Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the presentation of the certificate of discharge to the judge of the Federal Constitutional Court Johannes Masing and the awarding of the Great ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

13 July 2020 · Presentation of the certificate of discharge to Judge Johannes Masing of the Federal Constitutional Court and the award of the Great Cross of Merit

Context
Steinmeier addressed a ceremony at Bellevue Palace to present the certificate of discharge to Federal Constitutional Court Judge Johannes Masing and award him the Great Cross on July 13, 2020.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court, certificate of discharge ceremony, Johannes Masing, freedom of expression and information, data protection law, right to be forgotten, fundamental rights, women's equality and representation, balance of freedom and security, BND surveillance, constitutional complaints, digitalization and law
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,816
52nd percentile
Sentences
77
50th percentile
Readability
41
37th percentile
Grade
13.3
60th percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Ceremonial 41%40%
  • Institutional 36%35%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

77 sentences in 19 paragraphs

Now it has finally worked out before the summer break! My hope has indeed come true that we would see each other again in this hall in a relatively short time.

Here in this hall, almost exactly a year ago, a little more than a year ago, we commemorated the hundredth anniversary of the introduction of women's suffrage. We had a particularly interesting symposium with very engaged guests. And their message was: We have made significant progress on the path to equality – but we have not yet achieved it. There is still much to be done, and now, a year later, in the midst of the pandemic, the Berlin sociologist Jutta Allmendinger states that the pandemic has set back women's equality by decades. It is women who bear the burdens of combating the pandemic, especially in families. I hope that Ms. Allmendinger's prognosis does not come true.

The Federal Council could not have known all of this. Nevertheless, with its election on July 3, it has sent a clear signal: it has elected a woman as your successor, dear Mr. Masing. Christian Rath commented on this in Legal Tribune Online, stating that women are now significantly overrepresented, as the Federal Constitutional Court now consists of nine women and seven men. I cannot recall when journalists in the past commented on the opposite situation, which, as is well known, has continuously prevailed, as an overrepresentation of men? But that is just a side note.

Dear Mr. Masing, when you were appointed as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court twelve years ago, the then Federal President said that you would return to your dissertation topic at the Federal Constitutional Court: The multitude of constitutional complaints is part of the "mobilization of citizens for the law" – as stated in the title of your doctoral thesis. I think, as musical as you are, you could sing a song today about the many constitutional complaints you have dealt with as a reporter over the past twelve years: 4,423 have been counted!

Constitutional complaints – at least in my view – establish the reputation of the Federal Constitutional Court among citizens. And you have significantly contributed to this reputation in your area of responsibility. Because you were responsible for the right to free expression, the freedom of information, broadcasting, and the press, for the general right of personality, as well as large parts of data protection law, and until last year also for assembly law. Prominent – politically significant – areas that, in light of the unstoppable advance of digitalization, influence the daily lives of many people today, but which also often need to be legally redefined or adjusted.

Thus, you had to deal with the "right to be forgotten" on the internet and prepared two decisions of the Federal Constitutional Court that are of particular significance for citizens because they strengthen fundamental rights protection for life situations that are largely dominated legally by European Union law. And if the public impression prevails that the Federal Constitutional Court is particularly Eurosceptic, then one should take a closer look at these decisions. Because in the mentioned decisions, the Federal Constitutional Court incorporates European Union law and specifically the European Charter of Fundamental Rights alongside German fundamental rights as a standard for its review in constitutional complaints. This expansion of the review standard of constitutional complaints has significantly improved the legal protection options for citizens in matters shaped by EU law. I believe: a real advancement. The interpretation-hungry constitutional law doctrine is in an uproar; it has been said that long articles will be written about this innovation for years to come. You yourself will contribute to that.

Not quite as satisfied as the citizens may have been at times in politics with the procedures and decisions you oversaw as a reporter. Your department dealt with questions that fundamentally concern the balancing of freedom and security: How far do data protection and freedom extend when it comes to combating crime or international terrorism?

As a reporter, you had to deal with data retention in 2010, the anti-terror file in 2013, and the new regulations of the BKA Act in 2016. And in one of the last decisions you prepared, it was about the foreign-foreign telecommunications surveillance by the Federal Intelligence Service. According to this, the surveillance of the telecommunications of foreigners abroad by the BND in its current form under the BND Act violates the fundamental right to telecommunications secrecy and press freedom. But those who take these decisions seriously will find that the Federal Constitutional Court has always recognized state security interests and opened up possibilities to meet legitimate security concerns. The Federal Constitutional Court also pointed out here that a constitutional design of the legal foundations for foreign-foreign telecommunications surveillance is possible.

Dear Mr. Masing, the few references to the procedures you oversaw and shaped make it clear: you embody the liberal spirit of our Basic Law. And your biography also reflects this liberalism and openness.

With a lawyer as a father, the law was somewhat in your cradle. Nevertheless, you initially studied languages in Grenoble. In addition, you possess a pronounced musical talent: you played in the Army Music Corps during your time in the Bundeswehr, and to this day you sing in a choir. But what impresses me most is that alongside the already demanding study of law and philosophy, you also passed the diploma music teacher examination in piano at the State University of Music in Freiburg and then the artistic final examination at the Stuttgart University of Music.

You continue to pursue your language talent to this day and are learning, also out of family connection, the Polish language. I know how difficult that is. I have failed at it. Also because of this lived German-Polish friendship, you pay particular attention to the development of justice and the rule of law in our neighboring country – with the same concern that also troubles me, as I know from our conversations and encounters over the past year.

You committed yourself to constitutional law early on and were able to draw on rich experience when you joined the Federal Constitutional Court. Your academic career began after the two state legal examinations in 1989 as a research assistant at the Institute for Public Law at the University of Freiburg. At the same time, you worked as a freelance employee in a law firm. And I can imagine the four years as a research assistant in the "Third Senate" under Ernst-Wolfgang Böckenförde to be particularly inspiring. From 1998 until the summer of 2007, you were a full professor in Augsburg, and since then you have been a university lecturer in Freiburg. Although teaching may have taken a back seat in recent years as a constitutional judge, your annual seminars in Sitten in the Wallis are still praised: alongside the intensive academic exchange in the hut, skiing and the shared cheese fondue hold a special place. The students in Freiburg will surely be pleased to have more of Johannes Masing again!

In Karlsruhe, on the other hand, you will be missed – as a valued colleague and unpretentious boss. You are very popular with your staff in the department because you not only engage with them professionally but also maintain personal contact and, above all, always have an open ear for them. And although participation in the Senate's deliberations is denied to all of us, the discussions there are among the best-kept secrets of this republic, your intellectual sharpness, your enjoyment of argument and factual dispute, your persistent and steadfast struggle for the right decision are praised.

Dear Mr. Masing, twelve years is a long time and is now coming to an end. You enjoy traveling, as I have heard, even to Mongolia. You will have a bit more time for exotic travel destinations. But I am sure: we will continue to hear from you, as you will not retire but remain closely connected to academia. Today, I have the honor of presenting you, as a visible recognition of your services to our state – after the presentation of the retirement certificate – with the Grand Cross of Merit with Star and Shoulder Ribbon of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany.

I would like to invite you, esteemed Mr. Masing – together with President Harbarth – to come forward.

Dear Ms. Härtel, the Federal Council elected you as a judge of the Federal Constitutional Court last Friday as Mr. Masing's successor. The Federal Council has elected a highly qualified jurist who will be an asset to the court. I find it equally important that thirty years after reunification, someone from the now not-so-new states is coming to the Federal Constitutional Court. Because with you, for the first time, a female judge of the Federal Constitutional Court has been elected who can refer to an originally East German biography and will bring this into her court routine. Born in 1972 in Saxony-Anhalt, in Staßfurt, you experienced reunification during your high school years. You studied law at the Georg-August University of Göttingen. After the first and second state examinations in law, you became a doctoral fellow of the German Federal Foundation for the Environment and completed your doctorate with a thesis on agricultural and environmental law. Your habilitation was completed with a work on "European Legislation" in 2005. After academic positions in Göttingen and Bochum, you went to the European University Viadrina in Frankfurt (Oder) and served as its Vice President from 2015 to 2017. There, you hold the chair for public law, administrative law, European law, environmental law, agricultural law, and food economics law and lead the research center for digital law. Your research and teaching focus includes, among other things, data protection law and digital law. You also maintain contacts with practice as a member of the Digital Advisory Board of the State of Brandenburg and as a part-time judge at the Higher Administrative Court of Berlin-Brandenburg.

You are now entering the First Senate of the Federal Constitutional Court and will, like your predecessors in this position – an impressive line: Konrad Hesse, Dieter Grimm, Wolfgang Hoffmann-Riem, and Johannes Masing – help shape the jurisprudence of the Federal Constitutional Court. Our legal system faces great challenges in digitalization, and complex issues are awaiting decision. I am sure that with your research focus in digital law, you are well prepared and will quickly find your way into your new office. Much work awaits you, dear Ms. Härtel, but I am confident that your colleagues will make your start in your new position easy.

I would like to invite you – together with President Harbarth – to come forward for your appointment and then for your swearing-in after the appointment.

Dear Ms. Härtel, on behalf of everyone, as you have just heard, heartfelt congratulations on your new position!