Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the opening of the Round Table "Conflict in the Classroom: the War in the Middle East and Our Schools" on November 23, 2023, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

25 November 2023 · Round Table "Conflict in the Classroom: the War in the Middle East and Our Schools" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a Berlin round table on November 23, 2023, convened to discuss how the Israel-Hamas war was affecting German schools and social cohesion.
Main themes
Israel-Hamas war impact on Germany, antisemitism and anti-Muslim prejudice, social cohesion and coexistence, schools and political education, Palestinian and Arab community alienation, democratic responsibility, combating hatred and extremism, Jewish safety in Germany, Gaza civilian suffering, round table dialogue
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,094
59th percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
11.0
33rd percentile
Syntax
3.07
57th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
73rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 61%60%
  • Ceremonial 25%25%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

108 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Since October 7, news from the Middle East has moved German society like never before. The terrorist attack by Hamas on Israel has deeply shocked many people in our country; the images of murdered or abducted children, women, and men, of grieving and anxious relatives continue to haunt us even today, weeks later.

Moreover, the war in the Middle East, which Hamas has imposed on the region, is also affecting peaceful coexistence in our country. We are witnessing anti-Semitic and anti-Israel hatred in German cities. Jewish people are being attacked and threatened. This is unbearable, and it must not be indifferent to anyone in our country! The state and society, we all must ensure that Jewish people can feel completely safe in Germany. This is our task, and it is also a historical obligation!

But our public debate about the war in the Middle East has also triggered strong emotions in these weeks. Of course, Israel, as the attacked country, has the right to self-defense. Nevertheless, some have the impression that the suffering of the people and the destruction in Gaza are not receiving enough attention in the German public. That they are not allowed to openly show their pain, their grief, their despair. But who can remain indifferent to the images of endless lines of fleeing people in the Gaza Strip? Who is not touched by the images of innocent victims of airstrikes? I am touched!

Many people with Palestinian, other Arab, or Turkish roots, who call Germany home, feel alienated and marginalized in these days. Many are hurt because they feel that since October 7, they are no longer perceived as individuals, but rather again only as "migrants" or "Muslims." They are angry because they have the impression that they are being placed under general suspicion of sympathizing with Islamist terror because of their origin, their faith, or their name. It pains me to hear such reports. We are one country! Origin does not determine belonging. There can and must not be a general suspicion in our country!

Not a general suspicion. But all of us who live in Germany have a general responsibility in democracy. We must boldly confront all inhumane prejudices and resentments – against Jews as well as against Muslims and racism!

This is what is demanded of all of us: to take responsibility, not to be indifferent, not to turn away, especially not in this time. Together, with respect for one another, our voices must be stronger, more determined, and more noticeable than the voices of hatred and violence. Louder than the voices of extremists, provocateurs, and ideologues. This is our task.

Let us take on this task! Let us together set a sign in this country: We, the democrats, the vast majority in all our diversity, will not be driven apart. We stand together against prejudice, hatred, and violence – no matter where we come from, what we believe!

We cannot resolve the conflict in the Middle East on the streets of Berlin, Cologne, and Munich, nor in the schoolyards of German schools. But we can do something together for social peace in Germany. Two weeks ago, I invited some of the many committed people in our country – Jews and Muslims, Palestinians and Israelis – to the first round table for peaceful coexistence in times of war in the Middle East here. We discussed what we can do now to prevent the conflict from opening unbridgeable chasms in our German society. It was a conversation that gave courage, and I am pleased that we can continue it today with a different focus and in a different composition.

In the next hour and a half, we will discuss how the war in the Middle East is affecting our schools, in classrooms and perhaps also in teachers' lounges. We want to talk about how school administrations and teachers should deal with the conflict. And we want to discuss how we can best support them in this.

Dear guests, all of you here at the table are committed in various ways to political education, respect, and tolerance – in politics, in schools, in extracurricular institutions and initiatives. I know some of you hesitated to participate in this conversation in days like these. Therefore, I am all the more grateful that you are here today. A warm welcome to you here in Bellevue!

In the schools of our country, the entire spectrum of feelings that the Middle East conflict triggers in our society is reflected – not just since October 7, but particularly since then. In our Jewish schools, students and teachers have followed the news from Israel in the days after the Hamas terrorist attack, mourned together, prayed, and provided each other with comfort. In other schools in our country, especially in large urban areas, there are many classes with children and young people who have relatives or friends in Gaza. Some of them are mourning their own relatives in these weeks, many are desperate and angry at the suffering and destruction, and not a few are agitated and disturbed by gruesome images, contradictory news, or – above all – propaganda on social media.

In classrooms and on playgrounds, this is manifesting in very different ways in these weeks. Some students withdraw, others want to discuss, while others stand out through provocations, and some want to see Israel wiped off the map. These are huge challenges for the schools in our country.

And it is wonderful what school administrations and teachers are achieving in this situation! I know many are seeking conversations with the children and young people, listening to them, catching their pain, anger, and grief, creating spaces where even irritating views can be openly discussed, and setting red lines. This is exhausting and, at times, I can imagine, hard to bear. But it is infinitely important to reach those who are susceptible to hatred and incitement!

Time and again, teachers – as they have told me – find themselves in situations where they feel insecure or overwhelmed. How does one respond appropriately when individual students refer to Hamas as a "liberation organization"? How does one react when they endorse terror? How can one manage to pull students out of their social media bubble, where they are trapped in a barrage of hatred and violence? How can one support children and young people who resist this but still feel marginalized or prejudged as members of a group or religion?

These are difficult questions, and I am very grateful that school administrations and teachers have been receiving support everywhere in our country since October 7. School authorities are providing teaching materials on the Middle East conflict and offering training on dealing with anti-Semitism and racism; associations and initiatives are organizing workshops for students and teachers in schools. And I know how many small teams are working tirelessly in these days and hardly find any rest. My heartfelt thanks today goes to them and to all others who are committed to good coexistence in schools in this tense situation!

And I also know: Of course, gratitude alone is not enough. Our schools need even more and, above all, sustainable support to strengthen cohesion in diverse school communities. We must focus on the prevention of hatred and violence, rather than always just playing firefighter when it burns. This is what responsibility for peaceful coexistence in our country demands. In the end, this is what responsibility for democracy demands!

Schools in our country are schools of democracy. They are places of diversity where young people with different backgrounds, influences, and experiences come together. And they are places of freedom of expression, where even ambivalent and disturbing views are allowed. Schools of democracy are places of openness, yes. But they are not neutral when it comes to the foundations and prerequisites for peaceful coexistence in our country or, in other words, for the coexistence of the different. Every student in our country must know German history. Everyone must understand what Auschwitz means and what responsibility arises from it for us.

Dear guests, finally, in my opening remarks: The agreement for the release of hostages and a ceasefire in the Middle East is giving rise to a bit of hope these days. Hope that a way can be found that will eventually allow Israelis and Palestinians to think about how they can live together in peaceful neighborliness. I hope that in our country, too, we do not cement the conflicts, that we do not completely alienate from one another, that chasms do not become unbridgeable, but that we preserve our peaceful coexistence in Germany despite all differences.

To our guests. If you allow me, I would like to briefly introduce you one by one:

Education policy at our table is represented by Katharina Günther-Wünsch. She is the Senator for Education here in Berlin and also the President of the Conference of Ministers of Education. Dear Ms. Günther-Wünsch, since October 7, you have been working to support schools in dealing with the Middle East conflict, and you have been addressing the question of which red lines students should not cross. It is wonderful that you are here today; welcome!

The schools will be represented in our round today by five guests. I welcome Noga Hartmann, Director of the Lichtigfeld School of the Jewish Community in Frankfurt am Main. Dear Ms. Hartmann, you studied Islamic Studies and the History of the Middle East in Tel Aviv and organized project days on the topics of the Holocaust and anti-Semitism at Berlin schools. As a school principal, you are now cooperating with a school in your Frankfurt neighborhood, in Eschborn, to jointly combat anti-Semitism and racism.

Here with us is Mehmet Can, a teacher of politics and history at Campus Rütli in Berlin-Neukölln. Dear Mr. Can, you founded a "Jerusalem Working Group" at your school, traveled with students to Israel and Palestine, and subsequently developed the comic "More than Two Sides" together with the young people. Last but not least, you are also active as a freelancer in historical-political education, dealing with anti-Semitism, racism, democracy, and tolerance.

I welcome Gresa Arifi from Gelsenkirchen; she is a student teacher with majors in German and history and a scholarship holder of the Avicenna Study Foundation, which supports young talented Muslims. Dear Ms. Arifi, you have already gained teaching experience at an elementary school, are currently doing a practical semester at the comprehensive school in Hattingen, and can report to us how the Middle East conflict and the debate about it are affecting you.

It is especially nice that we also have a student and a pupil from Berlin at the table today, who can share their experiences from these last weeks: The student representative of the Jewish Gymnasium Moses Mendelssohn – a warm welcome! And the state student representative Aimo Görne. Dear Mr. Görne, you are in the 13th grade at the Paula-Fürst Community School in Charlottenburg, and you are also engaged nationwide as a student representative and as a staff member of the State Center for Political Education.

Completing our round are women and men who are committed to historical-political education in institutions, associations, and initiatives. I welcome Deborah Schnabel, the co-director of the Anne Frank Educational Center in Frankfurt am Main. Dear Ms. Schnabel, you are active nationwide to bring the biography of Anne Frank closer to young people and adults, thereby raising awareness of anti-Semitism, racism, and other forms of inhumanity.

With us is Jochen Müller, co-founder and co-managing director of the association ufuq.de. You, dear Mr. Müller, are an Islamic scholar, have lived and worked in various countries in the Middle East, and today advise educators in schools and youth facilities to educate about Islam and Islamism and to prevent racism and anti-Semitism.

I welcome Aliyeh Yegane Arani, the head of the "Discrimination Protection Contact Point in Schools" here in Berlin. Dear Ms. Yegane Arani, you are a political scientist, an expert in diversity and human rights education, and you advise students, parents, and teachers who have experienced or witnessed discrimination.

Last but not least, I welcome Hetty Berg, the director of the Jewish Museum here in Berlin. You come from The Hague, dear Ms. Berg, studied theater studies and management of non-profit organizations in Amsterdam, and helped establish the Jewish Cultural Quarter. The Jewish Museum Berlin, which you lead today, sends its tour bus to schools across Germany to inspire students about the diversity of Jewish life in history and the present.

Ladies and gentlemen, once again a very warm welcome to all of you!