Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the panel discussion "Trust in the Future in the Digital Modern Age" at the 37th German Protestant Church Congress on June 20 ...

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

23 June 2019 · 37th German Protestant Church Congress (Kirchentag), panel discussion "Trust in the Future in the Digital Modern Age" · Dortmund, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the 37th German Protestant Church Congress in Dortmund on June 20, 2019, opening a panel discussion on trust and digital modernity.
Main themes
Trust in society, digital democracy, democratization of digital space, social media and public discourse, rule of law, German Protestant Church Congress, democracy and constitution, Silicon Valley data giants, future optimism, community and coexistence, political participation, online hate and coarsening of discourse
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,478
81st percentile
Sentences
181
87th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 35%33%
  • Technological 24%22%
  • Ceremonial 18%17%
  • Institutional 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

181 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Large exhibition halls, thousands of uncomfortable cardboard stools – filled to capacity with warm-hearted, committed, and optimistic people. A bustling metropolis marked by colorful streams of visitors, with singing people in the trams and helpful scout groups on every corner. The old hands know it well, the youngest have been learning it since yesterday: It is Church Day again! Welcome to Dortmund, dear guests!

I am always happy to be here with you, dear sisters and brothers. Every time I attend a Church Day, whether as Frank-Walter Steinmeier, as a Christian, or as Federal President: I enter such a hall, see all of you, and immediately remember why I – despite all the upheavals – look to the future with great confidence! Thank you very much for the warm welcome!

What trust, dear sisters and brothers! What trust – as it is written in the Second Book of Kings. It is our motto for this Church Day.

What trust – tens of thousands come together peacefully, singing, praying, celebrating, and passionately discussing our coexistence.

What trust – this shapes not only Church Days but also the everyday life of our country.

What trust – this is what the young Syrian may feel, having fled civil war, as he walks calmly and safely through the streets of Germany, encountering police officers whose arbitrariness he does not have to fear.

What trust – this is what the emergency doctor may think on her way to the next assignment. Because whoever may be waiting for her, whether rich or poor, employed or unemployed – this person in need can be sure that help is on the way.

What trust – millions of parents have this trust as they bring their children to daycare every day, send them to school every morning, and take them to clubs and church communities in the afternoons.

As Federal President, I know: Our country is built on trust. This trust in one another and in ourselves is precious. It allows us to live together peacefully, to seek encounters and exchanges, to take responsibility instead of retreating into quiet rooms or echo chambers.

It is precious, and it is not a given. In other places, millions of people long for such trust. They struggle, often at great personal risk, to build it where it is lacking – and they suffer where it is destroyed, where hatred, brutality, and arbitrariness poison entire societies.

But we in Germany, we are allowed to trust: in the law and the rule of law that protects us, in democracy and its constitution, whose birthday we have just celebrated and which has supported us for 70 years. Let us be grateful for this trust – and let us handle it carefully!

We will need this trust in the future as well. And we also need the other: trust in the future. A few weeks ago, I spoke in another hall, also in front of thousands of mostly young and very engaged people. That was at re:publica, the large digital conference in Berlin. A major newspaper wrote the next day: "This is the high mass of the digital world. […] It almost has something of a Church Day!" Well, there were cardboard stools too, but not many green scarves.

Even there in Berlin, I spoke about trust – and about the role of social media. Because trust erodes when the boundary between what can be said and what cannot is increasingly blurred, when a shitstorm erupts over trivial matters and mockery pours over the misfortunes of others, when the haters are so loud and the reasonable are too quiet, when the roar of the few drowns out the decency of the many. There can only be one response to all this: Let us never retreat! Let us not leave the political discourse online to the angry and raging giants! They may be the loudest, but I am quite sure: They do not represent the majority of people in our country.

Nevertheless: Major upheavals are underway. Democracy is changing – also with the possibilities of communication. And it is good when more people can participate. But is it not a completely twisted view of things when a technology-fixated perception of society and democracy emerges? For years, digital pioneers have proclaimed that technology is far ahead of dusty politics, and that digitization must help democracy along. I fear this is a reversal of the actual problem. I believe: We must first and foremost concern ourselves not with the digitization of democracy, but with the democratization of the digital! The reclamation of the political space – against the coarsening and shortening of language, but also against the enormous concentration of power among the "Big Five," among a handful of data giants from Silicon Valley – that is the most pressing task!

Because let us be honest: Trust in the future is today being massively tested even among chronic optimists – and I count myself among them. And this means much more than the tone of discourse in social media. It is about a fundamental insecurity – about the question of whether we can still assert our liberal and democratic self-understanding, whether we can still uphold our standards from the centuries of enlightenment in the digital modern age.

At the end of last year, I was again in China, visiting Guangzhou, a megacity in the south of the country, located on the Pearl River upstream from Hong Kong. Skyscrapers of glass and steel as far as the eye can see, seventy, eighty stories high, and on every floor high-tech companies and digital start-ups. One such company produces robots in a factory that is as error-free as possible, independent of the "disturbance factor human." The young CEO told me, almost in passing, a sentence that stuck with me: "And if all this works," he said, "then we won't need humans here anymore."

"We won't need humans here anymore." This sentence has not left me even long after the trip. It made one thing very clear to me: When we think about digitization and technological progress, we are primarily thinking about ourselves. About our self-understanding as humans: Who are we? And where is our path leading?

For thousands of years, we humans have been asking ourselves these questions. For us Protestant Christians, but by no means only for us, they have been at the core of all humanity – and our answer in the past has been: freedom. We are neither gods nor puppets, but God's creations, with all our faults and shortcomings and the finiteness of our existence. Especially as Christians, we are free for a self-determined life. A life in which we make decisions and take responsibility for ourselves and others.

The freedom at the core of humanity – this conviction also underlies the constitutions of our modern democracies and our international law and extends far beyond Christianity. More than 70 years ago, shaken and shaped by the experience of the terrible crimes that had originated from our country, the peoples of the world gave themselves a common foundation: the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Human rights protect the freedom and dignity of every person, regardless of gender, origin, or faith. Our Basic Law has found the wonderful formulation of "inviolability" for this.

Today we ask ourselves: What remains of this self-understanding in the digital modern age? What remains of humanity when new technologies increasingly intervene in our decisions, direct our thinking, shape our desires? And how is society supposed to function when every fiber of individuality – no longer just every deviation from the norm – is recorded as a data point and processed in new contexts – by some from the state, by others from private data giants?

I want to talk with you about these questions today. Yes, there is much discussion, research, and writing about the profound consequences of digitization – but I find: Not everyone who is affected is yet participating in this discussion. This debate strikes at the core of our humanity – and therefore it belongs at the core of society and at the core of the debate!

Of course, we must not make it too easy for ourselves. It is not about euphoria or dystopia, glorification or condemnation, about a simple "yes" or "no" to digitization. It is happening. Nine out of ten Germans are online, and just as many consider the technological change to be unstoppable. It may boost the economy and prosperity. But many – I am sure, many here in the hall – look at its societal consequences with concern.

And there is reason for that: From Cambridge Analytica and the ever-new revelations at Facebook to the almost unlimited surveillance by state authorities in other parts of the world, whether in America and Europe or especially in China, to the everyday manipulation by seemingly free, brightly flashing, and attractive services that illuminate us from behind and suck up our data – in the short history of digitization, much hope has been disappointed and some trust shaken!

Whether new trust can grow is also our decision. Do we retreat into digital Lummerland, put our feet up, and turn on Netflix? Or do we start talking about what kind of digitization we actually want and how we can succeed in inscribing our freedom, our ideas, our rules, in short: the core of humanity into the digital future?

In my political life, I have repeatedly experienced one thing: resignation is not an option, and if it is, then always the worst option. The future is impatient. It wants to be shaped, because it will come one way or another. And if we do not shape the future ourselves, we not only jeopardize the foundation of our prosperity but will also continue to play by the rules of others. That cannot be our purpose!

Perhaps a look back can give us courage: Our country has always been strongest when we have not simply endured the future, when we have not only lamented crises but have tackled them – structural change and industrial revolutions, the sharp winds of global competition, and of course the great challenge of German reunification!

In short: The future has history with us. And wherever we have succeeded in the future, many have had their share: scientists and engineers, skilled workers and entrepreneurs. But it has never been just individuals; it requires this whole, vibrant, and interconnected society. The Germans are not anti-technology; on the contrary: This society believes in progress because it can shape it – because it sets an ethical and societal framework and does not blindly implement everything that would be technically possible. For this kind of progress, we need civil society, we need churches and trade unions, economic and welfare associations, the countless volunteer organizations, and yes, also the political parties. They have all contributed in the past to making us a peaceful, prosperous, and – in international comparison – a country with high social security.

I am reminded of a moment that at first glance seems so little related to our current topic of digitization and yet, on a second glance, has so much to do with it. Exactly six months ago, the miners at Prosper-Haniel in Bottrop, not far from here, completed the last shift and handed me the last piece of German hard coal.

On that evening just before Christmas, an era came to an end. There was sadness and melancholy, but there was also confidence and immense pride: We will not be defeated because we stay together! That was for me the essence of that moving evening: We will tackle this change because we do it together – with the solidarity of an entire society.

These miners, who have learned what solidarity really means under the harshest conditions underground, stood before me that evening with tears in their eyes and said: We have literally moved mountains here for two hundred years. Why should we not succeed in the future as well? Because we are and will remain buddies!

That last piece of hard coal is now in daily view across from my desk in Schloss Bellevue and reminds me of the motto that stood over that farewell evening and that can only be said here in the Ruhr area: "Good luck for the future!" I will never forget this historic moment and the people who shaped it.

This "Good luck for the future" in the face of apparent powerlessness against overwhelming change is for me a deeply impressive document of hope for the future, of trust in the shapeability of the future!

And with that, I return to digitization. Of course, the future does not succeed without change, without risk, without danger. But we must never view technological progress as a monstrous natural event to which we are helplessly subjected! We must want to understand what threatens our humanity and our cohesion. Our partly self-inflicted digital naivety must give way to enlightenment and maturity. The digital world has so far primarily been shaped around us and without our input. The digital world of today still serves the interests of those who preset our devices, program our applications, and want to direct our behavior.

Therefore, we need the courage to interrupt the game and review the rules of the game. What has been designed can also be redesigned! What has been programmed can be reprogrammed! So: Let us dare, and let us change the program!

Let us talk about changing the program: Our new program can be a good program.

Look: A young girl who goes to school today will raise her own children in 20 or 30 years, in 2040 or 2050. And these children, our grandchildren and great-grandchildren, could grow up in a world that may seem as unimaginable to us today as our current life does to the generations before us.

These children could learn more independently and be more oriented towards their own interests, with good teachers and also with support from digital tools, than has been possible in the school routine so far. Their mother could be sure that she would not be treated worse in her search for housing or in the granting of loans because of her appearance or her background. And the young family could cope with terrible sufferings such as skin cancer or rare hereditary diseases because they can be detected and treated earlier and more precisely thanks to technology.

All of this may sound utopian, but such a world is possible, and we can already set the course today to ensure its success.

Let us be more demanding in our expectations: We can already make algorithms more understandable today, regularly put their functioning and results to the test. We can already program learning computers so that they operate without discrimination or paternalism. We can already require companies to make privacy-friendly default settings. We can already create institutions that enforce our privacy against large companies where we cannot do so alone. We can already equip police and public prosecutors so that they can tear hate and incitement from the net of supposed anonymity and pursue them consistently. We can already design and renew the labor market and social systems so that the promise of social security also applies to new forms of work and professions, for people in the click and platform economy. And we can already agree that important decisions about life and death, about family and love, about pain and responsibility, in short: decisions about the core of our humanity, must ultimately always be made by people, despite all technical assistance.

Let us be more demanding! We can, and I believe we must, do all of this today! I have spoken up here because I believe we need to establish something like an ethics of digitalization: basic rules for the digital future, the adherence to which we must demand even in a time of tremendous upheaval. I believe we do not need new philosophies or dogmas for this, but we need a translation of what has already made us strong.

The ethics of digitalization is and remains, for me, first and foremost an ethics of freedom. It begins with the question: How can technology serve us humans? How does it lead to more self-determination – and not into new heteronomy? How do we use technological possibilities to overcome oppression and poverty, to spread education and enlightenment, to protect the environment and resources?

Freely after Kant, I would say: Technological progress should facilitate humanity's emergence from immaturity and not become a voluntary entry into new immaturity! I believe an ethics of freedom fits the Protestant Church Day!

Luther's "Freedom of a Christian," his duality "A Christian is subject to no one – a Christian is subject to everyone" has never been easy to translate into politics. But the double message remains highly relevant: No freedom without responsibility. No freedom without rules. This tension must be renegotiated in the digital modern age.

Every promise of freedom, including the digital one, looks forward to a new order: Freedom needs rules, and new freedoms need new rules! In a democracy – who makes the rules? In the end, we ourselves! Wolfgang Huber calls this communicative freedom, the freedom to engage, to participate, to shape.

And that is why an ethics of digitalization is more than a private appeal to virtue. Regaining control and maturity in the net cannot be achieved by any citizen or consumer alone, but it succeeds through joint efforts, in civil society organizations and solidarity alliances, with legal rules and international agreements.

The impulse, however, the initial spark, is profoundly emancipatory, and that is why it also belongs at a Church Day. Our ethics of digitalization begins with a political declaration of independence – against digital heteronomy and for reason, maturity, and democracy! That is what it is about, and that should be our common message!

Emancipation has many levels. It begins with ourselves – How do we move in digital media? How much do we disclose? – it requires state action and state rules – our German legislation is moving forward tentatively and on uncertain ground – but it naturally extends beyond national borders. I believe: Our declaration of independence should be a European one!

Europe has something to say, and Europe has something to offer in this world. Let us not understand the path into the digital future as a zero-sum game or as a defensive battle against the digital giants from the USA or China. Of course, we in Germany and Europe must remain competitive and even become competitive in many digital areas.

Then, I am convinced, "Made in Europe" can become a standard in the digital world – there are already examples of this – a standard that places the dignity and freedom of human beings at the center. Europe can be an alternative offer to a world that increasingly believes it can only choose between unrestricted digital capitalism in the American style on one hand or Orwellian state surveillance in China on the other.

And despite all the differences that separate us from these actors in terms of freedom, privacy, or security, we should dare to formulate and perhaps even agree on something like ethical minima with the USA and with China. This is difficult, but not impossible. We have successfully taken first steps together in medical ethics – ethical standards that still apply in China. Therefore, we should also seek dialogue on these ethical questions with difficult partners; Ms. Schavan will certainly speak about this on the podium shortly.

And so I come back to trust at the end. As Christians, we know all too well: Trust is something different from certainty. Trust and faith belong together. Because we are supported by God's love, we believe in a good future. Our faith is, in the words of the Letter to the Hebrews, "a firm assurance of what one hopes for, and a conviction of what one does not see."

So let us trust in our ability to design the future! And let us start right here, at this Church Day.

Engage concretely! Formulate and discuss your wishes, questions, and ideas for the future. I look forward to our discussion shortly afterwards – and I am also pleased that a resolution on digitalization is being worked on at the Church Day. This is an important impulse, even beyond the Church Day. I ask you: Carry the debate further, into the congregations, businesses, and associations; into the net and social media, into blog posts and online petitions. We are free to design, to shape, and we may trust.

Therefore, I say to you, not so much as Federal President, but as a human being, as a Christian, as Frank-Walter Steinmeier: I am 63 years old. I have white hair. And I am incredibly excited about the future!