Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the memorial ceremony for the 40th anniversary of the Oktoberfest attack on September 26, 2020, in Munich:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

27 September 2020 · Memorial ceremony for the 40th anniversary of the Oktoberfest attack · Munich, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a memorial ceremony in Munich on the 40th anniversary of the 1980 Oktoberfest bombing, honoring victims and survivors.
Main themes
1980 Oktoberfest bombing, right-wing terrorism, victims and survivors, commemoration and memory, unanswered questions and justice, financial support for victims, investigative failures, German reunification, right-wing extremism, solidarity with victims
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,305
64th percentile
Sentences
136
77th percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.82
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
60th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 44%42%
  • Social 32%30%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Geopolitical 8%7%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

136 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Four decades have passed since the attack on the Oktoberfest in 1980. Almost two generations and much history lie between this September 26 and today. From two German states, one has now become. Next week we will celebrate thirty years of unity. An eternity seems to have passed. And yet, this terrible day is close to us. Its horror is once again close to all of us, especially now, after the murder of Walter Lübcke, after the acts in Halle and Hanau.

But above all for you, for the victims and survivors, this September 26, 1980, remains infinitely close, an indelible date. A deep cut, a pain that does not go away. No one escapes the shadow that terror casts over a life. The past forty years weigh heavily on the victims, on investigators, politicians, lawyers, and prosecutors – on each of them.

In a very special way, however, it weighs on you, the surviving victims, the relatives who have lost children, mothers, or fathers.

How is a seven-year-old supposed to forget the image of his severely injured mother? The impression of helplessness that his father, the adults around him at that time, made on him? How could he forget the firefighter who wanted to pray the Our Father with him?

How is a passionate mountaineer, whose foot and back were shredded by the bomb, supposed to forget that in the long years after the attack, she only saw mountain peaks in photographs and instead had to learn to walk again with great difficulty?

And above all: How do the mothers, fathers, and children continue to live whose loved ones lost their lives? In whose lives a gap was torn that could never be closed again? Who had to bear the pain of their loss and the anger that their questions remained unanswered? Questions, namely, who inflicted this pain on them and why?

Yes, forty years later, we must shamefully admit: Many questions remain unanswered. Questions that a careful investigation should have answered. Questions that were not answered in the first instance and could no longer be answered in the second. This open wound remains. All the more, we are today obliged to support the survivors beyond the criminal investigation. How do they live, how are they today? Who alleviates their pain, who helps them in their daily lives?

These questions have also long gone unasked or remained unanswered. They were the subject of decades-long disputes and a source of much disappointment and despair for the relatives and victims.

I am therefore glad and grateful that the affected individuals, after forty years, are now receiving financial support beyond what has been achieved so far, which they have been waiting for so long. Mr. Mayor, you mentioned it. The fund of 1.2 million euros that the federal government, the Free State of Bavaria, and the City of Munich will now establish is a late but important sign of solidarity with the victims.

Beyond practical solidarity, we have a second obligation: to remember, to keep the memory alive, to mourn and to commemorate together. And therefore, I would like to thank you, the survivors and the relatives of the victims, from the bottom of my heart for being here today, for speaking to us and with us. We need your words and your testimony as we remember the victims of this attack, both the dead and the survivors.

I thank the City of Munich and the youth union for making this and other previous memorial events possible.

I thank Ulrich Chaussy, who has not rested in the past forty years, who never accepted the contradictions between witness statements, evidence, and investigation results, and who, despite all adversities, continued to dig and research.

My thanks go to Werner Dietrich, who, as a representative of the co-plaintiffs, gave a voice to the victims, tirelessly fought for a reopening of the proceedings, and ultimately achieved it – on the third attempt.

Yes, and I also thank the Bavarian Minister of the Interior, Joachim Herrmann, and the Bavarian state government for supporting this reopening of the proceedings.

My thanks go to all of you because you have done what is in your power to illuminate the blind spot of the events and to contribute to clarifying the background. Although the reopened investigations could no longer answer the open questions, they led to a clear classification by the Federal Prosecutor General: The attack on the Oktoberfest in 1980 was a right-wing terrorist attack. This realization makes a difference. Like every realization, it makes us freer. It was necessary – and it was a gain.

For the inadequate clarification of this act of terror – it not only pains the victims of that time. Our democratic community, our rule of law bears a wound from it – to this day. The connections of the perpetrator Gundolf Köhler to the right-wing extremist paramilitary group Hoffmann were already known in 1980.

However, after the reopening of the investigation in 2014, the evidence for a proof, such as DNA traces, was missing. Important, perhaps decisive pieces of evidence were lacking. The involvement of the Hoffmann paramilitary group or other right-wing extremist networks could no longer be proven. The failure to clarify where clarification was possible and necessary is inexcusable and a failure that touches the trust in investigative authorities and the judiciary.

Nothing like this should ever happen again in Germany! This realization is something we would have wished for ourselves, all together, as a lesson from Munich. A wish that was not to be fulfilled. In 2011, we learned of the murder series of the NSU. Ten people were murdered for right-wing extremist motives, without any serious investigations ever being conducted in that direction.

Have right-wing extremist networks been too rarely recognized and even less taken seriously in law enforcement? The history of right-wing extremist crimes and murder attacks in our country allows for two answers. Either the realization that these perpetrators also have an environment, are embedded in networks or are inspired by them, only emerged late – too late – or this realization was willfully ignored.

If we want to do justice to the victims of the attack forty years ago, then remembering them must also be a reflection on ourselves, a reflection on mistakes, on omissions, and on blind spots in the clarification of right-wing extremist attacks in the past. This reflection includes asking whether there were typical, recurring deficits in law enforcement and whether they may still exist.

We know: Right-wing extremist networks exist. The murder series of the NSU has shed light on this blind spot in law enforcement. It has shown – even in the judgment of security authorities – that investigations run into a dead end when they do not, as they should, take place unreservedly, but are guided by bias and prejudice; it has shown that victims and perpetrators are confused when investigators follow resentments; that patterns of crime and backgrounds are not recognized when investigative authorities do not share their findings.

Mistakes like these can turn law enforcement into its opposite. Yes, they endanger the democratic rule of law. Therefore, we must recognize and correct them – with all urgency and seriousness. Because the perpetrators and accomplices, who act out of racist, inhuman motives, who use hate, violence, and bombs, who commit serial murders, who mock their victims and deny responsibility for their actions, have a goal. This goal is all of us. It is our community, society, our free order – an order that they mock as a "system," which is to be destroyed. Their goal is to teach us fear.

We will not be forced into this ambush. We recognize the threat and overcome the fear. We stand together and help the victims and the survivors feel safe and secure again, among us.

When I think of the autumn of 1980, when the attack on the Oktoberfest was carried out, I remember the film by Margarethe von Trotta, which came to theaters shortly thereafter: "Bleierne Zeit."

The kidnapping and murder of Hanns Martin Schleyer, the drama surrounding the hijacked Lufthansa plane Landshut, and the suicides of the leading members of the RAF – all of this was just three years back in October 1980. The German Autumn, as this oppressive time in September and October 1977 is still called today, lay long, paralyzing, and leaden over our country.

In this rough atmosphere, a new Bundestag was elected in 1980. Those who experienced this time remember an extremely polarized election campaign, characterized by hard rhetorical duels and a political climate that was tense to the utmost. The opponents were Franz Josef Strauß and Helmut Schmidt. Two men who were political adversaries but who, as we know today, respected each other.

In the 1980 election campaign, no one would have thought that their political rivalry would one day lead to personal appreciation. The bitter disputes that Schmidt and Strauß engaged in during this election campaign, even more so the tumult and riots that accompanied this election campaign, made such a notion seem utterly impossible. The contrasts seemed too stark, the rhetoric too hurtful, the rift too deep. Between the individuals and between the political camps.

In this heated, hostile atmosphere, the perpetrator of September 26, 1980, detonated the bomb – nine days before the election date.

Even forty years later, the images emerge from memory: The chaos, the screams, the blood. Twelve people were murdered, 213 injured, many of them so severely that they fought for their lives for days in Munich hospitals. The Oktoberfest continued. It was only interrupted for 24 hours on the day of the memorial service.

However, the political disputes did not even pause for an hour. They intensified. The remaining days until the Bundestag election on October 5 were additionally marked by party disputes over political responsibility for the attack – the instrumentalization of the attack in the election campaign in both directions. Both sides attributed shared responsibility for the attack to each other and threatened with defamation lawsuits.

It is this situation that I mean when I speak of the ambush of terror. Perpetrators kill ruthlessly. Their victims are merely a means to an end. The end is only achieved when the target of destruction – the political order – shows the intended reaction. The goal of the right-wing extremist terrorist attack forty years ago was exactly what occurred: that democrats would be embroiled in disputes over responsibility for the act of terror. Worse still, that they would assign blame to each other.

That this dispute, these mutual accusations – at least among the democratic parties of our country – have been overcome speaks to the democratic culture and civility of our country. Whether the lesson has been learned permanently remains open. It depends on whether the democratic parties respect the important distinction between opposition and controversy on the one hand and enmity, hatred, and contempt on the other in the future as well. Controversy and even sharp confrontation are needed in every democracy, indeed. However, mockery, hatred, and contempt create a climate in which some feel encouraged to resort to violence.

This threat has not diminished forty years after Munich. Three days ago, I spoke in Berlin with relatives of the victims of the cold-blooded murders in Hanau. In two weeks, the attack on the synagogue in Halle will be commemorated.

Let us therefore keep the memory of Munich alive – also of the mistakes that were made. Only those who know their mistakes will be able to correct them. Because the same applies to Hanau and Halle: We may know the specific perpetrators. But that does not free us from the obligation to explore their motives, investigate their environment, and illuminate the networks with which they were connected.

Turning a blind eye is no longer allowed. Not after the Oktoberfest attack, not after the NSU trial, not after the threatening letters from NSU 2.0, not after weapons finds and enemy lists of so-called prepper groups with connections to reservists of the Bundeswehr and members of security authorities, not after the uncovering of a right-wing extremist chat group within the police in North Rhine-Westphalia.

For me, it is clear: Alarmism does not get us anywhere. But self-soothing is a danger. It is about the integrity of our rule-of-law institutions. We must protect them – for the future of our democracy!

I trust our police. I trust the many officers who stand up for justice and democracy every day and who are proud to protect freedom. I have met and spoken with many of them. I know what they do. They need this trust, and they deserve it. Enemies of freedom and democracy must not be tolerated in the police. Every effort must be made to expose right-wing extremist networks wherever they exist. Police leadership and political decision-makers must not tolerate a climate in which such networks can emerge and be covered by others.

This is our common interest. But I am convinced: It also corresponds to the will of the overwhelming majority of police officers that their reputation and the trust placed in them should not be damaged by constitutional enemies within their own ranks.

Right-wing extremism has deep roots in our society. The memory of the many right-wing extremist terrorist acts committed even after 1980 and the large number of their victims must find an appropriate place in the collective memory of our country. Today should be an occasion for us to promote and keep this memory alive.

The right-wing terrorist murders of the past decades were not the work of the confused. The perpetrators were embedded in networks of hate and violence or were incited to their acts by them. We must track down these networks. We must fight them – more decisively than before!

Thank you.