Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the kickoff conference for the international research project "Ethics of Digitalization" on August 17, 2020, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

18 August 2020 · Kickoff conference for the international research project "Ethics of Digitalization" · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the kickoff conference for the international research project 'Ethics of Digitalization' at Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, on August 17, 2020.
Main themes
Ethics of digitalization, digital governance and regulation, global internet governance, data privacy and protection, US-China tech rivalry, algorithmic revolution, digital space colonization, COVID-19 and digital acceleration, European data protection, artificial intelligence and autonomous systems, multilateral dialogue
Duration
~16 min
56th percentile
Words
1,972
56th percentile
Sentences
103
64th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 43%42%
  • Geopolitical 28%27%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

103 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Welcome to Schloss Bellevue! This applies to you here in the hall, and of course also to all the many people who have joined us digitally. It is wonderful to have you all with us.

Not only since the Corona pandemic has taken hold of our world have we felt that our lives, our interactions, and our communication have gained a new, digital dimension. The fact that we are only a very small circle of attendees here in the hall today, while in reality a much larger circle of participants and discussants is online, is indeed due to the pandemic. But what situation could make clearer and more urgent what we are to discuss today ‒ it is about the colonization of digital space.

The workplace, the classroom, the theater stage, the concert hall, yes, even Parliament have retreated into this digital space before the virus, at least temporarily. And all of us who have been swept along ask ourselves: What conditions do we find? Are digital spaces safe and reliable? Is our privacy, are our data protected from unauthorized access? What rules apply, and in particular: Are the rules that apply being adhered to? We remember data scandals, Cambridge Analytica, we follow the disputes over digital technologies and their foreign policy significance, for example in the conflicts surrounding Huawei and TikTok.

The questions about how we deal with digitalization have not diminished in recent months and years. And now the pandemic shows us even more clearly how closely we are interconnected through trade and technology. The revolution of algorithms, the enormous impacts of digital communication are a global challenge. No state in the world can escape it, and none could manage it alone.

That is why we must engage in dialogue, ask ourselves what rules we find in digital space and, above all, what rules we want to give it. Are we a global internet community, or do we remain Americans, Chinese, Europeans even online? What problems concern us? What can we expect from each other? And what commonalities can we build upon? We must ask ourselves these questions if we care about peace and prosperity in a connected world.

Two years ago, in 2018, I traveled to California and China in the footsteps of digital upheaval. Here – in Silicon Valley – the pioneers of the liberal, globalized data economy, whose products are used by billions of people, whose innovative power changes our lives, and who strive for economic gain with ever-growing mountains of data. And there – in Guangzhou, in Beijing – a state capitalism with enormous digital ambitions, with its own internet, a nearly isolated, state-controlled system that grows at incredible speed and renews itself almost daily – and that must always serve the central control urge and surveillance pressure of the party apparatus. And when I returned from these trips to Europe, the debate about the General Data Protection Regulation of the European Union was raging here, a framework for the protection of personal data in the digital world. This debate has shown me that even within Western societies, the notions of right and wrong in digital policy often diverge widely. Therefore, one thing in advance: The usual comparison of "here the European model, there the American model" often does not get us anywhere, and we should keep that in mind when we talk about commonalities and differences.

The internet spans the entire world. Digital companies from America, Europe, and even China serve customers on all continents, often with great agility and enormous adaptability to different political systems. After the initial euphoria, many states are increasingly asking how their spatially limited legislation, their limited influence on digital change can actually be reconciled with a global network. Some use new technologies like artificial intelligence, autonomous systems, or digital infrastructure as a strategic arm of foreign policy, while others rely on the power of their market, the purchasing power of their consumers, or the indispensability of their products. The escalating world conflict between the USA and China in these months must concern us all. Efforts to renationalize and fragment the internet for the purpose of state control and economic advantage, to create a "splinternet," so to speak, are an expression of this conflict.

I am convinced: Neither isolationism and small-state thinking nor the pursuit of dominance and fantasies of omnipotence should determine our common path into the digital future. We are steering into a dead end if we copy our response to digitalization from a handbook of statecraft from the 19th century. A new everyone-against-everyone situation is not something we should settle for; that is not where the solution will be found.

Seventy-five years ago, the most destructive of all wars, a world war unleashed by Germany, came to an end. The German perspective on the world cannot be explained without these experiences. However, the experience of this war has not only changed my country but has also brought us all, the community of states after 1945, a little closer to reason. The Charter of Human Rights and the United Nations, Bretton Woods and regional communities like the EU, the prohibition of violence, collective security: Seventy-five years ago, our ancestors decided to replace the law of the strongest with the law of nations, transcending all boundaries of geography, culture, descent, and religion. They created frameworks, built a normative framework supported by common ethical minimum standards with rules and institutions.

Of course, this order was and is not perfect, often dysfunctional, and never equally present for all. And it is by no means secured for all time, but has been increasingly questioned and challenged in recent years, even by some of the founders of this world order. But this international order has shown us that dialogue and understanding bring far more peace and prosperity than isolation and confrontation. Therefore, we should not carelessly throw it overboard, but we must defend it – we must improve it.

If we do not want the world to continue fragmenting, if isolated political and technological spaces arise between which there is no trust, no interfaces, no understanding, then we must take the initiative for dialogue ourselves. A dialogue that, despite all differences, makes a serious effort to understand, that aims for understanding and believes in the logic of cooperation. Because we need collaboration and cooperation today, more than ever, I am convinced. Precisely because the digital revolution raises similar questions in all our countries and shakes up our relationship with one another, it is about nothing less than the question of what order should actually guide the future world. To conceive such an order, we need dialogue about common ethical minimum standards that can provide a normative foundation across all borders.

It would indeed be surprising if the many different influences of our partners in Europe, America, China, and beyond did not lead to different answers to new challenges. And it would be naive to believe that from national rules and principles for social networks, for mass data analysis, for autonomous systems, up to weapons of war or the technical foundations of the internet, a meaningful whole would somehow emerge in the end. That is not the case! And it will not be! And if we do not want the law of the jungle to prevail in the digital future, then we must take care of a functioning international order and advocate for others to work with us on it.

International understanding of ethical standards for digitalization is becoming increasingly important if we want a seamless, open, free, and creative internet in the future, if digitalization is not to end up as a dystopia. In many areas of the digital realm, we still lack institutions and rules that enable cooperation and collaboration between states and societies; a common foundation on which trust can grow, because trust is essential if division of labor economic relationships are to be maintained in the future world. They secure our prosperity. It may indeed separate us in many ways. In many areas, our interests may cross each other. Many differences may seem, from today’s perspective, quite insurmountable. But the attempt to agree on fundamental minimum standards of an ethics of digitalization is, in my view, worth all our efforts. And that is precisely why we are here today.

We want to jointly launch an international scientific project in the coming hours with the Mercator Foundation and the Network of Centers that deals with the global foundations of an ethics of digitalization.

We in Germany and Europe certainly have our own ideas as well. Here I can say: For me, the ethics of digitalization is first and foremost an ethics of freedom!

Technology should serve humanity and lead to greater self-determination. Virtual reality must not become the only reality; it must never replace our public spaces and human encounters. Digital technology should overcome oppression, alleviate poverty, enable debates, not poison them, spread education and enlightenment, and, if possible, protect the environment and conserve resources. Digitalization should increase our freedom and overcome unfreedom. Once again: Digitalization should serve humanity – and not the other way around.

At the same time, every ethics of freedom is also an ethics of responsibility: freedom needs rules – and new freedoms need new rules. It is about finding the right balance between freedom and regulation, and establishing that is the task of politics. This applies to us in Germany, but I believe it also applies to our common international order. Yes, it is true, we all bring our own influences, our own perspectives on the world to the table. But we do not make progress if we say: "I am right, therefore all others are wrong." We cannot expect that our own perspective will be easily understood by others, let alone accepted as given. All the more important it is to seek dialogue on these issues. Because only if we seriously try to understand each other can we find commonalities, draft minimum standards and rules. That is what we all should be striving for!

Dear fellows, dear researchers, dear conference participants, in the coming months, you as technologists and social scientists will try to provide common impulses and answers for the international debate. Your work, I can assure you, should not remain an academic exercise, quite the opposite. Whether in science, in business, in civil society, whether in politics in your home countries or in the political search for global minimum standards: We all need your advice.

Successful politics, both national and international, balances interests and finds, with the help of ethical principles, rules for a flourishing coexistence. Digitalization fundamentally changes our society, the life of each individual. Therefore, it also demands an ethical framework. How much data do we disclose? What rules apply on the internet? What decisions does the algorithm make? What happens to my job when the business goes digital? These are the questions that people expect answers to. And rightly so. That is why we need this debate about an ethics of digitalization. What is crucial, above all, is that we understand ethics not just as an individual appeal to virtue, but as the foundation of better politics. Your normative impulse, which you give us, should enable good rules and laws, should create a common basis for the coexistence of peoples. That and nothing less is our goal.

You now have the privilege of dedicating yourselves as fellows to these very questions. Dare to think and write outside the beaten paths! Contribute your ideas to this great societal debate! And above all, do not shy away from politics – nowhere else are experts like you so urgently needed! I can assure you of that!

Thank you very much for coming, thank you to all those who are following us online today, and we will now begin the discussion on the podium.