Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of re:publica 2019 on May 6, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

7 May 2019 · re:publica 2019 · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the re:publica 2019 digital conference in Berlin on May 6, 2019, opening the event with reflections on democracy and the digital age.
Main themes
Digital democracy and political debate culture, long-form argumentation vs. simplification, technology and democratic vulnerability, social media and disinformation, hype cycles in democracy discourse, authoritarian exploitation of digital tools, cultural pessimism about technology, history of communication technology, liberal democracy's challenges, generational divides in digital discourse
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,384
65th percentile
Sentences
126
74th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
3.07
57th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 41%41%
  • Social 24%24%
  • Technological 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

126 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Thank you for the invitation to re:publica 2019! I was very pleased to receive this invitation! I will tell you right away why. But first, I must answer the question that perhaps some of you in the audience are asking: What is a so analog institution like the Federal President doing at such a digital event as re:publica? And the particularly critical might ask: How far has this free-spirited, unbound, non-hierarchical conference come that it invites the head of state to open it? Do we have to sing the national anthem with him in the end?

No, ladies and gentlemen, I can assure you: It is not etiquette that brings us together today, but it is the matter at hand! I believe that it is indeed a common cause. For the motto of this year's re:publica, "The Praise of the Long Argument," the commitment to research, differentiation, and weighing options against ignorance, coarseness, and false simplification, this motto is a wake-up call to the political debate culture – not only online, I add, but in general: a necessary wake-up call against the zeitgeist of reduction and simplification!

That is why I am happy to be here. I have spoken more frequently during my time in office about the importance of a culture of debate for our democracy than about almost any other topic. Yes, those who appreciate differentiation, weighing options, and nuances, who allow and endure ambiguities, who want to view things from different perspectives and are willing to listen for more than a minute, in short, those who do not declare subordinate clauses as enemies, have in this Federal President a natural ally!

Since you explicitly advocate for thoroughness at this re:publica, you will surely not hold it against me if I take a bit of time at the beginning of my speech – 200 years, to be precise. A few weeks ago, we commemorated the 200th birthday of Theodor Fontane in Neuruppin – also a proponent of the long form, by the way. Some of you may have been tormented by him in school. In preparing for the Fontane celebration, I came across a wonderfully ironic episode in his late masterpiece "Der Stechlin." It deals with the decline of the old world and its customs, and of course, the impending downfall of the West is invoked – perhaps this sounds familiar to you? Why? Because an innovation in communication technology shakes the Kingdom of Prussia to its core: the telegram!

"It is such a thing with telegraphing [...]" Fontane has the old Dubslav von Stechlin say. "Brevity is supposed to be a virtue; but to be brief usually also means to be coarse. [...] The finer manners are certainly suffering now."

What I want to say is: That technology changes cultural practices and some then promptly lament the decline of manners is not new. With the distance of history, we know: Prussia did not perish because of telegraphing. So you need not fear cultural pessimism from me today. However, neither do I have naive enthusiasm. I am convinced that neither telegrams nor tweets can undermine democracy from within. But technology has long since been unable to replace democracy!

We are familiar with "Hype Cycles" from market research, concerning new technologies and products. I fear that Hype Cycles also exist in political debate, especially when it comes to democracy and digitalization. I remember a time, not long ago: Communism had collapsed, and the worldwide triumph of liberal democracy seemed unstoppable. The "end of history" was spoken of everywhere. The pioneers of the internet, especially of social media, were seen riding at the forefront of the procession towards the sunset. Boundless, non-hierarchical, and lightning-fast, digitalization was supposed to help democratization along – hopes that were particularly projected onto the so-called Arab Spring at that time.

And today? Today we have landed in the reversal. Liberal democracy is being challenged. Authoritarian forms of rule are increasingly stepping onto the world stage with confidence – and are ruthlessly exploiting digital technologies and digital efficiency gains, from big data surveillance to troll armies. Western democracies, on the other hand, seem digitally vulnerable, their election campaigns shaken by manipulation, disinformation, and polarization. Today, hardly a week goes by without a new requiem for liberal democracy appearing – and social media being blamed as the nail in the coffin.

You will not be surprised that I have never found either extreme of this narrative convincing, nor do I find it so now. I wish – and this is how I understand the impulse of re:publica – that we finally leave false dichotomies behind: It is not a question of whether the internet is a good or bad thing for democracy, whether it is the savior or the wrecking ball. And we should certainly not give voice to a contradiction between generations, between a supposedly homogeneous "net community" and the clueless "offline oldies."

The truth is: 90 percent of Germans are now active online in one form or another. And thus, political discourse on the internet has, quite soberly, become a fixed part of our democracy. By the way, it is neither in place of the classic newspaper or television talk show, the marketplace stalls, or party congress debates, nor separated from these traditional forms, but simply right in the middle. And that means, democracy can only succeed in the future if it also succeeds digitally.

That is why I spoke at the beginning of a "common cause." There are no more analog institutions and no digital events where one side supposedly does not concern the other. No, what matters is: We have only this one democracy.

If we care about the future of this democracy, then we must work together on the political debate culture online! For this impulse, I would like to express my sincere thanks to the creators of re:publica.

How can this succeed? First of all, one thing is beyond question: The internet has produced more communication on more topics with more participants than ever before. The human gain is immeasurable – for science and research, for culture and creativity, for economy and prosperity! In Fontane's time, emigration meant a farewell forever. Today, parents communicate with their children, companies with their customers, scientists with their research partners around the clock, around the world. Everywhere in the niches of the internet, great forms of collaboration, creativity, and cultural progress are emerging. And of course: This digital progress can also benefit democracy – its potentials are far from exhausted.

Nevertheless, and all the more, I wonder why the political debates I experience online so often tend to become toxic. I ask myself: What fuels the rampant loss of reason, the furious search for scapegoats? Why does the appeal to our lowest, not our best instincts find so much resonance?

It is good that re:publica gives space to such questions. It is not paternalistic, but highly relevant and necessary to ask again fundamentally and anew: What constitutes a good, democratic debate? My answer would be: Reason on one side – the willingness to convince with arguments and to be convinced by better arguments – and on the other side, civility. This means appreciation and trust, empathy and respect for a counterpart, who – despite all the individuality or anonymity that the internet knows how to protect – always has a legitimate part to contribute to the debate.

Both qualities – reason and civility – must be protected. And both need space and endurance. Of course, a tweet can also be reasonable and civilized. Many a short hashtag has sparked great and important debates. However, important debates, if they are to be good, need time. That is why I am glad that the desire for the long form seems to be growing, especially online – in podcasts, for example, in "longreads," through ever better journalistic offerings on the internet.

Reason and civility are the currency of a good debate. But every successful debate needs a foundation, and that consists of rules. The 70th anniversary of the Basic Law these days reminds us of that connection, which is older than "online" and "offline": Freedom needs rules, and new freedoms need new rules. And with freedom of expression comes responsibility for opinions.

I know that rules are controversially discussed at re:publica year after year. From the Network Enforcement Act to the Telemedia Act, from freedom of expression to the General Data Protection Regulation – there are already many rules, and we will have to argue about more.

But despite all the justified controversy – one thing holds true, and I say it especially with regard to the big platforms: Whoever does big business here in Germany and Europe must adhere to our rules! Whoever does business here must respect applicable law – and not continually test boundaries, seek loopholes, and delay implementation. Those who do so must expect consequences and penalties. And this applies generally – from data protection to competition law to criminal law!

And because today is about political debate, I add: Whoever creates a political discourse space with a platform also bears responsibility for democracy – whether they want to or not! The business model itself, the maximization of advertising revenue certainly does not bring about a maximization of debate quality. That is why democratic regulation is needed. I believe that this is now understood in Silicon Valley as well. But one thing is missing for me: After many words and announcements, after discussion rounds and photogenic political appointments, it is time for Facebook, Twitter, YouTube & Co. to finally take their responsibility for democracy seriously and put it into action!

This applies, for example, to the issue of transparency. As long as the quick lie and the serious news, the verified fact and the mere opinion, as long as reason and incitement appear indiscriminately one after the other in news feeds, demagogues have it far too easy. We need crystal-clear origin labels for information – especially when it comes to political advertising!

Whoever deliberately and data-tailored places political messages must be forced by the operator and, if necessary, by the legislator to show their face: Who exactly sent me this ad? Who financed it? What other ads is this person or organization running? In short, whose game is my counterpart actually playing, and how can I withdraw from the game?

All of this should be known by informed citizens! And by the way: Transparency about money flows and dependencies is still the most effective way to take the wind out of the sails of demagogues and populists! We have seen this in many cases, both nationally and internationally – and we should not relent in this. Because everyone who operates a political or journalistic account has already experienced this, and studies repeatedly confirm it: It is relatively small groups that create disproportionately large noise!

We must admit: Those who want to harm liberal democracy are far too often more effectively organized online than those who stand up for it. This means: We must enforce rules better, yes – but above all, the democratic majority must not withdraw and be driven away by the noise of the few! Why do we allow the haters to be so loud and the reasonable to be so quiet – that the few appear so strong and the many so weak?! Yes, even if it may be more comfortable in our own liberal comfort zone, we must hold ourselves to this standard: Let us not leave the political spaces online to the raging giants!

I know how many online, how many right here in this room are fighting for just that! I want to thank you all for your tireless, often burdensome, and generally voluntary commitment! Thank you to those who are forging new initiatives, formats, or alliances; to those who, like Nanjira Sambuli, want to overcome the digital divide; to those who help convey media literacy; to those who work towards freely accessible knowledge for all; to those who cultivate a culture of debate where it exists – or go precisely to where it is about to break, as the initiative #ichbinhier does.

It is not just about rights and rules; it is above all a strong civil society that distinguishes us in Germany. As Federal President, I wish that this strength also comes into play online, much more than I can currently recognize! I wish for more exchange between the digital civil society and the long-established analog structures, more exchange also with the institutions of politics – and this please in the mutual understanding that in this difficult tension between the freedom of the internet and the protection of the individual, no side always has the ready-made answers.

Isn't that, in the end, exactly what democracy is all about? Democracy requires that we allow each other to be in search. That is how I understand your invitation to me – and that is how I would like you to understand my speech to you. Only in discourse, in debate, in research, in the nuances do we approach solutions that no one possesses alone.

Digitalization means being connected. But democracy means being united. In democracy, we are dependent on each other in a deeper, political sense, more than just through likes or dislikes. This step from being connected to being united is what we must achieve in the future of digitalization. Whether we succeed is not determined by ever new technological leaps, but by a democratic culture of discussion and debate online, by reclaiming the political space, against the "too long, didn’t read," against pure economization and against the concentration of power in the hands of data giants. It is not about the digitalization of democracy, but the democratization of the digital – that is the most pressing task!

For this reason, I am very grateful to re:publica for its motto this year. The "Praise of the Long Argument" is more than a matter of taste. It is a deeply political appeal, for democracy is politics in long form. Populists appreciate the simple answer, the quick process, the snappy tweet. Democrats do not settle for that – and you here at re:publica obviously do not either. And that is a good thing. In this spirit, I wish us and you long debates!