Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the eighth forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" on November 25, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

4 December 2019 · Eighth forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" · Bellevue Castle, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the eighth Bellevue Forum on the Future of Democracy in Berlin on November 25, 2019, discussing democracy, progress, and public pessimism.
Main themes
Future of democracy, trust in political institutions, fear of the future, progress and optimism, climate change and globalization, democratic resilience, public discourse and doom-mongering, liberal democracy vs. autocracy, German reunification legacy, civic engagement
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,199
61st percentile
Sentences
125
73rd percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.91
36th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
30th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 41%40%
  • Institutional 26%26%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Not in focus 2%

125 sentences in 33 paragraphs

"What Future? On Democracy and Progress"

What could be more fitting than to talk about the future in the foggy month of November in a castle named "Beautiful View"? We have wonderful guests here this morning, and I am pleased that you have all come to listen to us and to discuss with us. A warm welcome to the eighth Bellevue Forum on the Future of Democracy!

Beautiful views – that is not necessarily what people say today when they think about the future. The future of the climate, the future of work, the future of housing and mobility, of cities and villages, the future of democracy, the European Union, and the world order – all of this occupies us today and drives us.

There is often little sense of self-confidence, courage, and optimism in this regard. On the contrary, many people look ahead with great concern. Climate change, digital revolution, and globalization, tensions and conflicts on many continents – all of this contributes to insecurity. "My children should, my children will have it better than I did" – that was the driving force for generations before us. Today, instead, one often hears a resigned "It can only get worse."

"It can only get worse" – this expresses the fear that hard-won achievements will be lost. The prosperity that one has worked for in the family; the realization of one's own dreams; the feeling of security; decency and civility in social interactions, political achievements such as the rule of law and liberal democracy. And the longer this worry persists, the longer this uncertainty does not disappear, the more trust in the ability of politics and society to solve pressing problems and actually bring about improvement seems to fade.

And it is precisely here that fear of the future becomes a problem for democracy. Last week, we were startled by a poll that concluded that we are currently experiencing an erosion of trust in Germany – it was described as a landslide decline in trust. Apparently, fewer and fewer people consider our political system to be a particular strength of our country. Not even half of those surveyed believe that the state is capable of acting. In other words: everything is getting worse, but no one can do anything about it.

I consider these findings to be extraordinarily dangerous. Democracy is the form of government for the brave, not for those who have resigned. Those who feel powerless cannot participate, cannot engage, cannot change, and may not even want to. Because those who do not expect anything good from the future will not even try to engage for the better.

Yet we Germans have often experienced firsthand how open the future is; how much it depends on us, how great the possibilities for change are. Thirty years ago, a German citizens' movement brought down a dictatorship and reunited our country. And today we live in a strong democracy, the rule of law functions, we are still celebrating employment records, and the social security systems in Germany are among the most robust in the world. And even worldwide, despite all the crises and catastrophes, humanity is better off. Our guest Steven Pinker will soon report on this, making it clear. He says: No, it cannot always get worse. It can get better, much better even!

Sometimes it drives me up the wall how we downplay or completely overlook progress and success, opportunities and potentials. Allowing them to be overshadowed by the many negative news that alarm us anew every day and demand our full attention. The way we talk about ourselves publicly, our guest Maren Urner will have much to say about this, distorts our image of reality. It fosters powerlessness when the future is painted only in dark colors, when crises and catastrophes are the only dominating themes. And politicians also bear their share when they glorify a golden past to avoid having to provide answers to the complicated present. Or when they even play with doomsday scenarios to stir up fears and ignite anger from which political capital can be made.

Do not get me wrong. Democracy needs skepticism, doubt, and criticism. It needs ruthless debate about grievances. This is where the energy we need to move forward originates. But it is the daily apocalypse that paralyzes us because the challenges are described as too great and our possibilities as always too small. Constant alarm and doom-mongering weaken democracy. And that is all the more dangerous in a time when democracy needs all its strength.

Yes, we need a strong democracy, especially when the challenges are great. We should beware of downplaying the possibilities of liberal democracy – as many in the so-called West are currently doing – secretly glancing at the autocrats who can decide and implement things so quickly and efficiently. At whose expense, one wonders. There would actually be daily evidence for that. Democratic politics is complicated, never finished, like a steadfast, patient untangling of knots. The idea that someone will come along and cut through all the knots at once with a strong blow is an eternal delusion, but at the same time the hollow promise of those who want something other than democracy. We should not forget: Only democracy gives us the opportunity for self-correction, for a new start when paths have proven to be wrong or when we have not pursued paths with enough determination. And only an open society offers us the space to convince a majority in time that swift action and fundamental changes are necessary.

That is exactly what we are experiencing once again. Social engagement, even unconventional and loud, can not only open eyes but also create new opportunities for political action. We owe it primarily to the committed young people of Fridays for Future that we see the climate crisis today with sharper eyes. It has been and continues to be the dramatic appeals of the climate protection movement that prompt a rethink and help initiate necessary steps, but also – and this concerns all of us, not just politics – to distance ourselves from some comfortable habits. Fridays for Future are strong, they are impactful, and I am glad about that.

But at the same time, we should remember: That society drives politics is not entirely new in the history of democracy. Let us think of the introduction of women's suffrage, the opening of educational pathways, the anti-nuclear movement, the peace marches in the eighties, the elimination of discrimination against homosexuals, and much, much more.

If we look back at the history of our republic, there have always been situations in which politics has been prompted to rethink and change by society.

Because the future is open, we must talk about how this future should look, and where necessary, also argue about it. Because the future is open, we must not gamble it away – not for ourselves, not for our children and grandchildren. Making decisions today that will allow us to live together peacefully, sustainably, and adequately tomorrow: This responsibility lies with all of us – primarily politics, but all of us together.

Therefore, the horizon of politics must not be too short – until the next election or until the next summit meeting. And therefore, we need a multi-voiced conversation about the future, far beyond politics: in parliaments, also online, on the streets, at universities, in companies, in community centers, in coffee shops. And by that, I do not mean casual chatter. No, parliamentary democracy must also evolve. It may need new and more binding forms of participation to include those who have turned away from it.

I could say: "We must do a lot – but we can also do a lot," that at least is my fundamental feeling for democratic politics. Not that it can get worse, but that we can make it better, that is where we should focus our strength. And how that can succeed, I would like to discuss with you today.

What are the prerequisites for us as a society to become more future-ready again? How can we regain the necessary trust? I am pleased that today we have three guests with us who look at democracy and progress from very different perspectives.

Steven Pinker is an experimental psychologist, cognitive scientist, and linguist. He was born in Canada, lives in the USA, and teaches at Harvard, and most people know it: his books are bestsellers. Time once referred to him as a global star intellectual. But he is here not because he is a star, but because I read his latest book "Enlightenment Now" with great fascination.

The book is, completely against the trend, a defense of reason, science, humanism, and progress, a combative but also humorous plea against the prophets of doom and the enemies of the open society.

Pinker’s provocative message is: "The world has never been better than it is today." He wants – and I believe he can – to demonstrate with a wealth of data and facts that the living conditions of people have improved throughout history. And he sees this progress as a direct result of enlightenment, democracy, free trade, and international cooperation.

Steven Pinker describes himself as a passionate possibilist. He trusts in human possibilities; that we can promote our well-being with reason and compassion.

I want to talk to him about whether we can also tackle the climate crisis and other issues in this way. And I want to know, of course, why he believes in the future of liberal democracy and whether a look back at the achievements since the Enlightenment can help citizens regain confidence in liberal democracy and its institutions and representatives. I am very pleased that he is here today. Welcome, Steven Pinker!

My second guest this morning comes from my homeland, from East Westphalia. Maren Urner was born in Herford, she is a neuroscientist and professor of media psychology at the University of Media, Communication and Business in Cologne.

She deals with the question of how media influence our view of the world, our thinking, and our actions. And she says: The flood of bad news that we are constantly exposed to in the age of digital communication has fatal consequences, for the individual, but also for society as a whole.

Maren Urner therefore demands: "Enough with the daily apocalypse!" She advocates for constructive journalism that does not simply describe crises and problems but shows ways in which things could continue and improve. The online magazine she co-founded is accordingly called "Perspective Daily."

Is there a rethink in the media industry? And is it really only the media that make many people feel overwhelmed and exhausted today? We want to discuss that as well. Wonderful to have you here. A warm welcome, Maren Urner!

Last but not least, my third guest. You all know him, of course. He has been present in the German book market for almost 50 years. Ian McEwan is a British writer. His novels have been awarded worldwide. He writes not only about love and love's pain but also addresses current issues of the time in each of these novels – the big questions of our time.

Now, in these days, his latest work "The Cockroach" is being published in German. If you take it in your hands, you will – I even suspect: intentionally – experience some similarities with the current British Prime Minister. The book is an enjoyable, and in parts also horrifying, examination of the Brexit debate in the UK.

The novel before that, "Machines Like Me," is a novel about the establishment of artificial intelligence, about the difficulties that people have and could have with it. In this novel, a trick becomes clear that Ian McEwan often employs: alternative historiography. The novel is set in 1982, but John F. Kennedy is alive, John Lennon is alive, England has just lost the Falklands War. Ian McEwan shows us with his form of alternative historiography what an unlikely, infinitely fragile construct the present is, how easily everything could be completely different.

At the center of the story is the robot Adam, an attractive, intelligent, and very moral android, whose machine ethics repeatedly come into conflict with the much more flexible human morality. What happens when we create machines that are smarter than we are, and also stricter in moral terms? That is the question that Ian McEwan grapples with in this novel.

I would like to know from him whether literature can strengthen our trust in the future. And whether he personally has hope that the global trends of populism and nationalism are reversible, whether enlightenment and reason will become attractive again. Mr. McEwan, I’m glad you are here. Welcome to Berlin!

Alan Turing, one of the pioneers of artificial intelligence, once said: "We can only see a short distance ahead, but we can see plenty there that needs to be done." I believe that the more we look ahead, the better we recognize what needs to be done. So let us focus on the future today, on this November day here at Schloss Bellevue. I look forward to our conversation. A warm welcome once again to all of you.