Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier on the change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court on November 30, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

6 December 2018 · Change of judges at the Federal Constitutional Court · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremony marking the change of Federal Constitutional Court judges in Berlin on November 30, 2018, welcoming the newly appointed judge Kirchhof.
Main themes
Judicial independence, Federal Constitutional Court, rule of law, two-thirds majority consensus, constitutional judge appointment process, judicial selection in Germany, academic and legal career of Kirchhof, federalism and tax law scholarship
Duration
~17 min
57th percentile
Words
2,000
57th percentile
Sentences
93
59th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
41st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 39%39%
  • Ceremonial 32%31%
  • Social 28%28%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

93 sentences in 16 paragraphs

Warm welcome! I am pleased to see you today – one could almost say finally. The search for a successor for you, dear Mr. Kirchhof, was indeed unusually long. Sometimes it may be quite nice to learn that one is needed. But even at our last meeting, you felt it was time to move on. Because your term officially ended on June 30 of this year. Nevertheless, I would like to emphasize that the foresight of the legislator, which he made for the case that the succession cannot be arranged in time, was extremely wise, as we are experiencing again these days. For he anticipated that our rule-of-law selection process, which requires a two-thirds majority and thus a high political consensus in the electoral bodies for the election of constitutional judges, can indeed take longer for that very reason. Thus, the regulation in § 4 paragraph 4 of the Federal Constitutional Court Act is very forward-looking, stating that incumbents must remain in office until successors are appointed and sworn in. And when it takes a little longer, it does not only cause impatience for the incumbent. Whether it is about the formation of governments or the appointment of constitutional judges, if it takes a long time and longer than expected, then the process is discussed and criticism of the process is voiced. I have followed all of this, but I have not seen any proposals for better solutions. In our country, the judiciary is independent, and there is no one-sided political influence on the judiciary. Even if some want to publicly convince our neighboring countries, which certainly have reason to look at the preservation of their rule-of-law minimum standards. Of course, the selection of members of the constitutional judiciary is a political process. But the requirement of a two-thirds majority and the rotation between the electoral bodies of the Bundestag and Bundesrat also ensure that individuals are found who meet the requirements of independent judges to a high degree. That we have succeeded in this in the past and that this is also the case in the present, we see today.

Dear Mr. Kirchhof, you have had to show patience since June 30. However, showing patience is nothing new for you. For in 2005 you were already a candidate for the Federal Constitutional Court – the eligible voters then chose another candidate. However, you were able to view this with equanimity. Quality prevails – and so you were appointed in 2007.

Of course, you met all the requirements that characterize constitutional judges. In your case, there may also be a special predisposition: a kind of law gene seems to run in your family. Your father was a judge at the Federal Court of Justice, your older brother Paul was a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court. And as I have heard, nieces and nephews have also become judges. One of the nephews has even followed in your and your brother's footsteps and is already a professor of constitutional law. The legal profession is, so to speak, in the family. There is no shortage of conversation topics – especially since your wife is also the presiding judge at the Administrative Court in Mannheim.

She has led a straightforward, impressive legal career to the position of Federal Constitutional Judge. And, as I have noted, you picked up on this early: you completed your Abitur quite near your later place of work, namely at the Bismarck Gymnasium in Karlsruhe. It was only a few streets away from the then building of the Federal Constitutional Court, which you passed every day on your way to school. After two years in the Bundeswehr, you studied in Freiburg, Heidelberg, and Speyer, and then purposefully pursued an academic career. You submitted your doctoral thesis on "The Amount of the Fee" in Heidelberg in 1981 and habilitated on "Private Lawmaking" in Speyer in 1985. After teaching positions in Saarbrücken, Munich, and Speyer, you took over the chair for Public Law, Financial and Tax Law at the University of Tübingen in 1986. In both fields, I believe it can still be said, there remains a focus of your scientific interest to this day. Your publication list includes over 170 scientific contributions: from "Outline of Tax and Levy Law" to "The Finances of Federalism" or "The Development of Social Constitutional Law" to a classic topic of tax law: "The Principle of Ability to Pay according to the Basic Law" – just to name a few.

In addition to your academic engagement – you were also Dean of the Law Faculty at the University of Tübingen and its Pro-Rector – you always sought contact with practice. I would like to highlight only your work as an elected member of the Federalism Commission in 2003/2004 – I remember a time when we often crossed paths – and your membership in the State Constitutional Court of Baden-Württemberg from 2003 to 2007.

You are characterized by professional excellence, but also, if I may say so, by a calm restraint. Even if you have not published yourself, whenever you were asked, you did not hold back your opinions – always with judicial modesty, yet pronounced and, where necessary, strong in opinion.

"Demo-crazy," for example – that was the title of your analysis on the state of democracy in Germany and Europe at the end of last year. I find it a worthwhile piece on the current dangers to democracy and the rule of law. In many respects, we agree on the remedy you proposed of introducing direct democratic elements at the federal level; I am somewhat skeptical for more fundamental reasons – but what is important is that concrete proposals stimulate and invigorate the discussion. And that is what particularly characterizes your public statements.

In the First Senate, you were mainly responsible for "Social Law." No one was surprised at that time: you approached this relatively new field for you with the typical diligence and joy upon taking office. Although social law rules have immediate effects on many people in our society, the field has a somewhat less glamorous reputation in the legal profession. However, the significance that decisions in this area can have was demonstrated by the ruling on the subsistence minimum. Newspapers commented on the decision you reported on at that time, stating that you were an expensive judge for the state. In fact, you reminded the legislator of the need to consider the constitution when determining social transfer benefits. No more and certainly no less – but exactly your task. That citizens increasingly seek the help of the Federal Constitutional Court in social policy matters is also shown by the number of cases you handled: you were the reporting judge in 3,238 cases, the overwhelming majority of which were constitutional complaints. Many of these decisions are important for the reality of life for numerous people in our country, existentially important. I will mention just three that illustrate this: the decisions on the basic tariff in private health insurance, the ruling on Hartz IV standard benefits, which concerned the entitlement to a subsistence minimum, and the decision on the extent of the obligation to provide benefits by statutory health insurance for new treatment methods in the case of a life-threatening illness.

Behind the constitutional lawyer, constitutional judge, and Vice President stands the person Ferdinand Kirchhof. He does not push into the public eye, and as far as I know, there are no "homestories" about you. But anyone who comes together with you, works with you, or discusses professional issues experiences – I say this from my own experience – an incredibly approachable and, as I find, very humorous person. I have come to know you as such on the numerous occasions we have encountered in the past. You approach your counterpart openly and curiously. You prefer to discuss rather than lecture. And your colleagues particularly emphasize your willingness to be convinced by good arguments from other positions. As important as discussions are to you, the well-being of the people around you is equally important. Your "How are you?" I have been assured, has never been just a rhetorical question, but an expression of genuine curiosity to find out how those around you, your employees, colleagues, and coworkers are truly doing. You also place value on a pleasant, balanced working atmosphere – in the Senate as well as in your department's team. There, you are praised for your sense of duty, your generous nature, and your modesty. And therefore, for all these reasons, I am convinced that you have significantly contributed, especially in your role as Vice President, to shaping the public face of the Federal Constitutional Court.

With you, dear Mr. Kirchhof, not only an experienced but also an extremely competent judge is leaving the Federal Constitutional Court. I am sure you will continue to speak out with wise and thoughtful contributions – even if you are said to have mentioned that people will be surprised at how many requests you will decline in the future.

For your commitment and your efforts, I express my gratitude and my truly great respect today. As a visible recognition of your services to our state, I may therefore – only after the presentation of the certificate of discharge – award you the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany.

Dear Mr. Harbarth, the Bundestag elected you as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court on November 22, 2018, and the Bundesrat appointed you Vice President on November 23, 2018, as Mr. Kirchhof's successor. I would like to congratulate you from the bottom of my heart on this.

For you, two professional phases of life are coming to an end today, that of a lawyer and that of a politician. You are, so one could say, switching sides in two ways: from the legislative to the judiciary, from the lawyer's table to the judge's bench.

I am convinced that the Bundestag and Bundesrat have made a good choice. You are equipped for new tasks in every respect: after graduating from high school in 1991, you studied law at Ruprecht-Karls-University in Heidelberg. Following the First State Examination in Law in 1996, you moved to Berlin for your preparatory service, where you worked from 1997 to 1999 and completed it with the Second State Examination in Law. During this time, you wrote your dissertation titled "Investor Protection in Public Enterprises." In 1998, the University of Heidelberg awarded you your doctorate. This was followed by a study abroad in the USA with a scholarship from the German Academic Exchange Service. At Yale Law School, you earned the academic degree of Master of Laws. You then moved to a law firm specializing in commercial law.

Having been politically active since your youth, it was perhaps only natural that you entered active politics in 2009. Since then, you have represented the Rhein-Neckar constituency in the Bundestag, having been directly elected. That you have also been working as a lecturer since 2004 and as an honorary professor at the Law Faculty of the University of Heidelberg since this year alongside all these professional activities shows your great work ethic and high resilience, which your colleagues look forward to. You will likely need this given the large workload in Karlsruhe in the future.

With your election, dear Mr. Harbarth, a frequently lamented gap in the Federal Constitutional Court is being filled – namely, the lack of presence of legal expertise. And the experiences in politics are by no means detrimental, especially when they are combined with undisputed legal and professional competence, as is the case with you. I am convinced that with your diverse experiences, you will enrich the Federal Constitutional Court. Your colleagues will, I am sure, make the transition to the new role easy for you. I wish you all the best from the bottom of my heart for this new phase of life and the new tasks ahead.