Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the fifth forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" on October 4, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

8 October 2018 · Fifth forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" · Forum Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the fifth Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy in Berlin on October 4, 2018, discussing societal fragmentation and political resentments in Germany.
Main themes
Fragmentation of democracy, political polarization, social resentments, emotionalization of politics, populism, distrust in institutions, German unity and division, democratic cohesion, fear and insecurity, public discourse, liberal democracy
Duration
~19 min
63rd percentile
Words
2,266
63rd percentile
Sentences
102
64th percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
43rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 53%44%
  • Ceremonial 22%19%
  • Institutional 19%16%
  • Economic 4%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 17%

102 sentences in 34 paragraphs

"Cracks and Resentments – On the Fragmentation and Emotionalization of Politics and Society"

The day after the Day of German Unity – I don't know if anyone remembers –: At the ceremonial event last year in Mainz, I spoke about new walls that have emerged in our country. New walls, I said, that stand in the way of our common "we" in Germany. Walls of alienation, disappointment, and anger, walls that have become so solid for some that arguments can no longer penetrate them.

Yesterday, we celebrated German Unity here in Berlin and throughout Germany once again. And the concerns – I believe this is also your impression – have certainly not diminished over the course of the last year.

Some signs indeed suggest that the cracks have become even deeper and that the climate of public debate has heated up even further in the last twelve months. Many have pointed fingers at the disputes within the coalition government, especially in recent weeks. But that is not enough. For the same centrifugal forces are pulling at the parties; they are struggling with the same distrust that is unsettling our society. And I believe it is indeed necessary to talk about the reasons for this.

One would assume that strong feelings have their reasons. So what has changed? Why do people in our country feel overlooked, no longer perceived, no longer recognized, more evidently than ten, twenty, or thirty years ago? What are the causes of deep distrust or, as can also be observed, even contempt for democracy, democratic institutions, and their representatives?

I find that we too often experience a diffuse hatred towards the so-called "establishment," but at the same time towards minorities and dissenters. However, we should not only lament this hatred in shock but also fearlessly discuss its causes, illuminate them, and at least try to understand them. And that is precisely what I have invited you to do today. It is an invitation less to outrage than to decipher the resentments that I am convinced threaten our cohesion.

We observe how political camps entrench themselves against one another, how the language becomes increasingly coarse and ruthless, how people with differing opinions hardly engage in conversation anymore. The walls seem to have become so high that one believes one can only shout over them. Often, a moral reprimand follows the staged taboos broken by populists – and both contribute to further polarization.

I would like to encourage – not only here and today but also on other occasions – to break this spiral; today, at least for the duration of the discussion we are having, or in other words, we want to use this pause on the playing field to try to track the positioning of the competitors and the moves being made. We should not deprive ourselves of this space for reflection, at least here.

And one thing, I believe, we will certainly find: Our democracy is certainly not on the verge of melting down. The problem is rather, as I have said on other occasions, that far too many take it for granted and believe it is guaranteed forever.

When looking at the surveys, this is misleading from one perspective, as one finds different evidence for different views: When asked whether they are satisfied with their personal situation, 80 percent say "yes." When asked the same people whether they fear for the future, a similarly high percentage concludes that the fear is justified.

Objectively – we will soon debate and discuss whether this is objective – probably no generation in Germany has had it better than the current one. After all, we live in peace, the economy has been growing for six consecutive years, unemployment is decreasing, and businesses are urgently seeking young people with a future perspective. And our rule of law is functioning, despite all the attacks.

However, perhaps we need to do more than simply note this as "cool." Liberal democracy is, when viewed over a longer historical process, something like a place of longing for people all over the world. It is a unique historical achievement for which we may advocate with our own republican passion. And if we are already talking about emotions and politics, then I wish for more democratic patriotism in this time!

In this sense, ladies and gentlemen, dear guests, with a cool head, but hopefully not too cool, but with passion for the cause of democracy, I would like to welcome you all to the fifth "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy." A warm welcome to all of you!

Politics, as is not a completely new insight, is not only a rational business, but it is also driven and shaped by emotions. Feelings have always moved people, either enabling or complicating communication, and have influenced decisions about war and peace. And political forces have always tried to tame or stir emotions, depending on how they believed political goals could be achieved.

Today, we observe how perhaps a new generation of populists is trying to rationally exploit feelings of fear and insecurity to stir resentments and, I believe, to attack liberal democracy as a whole. During the peak of the refugee crisis, we also experienced the opposite. We saw how many showed compassion and solidarity throughout Germany and how many were willing to engage in committed help.

We know that feelings can be confusing; this is not limited to the years of puberty, and that is why I am pleased to welcome today a historian who has long studied the relationship between rationality and emotionality in societies: Ute Frevert, director of the research area "History of Emotions" at the Max Planck Institute here in Berlin, and with her, we will discuss the emotional temperature in our country. Welcome.

When it comes to describing cracks in our society, coarse labels are quickly at hand: "the people" supposedly stand against "the elites," "the locals" against "the foreigners," "the democrats" against "the populists." We experience daily how such attributions are politically and morally instrumentalized, how they fuel feelings of superiority and inferiority. We know, or should know, that such templates or other forms of black-and-white thinking are not suitable for adequately capturing our diverse reality, and often they even obscure the view of the real conflicts. And there are certainly always more than just one explanation for the developments I have briefly outlined.

I am therefore pleased that our second guest today brings a social science perspective: Ms. Cornelia Koppetsch is a professor at the Technical University of Darmstadt, and from her perspective, it is also, but – she will explain this in more detail – perhaps less economic than cultural conflicts that have contributed and continue to contribute to the attractiveness of populist positions, explaining why a politics of simple answers has become appealing to a large number of people in Germany. Welcome.

Ms. Koppetsch sees a "central axis of division" in our society between an academically educated urban middle class, which is gradually developing into a cosmopolitan upper class in our country, and a middle and lower middle class based in regions and small towns, which is still situated within the national economic space and feels its values, worldview, and place in society to be threatened.

What can we do to counter such divisions? Are there specific concerns in our country that are being neglected by politics, at least more than before? And how should politics and society deal with anger and protest? We will discuss this with her shortly.

What personally concerns me a great deal is the communicative climate change we are experiencing in our society. We are witnessing how digital and connected media lower the threshold for any form of "hate speech." Many people isolate themselves in peer groups, confirm each other in their perceived truths, and develop closed worldviews. And I believe this contributes to some groups being unable to communicate in public anymore – or perhaps I should say, unwilling to communicate – and therefore the actual strength of democracy, organizing compromise in a society, seems to be mutating into a weakness, at least from the perspective of many; compromise is now discredited by some as a sign of incapacity and powerlessness.

Today, however, we also experience how all kinds of information, relevant and absurd, including propaganda lies and conspiracy theories, are spread at lightning speed and shared millions of times. In the age of the internet, it seems that: A day without a scandal is wasted time.

Our third guest, media scientist Bernhard Pörksen, sees Germany already in a state of permanent irritation and great irritability. In his latest book, "The Great Irritability," he writes: "Everything that happens, that reaches the nerves of other people anywhere in the world, that moves, disturbs, or frightens them, can also reach and disturb us. […] Anyone who posts and comments, shares news and stories, uploads a mobile video online, […] contributes to the final expansion of the zones of agitation in the connected world." Welcome, Bernhard Pörksen.

With Mr. Pörksen, we want to discuss what paths lead out of this collective agitation, out of the permanent outrage, what we can all contribute to revive and strengthen a reasonably sensible public discourse in Germany – but also discuss when and how outrage can be a driving force to create more transparency and eliminate grievances.

However, we do not want to only talk about the big questions in an academic sense, but also about what we can concretely experience and do in everyday life to combat resentments and overcome divisions.

Those who know this particularly well are the many mayors who do not shy away from heated debates in their cities and communities, who go to the angry, listen to them, and who also have to deal with hostility, hatred, and violence. Some of them are here in the hall today, and I believe we cannot thank them enough for what they do daily for the cohesion of this society. Thank you very much!

One of them will soon take a seat here on the podium: Welcome, Andreas Hollstein, mayor of Altena. You know, Altena is a small town in North Rhine-Westphalia. Mr. Hollstein advocated in 2015 for his town to take in 100 more refugees than it was required to.

And in Altena, countless citizens volunteer to help refugees find their way into our society. But there was also an arson attack on a refugee shelter in the town, and in November of last year – some may know this here in the hall – Andreas Hollstein was attacked and injured with a knife.

This has not deterred him from his path. On the contrary: He believes that politicians must endure hostility and remain in conversation with all sides. He advocates for calmness and factual arguments. "Many people," he says, "have unjustified fears. And one can only address those if one," and he does, "radiates a certain degree of calm." Dear Mr. Hollstein, we already met in Altena in March. I am pleased that we can continue our conversation here and today.

In conclusion, I would like to share a thought from Christoph Möllers, who visited us at one of the last events here and sat on the podium. I want to quote him because he said something in which we can all find ourselves – all differently, but still a bit: "Much of the resentment against democracy stems from the injury that we are neither alone in the world nor more important than others. We want to get our way, but getting it is rarer in democracy than it is often."

There may be something to that! But recognizing this is, firstly, difficult, and it requires as much trust as reason. Trust in democratic and rule-of-law institutions on the one hand; reason in the sense of not taking one's own interest for the common interest of all and not viewing the existence of other opinions, positions, and interests as inherently unreasonable or even impermissible. And perhaps that is why liberal democracy is considered a rather cool form of government. Some criticize it for that, while others see it as its advantage.

Ralf Dahrendorf, for example, said: "Democracy and market economy are desirable because they are essentially cold projects that do not claim" – this is the crucial half-sentence – "that do not claim the hearts and souls of people." But I believe he had, when he wrote and said this, his own doubts about whether that would be enough, because abstract ideals, as he goes on to say, probably alone are not sufficient to hold societies together. And he is right about that. Even though democracy does not prescribe a way of life or a mental straitjacket for its citizens, it does rely on their inner conviction for this community and – above all – on the willingness to engage.

I believe that the willingness to engage is fortunately present in our country in millions – it does not arise solely from cool reason, but for most people from completely different motives, yet from the deepest heart. I believe that we can rely on this and certainly must rely on it. And from all of this, in my view, derives in the very best sense what I called at the very beginning the patriotism of democrats. We need that – especially in this country, especially in these times.

And for that reason, I am looking forward to the conversation that we will first have on the podium and then together with all of you. Thank you for coming. A warm welcome!