Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the ninth forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" on June 29, 2020, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

5 July 2020 · Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy · Forum Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the ninth Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy in Berlin on June 29, 2020, examining how German democracy fared during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Main themes
Democracy under COVID-19, public space and freedom, trust in democratic institutions, digital public sphere, civil solidarity and responsibility, restrictions on civil liberties, pandemic governance, authoritarian vs. democratic responses, children and education, police and public order
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,464
67th percentile
Sentences
114
69th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
11.7
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 50%50%
  • Institutional 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Not in focus 0%

114 sentences in 33 paragraphs

"Test Case Corona – How is Our Democracy Doing?"

A forum is a public space, a place where many different people with mostly different views come together, where many meet and exchange ideas. This has been the case since ancient times, and in this respect, this morning's forum is somewhat atypical. Because, as you can see, we do not have a large audience here; the hall is sparsely filled. I find it unfortunate that not more people can be here and participate in the discussion. But we want to continue to maintain distance to help tame the virus.

This is a special forum, but it is certainly not a ghost game. My guests are far too lively and clearly positioned for that. I am pleased that they have come to us today: the writer Herta Müller, the philosopher Rainer Forst, the political scientist Daniel Ziblatt, with whom I will discuss on the podium shortly. And in the first and only row, the virologist Marylyn Addo, the sociologist Heinz Bude, the legal scholar Anna-Bettina Kaiser, the journalist Elisabeth von Thadden, and the patroness of the German Children and Youth Foundation – my wife, Mrs. Elke Büdenbender, who focuses on the topic of children and education.

I also welcome a few representatives of the media here in the hall. And of course, all of you at the screens, wherever you are watching us. A warm welcome to the "Bellevue Forum on the Future of Democracy"!

The pandemic is testing democracies as well as authoritarian regimes worldwide. Today, we want to talk about how our democracy has fared so far in the fight against the virus, how it has coped with the restriction of freedoms, and what challenges it now faces. Before we dive into the conversation, let me highlight a few aspects that are particularly close to my heart. Just a few sketches on that:

Vibrant places that suddenly become deserted; barricades at playgrounds; parliaments with plenty of space between the chairs – these are images of a crisis that have left their mark. Even though temporary restrictions on our freedom of movement and assembly were well justified; even though they were discussed and reviewed by the public and the courts; even though a large majority supported them to protect health and life: The Corona crisis has made it clear to us that public space is vital for our democracy.

Democracy needs places that are open to all, where we can move freely, meet, and exchange ideas equally. It needs places where the hopes, fears, and conflicts of our diverse society become visible, where discontent and protest can also be expressed, as long as it happens peacefully and the state's monopoly on violence is respected. Squares, parks, cafés; schools, training centers, and universities; the shops around the corner, theaters, and cinemas; clubs, parties, and citizens' councils – all of these are places where we see each other, where we talk, argue, and thus live democracy.

In these days, as we gradually reclaim public space, we rediscover what we have in this public space. I wish that we protect it, nurture it, keep it alive and accessible to all, in the city and in the countryside. It is important to me to say once again today, and for good reason: It is also police officers who protect the peaceful coexistence on our streets and squares – especially when conflicts over the use of this public space are to be feared. All of you who put your health and lives on the line in serious situations deserve respect, not hatred and the vilification of an entire profession.

During the lockdown, we also experienced that we – in private as well as in public – are also dependent on the digital space. Therefore, we should now fight all the more decisively to ensure that it is not poisoned by hatred and denigration. Our democracy also needs a digital public sphere where respect, tolerance, and reason prevail.

You know, the pandemic is not over; it will occupy us for a long time. In these days, we see how fragile the successes in the fight against the virus are, how quickly infection rates can rise again. The social and economic consequences of the pandemic are neither resolved nor fully foreseeable. But as a preliminary conclusion, after the first weeks, it can be said: We have succeeded in a societal effort to flatten the infection curve and support those who were hardest hit by the crisis. And we did not achieve this effort because a strong hand forced us to, but because we wanted to do it, out of solidarity and a sense of responsibility. I hope that is true, and we will certainly verify that in the discussion shortly.

Some things we could see, some even measure: In a time of disturbing uncertainty, we saw that many people in our country have trust in democratic institutions. And we saw that trust in the acting politicians at all levels even grew during the weeks of crisis management, if the surveys are correct.

Trust, as we know, cannot be mandated. Trust in democracy includes the self-confidence of citizens. It is not blind trust, but one that is also based on skepticism, but above all on one's own judgment. It can only grow when politics is tangible. And that is exactly what we experienced in the crisis: Rarely has politics been so immediate, so vivid, so effective before our eyes as in the last weeks.

We were all, in a sense, live participants in the workshop of politics. We followed how parliamentarians and leaders at the federal and state levels had to take responsibility and make decisions, despite all uncertainties. We saw how important it is for them to explain the reasons for their actions; that they do not conceal conflicts of interest and injustices; that they disclose who they consult; that they also talk about their uncertainty and fallibility.

I believe that in the Corona crisis, citizens and politics have indeed come a little closer together, despite all the rules of distance. Whether that trust will last after the crisis will also depend on how open and transparent the political space remains. I hope that the tangibility of politics motivates even more people to engage within and outside democratic institutions for the common good. Because that politics makes a difference and that ultimately it depends on each and every one of us was something many experienced during this crisis.

The past weeks have shown that faith in reason, trust in science are special sources of strength for our democracy.

Hundreds of thousands have witnessed how researchers are feeling their way, literally feeling their way towards secured knowledge, how they repeatedly check and correct their statements and methods, how they also clarify the limits of their knowledge. Following this is a test of patience, because we all wish for a quick victory over the virus, progress in knowledge by the hour. But it also fascinates us, and it shows: Science is a permanent learning process; it thrives on rational debate, and that is precisely what connects it to democracy.

I am glad that in our country, large parts of politics and the public orient themselves to scientific findings, and that it is also clear: Science cannot and should not replace democratic debates and decisions, but rather improve the resilience of political decisions. I am equally glad that politics in the crisis is evaluated based on what it contributes to the solution, that seriousness and objectivity count in political discourse when it matters.

We also experience in the crisis how fragile the belief in reason and discourse has become in some parts of society. Where scientists are attacked and threatened, where findings are denied, conspiracy theories are spread, and aluminum hats are considered remedies, our opposition is needed everywhere. And the Corona crisis gives us the best arguments to advocate for science and democracy!

In the crisis, we see how much our democracy thrives on diversity of opinion. Rarely has the hunger for credible information and the need for fair debate been as great as in the last weeks. And rarely have so many voices from very different parts of society been heard.

We should not forget after the crisis how important critical, reliable, diverse, and well-informed media are for a vibrant public sphere and trust in politics. And we should also not forget how important it is to argue publicly.

Even irritating and crazy things must be able to be expressed in democracy. That may be exhausting, but democrats should adhere to the standards of rational criticism even when dealing with those who celebrate irrationality. However, where hatred and violence come into play; where human rights are violated; where the openness of democracy itself is attacked, democratic tolerance also ends.

We must stand up to those who act against all reason for political reasons and misuse the insecurity of people to sow doubt about democratic processes or against democracy as a whole; we must stand up to those who instrumentalize worries and fears to create a mood against the "system," the alleged power cartel of politics, media, and science, against the "real," the true people. Even in the Corona crisis and in the time that follows, we must remain vigilant. Let us work together to prevent viruses of anti-democracy from spreading! That we form democratic antibodies, as Professor Forst would say, is the task of our time!

The Corona virus has made us aware of how fragile what we call "normal life" is. The virus can affect anyone, but that does not mean that everyone is affected in the same way! Not for the first time do we experience: The crisis is not the great equalizer. This crisis has also made inequalities even more pronounced, and many young people are once again worried about their future. We heard this recently in conversations out here with young people – with students and apprentices.

At the same time, countless citizens in our country are showing solidarity in entirely new ways, protecting the particularly vulnerable, helping those who have fallen into distress. And many wish for a state that affirms this spirit of solidarity, not repressively or patronizingly, but supportively and encouragingly. My thanks go to all those who are there for others and look out for others. You all strengthen the cohesion that we need not only in the crisis but also in the time that follows when we must shape the restart.

That solidarity is anything but a given is something we are also experiencing in these weeks. Those who act irresponsibly and endanger others, whether out of impatience, selfishness, or ignorance, jeopardize what we have achieved together in the past weeks. The Corona crisis once again vividly illustrates how much we in politics and society depend on each other. A good coexistence is only possible if we care about more than just ourselves.

Trust, reason, diversity of opinion, solidarity – these are the strengths of our democracy that have been demonstrated in our collective response to the virus. I believe we should express this confidently, especially to those who doubt democracy or belittle it. Here at this point, in many forums that preceded today's event, I have often talked about the fascination of the authoritarian that we observe in many, in too many parts of the world, including parts of Europe. This danger is not averted. But one can dare to make this interim assessment: In the Corona crisis, the authoritarian has lost its allure!

It is unmistakable: In the fight against the pandemic, neither bold slogans nor bravado help, neither demagoguery nor overestimation of oneself. In the fight against the virus, it does not help if numbers are falsified or not even collected to make one's regime look better. And it is unscrupulous when elected governments misuse the fight against the virus to permanently eliminate freedoms and seek to cement their own power.

The past weeks have shown: Our democracy can respond to existential threats quickly, decisively, and powerfully. Together, we are capable of changing course in a very short time, leaving familiar paths, and making decisions even under conditions of uncertainty, admitting and correcting mistakes if necessary. And large parts of society have demonstrated the ability to show solidarity when called upon! I believe this experience can give us courage and confidence when it comes to tackling other challenges that also require a fundamental rethink and a politics of change.

In recent weeks, the development of infection rates and the fear of a severe recession have kept us on edge daily. Therefore, it has almost gone unnoticed that a fundamental debate about the future of our society has also begun. The question: How should we proceed afterwards? Many in our country are currently asking this question. I believe that to find good answers, we need above all one thing that has been demonstrated during the Corona crisis: the will and readiness to change course.

Whether this will persists after the crisis, whether a general fatigue with crises will set in, is currently an open question. Unlike the pandemic, disasters such as climate change unfold gradually and almost imperceptibly for some, and many of us know the longing for a return to "the old normal" all too well. Yes, it is unclear whether democracies will be willing to change course even after the Corona crisis.

But I am convinced: We need this will to change course. We need it if we want to pursue climate policies that implement the goals we have set for ourselves, secure future-proof jobs, and leave a livable planet for our children and grandchildren. We need it if we want to make the European Union future-proof, and I believe it is already evident in the bold European plans for recovery. And we need this will to change course, not least if we want to protect health and peace and create more global justice, together with neighbors in Europe and the world.

In the fight against the pandemic, in which states have turned more inward and closed their borders, we have once again become aware of how much we need the exchange of knowledge and cooperation across borders, especially when we want to tackle global crises. We can all see: Isolation, division, and unilateral actions do not lead to a better future.

What the world will look like after the crisis is open. What it should look like, we must debate and decide in democracy, under the conditions of equality and freedom. With that, I want to open the space for our discussion. I think there are enough questions on the table. Once again, a warm welcome to all of you at the "Bellevue Forum on the Future of Democracy"!