Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the discussion event "Together Against Hate and Violence – Do Not Leave Local Politicians Alone!" on March 10, 2020, in Zwickau:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

10 March 2020 · Discussion event "Together Against Hate and Violence – Do Not Leave Local Politicians Alone!" · Zwickau, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a discussion event in Zwickau on March 10, 2020, calling for collective action against hate and violence targeting local politicians.
Main themes
Hate and political violence, protection of local politicians, right-wing extremism, democratic participation, civic responsibility, threats against elected officials, silent majority, community resilience, extremist networks, public safety
Duration
~15 min
53rd percentile
Words
1,841
53rd percentile
Sentences
97
61st percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
10.6
28th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 56%56%
  • Institutional 32%32%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

97 sentences in 24 paragraphs

My first thanks today go to the city of Zwickau. When you, dear Mayor, visited us in Berlin in 2018 and we talked about the situation of threatened officials and elected representatives in municipalities, we did not want to stop at the distressing analysis. We wanted to stay in touch and find support. Just two years ago, with less public sensitivity, this was no easy undertaking.

A year later, the Regierungspräsident of Kassel, Walter Lübcke, was murdered, and the horror was followed by intense, important debates – again with us in Bellevue, with a whole series of mayors and municipal councilors who had experienced hate and threats firsthand. Many journalists could hardly believe what kinds of hostility were already commonplace across the country. The discussions about this should not fade away, which is why we agreed back then to continue here in the town hall.

Within just a few months, further attacks followed, more victims: two dead in Halle and only a wooden door that could prevent a bloodbath in a fully occupied synagogue; ten dead in Hanau and so many wounded – in body and soul – for whom nothing is the same as before after this racist act of terror; ninety injured in an incident in Volkmarsen, the background of which we do not yet know precisely.

There is no doubt anymore: Germany has a massive problem with hate and violence. It does not show up comprehensively in crime statistics, but it reveals itself through incidents that must truly alarm us. This includes right-wing extremist conspiracies, as uncovered here in Saxony with "Revolution Chemnitz." This includes networks that, as seen in the recent raid, extend across several federal states or had their roots abroad. But it also includes, and that is why we are here today, hate and violence right at our own doorstep, in your own citizen's office hours.

The spectrum is unimaginably wide. It ranges from slurs via email to what clearly belongs in the hands of the domestic intelligence service. The attacks are sometimes ideological, sometimes simply driven by raging anger. And they affect representatives of all parties, people with and without a migration background, people with and without religious beliefs, people in the east as well as in the west of our country. As different as the phenomena are individually, they thrive in the same dangerous climate that has reached town halls and parliaments just as much as schoolyards and internet forums. A climate of outrage and unrestrainedness, a climate of degradation and hate, a climate that we can no longer tolerate.

At all these places, in all these moments, we now need our collective, clear no. No one should be able to say anymore: This does not concern me. And no one should remain silent anymore. I believe that the so-called silent majority has been quiet for too long, even though we know: It exists, this majority of people in our country who want to live together peacefully and clearly condemn violence. But exactly this majority must become louder.

I am very grateful that so many have come today, from eighth graders to those over eighty. Our message is: We will not remain silent. We stand together against hate.

Let me start where you, dear local politicians, do your work – in Reinsdorf or Sindelfingen, in all the places from which you have traveled here today. There, you ensure that fiber optic cables are laid or integration councils are heard. You congratulate the medium-sized business on its anniversary or the youth team on their championship. You are almost everywhere, especially where you are needed. And what makes your work so valuable and indispensable – the closeness to citizens – is precisely what also makes you vulnerable.

In most cases, you have no personal protection and no armored vehicles. The volunteers among you also do not have their own specialized department that could advise them. And when push comes to shove, you stand completely alone on the sidewalk. What those affected tell me ranges from egg-throwing to feces in mailboxes to cases like the one where a gallows was already set up in the front yard of a mayor. Many perpetrators remain anonymous or express themselves from a distance. Others shout out loud what or whom they want to get rid of.

Of course, there have been incidents in the past, disputes with the mayor at the regulars' table, that is nothing new, occasionally even brawls in the beer tent. However, recently the assaults have reached a scale and frequency that allow me only one conclusion: We must not allow local politicians in our country to become doormats for the frustrated. We need all the people who are willing to take on and bear responsibility locally. They are the foundation on which the building of democracy rests. Therefore: We must defend civility, regain decency and reason.

This will not happen overnight; who knows that better than you. There is the Reichsbürger who boasts about his weapons in the open street. But there are also the previously inconspicuous neighbors, the homeowner who explodes at the office over his property costs, or the tenant who suddenly pulls out a knife at the job center. Too many who never engage themselves but complain about those who do engage for the city or the region.

When I talk about threats in local politics, I also think of the employees in the administrations who attend self-defense courses, who have to attend them, or who give up due to exhaustion. Not everyone is so severely affected, but you all experience in your daily lives that the line between what can be said and what is unspeakable is shifting further and further. And the boundary of the resulting actions for some apparently as well.

Only a small part of this entire panorama is included in police statistics, is prosecuted under criminal or civil law. Because no report is even filed. Because there are no witnesses. Or because no legal offense applies.

Many forms of threat actually lie below the threshold of prosecutability. Yet they lie above the threshold of what people can endure without eventually becoming worn down. With sentences like "I know where your daughter goes to school," even for those who have endured for a long time, a limit is reached. Some cases of resignations have now become known.

However, the number of those who do not stand for re-election without giving reasons when a local office is to be filled is suspected to be significantly higher. Some do it quietly and secretly to avoid going down in local history as a failure or as a troublemaker. Others are afraid of worsening their situation with media attention.

The question of how to make the threats against local politicians public has also occupied me for a long time. I am very grateful to the German Association of Cities, the German Association of Counties, and the German Association of Towns and Municipalities for considering together what the right way might be. On the one hand, one does not want to give the perpetrators a stage for their craving for attention and thus encourage opportunists. On the other hand – and this is my deep conviction – problems must be named, also publicly named, in order to solve them. The challenge we face here can only be met with a broad alliance, with public support, which is why the word "together" is on the invitation card.

It gives me confidence when I look back on the past two years that something has indeed begun to move. In my political life, I have experienced numerous trends in topics, but I am truly grateful for the recent development: The media have been reporting more frequently since last summer. The Bundestag is currently discussing a draft of a "Law to Combat Right-Wing Extremism and Hate Crime," which includes an amendment to Section 188 of the Criminal Code; local politicians would thus be explicitly protected as "persons of political life." The federal government also wants to take a tougher stance against digital hate, and the Federal Criminal Police Office is establishing a central reporting office for hate postings. In more and more states, specialized public prosecutors or other points of contact are being established, as we will hear later on the panel.

Democracy must be able to defend itself against its enemies, and it must also show this defensibility.

It will take time for the measures to take effect in practice. Perhaps we will discuss next year where further action is needed. However, what is crucial is: There is a broad political consensus that the necessary finances and structures will be provided to effectively counter hate and violence. And I am sure we will need even more instruments over time to uncover the strategically designed manipulations on the internet and to expose those who operate their democracy-destroying work under the cover of anonymity, with fake accounts or on closed communication platforms.

Our panel today should also reflect this process of dealing with digital hate; that is why it was important to me not only to give a voice to the problems but also to the solutions. Exemplarily – I would like to say, as a model – we have invited a representative from law enforcement, academia, and civil society. We have scheduled time to allow many more from the audience to speak, whether with their own experiences or suggestions.

I hope that we will talk extensively about prevention alongside law enforcement. Political education plays a significant role, even though it is often downplayed or underestimated. We have also dealt intensively with this in recent years and tried to support political educators.

Numerous initiatives from civil society are working against the dangerous trends I have just described. When you talk to the activists, you quickly realize that the problems of local politicians overlap with the experiences of many other engaged individuals, both paid and voluntary. Firefighters and police, for example, have joined forces for a campaign titled: "Respect? Yes, please!" We need more such impulses across the entire breadth of society to achieve what I described at the beginning: the reclamation of civility.

This learning process also means, of course, coming to terms with our own mistakes. Memory, where we must not forget. Dear Mr. Killat, you are an honorary citizen of Zwickau, born here in 1933, and you initiated the memorial site for the victims of the terrorist group "National Socialist Underground": ten trees in a peaceful, spacious park. At first glance, one does not recognize that it is a memorial site. Those who want to understand must look closely. How fitting for the history of the NSU. And how fitting as a call for the present. I will also take time for this today.

I admit, we have not taken on easy topics. But I wish for us to use these hours and for each of you to go home with the certainty: I am not alone. We are many – together against hate and violence!