Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the discussion event of the ZEIT Foundation "What Holds Society Together: Civic Engagement and Foundations for a Strong ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

23 January 2018 · Discussion event of the ZEIT Foundation "What Holds Society Together: Civic Engagement and Foundations for a Strong Community" · Hamburg, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ZEIT Foundation discussion event in Hamburg on January 23, 2018, exploring civic engagement and what holds German society together.
Main themes
Social cohesion, civic engagement, foundations and philanthropy, political turbulence in Germany, nostalgia and social change, identity and homeland, immigration and diversity, fragmentation of society, democratic values, community and belonging
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,820
52nd percentile
Sentences
87
56th percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
12.6
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 63%63%
  • Ceremonial 23%23%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

87 sentences in 20 paragraphs

When we prepared the inaugural visit in Hamburg and today's agenda item with the ZEIT Foundation, we all had no idea what domestic political turbulence our country would experience in these weeks. At the Senate breakfast just now, we discussed the situation in Berlin as intensely as we did about the Hanseatic city. Therefore, allow me to adjust my speech somewhat differently than I would have done six months ago.

"What holds society together" is the title of this event, "Civic Engagement and Foundations for a Strong Community" right behind it – very rightly so, in my opinion. My predecessors have just mentioned impressive evidence from the foundation capital of Hamburg, and surely no one here in the hall would want to deny the significant role of foundations in fostering cohesion. We could easily fill our time on the podium solely with best-practice examples, as there are countless: in education, in social issues, in culture and media. The tribute to The New York Times for the Marion Dönhoff Prize recently brought me to Hamburg. Of course, foundations also have an impact in science, as I was reminded just last week during my meeting with the Stifterverband für die Deutsche Wissenschaft. Most of you – dear guests – know all this as funders, idea generators, doers, and allies from your own experience. I look forward to exchanging these encouraging success stories shortly on the podium and with you here in the hall.

However, I believe that in a political and social situation like the current one, it is worthwhile to step out of the project level of the foundation world and illuminate the concept of cohesion as such. It is currently used so often and by such different senders that its core is hardly recognizable. In the wave of debates about homeland, identity, and immigration society, appeals for cohesion can be found across the entire political spectrum. What remains unspoken, however, varies greatly: Cohesion from whom? Cohesion for what? Often also: Cohesion against what?

Cohesion – this precious word can be bent as a demand in almost any direction. And those who travel through the country, who leave political Berlin, hear very different motives that justify the desire for more cohesion. In East Germany, for example, many older generations compare the present with their memories of the time before 1989, when cohesion, as they say, was "a completely different" thing. For some, there is a hint of regret or even a bit of Ostalgia, while others recount how cohesion was created back then: through forced collectivizations of all kinds, in schools, in workshops, even extending into private life, when it was necessary in a scarcity economy to get along well with the neighbor in case one urgently needed to borrow a drill or wanted to exchange a basket of strawberries from the allotment garden for fabric for trousers.

In West Germany, the call for more cohesion is often associated with a "previously" as a benchmark. The generation of Professor Manfred Lahnstein still remembers well how the plant manager greeted the doorman by name in the morning and knew, or wanted to know, whether his wife was raising two or three children at home. Today, the working world is quite different. In medium-sized companies, there is still manageability and familiarity, but often a private security service fulfills the former duties of the doorman. A job no longer lasts a whole working biography; employees are encouraged to be mobile and flexible. And who has how many children or raises them together is no longer so clear-cut and does not have to be.

We should beware of nostalgia, that is my advice. Our society has made great progress. We should not wish back the social closeness of prescribed life decisions. The internationalization of relationships of all kinds, not just political ones, broadens perspectives and opens horizons. Speaking more than one language is beneficial. And we, as democrats, rightly categorically reject a commanded cohesion. But we must also recognize: From the once very limited number of generally accepted life models, an almost unmanageable abundance has grown over the decades. The reliable planability of one’s own life has given way for a large part of the population to the constant changeability of life circumstances: at the workplace, which remains of paramount importance for social integration, but also in cultural interactions, in social and family ties – undoubtedly a gain in possibilities for millions of biographies, but at the same time an unavoidable loss of certainty, of bindingness.

Thus, the joy is not entirely unclouded. For with diversity came a progressive fragmentation of our society, to social niches that some hardly leave. What places or events still convey cohesion today? Where do people meet across social and political boundaries and actually experience themselves as a large community? One may hardly say it in Hamburg these days, but football is often mentioned – setting aside trends like commercialization. It is particularly unifying when our national team reaches the final of a European or World Championship. However, there are few other examples of this magnitude.

Even classic learning places for cohesion across class boundaries have lost their binding power: schoolyards, for example, since private schools have boomed. Or the Bundeswehr, since compulsory military service was suspended. Neighborhoods and districts, whether through under- or over-privileging. Even media meeting points, which were long a fixed appointment for millions of households, like the evening news, are now considered just one option among many. A large part of the youth no longer watches traditional television but gets news online, sometimes here, sometimes there. This development is not fundamentally to be criticized, but I need not explain in this circle that the internet has not only created delightful spaces but also less delightful echo chambers.

There are thus objective findings for the loss of cohesion, most of which are fed by long-term developments – some desired and sought, others merely endured.

At the same time, there is a current debate that closely links the topic of cohesion with the events since September 2015, with the management of the refugee crisis. I want to warn against this shift in discourse. It is true, of course: The polarization in our country has since experienced a new, concerning dynamic. But the key questions regarding cohesion cannot be answered by narrowing the focus to issues like family reunification. We need a much broader debate. We need a new societal understanding of what order, what vision of the future we want to live together. By "we," I do not only mean locals and newcomers; I also mean old and young, rural and urban dwellers, conservative and progressive contemporaries, those with higher education and those without – numerous parts of our society that each operate in their niches and too rarely engage in conversation with one another.

Only where there is communication, are there also compromises. In the formation of government, we are currently feeling how laborious this principle can be. But it is one of the most important principles we have in our liberal democracy. And the only principle that truly allows pluralism to be lived.

Perhaps it can help us to renew our understanding of cohesion and not to see it as something static, but quite the opposite: Cohesion thrives where opinion and counter-opinion lead to dialogue, to new perspectives, new solutions. Cohesion means: enduring contradictions. Cohesion does not necessarily have to function harmoniously, not always in consensus: The more heterogeneous a society, the more it needs constructive friction. But it also requires the willingness and ability to define and accept common rules for engagement. Understood this way, cohesion is not something one can passively wish for, but an active learning process that must be jointly supported by many.

We are currently witnessing such a learning process. The parties have long known that they themselves are affected by fragmentation and have been finding it increasingly difficult to maintain a core voter base – the interests are too differentiated, the political inclinations too volatile. The parties are fundamentally in the same situation as churches, trade unions, and other large societal institutions. But for the first time, it has now become clear that this development can paralyze us if substantive disputes are not conducted in a timely and intense manner or if the willingness to compromise is lost.

I know many foundation representatives are closely following political Berlin and drawing conclusions for their own agendas. However, the reverse path is particularly valuable right now: Take your wealth of experience from countless projects and advise politics on what could work on a broader scale – and what could not.

Gerd Bucerius, highly esteemed along with his wife Ebelin as the namesake of the ZEIT Foundation, once said: "The power to decide great things comes from the uninterrupted observation of small things." How true. And who could report more vividly from vital small encounters than you, dear engaged individuals?

Professor Göring already mentioned how quickly the Hamburg foundations came together in 2015 to support refugee assistance. Politics and administration have relied on this, as civil society with millions of volunteers is doing outstanding work nationwide: What a tremendous effort from the clothing donation center to the mentoring program! When I meet such engaged individuals, I ask myself: Has this commitment been sufficiently recognized? Opinions on this vary, which is why I will, as often as I can, incorporate conversations of this kind into my calendar, shake hands, and say thank you.

My thanks also go to societal engagement in general and today – pars pro toto – to the ZEIT Foundation, especially for its focus on education, the key to the future of the coming generations! I sincerely thank all of you here in the hall, who – each in your own way – preserve, strengthen, or regain cohesion in Germany.

I would like to add a request. Let us address not only the examples of success on the podium but also the problems and ask where there is still work to be done: How can we ensure that foundations, which so often help in times of need, do not themselves become the stopgap for the state, the gap filler? How do we continually bring state welfare and civic initiatives into the right relationship? Or: How do we win young people for volunteer work? Here at the Bucerius Law School, there are very good experiences with this, as I have read. Last but not least: How do we create contemporary framework conditions, for example, for relatively new models like the community foundation?

Dear Professor Lahnstein, perhaps you would like to include a question in your summary later that is currently – in my opinion – one of the most important questions for our country: How do we foster enough common good for the future amidst all the diversity?

I am very much looking forward to discussing this with all of you now.