Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the seventh forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" on May 14, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

17 May 2019 · Seventh forum of the event series "Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy" · Forum Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the seventh Forum Bellevue on the Future of Democracy in Berlin on May 14, 2019, ahead of European Parliament elections.
Main themes
Future of the European Union, European Parliament elections, liberal democracy, European integration, crisis of trust in EU institutions, populism and Euroscepticism, Brexit, economic inequality among member states, freedom of movement, rule of law, democratic participation, climate change and digitalization
Duration
~17 min
58th percentile
Words
2,031
58th percentile
Sentences
91
58th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
12.2
48th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 61%58%
  • Ceremonial 22%21%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

91 sentences in 25 paragraphs

"The European Union: What is at Stake"

Anyone who asks what is at stake already makes it clear in the question what it is about: It is about a high stake and a significant goal. I am therefore particularly pleased that so many have come today, as it shows that you also assess the importance and urgency of the question. A warm welcome to all of you to a Forum Bellevue as part of the series "Future of Democracy," which aims to address Europe.

Indeed, this upcoming European election is about a lot. It is about our prosperity, about the economy and work, about our social model in global competition, about common responses to climate change, digitalization, and migration, and not least about our fundamental rights, about freedom and equality as the legacy of the European Enlightenment. And finally, the European Union also stands for the model of liberal democracy, which is closely linked to European history.

We remember: Europeans had good reasons to come together as a community after two devastating wars on the continent, and they had good reasons to expand this union. With the eastern enlargement of the EU – which was indeed a reunification of Europe – we experienced a momentous hour of European integration.

The EU has always wanted to be an alliance for mutual benefit that strengthens its members. A community of states that are determined to give up part of their national sovereignty in favor of a common European sovereignty and to create new institutions for that purpose. This was and is the founding idea of the European Union and its predecessors. And this idea has lost none of its greatness!

In the spirit of this moment, 21 heads of state of the European Union have decided to issue a joint call, which I hope most of you received last week. It is an appeal to the citizens of the European Union to preserve this moment of unity, to participate in the election, and to strengthen Europe. I am proud that this call has succeeded in bridging the gap between Eastern and Western Europe and between North and South. No, we do not agree on all issues, but we agree that we want to preserve this European Union.

However, we would not need to ask about the future of the EU today if we did not also recognize its weaknesses, if the fractures and the loss of trust among many citizens did not confront us with a possible failure of the EU. To understand the causes of the decline in support and passion for the idea of European unity, we must, I believe, take a critical look at the crisis management of the EU and its member states. The consequences of the financial market crisis of 2008 have largely been economic, but politically they have not yet been overcome. And we cannot overlook the fact that the gap between rising wages and pensions in Germany and falling incomes in other EU countries contradicts the original idea of the European Union that everyone would benefit together and be united in their happiness! If this inequality of life opportunities and experiences becomes a permanent state, the founding idea of the European Union also loses credibility. The freedom of movement in Europe can only endure in the long term if it does not result in a massive emigration of the young, well-educated generation from many countries to Germany.

We should also remember that it was not only with Brexit that a referendum against the EU succeeded. Already in 2005 – and thus before the economic and financial crisis – the referendums on the European Constitution failed in France and the Netherlands. Many citizens apparently distrust the idea of European integration; it is a distrust of institutions and political processes that does not only relate to the construction of the EU and is also observable far beyond the borders of Europe.

The European project is threatened when the number of skeptics and opponents continues to grow, when external pressure increases, and when democracy and the rule of law are also called into question within the Union. But it is also threatened by indifference. By the misunderstanding that all the advantages and achievements of the European Union are guaranteed in the long term. The danger is real. The panelists this afternoon agree on that. And not least for this reason, they also agree that the question of the weaknesses of the European Union must be asked. Not to bring about its end, but – on the contrary – to find the right answers to preserve and make the political union of Europe future-proof.

If we want to undermine the strategy of the populists, the question we must ask is not: Are you for or against Europe? It must be: What policy do we want in the EU and for the EU? And there must be passionate debate about it. I am therefore very pleased that you have followed our invitation to discuss openly and critically about the future of the European Union.

The question of what is at stake always presupposes a crisis situation. And the European Union has indeed gone through plenty of crises in the past two decades. Starting with the financial market crisis of 2008, which our panelist Adam Tooze says was the first economic and financial crisis of global dimensions, through the Greece and Euro crisis, the Russian annexation of Crimea, and the war in Eastern Ukraine, to the refugee crisis in the summer of 2015 and the Brexit vote by a narrow majority of British voters – a veritable crisis parcours.

I think the remaining 27 member states of the European Union would do well to admit that the decision of the British to leave the Union affects them profoundly. The decision of the British has shaken the EU, but Brexit has not become an existential question for the Union. The European Union has looked into the abyss, but it has not jumped.

Not only has no other member state of the EU followed the example of Great Britain, but even the declared opponents of the EU have become more restrained at least in one respect. It seems to me that calls for an exit from the EU are currently not popular even among populists.

And the exit negotiations have not only strengthened the cohesion of the 27 remaining EU states, but they have also revealed once again, under the signs of crisis, the greatest strength of this Union: the ability to act in solidarity – the ability to recognize one's own gain in the gain of others; the insight that one cannot determine one's own interest without considering the interest of others.

But: Do we succeed – we Germans too – in doing this in Europe always and everywhere? I am sure our panelists have brought us an honest perspective from the outside on German European policy. On its strengths, but also on its self-deceptions. We Germans like to think of ourselves as the best Europeans. We certify ourselves special generosity towards our partners and special consideration for their interests. We also like to believe that we have learned the lessons of European history most thoroughly, perhaps even best.

But seen through the eyes of others, we often look very different. Do we really always act as our talk of the "community of fate Europe" suggests? In European security and defense policy, for example? Or in the economic and monetary union? In many of these questions, self-perception and external perception diverge: Germany often believes it is acting helpfully and in solidarity, while others accuse us of pursuing only national interests. And do we not often tend to overlook the contributions of others – for example, in the reception of refugees?

The risk is real that Germany isolates itself in Europe – even with seemingly the best intentions. This has become unmistakably clear in recent years. Because the dynamics of crisis have also led to a Europeanization of national public spheres. The mutual dependence of all on all has become apparent to every citizen of the EU. They can study it on the front pages of their daily newspapers, and they also perceive the differences and conflicts between the member states.

However, anyone who wants to win the national public spheres for a common cause will also have to recognize the resistance in the member states and fight for the best way forward. I would also like to discuss this with my guests today.

In the run-up to the upcoming elections, I have spoken particularly with many young people about Europe – here in Germany, but also in Slovenia, Slovakia, Croatia, Austria, France, and Bulgaria. I have come across exciting initiatives with which young people creatively inspire others for Europe and the European elections. It is wonderful that some of you are here in the hall today. A special welcome to you!

In my conversations with you, one thing has become particularly clear to me again: A justification of the European Union that relies solely on the experience of the past will not convince 20-year-olds. Those who want to win the young for Europe must convince them in the present with a policy for the future. It is indeed true to emphasize again and again that no country can tackle the great future challenges alone. It is true, but not enough. There must be concrete proof that we indeed want and can do it together in Europe – in climate policy, in migration issues, in digitalization, in protecting against the negative effects of globalization! Common strategic approaches towards China, common responses to the concentration of power of the internet giants – all of this must be part of a European policy that wants to be bold for the future! So, all in all, no small topics for our panelists today – so let me conclude with a brief introduction.

A warm welcome to Daniela Schwarzer, Director of the German Council on Foreign Relations; she can answer the question of what role and responsibility France and Germany have in the European Union after Brexit. Ms. Schwarzer is concerned with German and European foreign policy, Franco-German relations as well as transatlantic relations and European institutions, and – I can reveal this in advance – she is convinced that a strong Franco-German leadership duo is more essential than ever for Europe's self-assertion today.

A warm welcome also to Ivan Krastev, Chairman of the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia and co-founder of the European Council on Foreign Relations, from which we owe one of the latest surveys on the European elections. It has dispelled some myths and provided both encouraging and less encouraging insights, which we will surely discuss. Ivan Krastev's latest book "After Europe" has received much attention. We will be able to ask him why he sees a "European twilight" approaching, as the German title suggests, and what his current view of developments in Central and Eastern Europe is. I am pleased to note, as I can reveal in advance, that he observes in the conclusion of his book – in an interesting parallel to Luuk van Middelaar – that the art of survival lies in the art of improvisation. There is still hope for the European Union.

Luuk van Middelaar had already developed a whole series of suggestions in his book "From Continent to Union" on how the European Union should be rethought. I am very much looking forward to the discussion with you, a warm welcome to you as well.

And finally, I want to introduce Adam Tooze, a British economic historian with close ties to Germany and a fascinated and fascinating view of German and European history. His most recent book "Crashed" deals with the financial crisis of 2008 and declares it in the title to be far from over. We will be able to ask him what consequences it had for Europe, particularly as a trigger for populist movements, and how these continue to have an impact. A warm welcome, Adam Tooze.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for your attention, and I invite our guests to join me on the podium.