonn student leader Carl Schurz, later a general for the Union in the American Civil War, even had the city on the Rhine elected as the "site" of all German student bodies. And in the Frankfurt Paulskirche Parliament, there were seven Bonn professors in 1848 alone. In short: This university had a considerable share in the first, albeit fleeting, attempt at a united and democratic Germany.

Karl Marx, as old as the university, was also a listener of Schlegel. He received a one-day prison sentence during his two semesters on the Rhine for disturbing the peace at night and for drunkenness and illegal possession of weapons. That was probably not yet a revolutionary uprising, but perhaps an academic warm-up phase. It was not much more revolutionary when, at the behest of Berlin, women were first admitted to the university at the end of the 19th century, a total of 16 guest students in the winter semester of 1896/97. It would take another twelve years until the right to full enrollment and fourteen years until Maria von Linden became the first woman to be appointed professor – albeit still without venia legendi. What was particularly true back then still holds today: There is much to be done regarding equality in science. Not only here in Bonn but everywhere in Germany.

More than half a century after the first women at the university, after two world wars and the brutal Nazi dictatorship, there was again a noticeable democratic spirit here. As Gerd Bucerius wrote in the ZEIT at the end of the 1970s, the Bonn Republic in 1949 was by no means a foregone conclusion: "The conductors at Bonn station wrinkle their noses when a member of the Bundestag shows his free ticket. In the Federal House, we heard the carnival song from the pleasure boats passing on the Rhine: 'Who is going to pay for this, who ordered it?' Democracy had to be learned first."

Unlike the conductors, the Bonn legal scholars, who at that time were not among the most progressive forces, soon stood firmly in the service of German democracy. Like no other law faculty, they could – not least due to their proximity – shine with a direct line to government and administration, and perhaps like no other, they had an influence on the training of the civil service for the new republic. Added to this were innovations from other sciences, such as political science, which wanted to make the University of Bonn a place of learning for democracy, as Karl Dietrich Bracher, the first holder of the chair for political science and contemporary history established in 1959 at the "prisoner-of-war university" in Kansas, had experienced. He was part of the first generation of young scholars who, with relentless interest in enlightenment, examined the failure of the first German democracy. His study "The Dissolution of the Weimar Republic" from 1955 became a standard work.

The Bonn University was therefore not distant from the state at that time. And for the student body and young democrats, this resulted in an extremely practical synergy, so to speak, along Adenauerallee: Democracy at the university was firmly connected with democracy in the provisional capital. Neither the 1968 movement nor the peace movement left the electoral palace untouched, even if the protests at the universities in West Berlin or Frankfurt may have been larger in scale. It was students who repeatedly opened the windows to the fresh wind – for example, with the new university constitution of 1968, which was very controversial at the time. But above all, as a Bonn student, one only had to join the large capital demonstrations on the Hofgartenwiese – in the 1980s, these were the largest rallies the Federal Republic had ever seen. That too was democracy up close, to participate in and right at the doorstep.

The path of this university is closely intertwined with Germany's long journey to democracy. But it was not a straight path, not an easy one, and not always leading towards the noble goal. It was a winding path with detours and also deviations. We want to remember that today as well. The founding of this university was not a democratic act, but primarily the result of successful lobbying by the city leaders, sealed by a monarchical grant from Berlin. Incidentally, at the expense of two other, older university locations in Cologne and Duisburg.

The early years also fell under the deeply illiberal, undemocratic Carlsbad Resolutions of the German Confederation. In rare unity, "demagogue persecution" was in effect almost everywhere in Germany. The restoration resisted revolutionary ideas at the universities, against liberal-national romanticism among professors and students. For the new Bonn University, this early McCarthyism was a heavy burden. Some well-known and respected scholars declined their offers, including the Brothers Grimm and the philosopher Friedrich von Schelling. Soon, Ernst Moritz Arndt, the most prominent of the first Bonn professors, also had to vacate his chair. When academic freedom is only tolerated by the grace of authority, it can also be revoked – a lesson we sometimes need to remind ourselves of today. What was already true back then is even more so today: Whoever takes away the freedom of science, who scorns experts and elevates hostility to science as a stylistic device, is playing with fire and jeopardizing the success of the future. The freedom of science must never be merely borrowed; it must remain guaranteed!

Additionally, at that time, the Bonn University – named after the Protestant King Friedrich Wilhelm III of Prussia – had a distinctly culture-war colonial flavor in its first decades. With the exception of Catholic theology, most chairs were occupied by Prussian Protestants. Their work in the Catholic Rhineland almost took on missionary traits. Some even saw themselves as defenders of Prussian authority against Rhineland liberty.

All these conflict lines, these multifaceted ambivalences of polarization and plurality, had to be negotiated over long decades in painful culture wars and processes of unification. When we remember these conflicts today, we also remember the pain of confessional strife; the pain of lacking freedom, unity, and equality. When we in our country today again debate questions of belonging and identity, then the memory of the already overcome divisions and the freedoms already won can and should give us a little direction and perspective, even here in Bonn.

A hundred years ago, the grand celebration was canceled. Due to the war, the round birthday celebration only took place a year later, in 1919, in the young democratic republic, and the mood was at best cautiously optimistic: "The war has presented our people with tremendous, unprecedented tasks," said Rector Ernst Zitelmann at the 100th anniversary, adding: "Peace will likely present us with even more difficult ones." In the same year, the university decided to offer Thomas Mann an honorary doctorate – a German, by the way, whose path to democracy was as winding as that of his country. Even at the beginning of the war in 1914, that Thomas Mann wrote: "Away with the foreign and repulsive catchphrase democratic! The mechanically democratic state of the West will never gain home rights with us." Sentences that he later himself was shocked by when he fled with his family from the Nazis to the free and democratic exile of the West. I was only recently able to recall this in Pacific Palisades, in Thomas Mann's "White House of Exile," where he, inspired by Franklin D. Roosevelt, ultimately became a passionate fighter for a free and resilient democracy.

Meanwhile, the University of Bonn in Germany also turned its back on democracy. Although the National Socialists never won a majority in the free elections for the Bonn student representation, they did secure a third of the votes in 1932. As in the rest of the country, this university was placed under the totalitarian oversight of the Nazi state, and Jewish professors and politically undesirable staff were dismissed. The Protestant theologian Karl Barth refused to take the Führer oath and lost his chair. Many went into exile. Others, like the philosophers Paul Ludwig Landsberg and Johannes Maria Verweyen, lost their lives in the prisons and camps of the Nazis. Thomas Mann, the Nobel laureate, our writer of the century, had his honorary doctorate revoked in 1936 in a shamefully petty administrative act – a procedure, by the way, for which no one wanted to take responsibility after the war. All the many officials who had enabled the rule of injustice with their compliance believed themselves to be innocent after 1945. Thus, in 1946, it was easy to rehabilitate the honorary doctor Mann quietly and without any reckoning. The man, who had since grown into a proud democrat, showed true greatness when he accepted the award again.

The path to democracy for this university, as well as for our country, was long and arduous, guided by its own intellectual traditions and political upheavals, but it was only completed after the victory of the Allies over Nazi Germany through coercion and occupation. For the University of Bonn, the Anglo-Saxon partnership has remained formative – after all, there has been a vibrant connection with Oxford University since that time.

But when we look back today at these past 200 years, at this crooked path to democracy and all its detours, the question remains: What should universities actually achieve today? What can we expect from them? And what do we wish for? If I could wish for something myself, it would be this: that the university, while focusing on science, is always also one thing – a place of democracy.

What does that mean concretely? First of all, I believe that in order to be a place of democracy, the university must first and foremost be a place of freedom! Because, unfortunately, one must remind ourselves of this again in these times: democracy is not either liberal or illiberal. Rather, it is either liberal or it is not. "Illiberal democracy" is a contradiction in itself. Democracy presupposes elections, but it does not end there. It legitimizes the majority, but within the limits of law and constitution. This means: contrary to views that have recently been expressed in some parts of Europe, democracy cannot exist without the rule of law and minority protection; it withers without human rights and civil liberties. And it stands and falls with the freedom of the spirit!

Universities are places where the spaces of freedom and rights in a democracy are constantly re-explored. They are places for discussion about the standards of what can be said and what cannot, about the boundaries and the utility of new ideas. Yes, the university needs spaces of freedom, but at the university, spaces of freedom are also negotiated and defined! The academic search for truth and knowledge leads us repeatedly into such debates. This is challenging, often uncomfortable. In recent years, for example, there has been a tendency – especially in America – to develop universities into sheltered biotopes of clean language and emotional irritation-free zones. Out of excessive consideration and trigger warnings, Shakespeare is even disappearing from the curriculum in some places. I consider that to be wrong. Decent treatment of one another never means sparing intellectual challenge – especially not at a university!

But conversely, I say to those who have already turned the much-criticized political correctness into a battle cry: political correctness does not necessarily mean cowardice or language policing, but is first and foremost an expression of hard-won civility and historical sensitivity. And I believe we should not throw it overboard so lightly!

Learning democracy can only happen in freedom and responsibility! When soon half of a graduating class in our digital knowledge society goes to universities, then university teachers bear great responsibility for the future of democracy! Some say that university studies today, after the reforms of recent decades, resemble an all-inclusive cruise rather than an individual adventure trip. What is meant is probably a journey without the experiences necessary for locating one's future place in society.

I consider that to be somewhat exaggerated. But despite all the structuring and performance enhancement through Bologna, with bachelor's and master's degrees, modules, and grading, one thing is important: the freedom to choose one's course of study, the freedom to debate, and the freedom to exchange ideas, even across the boundaries of one's own discipline, university, and country. All these freedoms, dear university teachers, must be protected and nurtured if we, as Schiller expressed in his inaugural lecture in Jena, do not want only "bread scholars," but philosophical and – he would probably add today – also democratic minds.

You bear great responsibility in the presidencies, faculty councils, and at your chairs. Of course, you are entitled to a stable material foundation, to good financial resources. You must even demand it. International competitiveness and genuine top-level research, as we all desire, as well as intellectual independence and creativity – all of this requires appropriate resources. The state bears primary responsibility for this – and it is good to remind it of this repeatedly. However, I believe our country does not need to hide. Especially after the investments in science and research that have brought us back into the academic elite over the last one and a half decades – both in breadth and in excellence. And I am confident that we will continue to meet this demand in the future.

Dear university teachers, I would wish that you see your exercises, lectures, and seminars as an opportunity to fulfill the responsibility of science towards society and democracy! This undoubtedly includes that we have a climate at the university that promotes discourse and debate. That we need teaching of the highest quality – teaching that invites discussion. I am sure that this demand already guides your actions here in Bonn today. However, I believe that this alone is not enough. We must fundamentally debate and define what we expect from academic teaching in the 21st century. What should a degree serve today? What skills in thinking and acting should it impart in the future? And what must academic teaching achieve to meet all these demands? Can we leave it to chance whether a good scientist is also a good teacher? Must we find new ways to enable teaching, as some demand and as is already happening in many American academic institutions? I want to encourage you today to find answers to these questions!

In the independence of science, in the freedom of the spirit, lies the legacy of the European Enlightenment. It was the foundation of the Humboldtian ideal, which has influenced and even shaped the development of the university landscape worldwide for two centuries. But there is no question: the conditions for scientific work and research have changed in these two centuries. With the broad opening of the university – you notice, I avoid the term "mass university" – the creation of enormous research capacities outside the universities, the Bologna process – to name just three keywords – the academic infrastructure has changed significantly.

But today, I am not only concerned with change, but rather with what remains, or better, what must remain: the freedom of scientific research as freedom from state influence and limitation. This is guaranteed today by our constitution in Article 5, Paragraph 3 of the Basic Law – even without constitutionally immediate limits. This guarantee is neither a gift nor an end in itself. Rather, it embodies the interest, indeed even the hope of a modern, future-oriented society that only independence and freedom from state mandates unleash the creativity of scientific research and thus create the conditions for civilizational progress.

Independence from the state is guaranteed; for independence from others, science must take care of itself. And as far as I can judge, it is succeeding. If questions are occasionally raised about the consequences of extensive third-party funding in certain research areas, no one should complain. Such questions can be answered. What is important is that universities and research institutions are aware of the conditions of their independence and defend them in every direction!

Free and independent science makes our modern society possible. Without strong science, our country would not be viable. It is only through it that we become a partner in the international scientific exchange on which we depend. It is only through it that the foundation for innovations and perspectives for future generations is laid. And it is only the combination of academic freedom and research spirit in responsibility that creates the spaces in which society can assure itself of itself.

We need the great debates for this, including controversy – but above all, the great debates in our country must not drift into a competition of simple answers out of fear of complexity!

For this, we need you, because we need answers that hold. And we especially need the process in which they arise. A process that is credible because it cannot be co-opted by superficial political or other interests. A process based on arguments and facts, in which the actors participate with the self-understanding and ambition to contribute to the production of truth. The acceptance of science – it is challenged in the age of "felt" truths and sometimes devastating criticism of the political, economic, and even scientific establishment. Therefore, the credibility of the process – even more than any individual result – is crucial for whether and to what extent science is respected and its results accepted.

This also includes that we do not shy away from questions. Where science and research push the boundaries of our imagination, especially where they raise fundamental ethical questions that – as in the case of biotechnology and artificial intelligence – provoke uncertainty and resistance, we must try to answer societal questions instead of ignoring them.

I do not believe in the occasionally spread suspicion that Germans are fundamentally opposed to progress or fearful of technology. If that were the case, the reality of our research landscape and the modernity of our country would be hard to explain! But a little more confidence that open questions can also be answered, that risks can be influenced, that the future – despite all changes – remains shapeable: that is what I wish for from the Germans!

Finally: If universities – alongside their central role in academia – are also places of democracy – must be – then their responsibility extends beyond the laboratory and lecture hall! I wish for universities with self-confident people and convinced democrats who work at the university, learn to think and debate at the university, and – this too – who act in society from the university! We need clever idea generators from science not only in research and teaching, we need them in the public debates of our time. Science must fill the space that democracy grants it!

Perhaps – and with that I want to conclude – you can all see in the university's outward work an opportunity to convey the value of research and teaching in democracy and freedom, to participate in the great questions, the shaping debates, the negotiation processes that move societies on a large scale just as much as universities do on a small scale.

The University of Bonn proudly looks back on 200 years of history today. But it may be especially proud of how far it has come in these 200 years and what it contributes today to the reputation of this city, to the capacity for innovation, and to the prosperity of this country.

Most of all, however, the university can contribute to a self-confident, enlightened, and free democracy, because only in democracy does the freedom of science and research find its lasting place. That we succeed in this anew under changing conditions, I wish for you and our country. Happy birthday!