Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the eleventh forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" on March 1, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

1 March 2021 · Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy · Bellevue Palace, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the eleventh Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy in Berlin on March 1, 2021, discussing democracy's challenges in the digital age.
Main themes
Democracy and digital public sphere, social media algorithms and disinformation, transatlantic cooperation, US Capitol attack and election lies, regulation of digital platforms, freedom and responsibility online, conspiracy theories and radicalization, German and European elections, attention economy, Enlightenment democratic ideals
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,299
64th percentile
Sentences
116
70th percentile
Readability
40
37th percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 33%32%
  • Technological 26%25%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Geopolitical 11%10%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

116 sentences in 33 paragraphs

"Democracy and Digital Public Sphere – A Transatlantic Challenge"

In November, a superspreader event took place that the whole world has been talking about ever since. In no time at all, hundreds of thousands were infected. But not with a dangerous virus, rather with a conspiracy myth.

It was the malicious tale of a stolen election that spread like wildfire across social media. This lie unleashed the attack of an armed mob on the American Capitol, one of the oldest and most venerable parliaments in the world.

I welcome you to this Forum Bellevue, almost entirely digital for well-known reasons, hence also to the screens in Europe and the USA. Today, we want to talk not about the pandemic, but about democracy, about democracy and its public spaces in the digital age. There is certainly enough reason to do so.

The digitally fueled attacks against democracy surrounding the US elections are one thing; the digitally connected demonstrations for democracy in Russia and Belarus are another. And right in the middle, here in Germany, we have seven parliamentary elections coming up this year at the federal and state levels, the first two in just two weeks. For years, we have felt it all over the world: When it comes to the matter of democracy, the digital revolution is both a curse and a blessing, an opportunity and a danger.

Digital, universally accessible media initially appear as a truly democratic promise, a public space without borders and barriers, where everyone can receive from all and send to all. But especially now, after the television images from Washington, some illusions, including hopes, have vanished. The sober truth is: New freedom requires new responsibility, so that the digital public space does not end in chaos and self-destruction.

The democracies of the world must secure their constitutionality in the digital realm as well, against enemies from within and without. We are particularly concerned about social media platforms. It seems that social media amplify both the best and the worst in our societies. For democracy, they are neither a panacea nor a wrecking ball. But digital media have now become an integral part, indeed more than that: co-architects and pace-setters of our democratic public space, and therefore it is high time that we take a closer look at them and their societal consequences.

Since the change of administration in the United States, the problem has been high on the agenda on both sides of the Atlantic. The European Union, dear Ms. Vestager, is working on a comprehensive regulation of the digital public space, a Common Rule Book for the digital economy, and you personally recently offered a joint approach to the USA. President Biden is planning a summit for democracy and has placed the future of democracy at the center of his message in his speech at the Munich Security Conference: "America is back."

Liberal democracy is what connects us across the Atlantic more strongly than anything else. There is much to suggest that the questions we seek to discuss today will become an essential, perhaps even the central element of a new transatlantic agenda.

The public space of a democracy is supposed to achieve so much: reflect the plurality of society and be accessible to all, promote reasonable debates, open spaces for new ideas and political goals, provide reliable information, and strengthen the democratic maturity of all. These ideals have guided us since the Enlightenment. Every step away from them, every damage to our public spaces does not go without consequences for democracy.

This does not justify the increasingly inflationary dirges on democracy that have been written and published in abundance. But as early as 2009, the former editor of the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, Frank Schirrmacher, warned that the distribution of attention in the digital space would become the decisive power question. He predicted many details that are now common knowledge. Whoever has direct access to people's smartphones and laptops, whoever decides on the next content, undoubtedly wields power.

Today, social media have the most direct access to people – and their ad-funded business model demands attention at almost any cost. The algorithms of Facebook and YouTube, Twitter and TikTok direct our attention with icy precision, based on our own data patterns that we have laid ourselves, according to exactly two criteria: Which content keeps me glued to the screen the longest? And how can as much revenue as possible be generated with tailored advertising during that time? That is one thing. But it is striking:

Nothing apparently binds people to their devices as much as excitement and outrage, fear and anger. The algorithms learn to make individual news feeds and autoplay video sequences ever more exciting, ever more spectacular – even when it comes to politics, when it comes to the common good. Little value is given to the principles on which our democracies are built: respect, truth, civility, reason, factual responsibility. Unlike even a tabloid newspaper, there is no editorial team, no press council, and no competition to intervene in a moderating and controlling manner. On the contrary, balance and moderation disrupt the business. A purely profit-maximizing algorithm does not care what is true or false, nor what purpose a particular content was created for. But it can predict quite well what captivates each individual to the screen.

Thus, speed and escalation are rewarded, one-sidedness and untruth remain unchallenged, demagoguery and propaganda too often go unrebuked. Social media far too often reward the quick lie – at the expense of reason and truth. The business of attention becomes a danger for democracy.

And unfortunately, the enemies of democracy exploit these weaknesses to the fullest. With lies and deceit, they skillfully fuel the attention machines of social media to their own advantage. And in the end, insurgents occupy the Capitol.

The follow-up costs of this great structural change in our public spaces do not arise immediately from the digitization of our communication itself. On the contrary, hardly any technology initially holds more opportunities to create pluralistic public spaces, freely accessible to all, crossing borders, milieus, and largely generational divides.

No, the costs of the structural change of the public sphere arise from specific democratic political failures of the market-dominating platforms. These design flaws harm the public space – and democracy becomes collateral damage of the business model.

It is about the fundamentals. If every lie can become a dogma, every debate devolves into a screaming match, everyone huddles in their echo chambers, every disagreement threatens to cancel the democratic social contract, and in the end, no one wants to be responsible for it, then politics and the rule of law are called upon. Not only to protect citizens, of course, but to protect the existence of democracy.

The intentional manipulation of our attention exploits well-known psychological weaknesses of humans. Here, a market dominated by a few providers fails. It creates a societal evil by catering to our worst instincts. And we know the enlightened answer to such evils, and it is: the rule of law, rules, and institutions. The major platform operators have long resisted control and their own responsibility for the public space they have created with their infrastructure. Problems have been downplayed, relativized, and no liability has been taken for content, preferring to declare their own offerings as private rooms for family chats and vacation photos – and yet they have earned billions from political content and, above all, from the journalistic work of others. Regulation has long been declared the enemy of freedom, although the opposite is true: In order for freedom and democracy to be preserved for all, rules are needed. All the more remarkable is it when not only players like Apple and Microsoft, who pursue a different business model, call for regulation of the ad-funded competition; but when even a Mark Zuckerberg says: "Big Tech needs more regulation," it certainly raises eyebrows.

And it is true. As long as companies do not change course, such a call for rules may sound cynical. But the signs are increasing that Facebook and others can no longer rid themselves of the spirits they have called forth, and that the sharp criticism pouring down on them is increasingly taking its toll. We should therefore take the call for rules at its word.

And fortunately, we still have functioning public spaces; fortunately, there is a broad debate about the future of the digital public sphere. Against disinformation and hate, an ever-widening societal alliance is getting involved – and demanding better rules in Europe as well as in the USA. And the success of documentaries like "The Social Dilemma" shows that a global audience of millions can and wants to understand the problem.

For years, there has been discussion and debate about appropriate regulations, not only in Washington and Brussels, but also here in Berlin, for example, with the Network Enforcement Act. The appropriate remuneration for journalistic content, which is currently being negotiated in Australia, is an important aspect of this debate. Even more important is the gray area of legal but democratically harmful "harmful content," such as the systematic lie of the stolen election.

All these thoughtful debates are, in their entirety, good news. Because in all these debates, no matter how detailed and technical they may sometimes seem, it is about nothing less than the democratization of the digital. Democracy is not just any business model, no analog relic ripe for digital disruption. On the contrary: democracy and the rule of law are the foundations of our coexistence as free and mature citizens, a conditio sine qua non of our freedom! Democracy has made the development of a free internet, perhaps even the digital revolution itself, possible in the first place. I believe the major technology companies and platform operators know this as well. They should have no heightened interest in undermining our democracy, as it is also about their own life and survival.

America and Europe have a historic opportunity in these months to find free and democratic answers together. And only they – others will not even seek these answers. We know that in Russia and China, the seamless control over the internet has become a defining element of modern authoritarian regimes. Digital control, surveillance, and discipline, electronic attacks on democratic states and attractive, open societies are signs of a systemic conflict that is also digital. We must present a democratic alternative to the model of digital dictatorship on both sides of the Atlantic and together.

Of course, there are different cultural, political, and legal influences between Europe and the USA, for example, regarding freedom of expression, data protection, or the regulation of economic enterprises. All the more valuable is the increasing convergence of discussions, which in the USA no longer solely lead to unrestricted freedom and unlimited profits, and in the EU are no longer only focused on the dangers of market dominance and distortion of competition.

Both sides have recognized: In the digital public space, it is about the fundamentals, about the future of democracy, which is exactly what President Biden is also talking about. In this lies the great opportunity for a common agenda, for a re-establishment of the transatlantic partnership.

I hope that America and Europe will do justice to this opportunity. It would be an important first step towards a free "technosphere," a kind of global agreement on the future of democracy. The digital public space is a critical infrastructure of any future world order. Together with other democracies in the world, we can and must succeed in preserving the open internet and defending the digital space as a space of freedom.

Whether and how we can achieve a transatlantic breakthrough for the digital public space is what we want to discuss together now. I am sure that the opportunities to weigh our positions and explore our commonalities will not run out with all the many topics at hand.

First, the fundamental question of the extent to which platform operators should be responsible for and liable for content. What rules and standards are applied, how can transparency and trust be established? How much can work through private house rules, meaning corporate rules, and how much democratic legitimacy, oversight, and control, including through laws, is needed from the outside? How can we get a grip on the gray area of "harmful content"? What kind of content intervention is effective – temporary or permanent deletion of individual content, account suspensions, warning labels on Twitter and others, peer review like on Wikipedia, full transparency, or even bans on targeted advertising, especially political advertising? All questions that may concern us today.

And where are the limits of sensible regulation? Can commercial platforms even implement pluralistic and democratic principles? Are the current business models even compatible with democracy in the long run? And if so, how must they be adjusted? In light of data sovereignty, do we need either restrictions or individual deletion claims for specific collected data? How far do such experiences from the past, particularly with public and private broadcasting, carry us?

And finally: How can we empower the initiatives, authorities, and non-governmental organizations that are concerned with creating successful public spaces in the digital realm? What can we provide to people to strengthen their maturity and resilience in the digital space? How can attractive alternative offerings emerge in light of the technological and economic dominance of the major players, and how can they gain market share?

But we cannot answer all questions; by laying them out, it becomes clear to all listeners and viewers: These are not simple questions. We want to take the time today to discuss these questions, dear Ms. Vestager, dear Mr. Nassehi, dear Mr. Scott. You are all warmly welcome.

I look forward to an exciting and certainly enlightening discussion with you.