Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the German Lawyers' Day "Forum Hamburg 2020 – Pandemic and Law" on September 18, 2020, as a video message:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

27 September 2020 · Forum Hamburg 2020 – Pandemic and Law (73rd German Lawyers' Day)

Context
Steinmeier addressed the 73rd German Lawyers' Day via video message on September 18, 2020, as the pandemic prevented an in-person gathering in Hamburg.
Main themes
Pandemic and law, fundamental rights during COVID-19, rule of law, restrictions on freedoms, digitization and legal regulation, criminal proceedings, online platform regulation, labor and social law, public health emergency powers, democratic accountability, conspiracy theories and public discourse, sustainable urban development
Duration
~8 min
27th percentile
Words
913
27th percentile
Sentences
39
24th percentile
Readability
36
28th percentile
Grade
14.0
67th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
65th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 44%44%
  • Social 33%33%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

39 sentences in 11 paragraphs

If we were not in the midst of a global pandemic, we would be together today in Hamburg to open the 73rd German Lawyers' Day. The German Lawyers' Day has been held regularly since 1860. Only extraordinary circumstances have prevented this in the past – this tradition has only been interrupted during World War I and the Nazi regime.

In light of the Covid-19 pandemic, you have canceled the in-person event; the risk of infection does not allow for a German Lawyers' Day in the usual framework. There would have been extremely exciting topics for your in-person discussions – topics that are currently and fundamentally important for our society and our rule of law. It is very important to me to at least briefly address these, as the questions extend beyond the time of the pandemic and into the future. I am sure that the expert opinions already available on this will provide grounds for further discussions – now and not just during the negotiations at the next Lawyers' Day. Even though the pandemic and the legal questions associated with it currently occupy us, we should not lose sight of other topics.

The negotiation topics on digitization are very timely and future-oriented: This applies to the question of responsibility and liability in the decisions of digital autonomous systems as well as to the topic of stronger regulation of online platforms and digital companies. In labor and social law, you wanted to address the challenges and regulatory needs regarding retirement provision and demographics.

The issue of how much immediacy our criminal proceedings need also holds particular significance in the pandemic situation. And in public law, you would have dealt with the sustainable city of the future and the requirements for new regulations regarding traffic, environmental protection, and housing. It is to be expected that the challenge of combating the pandemic will demand new aspects from these topics that are noteworthy and worthy of discussion. I am confident that these topics will gain in relevance.

In today's forum, you will address the pandemic-related challenges for the law: the distribution of the burdens of the pandemic and fundamental rights in times of the pandemic. Highly relevant and sometimes controversial societal topics are thus being raised. I am convinced: It is important that you engage with these questions. But I also hope that this is done without the alarmism that characterizes some statements – particularly regarding fundamental rights issues – in the fight against the pandemic. There is hardly a superlative that has not already been uttered concerning the restrictions on fundamental rights.

Our fundamental rights ensure extensive freedom. However, most fundamental rights allow the democratically elected legislator to restrict them – proportionately – especially when it comes to the protection of other values that are also protected by fundamental rights.

The first measures initiated by the executive were very far-reaching, but I would like to point out that we were dealing with a completely unknown virus, the effects of which had not been researched. The state is obligated to protect the population, even when the defense against danger must be based on uncertain decision-making. If we now find that some decisions may not have been necessary, it is because we know more about the virus now. It is one of the democratic strengths of our political system that this can also be recognized retrospectively and that we can draw lessons for the future.

And I would like to remind you: These were not politically motivated restrictions on fundamental rights – it was a pandemic to be fought. The Nobel Prize-winning author Herta Müller, who comes from communist Romania, has rightly pointed out the significant difference between whether the state is defending against dangers to the life and health of the population or whether fundamental rights are restricted with the aim of eliminating the political freedom of citizens.

I would like to take this opportunity to emphasize: Our rule of law works! If people believe that the fight against the pandemic is going too far, that it is exaggerated, or if some people even subscribe to conspiracy theories and believe that the virus does not exist or was unleashed by dark forces, they can invoke freedom of expression. For it also protects the expression of falsehoods and nonsense. And of course, people can demonstrate. However, the freedom of assembly is only guaranteed to those who come together "peacefully and without weapons." But those who demonstrate also bear a responsibility; I have no understanding for demonstrators who allow themselves to be instrumentalized by enemies of democracy and political agitators. Those who invoke the freedom of assembly and expression should not align themselves with neo-Nazis, xenophobes, or anti-Semites who want to abolish these fundamental rights.

And to those who accuse politics of authoritarian action regarding the restrictions imposed, it must be countered: We do not live in a lawless space, nor in a space free of fundamental rights. The restrictions imposed by the authorities could from the very beginning be independently reviewed by the courts and constitutional courts – against the standard of our fundamental rights and rule of law principles. Administrative and constitutional courts have examined the restrictions on freedom rights for their proportionality and have adjusted the protective measures against the pandemic to a proportionate level as required at each point in time.

I sincerely wish you a successful event with exciting discussions, stimulating thoughts, and new insights! Best regards to Hamburg and to the virtual forum.