Speech by Federal President Dr. Frank-Walter Steinmeier at the reception for the members of the German Ethics Council on June 26, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Frank-Walter Steinmeier · Federal President of Germany

30 June 2018 · Reception for the members of the German Ethics Council · Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, Germany

Context
Steinmeier addressed members of the German Ethics Council at a reception at Schloss Bellevue, Berlin, on June 26, 2018, marking the council's evolving role in advising on emerging ethical challenges.
Main themes
Ethics of digitalization, artificial intelligence, human dignity, technological progress, genome and brain intervention, democratic society, political advisory role, German Ethics Council, Silicon Valley culture, Yuval Harari's thought experiment, innovation and risk, aging society and healthcare
Duration
~7 min
24th percentile
Words
834
24th percentile
Sentences
38
24th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.13
65th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
63rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 50%50%
  • Social 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

38 sentences in 14 paragraphs

How wonderful to have you here. A warm welcome to Schloss Bellevue!

I still remember well when the National Ethics Council was founded during my time in the Chancellery in 2001, which ten years ago evolved into the German Ethics Council. Today, we can rightly say: If the Ethics Council had not been established back then, we would need it more urgently than ever today.

Ethical questions have gained importance in political consulting worldwide in recent years. This is not only felt by us in Germany, but there are now national ethics committees in around 100 countries, and nowhere have these questions become less, let alone simpler.

In more and more areas of policy, we are encountering ethical boundary questions. And on many of these boundary questions, you have expressed your views in recent years through statements: on dementia and self-determination, for example, on pre-implantation diagnostics, or on the cost-benefit considerations in the ever-growing healthcare sector. In doing so, you are negotiating topics that could not be more relevant in an aging society and the current debate about the situation of care in Germany.

At the same time, you are looking ahead to the great ethical challenges on the horizon of science, which can be roughly outlined as follows: the intervention in the human genome, the intervention in the human brain, as well as the opportunities and risks of artificial intelligence. Many of these questions may still sound like science fiction to many of our citizens – but for you, they are on the table because they are already shaping laboratories and research centers today. For example:

How do we deal with "Artificial General Intelligence" – a perfected artificial intelligence that would completely surpass our own?

What are the consequences of intervening in the human germline? A utopia for curing rare diseases or a dystopia of limitless "optimization" of humans?

How will we coexist when brain implants are no longer only used in cases of illness, but are circulated solely for individual knowledge and competitive advantage? Or, as entrepreneur Elon Musk demands, to upgrade humans to cyborgs in the long term, because otherwise they would become redundant in the midst of artificial ambient intelligence?

Last week, I was in California and Silicon Valley. I had the feeling that there the focus is mainly on the opportunities of new technological possibilities, while the risks are often dismissed with a roll of the eyes, as if they were questions of naysayers and those stuck in the past. The motto: Economy and science drive technological change forward, and politics somehow deals with the consequences, I consider to be the wrong approach. I am convinced: Our society is not anti-progress. On the contrary: The Germans are proud that we are an innovation society. But the willingness to innovate, the curiosity, the desire for the future will only be maintained if answers are also provided to the open questions, the uncertainties, the risks that technological upheavals bring about. And these answers cannot be provided by politics alone; those who drive innovation forward must also be involved.

The Israeli historian Yuval Harari, whom you have invited to your conference and with whom I spoke at length last night, has posed the following thought experiment: If machines are fed more and more data about our wishes and longings, our pulse and heart rate, our purchasing behavior, and our GPS data, then at some point they will make all decisions for us. The new and dangerous aspect of this: Presumably, these decisions would be better, in the sense of more efficient, than any human could ever make. Our democratic society would be at an end if elections become unnecessary because the algorithm apparently knows my preferences better than I do.

That would be fatal, because technological progress is supposed to – in the spirit of Kant's Enlightenment motto – facilitate humanity's emergence from immaturity, and not be a voluntary entry into new immaturity. New technology, however, can do both: empower and disempower. If we are not vigilant, I see the risk that we will transition from an era in which the machine served humanity to an age in which humanity serves the machine.

To be clear: I do not share this fatalistic determinism. However, to prevent this from happening, we need a broad debate on the ethics of digitalization. Because this ethics is not primarily about the future of technologies, but about our own future – as human beings and as a human society. An ethics of digitalization is necessary so that we can shape the future in such a way that security and prosperity are maintained in change; and not just for a small technologically enhanced elite, but for all citizens.

With your work, you are making an important contribution to this societal debate. The dignity of the human being is your compass. Politics will urgently need your advice in the next ten years and beyond.

I thank you all for your commitment and look forward to the conversation with you.