Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the presentation of the Theodor Wolff Prize on June 9, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

12 June 2021 · Presentation of the Theodor Wolff Prize · Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed the Theodor Wolff Prize ceremony in Berlin on June 9, 2021, honoring excellence in German journalism and reflecting on the role of the press in democracy.
Main themes
Journalistic integrity and ethics, trust in journalism, Theodor Wolff Prize, quality journalism, local journalism, misinformation and disinformation, press freedom, democracy and rule of law, fact-based reporting, public opinion formation, pandemic media coverage, Theodor Wolff legacy
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,410
41st percentile
Sentences
61
40th percentile
Readability
39
33rd percentile
Grade
13.6
63rd percentile
Syntax
3.13
65th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
48th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 64%64%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

61 sentences in 20 paragraphs

None of you, as I know, does your work in order to receive an award one day. On the contrary, I believe that the pieces nominated for and ultimately awarded the Theodor Wolff Prize are written precisely out of a self-evident journalistic ethos.

Those who work like those who have been awarded this prize in recent years, and those who are candidates today, do not primarily think of themselves or their reputation among colleagues, but are passionately interested in the matter at hand, in the truth and in the relevance of an issue, also in the public discussion about it – and above all, and anew every day, in the readers.

Today, even before praise and awards reach some of you, I would like to consciously thank all journalists in our country – all those who pursue their work with this ethical attitude and with this passion and joy in the matter.

The Theodor Wolff Prize is awarded by the entire industry, and it can only be received once. The prize commemorates one of the best German journalists, a gifted editor, and a determined Republican and Democrat. One who had experienced the often constraining conditions of the Empire and who, during the First World War, early and courageously advocated for a peace of understanding with France. And who then worked with all his might to ensure that the young German Republic, with its democratic freedoms, could be accepted and appreciated by its citizens within a European peace order. If he, who was later expelled and stripped of his citizenship by the Nazis, had been accused of working for a so-called system press, it would not have seemed disreputable to him, but rather a title of honor. Because this so-called system: It is freedom, law, democracy, humanity. Theodor Wolff and his work obligate us.

The most important thing that critical quality journalism must preserve and strengthen is the trust of readers; trust in the truth of what is written, trust in the integrity and incorruptibility of the writers, trust in the impartial completeness of the reported facts, and trust in the conscientious, critical examination of the circumstances.

And perhaps also the trust that the subjects of reporting are not random favorite topics of the author or a momentary hype. That it is rather about stories, people, processes that are important for political and social coexistence or for the personal lives of the readers.

This is especially true for local journalism. The possibly more fragmented puzzle of difficult-to-obtain information in neighborhoods and municipalities, especially during lockdowns and contact restrictions, is not inherently an easier task than the analytical gaze of the correspondent on the great geopolitics in Washington or Beijing – not an easier task and above all not a less important one! Moreover, in the immediacy of local journalism, it is much easier for readers themselves to distinguish between true and false, between accurate and inaccurate.

Good journalism provides orientation. Or more accurately: It creates the conditions for individuals and society to orient themselves. This does not primarily require determined opinions. People like to form their own opinions – even if they occasionally want to know how experienced observers assess and evaluate this or that. The special responsibility that comes with such opinion pieces, of which a prominent example is being awarded today, goes without saying.

Most of the time, however, people primarily want critically examined, clearly presented facts: transparency in the unclear, discovery of hidden connections. And for that, you, the journalists, need a perspective on reality that is as fair, as experienced, and yet always curious as possible. On the reality as experienced by the majority, and on the reality as experienced by minorities.

If the old saying is true that the topics lie in the street, then journalists must actually go out into the street to find the topics there. Twitter & Co. are not the streets of real life. They are more like the highways of outrage.

To give just one example from this tumultuous pandemic year: In the debate about #Allesdichtmachen, the contributions of which I do not wish to comment on politically or aesthetically here, I had the impression that the waves of outrage and counter-outrage surged through the republic much faster and louder than a sober answer was sought to the rather obvious question: Who actually said what exactly and why? First reporting, then opinion – I would be grateful to be reminded of this order, not only as president but also as a reader.

More than just a few years ago, we, as you all experience much more strongly than many in the country, are not only exposed to an overabundance of information but increasingly to deliberate misinformation, purposefully spread lies, and false reports. Individuals can be manipulated, and entire communities can be destabilized. We have experienced this in the recent past – for example, in the targeted attempt to discredit certain vaccines or to instill fears in an audience that has no means of verification – and we have been warned by security authorities about what targeted attempts at influence may await us in connection with the upcoming federal elections. When foreign intelligence services repeatedly try to conduct an online election campaign elsewhere with fake identities and brutal lies, we must evidently be on our guard. We need maximum transparency: Who is behind a post? An automated bot, a purchased influencer opinion, or an independent citizen voice?

Of course, digital platforms bear a crucial responsibility in this matter. A responsibility that they have not yet truly fulfilled. But also, any control, filtering, or regulation does not work without the only real antidote: the critically examined representation of reality and information that people know they can trust.

Trust – publishers know this – is hard to gain but easy to lose. Especially in a pandemic, where what is considered true is never set in stone, but is contested week after week – through scientific discussion, through hypotheses and counter-hypotheses, through test series and practical experiences. Even "science" cannot – to the disappointment of many – fulfill the longing for clarity even in a crisis. And I thank all journalists who do not give in to this longing for clarity, no matter how many clicks it might bring.

In the end, it always comes down to the same question for people: Can we believe what we are told? This is the great responsibility in which every serious journalistic work stands, and I am grateful for the many of you, the journalists, publishers, and editors, who face this responsibility with pride and ambition.

One last thought: Letters are dangerous, words can hurt, can destroy. The classic film "All the President's Men" about the uncovering of Watergate begins with the typing on a typewriter. The letters can almost be seen and heard like gunshots hitting the paper.

This first shot of the film reminds us, perhaps somewhat martial, how dangerous enlightening, well-researched journalism can be for those responsible for the greatest injustices and who hide them, even for those at the highest levels. Today, however, we experience another side of the danger: Journalists themselves are at risk. And not only in dictatorships or authoritarian systems but also in liberal, democratic societies. An article, a broadcast, a podcast can not only lead to a nasty, even devastating shitstorm, but it can also lead to concrete personal persecution and threats, including to family members. A report on-site at a so-called "Querdenker" demonstration can, as has happened, end with the reporter in the hospital. These are intolerable conditions in a democracy that cannot be justified by anything!

I am very aware of the risks that many of you expose yourselves to, and I want to thank you, also on behalf of the readers, listeners, and viewers, for your efforts. For you, who muster what one should not have to muster for proper journalistic work in a free democracy: courage and fearlessness to uncover the truth and to stick to the truth.

But you all deserve not only thanks but a state that protects your work and a society that appreciates your work. And last but not least, you all deserve editors and publishers who stand by you. Who then, in serious cases, say to you what Ben Bradlee of the Washington Post once succinctly wrote on a note in the case of Woodward and Bernstein: "We stand by our story."

Because you can be trusted. Thank you very much.