Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the closing event of the campaign "Freedom is our System" of the Alliance of Science Organizations on September 26, 2019 in ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

4 October 2019 · Closing event of the campaign "Freedom is our System" of the Alliance of Science Organizations

Context
Steinmeier addressed the closing event of the Alliance of Science Organizations' campaign on academic freedom, held at the Futurium in Berlin on September 26, 2019.
Main themes
Academic freedom, Germany's Basic Law 70th anniversary, freedom and responsibility of science, threats to free science globally, democratic values, science and society, innovation and future, constitution and fundamental rights, autocracy and political threats to science, Alliance of Science Organizations
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,821
73rd percentile
Sentences
145
79th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
32nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 37%36%
  • Social 26%25%
  • Ceremonial 20%19%
  • Environmental 11%10%
  • Economic 4%3%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

145 sentences in 48 paragraphs

How wonderful it is to be with you today to conclude this equally important and diverse series on academic freedom, which has accompanied the 70th anniversary of our Basic Law.

I am very pleased! You cannot imagine how difficult it was a year and a half, two years ago, to even spark interest in this anniversary. Some believed that we should rather celebrate the 75th anniversary. Others doubted whether it could be sufficiently highlighted as a nationwide anniversary. And there were many reasons that spoke against it for one institution or organization or another. I am glad that the attitude has changed. Many events have taken place – not only serious speeches but also colorful events with great, broad participation, for example, at our place in Bellevue; of course, there were also celebrations in the German Bundestag or at the Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe. I am even more pleased that you, the scientific community of our country, are celebrating this occasion.

It is good to see how clearly and distinctly our science can speak with one voice on such an important topic – the constitution of our society. My heartfelt thanks go to the Alliance of Science Organizations and to all of you for that! And thank you for the invitation!

It is also nice to see you here, in a house of the future, dear State Secretary Lukas, dear Mr. Brandt – a house of futures, as you say, the new Futurium in the heart of Berlin. The tour just now has made me curious about all the possibilities for shaping our future, as they are made tangible here in the Futurium and especially accessible for young people. I am equally curious about what we can expect from the Futurium itself in the future.

We do not live in particularly optimistic times. Dark clouds shape the everyday picture in society, politics, business, and media: insecurity, despondency, frustration. Many fear that tomorrow will be less pleasant than today, and more and more seek refuge in yesterday.

I believe this house of futures is all the more important. I hope that this place will remind our country of what has made us strong, namely our ability to innovate, our trust that scientific and technological progress can and should serve our entire society, in short: what has always characterized us, our desire for the future. In this sense, I wish the Futurium much success – hopefully far beyond the haze of the capital! The beginning has been well made – congratulations on that!

Esteemed Ms. Wintermantel and Ms. Brockmeier, esteemed presidents of the Alliance of Science Organizations, your statements in the film we just watched speak a clear language. They call upon us – right on time for the anniversary of the Constitution – clearly and unequivocally that we have achieved something over these seven decades under this Basic Law that we can be proud of, namely a broad consensus on the freedom of science in our country. I add: Fortunately, this is the case, despite all challenges and far beyond the scientific community!

This consensus can be summarized in two sentences.

First: The freedom of science is a high good in our democracy, enshrined as a fundamental right in our constitution, and we all are obliged to nurture, protect, and, if necessary, defend it.

And second: The freedom of science in a liberal democracy is mirrored by an expectation, namely the expectation of the responsibility of science for the world it researches, for the society in which it researches, for humanity and nature in general.

Freedom and responsibility: The scientific freedom that we must protect and the responsibility that arises from this freedom are inextricably linked.

So, is that it then? A short film, a brief summary by the Federal President: academic freedom confirmed, one step closer to the buffet.

No, the unity in this room is hardly representative of the state of the world. We see attacks on free science – worldwide and very concretely.

We do not even need to look to other parts of the world, to the strong or newly re-emerging autocratic systems, for example, where freedom counts for little, in countries where science must serve authority and ideology.

We do not even need to look across the Atlantic, where decades of scientific knowledge can be brushed aside with a sharp tweet – and at worst, the public's ability to distinguish between one and the other is lost as well.

No, we only need to look at Europe, where an entire university is driven out of the country, where some leaders already wish for a world without supposedly bothersome experts, without critical minds, and with a science that completely submits to the political line.

All of this should concern us. And more than that: We must raise our voices where scientists are under pressure, and we must help where we can – for example, when researchers from these countries seek refuge with us.

The influx of threatened scientists shows: This Germany – with its truly difficult history – has today become a beacon of hope and a harbor of reason for many, a partner for those who demand the freedom of thought and the freedom of speech worldwide. Let us please preserve this claim!

Yes, academic freedom means something in this country. But that is not a reason to rest! Especially in this global situation, especially because we can see or hear every day how academic freedom is being challenged, we should ask ourselves how we can secure this precious fundamental right for the future. I want to focus on three areas in particular.

First, academic freedom always has a material component. You, the scientists of our country, are entitled to a strong financial foundation. Top-level research at the international level, as we all wish for, as well as intellectual independence and creativity, all require adequate resources. Our country certainly does not need to hide in this regard, especially after the increasing investments in the last one and a half decades. But maintaining this claim will not be easier in the coming years. This includes that universities and research institutions remain aware of the conditions of their independence and defend them in every direction – this applies to politics, but it also applies in the area of third-party funding, for example, from the economy. In my view, one thing is certain: The state bears primary responsibility for the material foundations of science – and it does not hurt if you remind it of this from time to time.

Second, academic freedom must not only apply at the top but also for the next generation. I wish for universities to be places where democracy is practiced. And for the university to be a place of democracy, it must first and foremost be a place of freedom. Some lament that studying today gives individuals too little space for the search for meaning and for finding their place in society. I consider that somewhat exaggerated. But despite all the structuring and performance enhancement through Bologna, with bachelor and master programs, modules, and grading, one thing is important: The freedom of students, from the choice of study path to intellectual development beyond the boundaries of their own discipline and their own country, this freedom belongs at the core of academic education, and it should remain there.

And later, for doctoral candidates and assistants, it is, of course, also the freedom to develop their own research focuses, well supervised but unburdened by outdated dependencies and excessive influence from the elders. Because the academic freedom to which we today commit ourselves does not begin only with the W salary scale; it is certainly also needed by research associates, doctoral candidates, and postdocs.

Third, finally, and this is the most important point, we must secure the freedom of research in society. In my view, this can only be achieved by fostering trust in its processes and procedures and renewing it where necessary.

The notorious "post-factual age" has not only broken out in other parts of the world. Even in Germany, 43 percent of respondents already say that facts are a matter of opinion. This finding can and must concern us. We must understand its reasons, yes – but more importantly: We must deal with it!

I believe that where trust in scientific findings is lacking, trust in the process by which these findings are generated becomes all the more important. The process must be credible – by not serving superficial interests. By relying on comprehensible arguments, verifiable facts, and transparent methodology. And by honestly distinguishing between established findings and hypotheses that are still disputed even within science.

Science must not – under the pressure of a polarized public – degenerate into an opinion bubble among many. Therefore, I want to encourage all scientists: Continue to participate in the scientific process with the ambition and the claim to contribute to the production of truth. Because societal progress needs the foundation of your findings. The great future topics need not only emotional but also well-informed debate!

Yes, responsible politics must stand up for and advocate trust in science – but science itself must also continually strive for this trust. You all know this, and you do it! Without trust in research, society will be blind to the opportunities of the future, and science will become an easy target for enemies of freedom!

What sounds very general here is of the highest practical relevance, as you will see shortly: A few months ago, I was in Iceland, a small country at the far edge of Europe, which is experiencing the effects of human-made climate change existentially. You can imagine what it means for a country that even has ice in its name when the first glaciers – already today – cease to exist. When not only the climate changes, but the land begins to rise with the diminishing weight of the glaciers.

As is often the case on such trips, I had also invited guests from Germany to represent our country. Among them are always scientists – including some in this room – and I am glad about that.

Now, during that trip to Iceland, we sat down and discussed climate change with scientists, and one thing was clear: No one questioned the authenticity of the facts in this debate. The data and their interpretation were not the issue.

The issue was rather why "the politics" does not act, why "the politics" does not fulfill its responsibility, why "the politics" – which must finally listen to science! – lets the necessary measures slide.

With that, I come to another, the most current topic that particularly moves and concerns me these days, and about which we must talk when it comes to academic freedom and responsibility: the relationship between "science" and "politics."

Especially regarding the major theme of our time, climate protection, I see and hear much misunderstanding, much disappointment, much annoyance when science looks at "the politics." I see and hear how "the politics" – not only on presidential trips but every day in the media, in the marketplaces of the entire country – is accused of unwillingness and outright failure, referring to scientific facts.

Of course, you do not expect me to comment on individual decisions now. As Federal President, it cannot be my role to simply and superficially side with one or the other. In my role, I must seek ways for the two levels to find each other.

To make my position clear: Every impatience is justified. And criticism is necessary. Of course, the initiative for action lies primarily with politics. It is also true that Germany, which was once a pioneer in climate protection and the development of renewable energies, is in danger of losing this position, and what is worse: this ambition. We set ambitious goals for ourselves years ago – now the political will to actually achieve these goals counts! Climate policy must be measured against this, and it must act boldly and decisively.

All of this is correct. The urgency of action cannot be questioned, and no one can deny it anymore. But we find ourselves in what one might very old-fashioned call a tension relationship. Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker coined the maxim that it is the first responsibility of the scientist to recognize the interconnection of knowledge and world change.

Yes, knowledge and world change are closely intertwined – but they are not the same! It’s a pity, some of you may think, and the old Plato would probably agree with you. We need philosopher-kings – instead, we have subcommittees, summits, and climate cabinets.

As Federal President, I am not here to justify politics – especially not individual decisions made by the coalition regarding climate protection. But perhaps I can say this in this circle: democracy is not the same as science. And above all: democracy does not function like science. In democracy, sharp intellect, selection of the best, peer review, and impact factor are not the only things that count. Politics in democracy follows its own rules. It should not be dismissed – not even by science – as fundamentally incapable of making decisions or even as a nuisance.

Science is, by its very nature, primarily oriented towards knowledge – politics, by its very nature, is action-oriented. This means: democracy needs science – indeed, it absolutely does! – but democracy also needs a few other things: weighing different perspectives and priorities, balancing interests, campaigning for majorities, striving for compromises, and taking responsibility for those who are left behind on the road to progress or who are particularly hard hit by the dynamics of social transformation.

However, not only in the discussions during the trip to Iceland did I have the impression that we are almost speaking different languages. That we are increasingly falling into the trap of viewing "science" and "politics" as two orbiting planets that exchange fragmented radio messages in a command tone and then ritualistically get upset with each other when the other side does not immediately respond with "Roger."

My main concern today is this: misunderstanding and speechlessness must not become the modus operandi between science and politics! And this demands effort from both sides! Politics, on one side, must not take the easy way out, the path of least common denominator, of least resistance. Politics should drive – and not be driven, as sometimes seems to be the case with climate change. Politics must have the courage to take the big step. Politics can utilize the spaces that are currently being opened up by civil society.

And especially with such a highly complex issue as climate change, it holds true: politics needs expertise and evidence. Politics should more frequently seek the path into seminar rooms and laboratories. Politics must continually challenge itself to seek the advice of experts, it must rely on scientific expertise – and defend this expertise against the notorious simplifiers, mood-makers, and populists.

But my appeal also goes the other way. Science, especially because it enjoys special freedoms and privileges, bears a special responsibility for the success of democracy. This means, first and foremost, that it must remain honest and transparent to itself and to the public in Weber’s distinction between factual and value judgments. And it further means: when science makes normative judgments, when it recognizes necessary changes, it must be willing and able to engage with politics and society to explain, advocate, and mediate. It must be ready to be part of the democratic debate, and not set its own singular insight so absolutely that the plurality and complexity of democracy ultimately appear not as a path to solutions, but as an obstacle. This cannot ultimately be in the interest of a science that sees democracy as a constituent of its freedom.

In short, our path must not be: science against politics – and certainly not against democratic politics.

We are certainly dealing with the proverbial Gordian knot when it comes to climate change. And no actor – and no legislative package – can cut through it alone outside of the realm of Greek mythology. However, if we start, in frustration over this state, to pull at the knot individually and against each other, it will only tighten further. My wish is this: let us stay together, and let us continue to demand from democracy no more, but also no less than what it is: the space for solving the knot together!

Everything else is apocalypse. And – I don’t know how you see it – apocalypse paralyzes. It does not encourage. It instills fear where we need courage for change. It makes doubt appear larger and every engagement seem futile.

That is my plea to science: stay persistent! Explain what needs to be explained – if necessary, more than once! Show the perspective! Encourage! Illuminate our democracy! And the very big request: get involved!

Thank you very much.