Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the reception for the Association of State Councils and Supreme Administrative Courts of the European Union on May 13, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

17 May 2019 · Reception for the Association of State Councils and Supreme Administrative Courts of the European Union · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed representatives of European supreme administrative courts and state councils at a reception held at Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, on May 13, 2019.
Main themes
European administrative jurisdiction, rule of law in Europe, judicial independence, separation of powers, German federalism, decentralization of courts, European integration through law, interstate judicial cooperation, history of German administrative courts
Duration
~16 min
54th percentile
Words
1,894
54th percentile
Sentences
85
55th percentile
Readability
39
33rd percentile
Grade
13.3
60th percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
34th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 50%49%
  • Geopolitical 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Technological 11%11%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

85 sentences in 18 paragraphs

It is a great pleasure for me to welcome you all here at Schloss Bellevue. And I am very happy to continue the tradition of receiving you all as representatives of your courts for Germany – for the second time since reunification. As you may know, I have a special connection to administrative jurisdiction: My wife is, although currently on leave, an administrative judge – just a few streets away from Bellevue at the Berlin Administrative Court. Therefore, a very warm welcome to you.

You have traveled to Berlin for the seminar, even though the Federal Administrative Court is based in Leipzig. For some of you, it may be somewhat unusual that the highest administrative court of a state does not reside in the capital. As you know, in Germany, the judiciary is a matter for the states. At the federal level, there are only five supreme federal courts – the Federal Court of Justice, which is responsible for civil and criminal law, the Federal Administrative Court, the Federal Labor Court, the Federal Social Court, and the Federal Finance Court. These supreme federal courts are also decentralized. No supreme German court resides in the capital.

What you may not know is that Berlin was the seat of the Federal Administrative Court until 2002. Until 1989, this exception to the rule primarily served as a sign that West Berlin belonged to the Federal Republic of Germany. After reunification, many federal authorities and federal courts relocated. Our German understanding of federalism includes that federal bodies and institutions are located in the states – especially in the new states. It creates a certain proximity to citizens when the federal government is present with its authorities and courts on site, and therefore it was right that the Federal Labor Court moved to Erfurt and the Federal Administrative Court to Leipzig.

Leipzig is not only a trade fair city but also the city of the first Monday demonstrations, the beginning of an uprising that led to the peaceful revolution of 1989. And Leipzig is ultimately also a city with a long-standing, vibrant legal culture: A traditional yet young and modern law faculty is located there, a criminal division of the Federal Court of Justice is based in Leipzig, and the Federal Administrative Court was able to occupy the building of the former Reich Court, which may even be a more representative building than the head of state here in Berlin!

Even the Federal Constitutional Court meets far from day-to-day politics in Karlsruhe. The spatial distance of the Constitutional Court and the supreme federal courts from the legislative and executive branches is primarily due to historical and federal reasons. I am convinced that this spatial separation of the judiciary from day-to-day politics benefits the separation of powers – even if one does not have to be in the same place to communicate with each other. For the spatial distance contributes to a focus on the application of existing law and prevents possible influence on the judiciary from too much proximity to politics.

You all come from the member states of the European Union, from the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg, you come from Norway and Switzerland, and as observers from Montenegro, Serbia, and Turkey. Thus, you embody Europe as representatives of the highest administrative courts and state councils of your countries. The European legal tradition is significantly shaped by respect for the law. Not a few legal historians determine the extent of Europe by where Latin law has become the legal foundation of legal and social orders. The limitation of power by law is one of the essential characteristics of legal cultural development. It is therefore not surprising that European unification followed the idea of creating integration through law. The European Union is an association of states that were formerly hostile to each other and today understand themselves as partners based on a subordination to a legal order consented to by all member states and applicable equally to all. This united Europe is not a community enforced by mere power, but a space of freedom, security, and law.

The persuasive power of this idea is also reflected in the development of an independent administrative jurisdiction in the states of the European Union. It is visible in the association of the courts that you represent here. It is visible in your cooperation, in your exchange of thoughts and experiences. Your meetings promote mutual understanding – for each other's legal systems, but also for the differences and commonalities. And last but not least – I am convinced of this and know it from my own practice – personal relationships and friendships arise. You all maintain this tradition since the highest administrative courts of the then six EC states first came together in 1968. In doing so, you make an indispensable contribution to the integration of Europe, and that deserves the highest recognition and respect.

When your association last visited Germany, my predecessor Horst Köhler could still state that although the European euphoria of the founding years and then the years after the Maastricht Treaty had faded. In a Europe of 25 or even 30 member states – Mr. Köhler said at that time – it would not be easier to achieve the unity of Europe in light of the diversity of languages, history, culture, and economy. And he already said at that time that we must take the fears of the people seriously. That was in 2006!

Since then, much has happened in Europe that is crisis-ridden. So much that we would not have thought possible at that time: sovereign debt crisis, stagnating economic developments, partly high unemployment rates, Euroscepticism, rising nationalism and populism, not to mention the exit declaration of Great Britain – I will only mention a few keywords here. And recently, we have also been confronted with an offensive, sometimes even aggressive rejection of our liberal, democratic, and constitutional beliefs, a rejection that poses a serious threat to what has been achieved. You know: It took a long time to arrive at this united Europe in its current form. Over the past nearly 70 years, promises of peace, freedom, and prosperity have been fulfilled on our continent. It is an illusion for national politicians to believe that as a nation-state one can survive in globalization, or even to say that peace, freedom, and prosperity can only be better defended by the nation-state. In the 21st century, they are only truly secured in a strong community with solid partners by their side. And we should be clear: Much faster than this Europe was built, the European unification project can be brought down by its opponents. How quickly seemingly stable social orders can collapse, we experienced in 1989/1990.

We must defend daily what counts as our foundations, and we must work for it every day. Especially at this time, before the elections to the European Parliament, we must advocate for the advantages of a united Europe, without denying that there is also much to improve and many reforms to be made in this European Union.

Our Europe includes a liberal, constitutional democracy. Freedom of opinion, assembly, and the media, a control of political power, and independent courts are indispensable. Essential to our understanding of democracy is full equality of opportunity for the opposition to gain political power in free, unmanipulated elections. This also includes the risk of losing that power in elections. Unfortunately, there are also enemies of democracy in Europe who reject or even disregard these principles of a liberal constitutional state! Those who claim to represent the true people under the guise of an illiberal democracy and to be the sole holders of the truth. We all know that both do not exist: the people and the sole truth.

But experience teaches us: Authoritarian politics eliminate all forms of legal constraints as one of the first steps. They attempt to limit the independence of the judiciary, curtail press and freedom of opinion, and try to influence elections in their favor. And they also resort to false news, targeted disinformation, or the manipulation of elections – which today can sometimes succeed with the means of modern technologies of the internet and social networks. Those who use these means to come to power will also have little scruples about undermining or even abolishing all democratic constitutional safeguards and precautions. It is also the task of the courts to counter such tendencies. You, the courts that are called upon to review and control state actions, should also contribute to this.

In conclusion, I would like to look to the future and address another challenge that also concerns administrative jurisdiction. It is about the profound changes that come with digitalization and that will also influence the administration of justice and jurisprudence in the future.

Thirty years ago, when I was working at the university, these developments were unpredictable: A German pioneer of legal informatics – Fritjof Haft – considered it impossible at that time that a judge could be replaced by a subsumption machine. Fritjof Haft, actually a criminal lawyer, always illustrated this with a criminal offense that we call leaving the scene of an accident. In Germany, this offense contains particularly many indeterminate legal terms for which there is an almost overwhelming case law. At that time, it was unimaginable that the diversity of cases could be captured by a computer. In the meantime, the explosion of storage capacity and computing power allows for the processing of countless decisions. Therefore, we are at the beginning of a development today in which self-learning algorithms and artificial intelligence could perform the subsumption of the facts under a legal norm without the human legal practitioner. Where comparatively simple legal norms are to be applied – in tax law, for example, by the tax authorities – computer applications are already checking tax returns today. Already today, the tax official is only active in exceptional cases.

It does not take much legal imagination to envision such scenarios in other areas of legal application.

Even if the path to such a future seems far away – autonomous driving cars were also a utopia not too long ago – we should ask ourselves and discuss: Do we want such a technical and cold application of the law, do we want dehumanized courts? Emotionless equality before the law? Much better than I do, you all know: There is an enormous difference between assessing a case based solely on the file, based on what is written down, or based on the lived reality of those affected. It is indeed something different when the parties stand before you, and all judges have surely experienced in their professional lives that one assesses a case differently when one knows the person and speaks with them. I am firmly convinced: We should not give up this human component in our judiciary under any circumstances.

It is exciting what you address in your colloquia, and I am convinced that we all benefit from it. Thank you very much for your commitment and your ongoing work on the further education of the law, on the development of a European ius commune. I look forward to what you, dear Mr. Rennert, will now report to me. And I look forward to many conversations that we can have afterwards during the reception.

Thank you very much for coming!