Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the 12th Bellevue Forum "What Can the State Do? Lessons from the Pandemic" on November 15, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

17 November 2021 · 12th Bellevue Forum "What Can the State Do? Lessons from the Pandemic" · Bellevue Palace, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier opened the 12th Bellevue Forum in Berlin on November 15, 2021, addressing state capacity and lessons learned from the COVID-19 pandemic.
Main themes
Lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic, state capacity and crisis preparedness, vaccination urgency, fourth wave response, democracy vs. populism and technocracy, Hegel and historical learning, climate and environmental disasters, crisis memory and institutional resilience, representative democracy, public trust in government
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,771
72nd percentile
Sentences
107
66th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.24
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
36th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 60%60%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Not in focus 0%

107 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Whoever speaks about the state and lessons in a Berlin palace cannot bypass Hegel. With regard to the learning ability of societies, the great Prussian philosopher of the state rendered a judgment that is as dark as it is strict: "What experience and history teach," wrote Hegel, "is this, that peoples and governments have never learned anything from history and have acted according to lessons that could have been drawn from it."

Now, the coronavirus pandemic, as we painfully experience this autumn, is not yet history; it also defines our present these days. But if we want to refute Hegel's pessimism and draw lessons from this crisis, we must not lose any time. In these weeks, when the fourth wave hits us with brutal force, when thousands are once again struggling with the virus in intensive care units, when children, adolescents, and especially many unvaccinated individuals are getting infected, we must do more to break this wave. But in these weeks, we also become very aware that we must now begin to prepare for the future.

This morning, we want to talk primarily about what our democratic state can do and achieve. Under the impression of the dramatic coronavirus situation, I want to briefly address the citizens directly once again.

The fourth wave is hitting our country harder than it should. For we know what to do to finally leave this pandemic behind us. We can all know it. The vast majority of people in our country are getting vaccinated to protect themselves and others. Those who do not get vaccinated are putting their own health at risk, and they are endangering others. It is primarily the unvaccinated who are getting infected with the virus this autumn. It is primarily the unvaccinated who are fighting for their lives in intensive care units.

When I hear that people who are struggling with the virus in the hospital still deny that this virus exists, it deeply shakes me. It is tragic and deeply concerns me! To those who are still hesitating to get vaccinated, I want to ask directly today: What else needs to happen to convince you? I ask you once again: Get vaccinated! It is about your health, and it is about the future of our country!

Almost two years after the outbreak of the virus, in the rapid dynamics of the fourth wave, at the beginning of a new legislative period, now is the opportune moment to draw initial conclusions and prepare ourselves for future crises.

For we also know: Hegel was not entirely wrong. Our crisis memory is a short-term memory; we quickly suppress and forget bad experiences, we like to return to old paths, and public attention soon shifts to the next and the one after that topic. Even now, we must ask ourselves whether we – all of us, in politics and society – really wanted to learn enough from the second and third waves, whether the desire to finally banish thoughts of the plague stood in the way of a consistent defense against the fourth wave. It is all the more important that we remember the profound experiences of these weeks and months so that we do not neglect crisis preparedness even in "normal times." Out of sight, out of mind – that would certainly be the most shortsighted attitude after this pandemic!

How important it is that state institutions, which are built for normal circumstances, can respond quickly and effectively in times of crisis, we also saw this summer during the flood disaster in the Ahr Valley. In the age of global warming, our state must be prepared for further environmental disasters, it must be prepared for further pandemics, and it must – paradoxically – also be prepared for crises of a nature and magnitude that we cannot yet even know. Precisely because we do not know exactly what is coming our way, we must try to anticipate dangers and prepare with robust infrastructure.

In recent years, our state has been under constant crisis pressure. Financial market and debt crises, refugee and migration crises, climate crises, coronavirus crises – all of this has led to a general feeling of crisis spreading in parts of our society. And it is this feeling of crisis that increases the longing for populist or merely technocratic or expert-driven politics among some.

While some hope for an authoritarian leadership that implements the supposedly unified will of the people, which the "establishment" in politics, media, and science regularly betrays, others want to make politics merely the executing organ of an allegedly clear scientific truth, in order to act quickly and uncompromisingly. Populists and technocrats, whom I understand here as ideal types, differ, of course, in terms of values, paths, and goals, but they also have striking similarities: Both seem to consider the struggle for compromises and majorities in the institutions of representative democracy a weakness; and both justify their political vision by claiming that existential dangers must be averted.

For this reason, it is also important that we handle the concept of crisis carefully in democracy and do not constantly maintain the narrative of state failure, so that the mere rhetoric does not create the impression that the state of emergency is a permanent condition and that democracy is systematically overwhelmed, almost devoid of problem-solving competence.

First,

I believe this finding is not correct, but second,

it is still important that we learn from the pandemic and further develop our democratic state so that it can respond even more powerfully to the great challenges of the future, precisely because it relies on freedom and equality, even in difficult times.

"What can the state do?" – that is our topic today here at the twelfth "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy." I am pleased that we could come together – vaccinated, recovered, and also tested – and I am particularly looking forward to my three guests: the medical ethicist and chair of the German Ethics Council Alena Buyx, the legal and administrative scientist Laura Münkler, and the vice president of the Schleswig-Holstein State Parliament, Aminata Touré. A warm welcome to all three of you! And a warm welcome to all of you who are here in the hall and to those who are watching us on screen.

The pandemic has put our democratic rule of law and social state to hard and novel tests. After the outbreak of the virus, the federal and state governments had to act in the shortest time and under the greatest uncertainty to contain the pandemic and fulfill the state's duty to protect. At the same time, politics had to – and must – repeatedly weigh whether and to what extent restrictions on freedoms are necessary and still appropriate. It must compensate for injustices and take care of those who have been particularly hard hit by contact restrictions, closed schools, businesses, and cultural institutions. And it must preserve social cohesion under the most difficult conditions.

In our state, which, unlike Thomas Hobbes, is not an all-powerful "Leviathan," but a federal res publica, political decisions must be democratically legitimized in the interplay of governments and parliaments, federal and state levels, and must also withstand independent judicial review.

In the fight against the virus, not least the administration at the federal, state, and municipal levels is under constant stress. Whether health authorities, school administrations, or the Robert Koch Institute, whether the Federal Employment Agency, student services, or the Reconstruction Loan Corporation – the various state institutions have been and are called upon to develop hygiene concepts, to get the vaccination campaign rolling, to enable digital teaching, to process applications for state aid, and much more.

It is primarily the performance of our state that is in focus in this extraordinary situation. In recent months, we have gained deep insights into the workshops of politics and the engine rooms of administration: The struggle between the executive and legislative branches, federal and state levels; the public debate over restrictions and relaxations; also mishaps in testing and vaccination – all of this has tested the trust in the state and democracy. Crucial for this trust, as we experience, is the image that our state presents as a whole. Trust in democracy is not blind trust from subjects, but critical trust from self-confident citizens, a trust that relies on skepticism and judgment, on the self-confidence of these citizens.

The pandemic shows us what the state can do – also thanks to its responsible and committed citizens, thanks to its outstanding scientists, thanks to its economic strength, its political order, its healthcare system. That is one thing.

But of course, the crisis has also ruthlessly exposed weaknesses in our state that existed even before Corona, "like under a magnifying glass" – this old metaphor has made a remarkable comeback in recent months. Deficiencies in preparedness and foresight, backlogs in digitization, cumbersome processes in intertwined institutions – all of this contributes to missed opportunities, to often long delays before we can implement what we have already recognized as right. Corona also highlights how we often weaken ourselves in our country: sometimes through fear of the new; sometimes through the tendency to want to regulate everything; sometimes through the search for culprits instead of solutions or through the shifting of responsibility between the various levels of government.

If we want to learn from the pandemic, we must take a close look at the structural weaknesses of our democratic state. And that is exactly what we want to do together on the podium this morning.

One topic that is particularly close to my heart is the relationship between science and politics, science and democratic politics. The pandemic has taught us that political decision-makers depend on scientific advice, especially when they want to solve complex problems with appropriate means. However, it has also made us very aware that political decisions do not simply arise from scientific findings, that they cannot be derived from numbers and curves without further ado.

Politicians must orient themselves to scientific knowledge, but they must do much more in a democracy: They must weigh values, balance interests, create compromises, convince majorities, decide to the best of their knowledge and belief, publicly justify decisions, and of course take responsibility for the consequences of each of their actions, each of their decisions.

Through this process, political power is legitimized in democracy. Democracy provides space for debate and differing convictions. There are many at present who hope that democratic debate could be replaced by scientific knowledge. I have my doubts about that, to put it frankly! Even more: I fear that already in the spring of 2020, that is, more than a year ago, the relationship between science and politics began with a misunderstanding, a misunderstanding that has turned into disappointment. Many apparently hoped at that time that the multifaceted political debate, which existed, the debate over the right measures, over tightening or relaxing, would finally be replaced by unanimity and clarity of scientific recommendations. But science did what we expect from it even outside of crisis times: It debated the right path, the provisional nature of its assumptions, and did so with different representatives and increasing sharpness, even in front of rolling cameras, documented for weeks and months for a large audience in countless special broadcasts by television stations.

Science, as Corona vividly shows us, exists only in the plural of its disciplines, questions, and methods. It does not produce absolute certainties, but specific, methodologically derived, thus reliable and verifiable knowledge, which is always subject to the reservation that one may know better tomorrow.

The "approach to truth," as Karl Popper spoke of it, this progress in knowledge is only possible if science is understood as an unfinished learning process. There are well-verified insights that either repeatedly prove themselves experimentally – no one in their right mind would question gravity – or that are fed by data and are verifiable again and again in the computational model, such as climate change. Reason demands that we follow these insights, even if they challenge our expectations of comfort and suggest behavioral changes. And yet: The fact that very many scientific answers are not eternal truths does not diminish their value, but rather points to the principle of progress. Only doubt and criticism, trial and error, the competition of theories and methods lead to new, also shared insights.

Even this culture of rational debate is something that science and democratic politics have in common, in my opinion. But despite this commonality, science and democratic politics are based on different logics, and the pandemic has taught us that we must not only respect these differences but also make them publicly visible—especially when scientists advise politics. We must not blur the boundaries between these two spheres, and we must not pit the perspectives of science against the requirements of democratic politics.

Democratic politicians must seek the advice of scientists; they must involve different disciplines, virologists and medical professionals as well as philosophers, psychologists, economists, social scientists, and legal scholars, and they must defend their expertise against deniers, instigators, and populists. Yet politicians must not overwhelm those they make their advisors; they must not obscure the political nature of their decisions, because in the end, they can only refer to the scientific position that seems most convincing and most strongly supported, as Laura Münkler recently reminded us.

During the pandemic, we are experiencing how important it is for politicians to disclose which experts they include in the decision-making process, which facts and value judgments they consider, and what uncertainties and ambiguities exist. We are also witnessing that scientists bear a special responsibility for democracy. They too must be aware of their role and respect democratic procedures. When they advise politics, they should not act like activists; and when they engage in public debate, they should not give the impression that they are the better politicians. They should explain the subject of knowledge as well as its limits and respect that in political decision-making, additional criteria beyond those derived from their own discipline may need to be considered.

In other words: Where politics hides behind science or vice versa, where science takes the place of politics, where politicians and scientists use each other to achieve their goals, we weaken trust in both science and democracy. However, if they acknowledge and make visible the inherent logics of both spheres, we can even strengthen that trust. And we need this trust in science and in democracy; we will even need more of it in the foreseeable future, as we will be confronted with increasingly complex challenges.

Today, we also want to discuss the interplay between governments and parliaments, between the federal and state levels, which has occasionally become a point of contention during the pandemic. Whether there was an "overruling" by the executive at the beginning, as has often been claimed, will be a question we discuss. Whether it is a strength of our federal state that states and municipalities can act as required by the infection situation in their respective regions, or whether the leeway and regulatory diversity rather confuse and cost acceptance, is also an open question. By the way, this is a question that is becoming very concrete again this week, as the heads of government meet again to discuss joint steps in the fight against the fourth wave.

I come to the end: Our third major topic today is the modernization of the state. The pandemic has made it clear, even to those who long refused to believe it, that we urgently need to bring our administration up to date. The state must become more capable of action, more agile, and more open to innovation. And it must become, above all, more digital. Whether it concerns tools, competencies, or working methods: The digital backlog in authorities, in schools, in the healthcare system—this backlog is not only regrettable, it is sometimes even embarrassing, and the efforts to remedy these deficits are objectively progressing too slowly. Therefore, we need a new push for the modernization of our state, and I am pleased that this topic is now at the top of the political agenda, almost regardless of parties and coalitions.

Unlike Hegel, I am convinced: Our society has the strength to learn lessons from this crisis. Therefore, I would like to conclude, here in this Berlin palace, by quoting another Prussian contemporary, namely Wilhelm von Humboldt, the Prussian scholar and statesman. His credo was: "Always remain in research." I think that is a beautiful motto for our "Forum Bellevue for the Future of Democracy." And now I look forward to the conversation!