Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the discussion event of the Konrad Adenauer Foundation "Strengthening What Connects Us: Mandatory Service for Our Society" on the 3rd ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

3 December 2024 · Discussion event of the Konrad Adenauer Foundation "Strengthening What Connects Us: Mandatory Service for Our Society" · Konrad Adenauer Foundation

Context
Steinmeier addressed a Konrad Adenauer Foundation event on December 3, 2024, discussing proposals for mandatory community service to strengthen social cohesion in Germany.
Main themes
Mandatory community service, social cohesion, democracy, youth engagement, volunteering and civic commitment, societal division, freedom vs. obligation, crises and uncertainty, democratic debate culture, aging volunteer base
Duration
~15 min
51st percentile
Words
1,747
51st percentile
Sentences
97
61st percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.91
36th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 69%68%
  • Institutional 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

97 sentences in 14 paragraphs

There are often reasons to complain about the climate of debate in our country. If I remember correctly, my last appearance at the Konrad Adenauer Foundation was precisely about how the boundaries of what can be said are gradually shifting into the unspeakable. The discussion about a mandatory service is different. Since the first proposals and ideas were developed, a lively, broad, and also controversial debate has emerged – and this has been going on for several years now. And as you surely know, I am not just a presidential observer of this debate, but an active participant with proposals that have received both support and rejection. Nevertheless, we have seen in this debate how fruitful it can be when not only controversial positions are presented, but when arguments are actually exchanged and weighed, and other opinions are listened to with genuine interest. I have been very impressed by the openness, seriousness, and depth of the discussions so far. And I am convinced that we – regardless of today’s topic – need more such debates in our democracy, because it thrives on debate. And we must conduct these with dignity and fairness.

The discussion about a mandatory service clearly shows – despite all the differences in positions – one thing: how many people consider it important to strengthen cohesion in our society, and how great the need for cohesion is. And I believe we feel every day: This need is likely to grow even greater in a time of crises and uncertainty. We are all experiencing how our democracy is currently being put to the test. We are all witnessing how crises and upheavals put pressure on society, leading to insecurity and friction. COVID-19, Russia's war of aggression against Ukraine, climate change, terrorism and war in the Middle East, but also inflation and economic crisis – all of this leads to burdens and worries many people in our country. And this crisis mode affects our daily lives and our coexistence. Social groups are drifting apart and sometimes face each other with increasing intransigence. The tone in social debates is becoming sharper. It is all the more important that we think about what we can do in such times, better yet: what we must do, so that our society does not drift further apart. I consider this crucial for the future of our democracy!

When one presents a proposal to the public, it is often the case that the longer the discussion goes on, the more reservations grow, the greater the criticism becomes. The debate about a mandatory service, in my impression, is developing in the opposite direction. Nearly three-quarters – 73 percent – of Germans currently support a mandatory community service according to a recent Ipsos survey. Yes, of course, there are also fundamental concerns about such a model. Someone told me that it is nothing more than a theft of life time. Others argue that only voluntariness is inherently a characteristic of true commitment. Still others question whether it is proportionate to intervene in an individual's freedom for a mandatory service. And it is primarily younger people who have strong doubts and reject such an intervention in freedom.

And that is why I consider it crucial whether we can succeed in winning the majority of young people in our country over to this idea. Because it is about how we will strengthen cohesion in the future – and it is their future. All the more I am pleased that so many young people are here today. It is wonderful that you are all participating in the discussion and reporting from the "ChancenZeit" project – a participatory format with exemplary character, which is ideally suited to discuss such a complex topic as mandatory service as broadly as possible. My heartfelt thanks to all who support this initiative, and thank you for the invitation today. I am very happy to be here!

We have been seeing for some time how voluntary engagement, especially how traditional volunteer work, is changing in our country. Yes, millions of people still dedicate themselves to others day after day. They listen, support, encourage, and lend a hand. They help where help is needed. They often do this alongside their jobs and studies. And they do it even though there is much to do in their own lives and they have their own worries. I am continually impressed by this voluntary commitment, without which our community would be unimaginable. Volunteering is and remains the backbone of our society. But in the dense network of voluntary engagement that spans the country, the gaps are widening, as our society is aging. And with it, volunteering is aging. The consequence: volunteer positions are being distributed among fewer and fewer shoulders. Some are consequently overwhelmed by the growing burden. This leads to positions in clubs and associations remaining unfilled, the number of active members decreasing because no successors can be found. The structures that promise duration and reliability are therefore often no longer secure. This is the case even though many young people are also engaged. But a large part of them prefers to engage in project-based or sporadic activities rather than in long-term organizations, the traditional clubs and associations.

Yes, there are still hundreds of thousands who are getting involved in voluntary services. That is great! But this engagement does not yet permeate our society as a whole. Studies show that the vast majority of young people who have so far committed to a voluntary service have completed their Abitur, while young people with other school qualifications are significantly underrepresented. In other words: The opportunity for a voluntary year – such as a Voluntary Social Year or Voluntary Ecological Year – does not reach all young people by any means. Cross-societal effects, as studies have shown, are still too little visible. There are reasons for this. It may also be that many simply cannot afford such a service to society over several months. It is therefore important that we build structures that truly enable everyone to get involved here. We really need everyone to hold our society together!

Because when social bonds become increasingly loose, when many only stay among themselves – in the neighborhood, at work, in school – and when retreating into one’s own “bubble” prevents one from perceiving perhaps different perspectives of others, then empathy and understanding for those who think and live differently are at risk of being lost.

But the core question is, of course: If that is the case, should we then already think about introducing a mandatory service? Some believe that any obligation is fundamentally incompatible with a notion of freedom that underlies liberal democracies. This is historically incorrect, says Francis Fukuyama. He points out that classical liberalism, which defends individual freedom, simultaneously demands responsibility and obligations to secure the foundations of a stable, just, and free community. This balance, Fukuyama assesses, is repeatedly undermined by excessive individualism. He writes literally in his latest book "Liberalism and Its Enemies": "While the individual has always resisted the structures imposed on him by 'society,' he simultaneously longs for connection with a community and social solidarity and feels lonely and alienated in his individualism."

What this quote emphatically underscores is: Our liberal democracy thrives on individual freedom, yes. But for this freedom to be livable for all, it also needs social bonds. It needs people who take responsibility for one another because they recognize the humanity of the other and are willing to stand up for it. Or to put it more succinctly: The "I" in democracy always also needs a "we." In other words: In modern society, shaped by individual claims, it is simultaneously important to strengthen everything that connects us. We must ensure that we promote exchange between the different groups so that encounters can also lead to a sense of connection. Because only from connection does shared responsibility arise.

And a social mandatory service can make a very important contribution to this. It leads us – at least once in our lives – to dedicate a period of time to other people with whom we otherwise have little to do in our daily lives. It would encourage us to look beyond our own plate, to think beyond our own benefit, and to turn to other life worlds, other worries and hopes. And let us not forget one thing: Those who engage – there is plenty of evidence for this – receive a lot in return. They gain new experiences that can be formative, find orientation, new perspectives, and sometimes even friendships for life.

Above all, however, with a mandatory service, we could practice a sense of community as a society. We could understand through action that our own interest, our own well-being cannot be the only measure when we want to solve problems together. We could strengthen a culture of new normality that makes it clear: Helping and shaping together should be the norm for everyone. This is the core of the idea to strengthen our cohesion – especially in a time like the present, in which we have to cope with crises and upheavals.

Let us face this challenge with ambition and confidence. That is what I wish for. Yes, we are dealing with different tasks and threats than we have for many decades. But I am convinced: We can master these challenges as a society if we practically strengthen our resilience. We need commitment and effort for one another, whether in disaster relief or emergency services, in the armed forces, but also in homeless assistance or elsewhere in the service of people for people.

I wish for a society in which it is completely natural to be there for others. There may be different paths to that. One possible way leads through a mandatory period that creates encounters between different people. Those who take on responsibility for others or for the community gain experiences that shape them. They learn that together we can make a difference. They feel a sense of self-efficacy and simultaneously strengthen what connects us.

It is also clear, however: A decision for a social mandatory service requires a broad societal and political majority. Let us therefore continue the debate about it with seriousness and fairness. It should – this is my plea and my hope – not once again fizzle out, but end with a decision that strengthens our democracy. And rarely has our democracy needed strengthening more urgently than it does right now.