Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the ceremonial act for the change of presidency at the Federal Constitutional Court on November 12, 2021, in Karlsruhe:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

14 November 2021 · Ceremonial act for the change of presidency at the Federal Constitutional Court · Federal Constitutional Court, Karlsruhe, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremonial event in Karlsruhe on November 12, 2021, marking the delayed recognition of Federal Constitutional Court leadership changes made in summer 2020.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court presidency change, constitutional jurisprudence, European integration and EU law primacy, fundamental rights protection, digitalization and data protection, freedom of expression and press freedom, judicial leadership and team building, court transparency and public communication, democracy and rule of law
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,506
68th percentile
Sentences
99
62nd percentile
Readability
37
29th percentile
Grade
14.1
68th percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
50th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 58%58%
  • Ceremonial 35%35%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

99 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Last year, we had a change of president without a celebration; today, we celebrate without a change of president – the pandemic forces us to be particularly flexible. Therefore, we are only now honoring the personnel changes that the Bundestag and Bundesrat made back in the summer of 2020 in this grand setting.

You were sworn in back then at Schloss Bellevue in the smallest circle. Nevertheless, once again today: Dear Ms. Härtel, dear Ms. Wallrabenstein, dear Ms. König, dear Mr. Harbarth, congratulations! I am glad that we can solemnly commemorate this act today and thus make such an important part of our constitutional life truly visible.

Dear Mr. Voßkuhle, dear Mr. Masing, I already extensively acknowledged you and your work as constitutional judges last year. I do not want to repeat everything; let me just highlight a few things once more:

Dear Mr. Voßkuhle, before your election – a long time ago – you were, of course, known to insiders. Nevertheless, you were considered something of a hidden gem when you took office at a relatively young age. It quickly became clear: In your person, professional brilliance is combined with pronounced social competence. Both enabled you to bring together the very different personalities of judges – with sensitivity and finesse. A social vein and high integrative power characterize you. The means by which you particularly fostered team spirit, I and others described last year – I will only mention the keywords of joint ski trips and cooking evenings. You will be remembered here in Karlsruhe for that as well as for your highest professional authority and the passion with which you have exercised your presidency here.

You have also represented the Federal Constitutional Court in your own unique way. The visibility of state institutions and the comprehensibility of their decisions have always been important to you. Highlighting the significance of the court for our state community has, in my opinion, always been excellently accomplished by you.

With a twelve-year term, it goes without saying that important decisions were made in which you – as Primus inter Pares – have clearly left your mark. I would like to mention here those decisions that dealt with Germany's position in the European Union. Because these decisions are perceived to a particularly high degree beyond the borders by the other member states of the European Union. The impact of these rulings is therefore not limited to the national sphere. Rather, they have a signaling effect throughout the entire European legal space and often even beyond.

The Federal Constitutional Court is very aware of the enormous reach of its decisions, which has led to the translation of important decisions into English and French being firmly established during your term as part of the court's routine press and public relations work.

With the decisions on European integration comes great responsibility – the responsibility for cohesion in Europe, which is also a constitutional obligation. It fills me with great concern that courts in other member states misuse the decisions of the Federal Constitutional Court to question one of the fundamental foundational decisions of the European legal community, namely the primacy of Union law over national law.

After your departure from office, you did not take much time for leisure. You have taken on responsibility for the common good in other ways and are actively applying your authority, knowledge, and experience for that purpose. That you are doing this, among other things, with the initiative "Against Forgetting – for Democracy" is a particular joy for me and deserves our special recognition. As a university lecturer, you have the great privilege of being able to wonderfully combine the constitutional practical perspectives gained at the Constitutional Court with your research focuses. I look forward to hearing your voice in the future on fundamental questions of our constitutional life.

Dear Mr. Masing, after twelve years as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court, your name stands for the protection of such important fundamental rights as the right to free expression, the freedom of information, broadcasting, and the press, the general right of personality, or data protection. You were the rapporteur in the relevant proceedings that dealt with case scenarios and legal questions that were often publicly discussed in very contradictory ways.

In light of an ever-advancing digitalization, you have significantly shaped these areas of law, which are particularly important for our social coexistence in the 21st century: In your department, freedom and security, data protection, and crime fighting were located. Many of the open legal questions arose only through the rapid development of new information technologies; there were often, as I know, no adequate legal foundations regarding fundamental rights, let alone solutions that had already been concretely laid out in the court's earlier case law.

Given such opposing legal goods, it was therefore hardly surprising that decisions you had pre-structured and shaped in the Senate occasionally remained subjects of controversy even after the decision. That cannot be otherwise; it is part of it, and I know it does not deter you. I said it last year: You embody the liberal spirit of our Basic Law.

And the question of whether there can be a fulfilled professional life after leaving the Federal Constitutional Court can be answered for you in a similar way as for Mr. Voßkuhle. You both, as I know, answer it in the same place, at the University of Freiburg. Once someone has taken up the profession of university lecturer, they practice this profession with passion and without an age limit. I have heard that you have become a fellow at the Käte Hamburger Kolleg "Law as Culture" in Bonn and are contributing your constitutional court experiences to scientific inquiry there, among other things. For that, we thank you very much.

As successors to Andreas Voßkuhle and Johannes Masing, the Bundesrat has elected Astrid Wallrabenstein and Ines Härtel. It is obvious that the Bundesrat has elected two highly qualified constitutional lawyers to the Federal Constitutional Court; I have tried to outline your biographies at the time of your appointment in the most important stages. Your selection and election – it should be noted – took place as with all those who are elected as judges of the highest federal courts and the Federal Constitutional Court, in a process laid down in the constitution and in the relevant laws and carried out by the designated bodies.

The selection process is, as we all know and have experienced, not a simple decision-making process. The requirement that candidates for the Federal Constitutional Court need a two-thirds majority in the respective electoral bodies already prevents that for the Federal Constitutional Court. The federal structure of the German judiciary also guarantees a plural composition of the courts, as justice and legal administration, with the exception of the Federal Constitutional Court and the highest federal courts, fall under the jurisdiction of the states. Moreover, it is one of the qualification criteria for judges that they are personalities who guarantee political independence.

Even if the selection may be a political process, the precautions described in Germany prevent a court from being composed exclusively or predominantly in a one-sided manner. The procedures ensure that the independence of judges – as an essential good in the rule of law – is maintained.

What is special about your election, dear Ms. Wallrabenstein, dear Ms. Härtel, to the Federal Constitutional Court is that for the first time, women constitute the majority within a constitutional body. This is by no means a given, but it does correspond to a judicial reality – it is not a novelty in the lower courts, but still an exception in the upper and highest courts.

I should wish you both good success, but – as we have just heard – that is hardly necessary, as you are "succeeding" here at this court every day, and have been for many months.

Even though you, dear Ms. König, dear Mr. Harbarth, have only invited us today to honor the outgoing judges and to appoint the new judges, this change of judges takes place in the context of the seventieth anniversary of the Federal Constitutional Court. Not only for constitutional lawyers, for professors of constitutional law, but above all for the citizens in our country, the Federal Constitutional Court is of fundamental importance for social coexistence and the realization of freedom and equality of individuals.

Karlsruhe decisions shape and design our more liberal constitutional state, our social coexistence – and that significantly. And not only that: The Federal Constitutional Court is one of the institutions in Germany that can claim the highest esteem. According to a survey from early 2021, the Federal Constitutional Court enjoys "very great trust" from 78 percent of the surveyed citizens. In its seventy years of existence, the Federal Constitutional Court has contributed immeasurably to solidifying our state and our social system with a case law that is always up to date.

That the Basic Law also established a constitutional jurisdiction that makes fundamental rights enforceable and actionable against the state is an achievement for all citizens. It is not the task of constitutional courts to give state authorities a presumption of trust – on the contrary: a certain distrust belongs to the work of constitutional judges, as one of your former colleagues once said.

This may not be well received in administration and politics, but it is probably one of the main reasons for the trust of citizens in the court. The sheer number of constitutional complaints filed each year allows you to not only see many socio-political questions of daily life but also to address them here. Even if they are often only individual cases, many of them have fundamental significance and extend far beyond the horizon of the individual case. And thus, the court is present in daily life, as questions are brought to the judges that are directly important for the everyday lives of people.

In the history of the Federal Constitutional Court, there have repeatedly been decisions that have often been labeled "groundbreaking," "pioneering," or even "revolutionary" in public and political discourse. Decisions that have frequently mirrored societal developments. This was true for the ruling of July 29, 1959, a cornerstone for equality, as it ended the legally guaranteed dominance of men in the family. Or for decisions that every law student will count among the core of the early case law of the Federal Constitutional Court, associated with names like Elfes and Lüth.

The census ruling of 1983 marked the birth of a new area of law – with the right to informational self-determination derived from Article 2(1) of the Basic Law (GG) in conjunction with Article 1(1) GG. This began what we later referred to as the development of constitutionally protected data protection. The demonstrations against nuclear power were the occasion for the Brokdorf decision of 1985, which was fundamentally important for the exercise of the right to demonstrate and assemble. With the ruling of July 12, 1994, the court established that a constitutive resolution of the Bundestag is required for an overseas deployment, as the Bundeswehr is a parliamentary army.

Even in more recent times, there have been such fundamental decisions. I think, for example, of rulings such as those on European integration, the decisions on the right to be forgotten, the financing of public broadcasting, the so-called ecotoxicity ruling, and certainly – a few words on this – not least the climate protection ruling.

It is not surprising that the complainants in the climate protection lawsuit have welcomed their success in Karlsruhe more than warmly. The decision has also received much approval in the broad media public, and in some places even enthusiasm. In the legal, especially in the constitutional law professional community, the response was equally lively, perhaps a bit more mixed.

The decision undoubtedly has far-reaching implications, and I believe that is reflected in the positions of both the supporters and the critics of the decision. Thank God the Federal President does not have to decide who and which position is right, and I admit I am glad about that. But it can be predicted that the climate protection decision will be one of the milestones in jurisprudence.

The consequences may not yet be fully foreseeable; what seems certain to me is that political decisions in a central area of societal future shaping will henceforth be measured and reviewed by the Federal Constitutional Court with the yardstick of intergenerational justice. This, of course, does not remove debates from the political arena, but the dispute over pivotal decisions, and especially over the absence of pivotal decisions in climate protection policy, will likely be carried out more in courts and not just before the Federal Constitutional Court in the future.

The decision, I want to say, evokes both fears and expectations. The fear is, for example, that the traditional boundaries between the judiciary and the legislature will be shifted, that it will provide impetus for further legalizing the political discourse. On the other hand, the expectation is expressed that the topic of generational justice will now be consistently transferred to other areas of policy; that in the future, generational justice will also be available as a standard for the Federal Constitutional Court in reviewing actions and omissions in the field of social security. This is how I understood the expectation of the President of the Federal Social Court.

We are naturally not at the end of the debate about what is certainly a very significant decision of the Federal Constitutional Court, but rather in the midst of it. The Federal Constitutional Court is not experiencing such discussions for the first time, and I am sure we will quickly recognize in the further upcoming decisions of the court where and how the court positions itself in the debate.

The Federal Constitutional Court rightly enjoys a high reputation, and its jurisprudence has contributed to the success of democracy. You have often had to make decisions in existential boundary questions or other issues where completely opposing views were represented in our society. Whether it was about the life of a politician kidnapped by terrorists, questions of abortion, euthanasia, or the legal permission to shoot down hijacked airplanes used as weapons. All of these are questions that were objectively not simple, and the court, the judges, have never made the answering of them easy. This certainly also applies to the questions now pending decision in the fight against the pandemic.

You and your predecessors in office have always managed to maintain the balance between legitimate interests and to find appropriate and, above all, widely accepted solutions for the protection of the rights of citizens. For this, I would like to thank you on behalf of our country. For your conduct in office, dear Mr. Harbarth, dear Ms. König, dear Ms. Wallrabenstein, and dear Ms. Härtel, I wish you – now I can already say: continue to have – a steady hand. I wish you all the very best from the bottom of my heart!