Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the "Forum Bellevue on the Transformation of Society" on the topic "Digital Public Sphere – Do We Need a New Enlightenment?" on the 10th of ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

11 July 2024 · Forum Bellevue on the Transformation of Society · Bellevue Palace

Context
Steinmeier addressed a Forum Bellevue symposium at Schloss Bellevue on July 11, 2024, exploring AI, digital democracy, and the need for a new Enlightenment.
Main themes
Digital public sphere, artificial intelligence and democracy, technological totalitarianism, disinformation and manipulation, digital enlightenment, surveillance capitalism, freedom and responsibility in the digital age, understanding and shaping technology, AI risks and benefits, public trust in digital transformation
Duration
~18 min
60th percentile
Words
2,140
60th percentile
Sentences
117
70th percentile
Readability
38
32nd percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
55th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 52%50%
  • Ceremonial 19%19%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 3%

117 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Ten years ago, the publicist Frank Schirrmacher passed away far too early. I want to remember him today because, in his last years, he posed a burning question like few others in Germany, a question that still haunts us today: Has the era of "technological totalitarianism" begun, in which the power of the machine – the digital machine – will disempower humanity in a new, unprecedented way? Mobile communication technology undoubtedly offers enticing opportunities for exchange, networking, information gathering, and individual self-presentation. Yet beneath the user interface, it collects and commercializes personal data on an unimaginable scale and exploits it, turned against the unsuspecting user, for consumption and control, as well as for manipulation and surveillance.

"Technological Totalitarianism" was also the title of the volume published in 2015 under Frank Schirrmacher's posthumous editorship. He brought many authors into the German public eye for the first time. Evgeny Morozov, Shoshana Zuboff, Jaron Lanier wrote about "digital wishful thinking," about "mining rights to life," "data that determines our fate." The book, ten years old, aimed to enlighten, to awaken, and to mobilize the political forces of the rule of law and democracy against the digital overwhelming of humanity.

Today, we want to ask where we stand ten years later. Why is digitalization on everyone's lips, yet we have relatively few answers to the risks of digital manipulation, and many users seem to have become "insensitive" to the topic; digital enthusiasts, on the other hand, react sensitively to questions about risks. The reason seems obvious: The attractiveness of the digital, even more so, the indispensability, the omnipresence of applications in more and more areas of our lives is overwhelming. It has become a cultural technique of modern humanity. A cultural technique that now also defines us. A blessing for some, a curse for others, an everyday reality for all.

And yet it would be cynical to say that Schirrmacher's question has thus become irrelevant. Democrats must engage with it. Therefore, we want to pose it anew today, the question of public space in the digital machine age, the question of the ethical minimum that must and should guide us.

In this context, the "smart" machine is a topos that has haunted utopian or dystopian literature for centuries. The difference is: It seems to have become or is becoming reality. The data repositories have grown large enough, the digital computing power for their lightning-fast processing is so immense that our computers make predictions, translate languages, not only answer knowledge questions but also spit them out in essay form, imitate voices, write poems, imitate photos or paintings of old masters, and much more. What is the benefit, and where are the risks for freedom and democracy?

This is what we want to discuss today in a series of conversations that focuses on the great transformation. We have talked several times about the detachment from fossil energy sources; now we are discussing the development of the digital key technologies of the future. I warmly welcome you all to Schloss Bellevue.

Before we dive into the discussion, I would like to talk about three central things, in my view, that are needed when it comes to Artificial Intelligence (AI) and its possibilities: understanding, responsibility, and trust.

The invention of the internet is often compared to the invention of the printing press. It revolutionized the world of its time. Writings could be multiplied, including religious and political pamphlets. Information, but also beliefs, could be disseminated quickly and for the first time widely. The Reformation is as inconceivable without the printing press as the idea of democracy, which, as we know, presupposes widespread literacy and public debate among the informed. Gutenberg laid the foundation for modernity with his invention – he was actually just pursuing a business idea, the mass distribution of written material of all kinds.

Gutenberg's example shows: Every invention can have unintended side effects. It is not always a media revolution. But understanding the social and political consequences is the foundation for developing and ultimately utilizing technological innovations appropriately and responsibly. Understanding a technology also means being prepared for the various possibilities of its use. And we should prepare better. Because we cannot ignore what has been invented and can rarely reverse it.

It is no longer a question of whether AI will continue to influence our lives, but how. I am convinced: We are not at the mercy of this technical development. But I am equally convinced: We must understand it in order to shape it.

The "World Risk Report" – such a thing exists – painted a seemingly bleak picture in January of this year. The analysts of the World Economic Forum assessed AI-generated fake news, cyberattacks, and disinformation as major dangers. All of this ranks in the analysts' description ahead of extreme weather, societal polarization, and surprisingly ahead of armed conflicts. But: This is by no means a prediction of the future. Because how great the danger to our democracies from Artificial Intelligence actually is, is in the hands of governments, companies, and societies.

Especially in the 300th anniversary year of Immanuel Kant, we must ask ourselves: What can we do to maintain our digital maturity, to promote understanding and communication, co-determination and participation? When citizens become suppliers of data sets and become dependent on technologies, business models, and content that they do not fully understand, this contradicts the idea of enlightenment.

Media education is also education for democracy. We must develop a common understanding of AI. And we must sharpen our judgment, empower people to critically question sources based on verifiable facts to avoid misjudgments. Both expanded media literacy and improved protection against abuse are needed.

This brings me to my second point, responsibility. The rise of radical populism in Europe, Russian disinformation campaigns, and the Chinese surveillance state – all these developments are closely linked to the transformation of our communication ecosystem. With the introduction of ChatGPT, entirely new questions have arisen for our political public spheres at the end of 2022.

"Our future depends on these technologies, but is simultaneously endangered by them," describes British entrepreneur and AI expert Mustafa Suleyman in his book "The Coming Wave."

So who decides what our future looks like? Tech giants? Start-ups? Markets? Authoritarian regimes? Democratic societies? Where our public spheres are undermined by autocratic systems, democracy is to be eroded with the poison of distrust. These are attempts to disrupt opinion and will formation, but also elections in liberal democracies, thereby discrediting and delegitimizing democracy itself. We urgently need common European responses to protect our democracies – and our citizens – to empower them as self-determined citizens, free in their decisions and politically capable of action, and to counter the technology of disempowerment with the agency of the empowered.

I am convinced that we have the best conditions for this. Germany is now among the world leaders in AI research and attracts excellent scientists. But we need to become better in our country at creating the economic environment to lead innovations from basic research to market readiness – and to bring political elites and administration up to date with the latest technological developments. In short: Naive rejection would be as unwise as pure imitation. Instead, we need curiosity, research and development, acceleration in application, and innovative ambition in companies and public administrations.

We still have the chance to shape the framework for AI so that it serves humanity and the common good at the same time. If we succeed in doing this, we will be able to set global standards and perhaps even strengthen trust in new technologies. It would not be the first time: The AI Act of the European Union is not only extensive, but we have also quickly taken responsibility and made clear what is important to us: We do not simply brush pressing questions aside! We provide answers that are not definitive, but we show the direction in which future we want to live. And we also show: This is a field for which we need rules. We show: Here with us, there are rules, here the law applies.

I am convinced that "made in Europe" can become a quality label in the future – a path beyond pure data capitalism on one side and authoritarian surveillance on the other side.

Now I come to my last keyword, trust. Disinformation and fake news are not new phenomena, but they are massively amplified by AI. The more journalistic work and scientific findings are called into question, the more difficult a constructive and reasoned discourse becomes. It is clear: Those who want to sow instability have it much easier in the digital age. In such a communication environment, not only independent, professional, and serious journalism becomes even more important. More than that: We need something like a provenance label for information. There are proposals on how we could create an alternative infrastructure to global platform companies, for example, with a common European media platform that is publicly organized and makes us less dependent on American or Chinese algorithms.

Whether that is realistic, our discussion partners today will have an opinion. After all, the idea is already more than ten years old. Whether it is this or newer ideas for containing dangers to democracy and cohesion, it is clear: Citizens must be able to develop trust – in the law and the rule of law. Therefore, we should also continue to advance political initiatives in the field of AI and, above all, work together on a positive European vision, on ethical guidelines for the development and various applications of AI.

Democratic societies urgently need to think about how they want and can live their freedom, their democratic convictions in an increasingly digital future. Maria Ressa, whom I welcome here and will introduce shortly, has already revealed her recipe: "In the long term, education is the most important thing, […] in the medium term, it is laws, […] that restore the rule of law in the virtual world […]. In the short term, it is up to us: Collaborate, collaborate, collaborate. And it starts with trust."

Understanding, responsibility, trust: Neither IT developers nor governments nor digital civil societies will be able to solve the challenges that lie ahead of us alone. We need a common vision, we need a common movement – at least a European movement – and we must be clear: What we are talking about here is a generational task.

The author Sascha Lobo recently put it succinctly: "The bad sides of AI come by themselves – for the good ones, we need to work intensively together." Therefore, it is particularly nice to see who is represented here in the room for our conversation: representatives from politics, business, and civil society. Once again, a warm welcome to Schloss Bellevue! And I would like to ask you all: Participate in our debate! I am looking forward to your experiences, your thoughts, and ideas.

And now I would like to welcome our two discussion partners:

Maria Ressa is a Filipino journalist and author. She grew up in the United States and then returned to her homeland. After holding senior positions at major broadcasters – including CNN and the Philippine TV and online network ABS-CBN – she became known beyond the borders of her country for co-founding the digital news portal Rappler in 2011, which has consistently reported critically, including on the then Philippine President Duterte. As the head of Rappler, Maria Ressa has faced numerous instances of state interference and harassment. She has shown how courageous journalism can fight for a counter-public using the means of the digital age and thus hold the politically powerful accountable. She has received numerous awards, including the Nobel Peace Prize in 2021.

Meredith Whittaker is the president of the Signal Foundation, representing a service that enables truly private digital communication through end-to-end encryption and makes no compromises when it comes to privacy protection. As an AI expert and informed critic, she has repeatedly shifted perspectives. Even during her time at Google, she consistently voiced critical opinions and advocated against surveillance. After leaving the company, she founded the AI Now Institute at New York University and has focused on the impacts of AI. In her advisory role for governments, the European Parliament, and other institutions, she has continually advanced the debate on data responsibility.

I also welcome Helene Bubrowski. She is a journalist and deputy editor-in-chief at Table.Media, and she will be moderating our event today.

I cannot conclude this introduction without expressing my heartfelt thanks to the Zeit Foundation Bucerius, which helps make these events with such ambition, scale, and international participation possible. Thank you very much!

I would now like to invite the three of you to the stage. It’s great to have you all here. I am very much looking forward to the discussion.