Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the exhibition "Conspiracy Theories – Past and Present" on May 17, 2019, in Lichtenau-Dalheim:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

17 May 2019 · Opening of the exhibition "Conspiracy Theories – Past and Present" · Dalheim monastery complex, Lichtenau-Dalheim, Germany

Context
Steinmeier spoke at the opening of the exhibition 'Conspiracy Theories – Past and Present' on May 17, 2019, at the monastery complex in Lichtenau-Dalheim, Germany.
Main themes
Conspiracy theories, democracy and reason, antisemitism and historical conspiracies, Enlightenment vs. irrationality, populism and disinformation, social media and filter bubbles, fake news and alternative truths, great replacement theory, historical examples of conspiracies, cultural heritage in rural Germany
Duration
~10 min
37th percentile
Words
1,251
37th percentile
Sentences
63
41st percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 37%22%
  • Ceremonial 29%17%
  • Institutional 21%13%
  • Technological 8%5%
  • Economic 5%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 40%

63 sentences in 17 paragraphs

I am pleased that so many of you have come, and a special thanks goes to the director of this museum for the invitation. Dear Mr. Grabowski, I am very happy to be here today – here in this beautiful monastery complex in Dalheim! And thus also in my East Westphalian homeland, which I still know a little about. Yes, we are here in a rural region by common standards. But rural does not mean left behind, nor does it mean neglected. East Westphalia is a successful economic location and rich in cultural treasures. That is exactly what I want to show at as many places in Germany as possible. And that is why this journey through the country is titled "Land in Sight." What I have described elsewhere applies here, and even more so: Art and culture exist in Germany not only in the metropolises, but everywhere in the country and in the countryside. So thank you to all of you who run and support this museum so passionately! And thank you very much for the invitation!

It is no coincidence that I am here. And it is certainly not dark forces pulling strings in the background to bring me to Dalheim. Conspiracy theories do not need to be invoked – not here and certainly less often than they actually occur.

Nevertheless, I know: The belief in conspiracies is probably as old as humanity itself. For a long time, it was primarily religiously motivated – perhaps a former monastery is therefore particularly suitable for such an exhibition. The tour we just took is a fascinating journey through time that I can recommend to everyone. It deals with pacts with the devil, with the Knights Templar and the Illuminati. And also with the Enlightenment – the Enlightenment that struggled with conspiracy theories and yet could not defeat them. Both – Enlightenment and conspiracy theories – continue to battle each other into the present, just think of the so-called stab-in-the-back legend after 1918, the wonderfully portrayed "staged moon landing," or the "real puppeteers" behind the attacks of September 11, 2001. One of the most insidious and, in its consequences, murderous conspiracy theories was that of an alleged Jewish world conspiracy, which continues to live on in modern anti-Semitism to this day.

No, despite all progress in science and society, despite all enlightenment and rationality: To this day, many people believe that real or imaginary conspirators secretly come together to forge dark, often criminal plots.

Such theories, as we know from research, are not only unprovable, but they always follow the same simple pattern: They reduce highly complex, sometimes difficult-to-explain events and circumstances to a single cause, which is then sold as fact. Apparently, this is a deeply human need to simplify a complex world. The more uncertain the times are, the deeper this need goes. The more difficult the question, the simpler the answers should apparently be.

And so it is hardly surprising that today, even in our country, conspiracy theories are flourishing and thriving, indeed even gaining more seductive power and influence than they did a few decades ago – a true renaissance of conspiracy theories. That there are agents of the devil at work may no longer be believed by anyone. But nearly half of all Germans – as a recent study has shown – are convinced that there are secret organizations and powers that influence political decisions.

On the internet, in social networks, such ideas find broad resonance – and are spread at lightning speed. Facts play hardly any role in these filter bubbles; instead, the counterfactual is celebrated with great joy. And that is precisely why this exhibition is not only highly relevant, but above all, it is fact-based and enlightening in a very beneficial way! And that is exactly what we need in these times.

As Federal President, I am particularly interested in these phenomena for a very specific reason. Not out of curiosity for the curious – I have that occasionally too, but because it has something to do with democracy. Like no other form of government, democracy is based on reason. On the premise that we maintain the claim to hold on to the difference between truth and lies.

Last year, at an event on fake news at Schloss Bellevue, I hosted the Tübingen Americanist Professor Butter, a scholar who has long been engaged with conspiracy theories. The new belief in conspiracy theories, he writes in his latest book, is a symptom of a deeper crisis in democratic societies.

We live in a time when reason, in which our democratic values are increasingly discredited. Populists in many countries spread not only so-called alternative truths but also obvious lies, new conspiracy theories – I am thinking, for example, of the truly dangerous claim of an alleged great replacement of the population in Germany, supposedly driven by politics. And new nationalists spread the theory that the so-called elites from politics, churches, business, and media are conspiring against the people.

Yes, even in the past, facts were twisted, and conspiracy theories were instrumentalized for political purposes – even in the liberal democracies of modern times. What is new, however, is that alternative facts, that obvious lies can reach millions of people within seconds. But it should not be given the impression that the internet is a tool of the devil. Because especially in social networks, false facts and conspiracy theories are often quickly exposed, and that creatively and humorously.

I am convinced: The future of our democracy also depends on the distinction between facts and fake news, between facts and opinions. Because a reasonable public discourse requires that it is based on verifiable and generally accepted facts. Only then are reasonable political decisions possible.

Anyone who seriously believes that dark forces are behind political decisions cannot believe that they can influence political will formation, cannot have trust in democracy and democratic institutions. And, as research shows, they are often difficult to reach with rational arguments. Nevertheless – and that is democracy – we must rely on the power of enlightenment, on the power of reason.

The fight against disinformation and conspiracy theories is one of the great challenges for liberal democracies. It is a struggle that concerns us all, which must be waged in families, schools, offices, and businesses just as much as in newspaper editorial offices, social networks, and parliaments. And it is indeed being waged everywhere, by the descendants of Erasmus, Galileo, and Voltaire, by scientists, journalists, and bloggers, by members of parliament in investigative committees – and by exhibition makers like you here in the monastery of Dalheim!

The word is powerful. One does not need to repeat that in a place like this. It is at the beginning of all things, and it has power over our perception of the world. In a time of constant simplification and reduction of complex issues and the compression of news into news feeds, we must – I believe – relearn how to handle words and the reverence for the word.

And that is why an exhibition like this is so important, because it shows how conspiracy theories arise, how they function and have an effect – and how they can be exposed. If we succeed in this, if we expose them time and again, then we reclaim the space in which democratic politics and democratic participation can actually function. Therefore, I sincerely wish for you and for this exhibition to interest many people.

Thank you very much!