Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the panel discussion at the 36th German Protestant Church Day on May 27, 2017, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

30 May 2017 · 36th German Protestant Church Day panel discussion · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed a panel discussion at the 36th German Protestant Church Day in Berlin on May 27, 2017, reflecting on reason, faith, and post-truth politics.
Main themes
Reason and faith, misinformation and conspiracy theories, post-truth politics, Enlightenment and science, Reformation history, Luther and Augustine, superstition and irrationality, truth in public discourse, Christianity and rational thought, internet and misinformation
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,344
65th percentile
Sentences
128
74th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.93
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 71%68%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 7%6%
  • Technological 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 5%

128 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Did you actually know that?

The moon landing never took place; it was all just filmed in Hollywood studios.

Climate change is by no means caused by humans.

The contrails from airplanes are actually chemicals that the government wants to use to slowly poison us.

AIDS is not transmitted through infection and is best fought with vitamin tablets.

The theory of evolution is blasphemy and has no place in schools!

Dear friends, this litany of old and new nonsense could be extended indefinitely. As if education and knowledge, as if the European heritage of the Enlightenment had suddenly been forgotten, as if the emancipation from science, the struggle for truth were no longer worth anything, superstition, irrationality, and conspiracy theories are celebrating a joyful revival. Especially on the internet. "Even a short hour spent online is enough," says Susan Neiman in her book, "to drive a thoughtful reader to despair."

A few years ago, I would have considered the question at a church convention to be presumptuous; today it is necessary: "Is reason still salvageable?" I believe it is necessary, and the question belongs at the church convention! All the more so at a church convention that remembers its Reformation history!

Critics will say: "Reason? You of all people? You who believe?" "Yes," we must answer. The relationship between faith and reason has never been simple, never definitively clarified, always fraught with tension – but above all, always in change! Luther's often-quoted polemic: "Reason is the highest whore. Whoever wants to be a Christian must pluck out the eyes of his reason," he himself has refuted!

This is not surprising: Already a good thousand years before Luther, Augustine found those Christians "bold" who tried to challenge scientific knowledge with biblical quotes.

Immanuel Kant could not imagine reason without faith. And conversely, can faith exist without reason?

Wolfgang Huber has answered this – certainly pointedly, but correctly –: "A faith not illuminated by reason carries the danger of becoming barbaric and violent." Instead, he says, it is necessary to continually unfold the mutual interdependence of reason and faith.

I am not a theologian, as you know. And I do not belong to those who read more into the Bible than is there to be read, but here I ask myself: Does not the Bible itself provide sufficient examples of responsible thinking?

I admit: In the New Testament, the miracles from the earthly ministry of Jesus of Nazareth are certainly more familiar, in which Jesus teaches the lame to walk again or restores sight to the blind.

But there are also other texts in the tradition. People are healed who are no longer in control of themselves, who cannot use their free will, who are subjected to madness or – in the language of the ancient Orient at that time – are possessed by evil spirits.

Isn't it already about something there that we would today call the "salvation of reason"? And can there be anything more reasonable than helping people to leave their misguided paths, to see through their superstitions, to overcome their pathological fear of the foreign, to be shocked by their own envy, to recognize their own blindness, to transform their black-and-white worldview into a colorful and livable one? To be freed from tormenting, equally demonic fixations – there is really nothing more reasonable to do!

Kant called it the ability to use one's own understanding. Sigmund Freud said that the ego should become master in its own house. And the Christian faith says that the truth sets us free. All allies in the fight for reason – and to this day!

Many allies, one might think, but why so little reason? "Is anyone still interested in the truth?" a German daily newspaper titled its coverage of the American election campaign last year. Others wrote about the "virus of the absurd." It has been heard recently: The age of the post-factual has begun – that always seems a bit too much for me. But that there is, even among us, an increasingly aggressive aversion to facts and a simultaneously furious longing for scapegoats is undeniable. The appeals to our lowest, not our best instincts are becoming increasingly louder, even shriller. We are experiencing how politics is being made with the fear of people, rather than relying on the strength of their hopes and their will to shape. In some places, truth is no longer just intentionally falsified; much worse, it seems to no longer count. After all, it was a cabinet member in Britain last year who publicly said before the Brexit referendum: "The people in this country are fed up with experts!"

Hannah Arendt wrote one of her famous essays on "Truth and Lies in Politics" half a century ago. So the topic is not new! What is new? What is different in our political discourse today, which apparently – more strongly elsewhere than with us – promotes a rampant loss of reason?

It is not easy to separate cause and effect. Is it overwhelm in the growing complexity of the world, or is it the frenzied speed of change, or is it the dramatic acceleration of information flows in the digitized world that leads to a loss of control?

Not an easy decision! Presumably, besides the three, there are likely other causes being debated. And that should not be surprising. We are currently still at the beginning of a new debate about globalization. After the fall of the Iron Curtain, everyone believed that all fundamental questions were now answered for us; the West had won – globalization would therefore change all others, but not us!

But history is apparently not over. In the quarter-century of German unity, not only has Germany come together, but the whole world has also grown together and has created entirely new power – and influential centers, especially in East Asia – and has produced both: new prosperity, but also increased inequality, made especially dramatically visible. The strongest driving force of this globalization is undoubtedly the digital revolution, which not only creates global networking, knowledge of one another, but also generates an enormous global synchronization pressure that affects very different living conditions, cultures, traditions, and perceptions and levels differences! Many of the migrants who come to us live in their homeland in a time zone whose delay they find unbearable when they compare their meager existence with our lives. This comparison is a daily reality for every smartphone owner in Africa. "Who should be surprised," writes Susan Neiman, "that the young man from Niger is not held back at home when he sees daily the difference between Kim Kardashian's life and his own."

What I mean is: Here and there, people's expectations have risen enormously when looking into other worlds. But unfortunately, the ability to empathize with other realities and perceptions has not kept pace. Our adaptability is being overwhelmed. And this overwhelm produces counter-reactions – fear of identity loss, a return to supposedly familiar things: nation, region, ethnicity, religion. I advise us to take this counter-reaction seriously. Identity is not just a secondary need. I predict: In this unbounded globalized world, it will gain even more significance, as it is a search for the place where one feels at home. But if this search ultimately is only paired with exclusion, rejection of the foreign, especially with fear of the future and glorification of one's own great past, then the reaction will not only be unreasonable but dangerous, because it loses sight of reality!

It is true: With growing networking, the complexity of our environment has increased enormously. National, European, and global crises intertwine, mutually reinforcing each other: trade surpluses, Greek debt burden, Ukraine, Middle East, Libya. The ability of most people to penetrate this fog with the instruments of our understanding is reaching its limits.

And who is surprised: If we can only process the unpredictability and uncertainty of future developments with great effort, it becomes even harder to debate this complexity in our societies, to even explain it! But this is by no means only a problem of growing impatience and decreasing attention spans in the media and among people. I know from personal experience: How should I weigh the daily horror images of the terrible war in Syria against long-term progress in education, health, and poverty alleviation in many countries of the world?

How does the soberly depicted picture, that we today – historically speaking – live in the best of all worlds, reconcile with our subjective feeling that we live in a world gone awry, where one crisis chases another? The complexity in which we live is multidimensional, the digitally mediated image is often one-dimensional!

This leads to the next major challenge: the change in our information behavior. The internet gives us access to an unprecedented wealth of information from a multitude of sources of completely different quality. But we must not confuse the flood of information with knowledge – and certainly not with wisdom. Knowledge requires verifiable facts and established connections. Wisdom requires experience and judgment. Much of what the information machine internet delivers is indeed the exact opposite. A constant rain of information, the 24-hour bombardment with chatter, washes away crucial standards of objectivity. Studies say: Where the need for self-confirmation dominates in online communities, only what the user already believed or suspected is taken in. "Felt truths" threaten to permanently replace verified facts. Those who do not believe it should occasionally take a look at the comment sections of Facebook!

To avoid being misunderstood: Networking through social platforms can also have enormously positive political effects. Especially in repressive societies, it can mobilize a sense of community, organize protests, and possibly contribute to "fear changing sides." There are impressive examples of this from recent years, such as in Tunisia during the overthrow of dictator Ben Ali.

Here, in democratic societies, the effect is different, not so positive! I fear, when I see the mockery, hatred, and harshness of many online comments: This will not leave our society unscathed in the long run. It is not just that – as Peter Strohschneider has put it – in the anonymity of the internet, the boundary between what can be said and what cannot is increasingly fading. It seems to me that especially those are right who say that fragmentation, self-confirmation, and self-reflection lead people to increasingly ignore doubts, that they only find the simple answers that algorithms or Twitter bots, or trolls from outside provide them. These mechanisms, we are only at the beginning, make it increasingly difficult in the digital world to verify what is actually true and what is not.

This mirroring and amplifying of moods – whether from individual inclination or from manipulative political interests – is the allure of the new media, but it also contains the threat to an enlightened, democratic culture in the digital age. The price for this is high, too high. I fear that the "post-factual" or the playful handling of "alternative truths" is not just annoying, as Susan Neiman says, or a catchy label for modern political entertainment. When it becomes a method, it indeed poses an existential danger to our political community. Even if it sounds boring: We cannot do without reason in the digitized world, nor without the productive doubt that always precedes the search for better solutions. Those who declare facts, scientific research results irrelevant make a serious debate about the future impossible. Therefore, we could know: The decomposition of reason is the beginning of the decomposition of democracy.

So what can we do? A lot – and we will discuss that shortly – but above all: We must invest in our judgment! Not magnifying everything into woodcuts, but paying attention to discernment and accuracy beyond clichés. This means: investing in social institutions and systems that claim to "produce truth" – schools, science, justice. This requires media where not only click numbers and ratings count, where curiosity and objectivity remain the journalistic drive.

You will be surprised, but with this we come back to the Reformation in the end. Since Luther and the Enlightenment, the conviction has grown among us that culture and education make a self-determined life possible. And for decades we have all lived in the security that this conviction is no longer questioned.

And indeed: Germany is a stable democracy with millions of people committed to democracy. This distinguishes us from the first democracy on German soil, which began nearly a hundred years ago. But we should not ignore warning signs:

A new fascination with authoritarianism is spreading – even in Europe.

The disparagement of democratic institutions.

The recent attempted revival of the Volkish.

Fake news and perceived truths as the foundation of a new irrationality are also present here.

Once again: There is no reason for alarmism. But there is enough reason for us to learn again to stand up for the legacy of the Reformation and European Enlightenment with conviction and determination. And that means for coexistence in democracy: not losing sight of each other, not allowing society to be atomized, seeking dialogue, even contentious dialogue, with an open visor – as we do here at the Church Congress. And that means: knowing that no one finds the philosopher's stone alone.

And that our nightly talk show race aimed at maximum escalation neither replaces politics nor brings us closer to the truth. No, reason in democracy means wanting to convince others with arguments – but always taking into account that the other might also be right.

The claim of a common, a political reason, the claim of measure and moderation in societal discourse, we have actually captured perfectly in a beautiful German saying: "Let us keep the church in the village."

At the end of my introduction to the conversation we are about to have, there is a thesis that is meant to be both an encouragement and a call to action. The question is not: "Is reason still to be saved?", but the question is: "What else is supposed to save us if not reason?"