Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of documenta on June 18, 2022, in Kassel:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

21 June 2022 · Opening of documenta fifteen · Kassel, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the opening ceremony of documenta fifteen in Kassel on June 18, 2022, engaging with controversies over antisemitism and artistic freedom.
Main themes
Freedom of art, antisemitism and Israel's recognition, documenta fifteen, Global South curatorial perspective, limits of artistic expression, colonialism and postcolonial identity, climate change and environmental pollution, art and political activism, social media and public discourse, boycott of Israel, contemporary art and society
Duration
~12 min
44th percentile
Words
1,492
44th percentile
Sentences
89
57th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
60th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 37%34%
  • Ceremonial 21%19%
  • Geopolitical 17%16%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

89 sentences in 26 paragraphs

I want to be open: In the past few weeks, I was not sure whether I would be here with you today.

It has been a good tradition since the first documenta, since the year 1955, for the Federal President to be present on the opening day in Kassel. Because the documenta is not only the most significant exhibition series of contemporary art: Every five years, it also engages with society by making the state of society itself the subject. The documenta has never been solely national; international art has always been present. And this year, for the first time, a curatorial collective from the Global South is responsible for this world art event – thus, documenta fifteen also brings the debate about global present here to Kassel.

It is fitting that I have just come from Indonesia: A country that has undergone a truly profound political and social transformation in recent decades. A country that has fought for its own identity and independence after a long history of foreign rule and colonization. The largest Muslim-majority democracy in the world.

But it is also a country that today feels the effects of climate change, the consequences of environmental pollution, and yes, also the effects of the Western lifestyle very directly. I have seen in Indonesia how – and under what conditions – people live on seemingly endless garbage dumps. I have seen how plastic waste is processed into bricks in an art project with the participation of the local population. A house is to be built from these bricks for the residents of the landfill – as a place for art, but also as a place for a foundation from which the people can benefit financially. Art emerges from waste. Waste becomes the future. And yet it is still waste, largely Western waste. It shamed me to see this – and at the same time impressed me.

All the more, I am pleased that an Indonesian curatorial collective has been selected for documenta fifteen. I was able to take a first look at the exhibits, and I am sure that during my tour immediately afterward, I will see even more surprising, exciting, perhaps also disturbing or offensive things.

So why my hesitation to come here today?

Rarely has a documenta provoked such a heated, such a critical debate in advance as this one. A debate in which little was argued about art, but a great deal about political messages. And I admit: The sharpness of the controversy, the irreconcilability in tone, has unsettled me.

We all know: Art cannot be had without dispute. A democratic society must not patronize artists, let alone instrumentalize them. Art has no political mandate. And politics does not determine the quality of art.

Art, on the other hand, can bring a society into conversation with itself – a conversation, by the way, that we all desperately need: A conversation striving for enlightenment, which is less promoted than suppressed in the outrage logic of social media and under the daily confession urge of many users.

So art cannot be had without dispute, but: Does that mean everything is art? Joseph Beuys would now say: "Yes!" But that cannot mean that all those who use art for their political messages remain outside of criticism. Especially not when they turn political activism into an art form. Anyone who enters the forum of politics as an artist must face not only aesthetic but also political debate and criticism. And there are limits!

To make this clear, I am speaking here today.

I have closely followed the discussion in the lead-up to the current documenta, about what art we can expect, but also about some thoughtless, careless handling of the State of Israel. Because as understandable as some criticism of Israeli policy, such as settlement construction, is: The recognition of Israel's statehood is the recognition of the dignity and security of the modern Jewish community. The recognition of their existential certainty. As the German Federal President, I affirm for my country: The recognition of Israel is the foundation and prerequisite of the debate for us!

I like to say again: Art may be offensive; it should provoke debates. More than that: The freedom of opinion and the freedom of art are the essence of our constitution. Criticism of Israeli policy is allowed. But where criticism of Israel turns into questioning its existence, the line has been crossed.

It is striking that there are likely no Jewish artists from Israel represented at this significant exhibition of contemporary art. And it disturbs me when representatives of the Global South increasingly refuse to participate in events, conferences, or festivals where Jewish Israelis are present.

A boycott of Israel amounts to a denial of existence. When independent voices from Israel are placed under a contact ban; when they are banned from the encounter and discourse of a cultural global community that otherwise prides itself on openness and freedom from prejudice; then it is more than mere ignorance. Where this happens systematically, it is a strategy of exclusion and stigmatization that cannot be separated from anti-Semitism.

Despite all this, we must look more closely, also listen, to the questions that move people in the Global South: The long colonial history of violence and exploitation and the countless blind spots in its processing. The experience of oppression and disenfranchisement. The handling of stolen cultural property. But also the already palpable, dramatic consequences of climate change with extreme weather, droughts, food shortages, and hunger.

Engaging with the legitimate interests of the Global South requires much: historical knowledge, political reason, sensitivity, seriousness, curiosity, and mutual respect. It requires, in a word: discourse.

I would have wished that all of this had been discussed before the opening of this documenta. And I regret that it was not possible to organize a direct discussion between representatives of the Global South, the Jewish community in Germany, and Israel. A discussion that might have illuminated the gaps in the postcolonial discourse among us. We do not discuss the pressing questions of the present – and the past – extraterrestrially. But in the real world, with its history of conflicts, wars, and experiences of violence. With all the deposits it has left in the perception of people and nations.

A global memory is still in the making. And it can only be convincing if it takes all memories into account. Including Jewish and Israeli memories.

This is all the more true for an exhibition venue in Germany. No one who wants to be taken seriously as a participant in the debate in Germany can speak about Israel but remain silent about six million murdered Jews. The wound of the Shoah remains open; we want it to remain visible. The suffering inflicted by Germans on Jews; the lessons learned by the descendants of the perpetrators; the miracle of reconciliation between Germany and Israel; all of this is experience that we Germans must not only contribute to a global memory but, I believe, must also contribute.

Therefore, I also address the management and shareholders of documenta today. It is part of the principle of this world art exhibition that each exhibition is curated independently. I know that. And the enormous significance of documenta as the forum of the global art community certainly also has to do with the great artistic freedom that each curator – or, as in this year, the curatorial collective – enjoys. But: The responsibility remains. Responsibility cannot be outsourced.

That is why I would very much welcome if the responsible parties of documenta would take on this demanding mediating task intensively – and also create suitable structures for it. I am quite sure: There will be no lack of support. The State Minister for Culture has also offered her assistance in this regard.

Far too many people are simplifying complicated contexts these days. There is only black or white, only "for" or "against," no differentiation, and no mutual desire to understand. Boycotting instead of discussing. But does this new rigorism really help?

The video and installation artist Leon Kahane has provided, in my opinion, a good answer to this in a guest contribution for the Süddeutsche Zeitung. Kahane wrote: "There are contradictions between the arguments and conclusions that arise from the processing of colonialism and the Shoah. These contradictions cannot be resolved. They can only be endured, discussed, and acknowledged."

And yet, Kahane writes, there are limits: "Anti-Semitism and racism are such limits."

The documenta is not only the most important but also the best place for the negotiation processes of contemporary art. I want to strengthen this place. And I want to strengthen the documenta. We need you! More urgently than the current debate suggests! It has earned the trust over decades to be the future place of a true global community of art – without boycott and without prejudice. A place of open encounter in the awareness of a shared humanity.