Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the festive event for the 100th anniversary of the dbb Beamtenbund und Tarifunion on November 29, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

6 December 2018 · 18th Asia-Pacific Conference of German Business (APC 2024)

Context
Steinmeier addressed the centenary celebration of the dbb Beamtenbund und Tarifunion on November 29, 2018, in Berlin, marking 100 years of the German civil service union.
Main themes
100th anniversary of dbb civil service union, history of German democracy, civil servant professional ethos, trade unions and democracy, Weimar Republic legacy, public service values, German civil service history, Nazi era and GDR trade union suppression, democratic oath and constitution, founding of dbb in 1918
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,597
69th percentile
Sentences
128
74th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 59%59%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Technological 7%7%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

128 sentences in 34 paragraphs

When I prepare for an appointment like this one today, I always take a look at the files of my office. Sometimes you come across surprising or amusing things, but always fragments of history, including the history between the Federal President and the civil service union. In these files, there is a note from Theodor Heuss, who in 1955 recorded a meeting with representatives of the dbb: "[...] received and treated the new board of the civil service union. A bit worried about how it would go." But apparently, the conversation went better than Heuss had expected. After the conversation, the Federal President apparently noted with satisfaction: He was pleased that "in an open conversation, something even came out of it."

You see: The close relationship between the dbb and the office of the Federal President has been built on a solid foundation from the very beginning. Thank you very much for your invitation. I, too, look forward to an open evening with you!

1918 to 2018 – 100 years since the proclamation of the Weimar Republic and 100 years of the dbb. In this anniversary year, we remember the hopeful beginning of the first parliamentary democracy in Germany. We also remember its end and the misguided path into the tyranny of the National Socialists, the new beginning of democracy in the Federal Republic, the division along the Iron Curtain, German unity, and European integration. At all these stages, the history of the civil service union is closely intertwined with our history of democracy. So, lean back for an approximately two-hour historical lecture.

No, don’t worry. But just a single, quick look at the history of German trade unions – their alignment during the Nazi era, their nationalization in the real-existing socialism of the GDR, their pivotal role in the social market economy of the Federal Republic – a single glance shows us: Free and strong trade unions, employee and civil service representatives are a hallmark of democracy! Both condition and support each other. That is precisely why the enemies of democracy have always targeted trade unions, professional associations, and civil service representatives.

It is a historical blessing that we have strong and responsible trade unions and civil service associations! And it is equally a blessing that our democracy can rely on a strong German civil service union and tariff union! The most important thing, therefore, right from the start: Congratulations on your 100th birthday!

I do not want to burden you today with overly detailed historical specifics, but for me, looking back over the past 100 years, one question stands at the center, which we, which you ask today – and time and again: What professional ethos actually shapes this "public service," that is, the service to the common good of our democracy? What expectations do we have of the employees, of the civil servants?

In the monarchies of the Empire, civil servants were to be first and foremost obedient officials and – beyond their service – nothing more than private individuals. The citizen did not appear, and certainly not one with democratic values and convictions. Only in the Weimar Republic did civil servants for the first time in the history of the German civil service no longer swear their oath to a person, to an emperor, king, or prince, but to the democratic constitution.

This democratic revolution certainly did not have only friends – especially not within the old authoritarian state. Many higher officials of the monarchy were opposed to the republic, even hostile. But central to the birth of the dbb were others: the hundreds of thousands of middle and lower-ranking civil servants – railway workers, police officers, and postal officials, employees in town halls and judicial administration. Many of them wholeheartedly supported the young democracy, from which they hoped for representation of their concerns as well.

After the Council of People's Representatives enabled civil servants to collectively represent their interests, the dbb was founded on December 4, 1918, with over a million members. Its co-founders, Else Kolshorn and Ernst Remmers, were powerful advocates of democracy. The spirit of many Weimar democrats increasingly enriched the training of civil servants. The administrative academies – perhaps even more so than some university chairs at that time – conveyed a self-confident and democratic understanding of the state. Legal scholars like Walter Jellinek or Hans Peters shaped at these institutions, closely connected with the dbb, the ideal of the civil servant as a citizen.

Let us also remember these women and men this evening: the committed and courageous civil servants and – for the first time with equal rights! – civil service women of the young republic!

What I said on November 9 in the German Bundestag, I want to reaffirm today: Let us no longer claim that the Weimar Republic was a democracy without democrats. They existed, and at all levels: engaged employees, not only out of official duty but out of inner loyalty to the constitution. I believe that those traditions of democratic awakening should and must be invoked by a modern, democratic civil service, for that is what you should be today: citizens in the service of our democracy! And I know: That is also your conviction!

I want to recall one episode as an example: The young civil service union was not only a support but was indeed among the lifesavers of the young republic. When the Kapp Putsch shook the country in March 1920, the dbb's response was: General strike until the constitutional order is restored. Across the country, railway workers, postal officials, and brave women and men in the offices defended themselves against the putschists and the attack on the young democracy.

Arnold Brecht, a democratically minded official of the Reich Chancellery, hurled at the insurgents: "I have sworn an oath to the constitution, and I do not carry my oath in my hand, like your people carry their hand grenades." And this Arnold Brecht had a little-known and therefore underestimated idea that helped preserve the republic: Just before the putschists arrived at the Reich Chancellery, he hid all the stamps! No chance for the putschists to produce documents. At least none that had the appearance of authenticity. That is the power of the stamp. This is also what creative commitment to the republic can look like!

However, when we look back at the history of the civil service union today, we must also be concerned about this: As powerful and courageous as many in the dbb stood by democracy at the beginning of the Weimar Republic, so powerless and cowardly did the union act in its last days. The civil service has always been a mirror of society. And so, the National Socialists also found their way into the offices and ministries. Through infiltration from within and pressure from outside by the new government, the alignment of the dbb ultimately occurred after the seizure of power.

And yet it is surprising – and should also disturb us – how quickly the dbb fell in line with the National Socialists. Already on March 17, 1933, the new board decreed in the association's magazine: "For the German professional civil servant, there can be nothing else than that he willingly and wholeheartedly makes himself available and supports the government through loyal fulfillment of duty." How little democratic ideals suddenly mattered, how quickly they were gone: the flight from responsibility and stubborn authoritarian thinking!

The cynically named "Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service" introduced the first "Aryan paragraph" in April 1933. With this, the National Socialists destroyed the foundations of the professional civil service: Democrats, liberals, and civil servants of Jewish faith were dismissed from public service. Where was the outcry from civil service colleagues over this blatant violation of the constitution? For the most part, it was absent!

But there was also resistance among civil servants against the Nazi regime. For example, the senior government councilor Arvid Harnack in the Reich Ministry of Economics, executed in 1942 in Plötzensee as a member of the so-called "Red Orchestra," or the Berlin city inspector Fritz Erler, who survived only because he was able to escape during one of the death marches towards the Dachau concentration camp. Too many, however, as historian Hans Mommsen wrote, became far too often not only unwilling executors of unlawful tyranny.

In the history of this dbb lies indeed both: motivation and admonition. Max Weber foresaw that bureaucracy is both indispensable and impersonal and therefore easily finds itself ready to work for anyone who knows how to seize it. Only much later did the Germans understand what he was warning against.

Hannah Arendt compellingly traced where blind obedience, not only among civil servants, led in National Socialism. And what lessons we must draw from it. "No one," is the seemingly irritating sentence from Arendt, "has the right to obey." That was her powerful rejection of blind obedience and herd mentality.

"No one has the right to obey." With that, she meant for service in the Nazi regime: No one can excuse themselves from their own responsibility by referring to orders and obedience. Courage for independent thinking and judgment, and if necessary, the courage, yes, the duty to dissent – that is what we expect from all women and men who serve our state. Blind obedience, that is the "rule of no one," as Hannah Arendt called it. Creativity, loyalty, and responsibility – also for one's own actions – that is modern civil service! You embody that in your association! I count on your commitment to democracy. Because every job in public service is more than just a job; it is a service to and for the community.

Conversely, the state is also obligated to its employees and civil servants. This includes proper funding of public service. This naturally means good staffing and fair pay. Increasingly, it also includes modernizing our authorities, for example, with efficient information technology that is up to date. Only in this way can public service remain an attractive employer and a strong support for our democracy! Perhaps we have never felt as strongly as we do today in the past 70 years that we need this strong support.

A public service as a support for democracy must, however, also reflect the democratic society in its own composition. There is still much to be done here. Diversity is not a buzzword. Only a civil service that reflects our society in all its diversity can provide the best possible service to that society. And that is why you in the dbb rightly ask: Why are there still far too few women in leadership positions today – 100 years after the achievement of women's suffrage? There may be explanations for this, but hardly any excuse!

And since we have already looked back at the history of our republic several times today, I would also like to recall the reunification of our country. The fall of the wall almost three decades ago would not have been conceivable without the courage and desire for freedom of the East Germans who took to the streets at that time. The success of state unity in the years after 1989 also certainly includes the valuable support that West German civil servants provided in the then "new" federal states. Many of them found a new home there. Today, however, we find that there are still too few tariff employees or civil servants from East Germany working at the management levels of many authorities, even in East Germany. It is time for that to change.

We cannot be satisfied as long as the children and grandchildren of those who came to us as labor migrants, then called "guest workers" in the 1960s and 1970s, and found their home here, work only relatively rarely in public service.

Anyone who meets the civic and other requirements should have the same access opportunities to a position in public service. This is important so that there are role models in citizen offices, on the benches of judges and prosecutors, or in ministries.

All of these are questions not only of equality and the appreciation of each individual citizen's biography, but they are also highly detrimental to the performance of public service if not all talents are equally promoted, if the full diversity of experiences and perspectives is not utilized for our community.

Public service must open up. And it must do so more ambitiously and quickly than before. The compatibility of family and work, flexible work models, career development, and the targeted outreach to underrepresented groups – these are just some of the areas where public service must make progress. I count on the strong momentum from the dbb!

Allow me to conclude with a thought on digitalization, for it too is changing our view of professions and the professional ethos in public service. What does it mean for our understanding of the state, for example, if in the future algorithms decide on the payment of state benefits instead of caseworkers, or if artificial intelligence applies tax law instead of a tax officer?

Your motto "Public service is service to people" also applies in the digital age. Digitalization can help significantly improve the services of the administration for the people. But it must not lead to a situation where there are no longer any people interacting within the administration. Such an administration would be a nightmare – anyone who wants to read more about it should look up Franz Kafka. That is not the public service you want, it is not the one I want, and it is certainly not what the citizens want!

In my view, a clear command also applies in the digital world: people must be able to make the final decision – we must never completely relinquish our autonomy and decision-making authority. This applies in general. And it applies even more so in public service. Work in public service is always more than mere data matching or computational optimization. The common good cannot be calculated by even the smartest algorithm. We must never delegate the common good to machines, for machines will never fulfill the democratic professional ethos of public service!

This professional ethos – as the view of the tumultuous history of this association teaches us – includes not only the obligation to the state but also to the fundamental rights of citizens and the core values of our democracy! They are the foundation upon which the traditional principles of civil service stand today.

We remember this and celebrate it on this 100th birthday. And we should also keep this in mind when bureaucracy and administration are criticized in this country. Jokes about civil servants famously fill entire books and seem to save some comedy performances on television.

But those who have dared to look over the garden fence for a while and have experienced public service in other countries will laugh a little less loudly. For they know that we in Germany are not poorly served with a professional public service along with rules and legal oversight of administrative decisions. There are many countries that envy us for this.

That is why I am primarily not here to congratulate on the birthday, but to express my gratitude to those who work daily for our community, to all employees and civil servants, to all of you. Not only my thanks, but the thanks of the Federal President, and I express this gratitude in the name of all those who depend on your commitment. And therefore, on behalf of all Germans: Thank you very much!